Quantcast

Are Corporations PEOPLE??!!

BlueRepublican 2012/07/13 00:40:28
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The Supreme Court thinks so. So do these guys below. What do you think?
romney obama
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Steve 2012/07/13 02:55:20
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Steve
    +9
    They aren't just people, they're super-people !!!

    Not only do they enjoy the right of free speech, they get favored tax breaks. Also, when a corporation gets convicted of a crime (and this has happened), nobody goes to jail. In my next life, I want to be a corporation, too !!!

    speech favored tax breaks corporation convicted crime jail life corporation

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • BlackwinterG36C 2012/08/11 09:53:23
    Yes, they are people (tell me why)
    BlackwinterG36C
    Corporations aren't people they are wicked entities that are the soul of the wicked capitalist machine that wishes to eat babies and old ladies. Only counter-revolutionaries would consider corporations,companies, and small businesses people.
  • RageFury 2012/07/18 05:43:41
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    RageFury
    They don't breathe.
  • Contarded Chickenhawk Con S... 2012/07/16 14:41:18
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Contarded Chickenhawk Con Slayer
    The day I see red blood coming out of the veins of a living corporation, will be the day I believe.. And not metaphorically speaking...

    Actual blood... coming from actual veins.
  • DefendnProtect 2012/07/15 19:19:15
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    DefendnProtect
    +2
    corporations are the masters

    Corporate owners are people, often controlling gov reg to prop up their cartels like Obomneycare and TBTF bailouts.
    goldman sachs rules the world

    blankfein
  • Beccy 2012/07/14 21:26:15
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Beccy
    +1
    Wonder what the court was paid to come up with that ruling?
  • Lindy... 2012/07/14 16:58:05
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Lindy...
    +2
    I think Mr. Lincoln and our other founders would strongly disagree with making corporations people. Corporations are NOT people and thay do not have what's best for America on their agendas. All they care about is power, control and personal wealth. Most of the 'too big to fail' corporations are evil and corrupt and they exist in the face of our Constitution, which forbids monopolies so that no company can grow so large that they endanger our economic systems or wield unwarranted power . They'll be the destruction of America in the end. Mr. Lincoln's remarks are even more relevant in today's political environment!
    "As a result of the war, corporations have been enthroned and an era of corruption in high places will follow and the money power of the country will endeavor to prolong it's reign by working on the prejudices of the people until all wealth is aggregated in a few hands and the republic is destroyed."
    -Abraham Lincoln 1864
  • texasred 2012/07/14 00:46:16
    Yes, they are people (tell me why)
    texasred
    As someone who worked for a corporation for almost 30 years and someone who represented that corporation with other corporations, customers, vendors... yes. People that I worked with outside the corporation didn't look at me as "the corporation." They looked at me as a person who represented the corporation.
  • aherbert 2012/07/13 22:59:37
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    aherbert
    +2
    mitt romney nope

    Remember the young lifeguard that worked for a corporation that fired him because he left his post and save another human being life. Corporation thought that since the lifeguard left his post he put the corporation in danger as no one was there to monitor the specific area however, the person … the lifeguard thought he should just save a human beings life … someone that needed his expertise. We all know how the corporation rewarded the employee … yep he got fired … corporations look at things at a corporate level … people look at things at a person to person level …
  • Matt 2012/07/13 19:31:04
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Matt
  • alun.palmer 2012/07/13 19:18:42
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    alun.palmer
    They are persons, not people
  • beavith1 2012/07/13 15:34:34
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    beavith1
    they aren't people. they are corporations. its just a construct that allows a business to continue on after its founders die or leave. that it is owned by stockholders...
  • Elaine Magliacane 2012/07/13 13:51:00
    Yes, they are people (tell me why)
    Elaine Magliacane
    +1
    Some corporations have LOTS of people, some LLC Corporations are ONE person. A Corporation is a LEGAL entity, people fill out the papers and pay the fees and taxes and lawyers to get the piece of paper that allows them to operate as a corporation. This is a really STUPID thing to argue about.
  • Scaldar... Elaine ... 2012/07/14 02:04:26
    Scaldari Anitoba
    the question is, are they a person as defined by the constitution and entitled to unlimited free speech.
  • Lindy... Elaine ... 2012/07/14 16:49:37 (edited)
    Lindy...
    I think Mr. Lincoln and our other founders would strongly disagree!!! What's stupid is pretending that corporations are people and that they care about our country. All they care about is power, control and personal wealth. Most of the 'too big to fail' corporations are evil and corrupt and they exist in the face of our Constitution, which forbids monopolies so that no company can grow so large that they endanger our economic systems or wield unwarranted power . They'll be the destruction of America in the end.
    "As a result of the war,corporations have been enthroned and an era of corruption in high places will follow and the money power of the country will endeavor to prolong it's reign by working on the prejudices of the people until all wealth is aggregated in a few hands and the republic is destroyed."
    -Abraham Lincoln 1864
  • Jeremiah 2012/07/13 13:38:08
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Jeremiah
    +2
    Corporations are definitely not people. The people who run them and work for them are people, of course, but the corporation itself is an entity, not a person. A corporation cannot cast a vote for an election, as a person can, although the Citizens United ruling allows it to vote anonymously an unlimited number of times with its pocketbook.

    Mitt Romney has said he believes corporations are people, but President Obama has not. There is no reason to believe he does.
  • Haightbear 2012/07/13 13:34:50
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Haightbear
    +3
    Ummmm....Obama doesn't think corporations are people...get the facts straight.
  • Ashley 2012/07/13 13:27:32
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Ashley
    They are made up of people who come and go...
  • keeper Ashley 2012/07/13 16:57:06
    keeper
    Then they are people, right?
  • tncdel 2012/07/13 13:16:45
    Undecided
    tncdel
    +4
    Those who don't understand legal concepts well mistakenly equate legal terminology in layman terms. Corporations have long been deemed entities same as persons for purposes of proceeding in a court of law.

    The whole point of incorporating a business reflects around the concept that a business incorporated [the word itself derived from the BODY of a person] has its own identity apart from those who invest in that corporation. So that, if it goes bankrupt, the investors are not personally liable, among other things.

    Trust funds and business trusts are also deemed by law to be entities on equal footing with actual persons.
  • BigFig#9 tncdel 2012/07/13 15:43:05
    BigFig#9
    It is definitely not a yes or no question and of course this whole question goes to 'do corporations have the right to back candidates and political causes under the premise of free speech'...(and of course similarly this would apply to unions, etc....) The broader question for the United States is what can be done to keep money and lobbyists from the increasing perversion of the political process that we have seen. I know the question but I don't know the answer.
  • Dwight-AFCL>dogsbody 2012/07/13 12:57:29
    Undecided
    Dwight-AFCL>dogsbody
    In the sense of being an individual, No.

    But when Government wants to tax them it is as a single entity, not as a group designed to share risk and profit.
  • Seonag 2012/07/13 11:37:26
    Yes, they are people (tell me why)
    Seonag
    +1
    The are made up of people.
  • elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard 2012/07/13 11:28:38
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard
    They are a business organization. If there were no people in them, they would be just some building. Why should the heads of the corporations have two voices to every else one!
  • Pedro Doller ~POTL-PWCM~JLA 2012/07/13 11:26:55
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Pedro Doller ~POTL-PWCM~JLA
    +1
    They are bought and sold every day. It's not legal for one person to own another one.

    Take Patents for example, they must be registered in a persons name, usually an employee, and then the Corp buys the rights to the Patent for a dollar.
  • Lefty 2012/07/13 10:31:30
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Lefty
    +2
    Corporations are tax loopholes!
  • Lady Whitewolf 2012/07/13 10:13:43
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Lady Whitewolf
    +3
    Romney DOES think they're people, Obama DOES NOT think they're people.
  • Jackal 2012/07/13 10:03:40 (edited)
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    Jackal
    +1
    Corporation is merely a vehicle that people ride...
  • Janoy Davis 2012/07/13 09:26:17
    Undecided
    Janoy Davis
    The same question arises when you ask "are cars alive?" (The answer is actually yes because cars are able to reproduce via production lines and blueprints, the air intake says they breath, gasoline usage says they eat, the cars internal computer says it thinks, not all cars need a person inside to drive IE: automated tram cars, they have oil their own version of blood, they have many fuel lines, oil lines, coolant lines etc, thereby a circulatory system. If damaged they make strange noise, and strange smells, much like a human.) I should have said yes to this question. Corporations exhibit similair traits to that of people. They marry each over and give birth to smaller businesses (just like ALLSTATE gave birth to ESURANCE) people inside of the corporation act like cells. Each cell (And in a large group forms a organ) has a unique job to maintain the operations of the corporations (i.e. HR, Finance, logictists). So yes (outside of usual thinking; sometimes you gotta think outside of the box) corporations are people.
  • elptrek... Janoy D... 2012/07/13 11:30:37
    elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard
    +1
    Cars do not reproduce them selves.
  • Janoy D... elptrek... 2012/07/13 12:20:49
    Janoy Davis
    Though they can not directly reproduce, cars have paper blueprints that give get car model their "genetic blueprint". Think of a car factory as a womb, from there, the car is assembled by robot arms inside and out. The car is born when it rolls off the line to go to a showroom.
  • elptrek... Janoy D... 2012/07/13 19:39:34
    elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard
    You are streching concepts quite a bit. The womb cannot be shut down with a flip of a switch.
  • Christy Janoy D... 2012/07/13 15:30:17
    Christy
    +1
    While amusing, that's a bad analogy. Cars are not alive.

    The 7 Characteristics of Life:
    1. Living Things are Composed of Cells:
    Single-cell organisms have everything they need to be self-sufficient.
    In multicellular organisms, specialization increases until some cells do only certain things.

    2. Living Things Have Different Levels of Organization:
    Both molecular and cellular organization.
    Living things must be able to organize simple substances into complex ones.
    Living things organize cells at several levels:

    Tissue - a group of cells that perform a common function.
    Organ - a group of tissues that perform a common function.
    Organ system - a group of organs that perform a common function.
    Organism - any complete living thing.

    3. Living Things Use Energy:
    Living things take in energy and use it for maintenance and growth.

    4. Living Things Respond To Their Environment:
    Living things will make changes in response to a stimulus in their environment.
    A behavior is a complex set of responses.

    5. Living Things Grow:
    Cell division - the orderly formation of new cells.
    Cell enlargement - the increase in size of a cell. Cells grow to a certain size and then divide.
    An organism gets larger as the number of its cells increases.

    6. Living Things Reproduce:
    Reproduction is not essential for the survival ...








    While amusing, that's a bad analogy. Cars are not alive.

    The 7 Characteristics of Life:
    1. Living Things are Composed of Cells:
    Single-cell organisms have everything they need to be self-sufficient.
    In multicellular organisms, specialization increases until some cells do only certain things.

    2. Living Things Have Different Levels of Organization:
    Both molecular and cellular organization.
    Living things must be able to organize simple substances into complex ones.
    Living things organize cells at several levels:

    Tissue - a group of cells that perform a common function.
    Organ - a group of tissues that perform a common function.
    Organ system - a group of organs that perform a common function.
    Organism - any complete living thing.

    3. Living Things Use Energy:
    Living things take in energy and use it for maintenance and growth.

    4. Living Things Respond To Their Environment:
    Living things will make changes in response to a stimulus in their environment.
    A behavior is a complex set of responses.

    5. Living Things Grow:
    Cell division - the orderly formation of new cells.
    Cell enlargement - the increase in size of a cell. Cells grow to a certain size and then divide.
    An organism gets larger as the number of its cells increases.

    6. Living Things Reproduce:
    Reproduction is not essential for the survival of individual organisms, but must occur for a species to survive.
    All living things reproduce in one of the following ways:
    Asexual repoduction - Producing offspring without the use of gametes.
    Sexual reproduction - Producing offspring by the joining of sex cells.

    7. Living Things Adapt To Their Environment:
    Adaptations are traits giving an organism an advantage in a certain environment.
    Variation of individuals is important for a healthy species.

    Copied from http://www.essortment.com/six...
    (more)
  • trentinafur 2012/07/13 06:59:16
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    trentinafur
    +5
    it's self-evident - to those who are people - is it not??

    Of course, Mitt's version of the Gettysburg address would change Lincoln's famous words to "Government Of the Corporation, By the Corporation, and For the Corporation".

    Why anyone would vote for this shill for the banksters is beyond reason.
  • Lady Wh... trentin... 2012/07/13 10:14:13
    Lady Whitewolf
    +1
    SO agree
  • Defendn... trentin... 2012/07/15 19:23:46
    DefendnProtect
    Exactly. I don't get it why people vote for Goldman Sachs Romney and Goldman Sachs Obama and not for the Green or Libertarian Party?
  • dallasjoe 2012/07/13 06:22:50
    NO, they are not people (tell me why)
    dallasjoe
    +3
    Tell me how many Corporations where drafted in the 1960's?
  • Lady Wh... dallasjoe 2012/07/13 10:14:27
    Lady Whitewolf
    good one!
  • dallasjoe Lady Wh... 2012/07/15 19:16:01
    dallasjoe
    Corporations have the rights of citizens but none of the Responsibilities
  • Cap 2012/07/13 05:20:55
    Undecided
    Cap
    +3
    My gut reaction would be "no", but before I came to any final conclusion on the matter I'd want to understand why the NYTimes was considered to be a "person" in the case of NYTimes v Sullivan, or why, if it wasn't, it didn't have to be in order to be entitled to First Amendment protections related to Freedom of Speech and Freedom of the Press.
  • USAF Vet Cap 2012/07/13 06:31:29
    USAF Vet
    +2
    Here's another 1000 raves!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/19 17:54:26

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals