Quantcast

Are all religions just tribal and myth in nature?

bob 2012/08/15 21:40:58
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • George Romney 2012/08/15 21:44:41
    None of the above
    George Romney
    +6
    Not all religions are founded in the definition of God, many are found in the pursuit of God. Hinduism and Buddhism preach that we do not specifically know God's will and that the best way to pursue it is to meditate, live a productive life, care for others and contemplate your subservience to a higher power. Even Christians are taught not to presume the Word of God and rather to take their lives as "signs".

    That "pursuit" of God is what drives the human existence to dream and wonder, and is a fundamentally good thing for us. To dismiss such perplex questions as our place in the Universe, questions of moral right and wrong, and the relationships people hold with each other as simply "tribal and myth[ical]" is ignorant.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • ghostrider 2012/09/08 19:06:08
    All religions are just tribal and myth in nature
    ghostrider
    +1
    ... of course they are.
  • bodaishinboy 2012/09/02 01:05:17
    None of the above
    bodaishinboy
    +1
    The Scientologist might beg to differ. Religion is a formalized set of beliefs that are accepted by a group.
  • JimTheGeek 2012/08/17 19:53:13
    All religions are just tribal and myth in nature
    JimTheGeek
    +1
    'Nuff said
  • Burnjuan 2012/08/17 17:46:20
    All of the above
    Burnjuan
  • Bill 2012/08/17 08:53:10
    None of the above
    Bill
    No Religion is not, but, bob certanly is.
  • Lawnmowerman~PWCM~JLA 2012/08/17 00:59:10
    None of the above
    Lawnmowerman~PWCM~JLA
    Myths don't have documented miracles associated with them BOB.
  • Mike Miller 2012/08/16 14:17:49
    None of the above
    Mike Miller
    +1
    Religions are not necessarily tribal but they are created by the very human need to feel that unexplained things have some explanation and since often it is beyond our understanding we like to think there is a God out there just making it happen. I imagine when we first looked up at the night sky and saw the vastness of the universe it was a bit intimidating and unexplained. We reached for definition and explanation. Many also feel safer and sense of purpose believing a God created us for a reason rather than some biological accident that evolved into us as a species.
  • bob Mike Mi... 2012/08/16 14:39:02
    bob
    Evolution is no accident. Life evolves in both body and soul
  • BILL 2012/08/16 06:50:28
    None of the above
    BILL
    +1
    Religion and God are two things that happen to be what ever people would like to make them out to be
  • Dynasty Fighter 2012/08/16 05:00:51
    I am spiritual and I believe that no man can define GOD or can claim that GOD...
    Dynasty Fighter
    +1
    i believe God is here for me
  • bob Dynasty... 2012/08/16 14:39:29
    bob
    so do I
  • lorrie 2012/08/16 04:19:28
    I am a moral person not a religious person
    lorrie
    +2
    Religion was created just to torment the rest of us. People use religion to justify thier horrible behaviour towards one another. The only higher power is within ourselves but we have been oppressed and brainwashed to believe otherwise. We have been led to believe that we need governments to control us.
  • bob lorrie 2012/08/16 14:39:53
    bob
    +1
    very true
  • Patent1 2012/08/16 04:02:06
    Undecided
    Patent1
    What, 3 questions in 3 days with a progression toward the degenerate cases of religion? You are doing a study?
  • bob Patent1 2012/08/16 14:41:12
    bob
    it would be nice to know. In the end knowledge is the only think you can really call your own
  • mikeeonly 2012/08/16 03:44:13
    I am spiritual and I believe that no man can define GOD or can claim that GOD...
    mikeeonly
    +1
    I believe, but not in organized religion
  • joan.sloane 2012/08/16 03:22:37
    All religions are just tribal and myth in nature
    joan.sloane
    +2
    That is my personal opinion. I have come to the conclusion that most of what we are taught to be true in life is not what it seems. Religion is one of the many falsehoods we have been brain washed into believing since childhood.
  • james.harper.758737 2012/08/16 02:23:43
    I am spiritual and I believe that no man can define GOD or can claim that GOD...
    james.harper.758737
    +1
    As a qabalist, i think the true nature of god is unknowable.
    Although I also believe that all religions are true; and alll gods are real.
  • Tastentier 2012/08/16 02:07:31 (edited)
    All religions are not just tribal and myth in nature
    Tastentier
    +1
    Tribal religions are belief systems that are limited to a single tribe or ethnic group. These religions are usually passed on through oral tradition rather than written manuscripts and are non-missionary, meaning that practicioners / believers don't attempt to spread their faith among nonbelievers.

    World religions like Christianity, Islam or Buddhism are not tribal in nature. Neither are non-missionary state religions, such as the Ancient Roman or Egyptian religions. Judaism started out as a tribal religion (Abraham was a nomadic chieftain) but turned into a state religion and later into a non-missionary world religion.
  • ZB 2012/08/16 01:21:59
    All religions are not just tribal and myth in nature
    ZB
    Except to those that don't feel they need to believe. We"ll see whose right when we die.
  • bob ZB 2012/08/16 14:42:54 (edited)
    bob
    not necessarly, it may take many more lives before you can look back on your history
  • Bob P. Clarkson 2012/08/16 00:52:22
    All religions are not just tribal and myth in nature
    Bob P. Clarkson
    Only if higher mathematics is tribal and mythic in nature.
  • bob Bob P. ... 2012/08/16 14:46:11
    bob
    In our history, higher mathematics were used to control a tribe. In reality it's knowledge, and people w/o the knowledge believe it's magical
  • skroehr 2012/08/16 00:37:59
    None of the above
    skroehr
  • Nam Era Vet #1 DNA TLC 2012/08/16 00:16:29
    None of the above
    Nam Era Vet #1 DNA TLC
    +2
    Another religious question. LOL
  • ZB Nam Era... 2012/08/16 01:24:28
    ZB
    +1
    not happy unless he's bashing someone.
  • Nam Era... ZB 2012/08/16 01:35:32
    Nam Era Vet #1 DNA TLC
    +1
    Yep I think I'm beginning to catch on. LOL
  • ZB Nam Era... 2012/08/16 17:32:27
    ZB
    +1
    It took me a while too. Don't feel bad.
  • mind-pilot 2012/08/15 23:29:44
    All religions are just tribal and myth in nature
    mind-pilot
    +1
    Absolutely created before mankind had the computer,tv or radio.....and man was it boring back then too.
  • VERYwiseguy 2012/08/15 23:20:40
    All religions are just tribal and myth in nature
    VERYwiseguy
    +2
    History 101.
  • bob h. 2012/08/15 23:03:38
    I am spiritual and I believe that no man can define GOD or can claim that GOD...
    bob h.
    +1
    I believe that man can live on three levels. 1)multiple personality, most politician types, 2) center/soul/essence and lives accordingly/ 3) spirit living in the collective. Anything past that is unknowable by man. Spirituality is striving upwards, religion is slipping downwards. If not for the tax free status, would there really be a Scientology, Kabbala, 7th Day Adventist, Mormonism, Jehovah's Witnesses, and a thousand others?
  • Bob P. ... bob h. 2012/08/16 01:03:59
    Bob P. Clarkson
    You appear you might be wise, but you've forgotten simple history, even as recently as .....seconds ago.

    Is Islam taxed in the Middle East? Are Hindus taxed in India? Are Atheists taxed anywhere.
    How about Catholicism in Italy?

    The WORLD is a very large place.

    Please remember, before the IRS, before the founding of our country, churches existed in what would become the United States - and no one was "wise" enough to tax them. No one was that ignorant of the consequences of, what in effect, would be at least political suicide.
  • bob Bob P. ... 2012/08/16 14:48:06
    bob
    as respective, the earth is a very small place in the universe.
  • bob h. Bob P. ... 2012/08/16 22:57:14
    bob h.
    Whoa...Islam, Catholicism and Hinduism are legit Religions.
  • bob bob h. 2012/08/16 14:47:10
    bob
    neat
  • HenriLewkowiczhenri 2012/08/15 23:01:19 (edited)
    All religions are just tribal and myth in nature
    HenriLewkowiczhenri
    +2
    " in god we trust "More then a myth ....a total delusion created by VERY smart peoples to control all the " others "
  • no no 2012/08/15 22:40:26
    None of the above
    no no
    +2
    From another post :Gods and eventually organized religions were created by primitive and evolving man to explain the unknown. The concept of omnipotent beings, objects, etc ascribed life-like attributes evolved into organized religions to help and assist in explaining the unknown and the existence of mankind. As the evolution continued, one dominant concept of a god took hold and was spread through myths and fables. Not being satisfied with an invisible one, some had to bring back into existence again a life-like human form to help explain and continue to promulgate the god concept. A concept with subtle threats, that if you don't do as I say and I do, you will not have a good after life.
    As mankind's knowledge base increases, the less of fables and myths is needed.
  • Bob P. ... no no 2012/08/16 01:23:56
    Bob P. Clarkson
    "Subtle threats"?

    Such as your father might make to keep you in line as a child "....., or else!"

    Anyone who claims they "know" how things are, is simply involved in self-hypnosis. Religions require faith. If you are a Darwinist, you need to dig deep to find where Darwin admitted that his theory couldn't explain the human eye, and thus his entire theory should be put in question.

    Even after all these years, evolution is still just another theory. Creationism is also a theory, except if you are not a gambler and base your life on faith.

    A simple example: If you are a gambler and have no faith in God, then when you die, the only thing that will happen is that you die. I will then be in the same position as you. As a person of faith, I believe that there is a "beyond" and that we are all sinners. I believe that at the end of my life, we will be judged by Grace. In that case, you would be eternally confined to a lake of fire while I went on to what my essence (soul) was directed to do.

    As a gambler, 50% odds, pure chance, is not a smart bet. You can't "hedge" your bet here, can't buy insurance. You either open your heart and have faith, or you don't - with consequences as stated.
  • joan.sl... Bob P. ... 2012/08/16 03:42:31
    joan.sloane
    Okay, so here’s the thing. I really, truly, honestly do not believe in any shape, manner or form in any part of this fantasy. So are you suggesting that I can decide to pretend to play the game just in case I am wrong? Is this going to fool God into opening the gates of heaven to me.

    I have no fear of hell because it doesn’t exist. It would be insane of me to pretend I did.
  • no no Bob P. ... 2012/08/18 15:46:11
    no no
    The concept of an "after life" if you are "good" is a simple manifestation of what happens to me when I die carried from primitive man until today. Why would a life be created, destroyed and then transformed into some mystical after place. Why not just stick with the original and let man live forever in the present life. Thus, the evolving religious cults to promulgate a reason. Makes no sense. Look around us, when anything dies, it eventually is reduced to some form of waste, sometimes reusable and sometimes not.. Bottom line. That collective "souls" will live someplace forever stretches the imagination. The lyrics from an old song says something to the effect, "you're done when you're dead
    you rascal you." Religions require more than faith, most require the belief that one can live forever.. it is the belief in immortality. Perhaps IT placing faith in someone or something that can assist with being immortal.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/25 04:14:38

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals