Quantcast

5 Dead, 15 Missing in Italian Shipwreck: Are You Less Likely to Take a Cruise Given the Costa Concordia Tragedy?

SodaHead News 2012/01/15 02:49:26
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Answer all questions about the cruise line accident in our Costa Concordia quick poll.

100 years after the loss of the RMS Titanic, another luxury cruise ship has now experienced maritime disaster. On Friday the 13th, with over 4,000 individuals onboard, the Costa Concordia ran aground off the coast of Tuscany, flipping the ship on its side and tearing a 160-foot gash in its hull.

costa concordia shipwreck

So far 5 deaths have been reported, over 30 individuals are injured, and 15 others remain unaccounted for—though they may be in hospitals and shelters. Late Saturday night, rescuers found two survivors, one man and one woman, inside the ship after hearing their screams. A third survivor was found alive and onboard early Sunday morning.

The timing is not the only thing that brings back memories of the Titanic tragedy. According to survivors, the chaotic escape from the Costa Concordia could have been pulled straight from the movie. There are reports of passengers running, screaming, falling down stairs, and crawling on their knees in the dark attempting to escape. There were also individuals fighting over lifejackets and others falling or jumping overboard, leading some to suffer from hypothermia.

According to passenger Benji Smith of Boston, a lifeboat crew member instructed those boarding that it was “women and children first,” requiring family members to split up. Many men refused to go along with this plan, resulting in great confusion.

The cause of the wreck is still unknown, but ship’s captain was detained late Saturday and is being investigated under manslaughter allegations, as well as for his decision to abandon ship before many of the passengers were rescued.

Many questions remain: Why did the boat hit a reef to close to the Tuscan island of Giglio? Did a power failure cause the crew to lose control? Did the captain steer the ship in the wrong direction on purpose? Why did it take so long for crew members to tell the passengers that they were in danger?

The Costa Concordia, owned by the U.S.-based cruise giant Carnival Corp., was built in 2004-2005 at a cost of 450 million euros ($570.7 million) at the Fincantieri Sestri shipyard in Italy.

How does this tragedy affect you? Does it make you less likely to take a cruise?

Read More: http://www.cnn.com/2012/01/14/world/europe/italy-c...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Gordon 2012/01/16 00:09:47
    Yes
    Gordon
    Especially on Costa or Carnival ships. This sounds like a tragedy of errors from A to Z.
  • beck 2012/01/15 23:45:18
    No
    beck
    +4
    sh*t happens.
  • thє вlu... beck 2012/01/16 00:32:15
  • Kat Elliott 2012/01/15 23:31:06
    No
    Kat Elliott
    +1
    I am going to take a cruise in February.
  • thє вlu... Kat Ell... 2012/01/16 00:33:50
  • Kat Ell... thє вlu... 2012/01/16 00:41:08
    Kat Elliott
    Sorry the tickets have already been bought.
  • Dynasty Fighter 2012/01/15 23:17:21
    Yes
    Dynasty Fighter
    +2
    Oh my God if they were that close to land then why the hell didn't they swim to shore
  • thє вlu... Dynasty... 2012/01/16 00:35:47
  • Mrs. V 2012/01/15 23:04:42
    No
    Mrs. V
    +2
    I've been on a cruise in the Mediterranean. We passed the Rock of Gibralter headed out to Lisbon. Never got that close to shore.
  • DoxieDad 2012/01/15 22:38:16
    No
    DoxieDad
    +2
    Do we stop flying because an airliner crashes? Given the amount of cruise ships on the seas and the total number of safe cruise departures and returns. Cruise ships have one of the best safety records of any passenger transportation. In the aftermath of this accident those of us who do cruise will pay more attention to where the life preservers and life boats are given the fact that the crew became a mass of confusion.
  • Oli 2012/01/15 22:01:32
    No
    Oli
    +1
    For a tragedy, i think they were pretty lucky that they weren't out in the middle of the ocean.
  • glasspixel 2012/01/15 21:59:00
    No
    glasspixel
    +1
    Accidents happen on everything, this incident made the outcome even worse by not having clear cut instructions on what to do in case of an emergency.
  • SOM3RANDOMDUD3 2012/01/15 21:58:31
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    SOM3RANDOMDUD3
    +5
    A shipwreck...on Friday the 13th? Coincidence? I THINK NOT!!!
  • Kat Ell... SOM3RAN... 2012/01/15 23:32:40
    Kat Elliott
    I don't trust that date either.
  • S123 SOM3RAN... 2012/01/16 02:09:22
    S123
    Okay, so cruses are fine, as long as it isn't friday the 13th. Good to know.
  • VampireKisses<3 2012/01/15 21:29:38
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    VampireKisses<3
    +3
    At this exact moment Celine Dion looked up and knew that another ship had sunk :P
  • joe mauro 2012/01/15 21:26:22
    No
    joe mauro
    +1
    i have on cruise ships,it would not effect me one way or another,accidents like these are usually preventiable
  • HiYa 2012/01/15 21:14:51
    Yes
    HiYa
    +1
    My family was planning one this year. Now we're not entirely certain.
  • TeardropsOfBlood4The1iiLove♥ 2012/01/15 21:06:34
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    TeardropsOfBlood4The1iiLove♥
    +1
    I dont like cruises.
  • AN 2012/01/15 21:03:48
    No
    AN
    +4
    It's so sad & very irresponsible of the caption to abandon the cruise before most of the passengers. It wouldn't stop me from taking a cruise though, cuz accidents happen! with every single mean of transportation; cars, buses, planes...etc.
    But do u think it's fair to compare it to titanic?? I mean thank god there aren't a lot of deaths (of course it's sad that some ppl died, but Titanic was way more tragic with 1517 deaths).
  • HiYa AN 2012/01/15 21:17:50
    HiYa
    Good point!
  • wqerwqerwe 2012/01/15 21:02:32
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    wqerwqerwe
    I like to think I am a good enough swimmer and diver that I could escape an incident like this. But, the dynamics of a sinking ship this size are much different than smaller boats and has enough force to kill you in many ways.
  • 16 2012/01/15 20:59:26
    No
    16
    +2
    Taking one this summer.
  • Tommy 2012/01/15 20:56:45
    No
    Tommy
    +1
    Not a chance that this accident would put me off. I'm not sure if a cruise appeals to me though. I suppose the setting could be quite romantic - standing on the deck with your sweetheart, looking out to a full moon that is reflecting on to a calm Mediterranean.
  • Shawna Tommy 2012/01/16 07:12:14
    Shawna
    +1
    Not so romantic if either one of you gets sea sick.
  • Tommy Shawna 2012/01/16 15:10:30
    Tommy
    +1
    True - vomiting has never had much of a place in a romantic setting....

    "Wait.... hold that thought....." BLAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHH (wipes mouth) "Okay.... where were we?"
  • Shawna Tommy 2012/01/16 17:44:06
    Shawna
    +1
    EEEEeeeeeeeeewwwwwwwwwwwwwwww...
  • Annie Innecco 2012/01/15 20:56:40
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    Annie Innecco
    +1
    I get seasick really easily S:
  • ericaascherhager 2012/01/15 20:44:33
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    ericaascherhager
    I certainly cant afford a cruise -- oh well maybe the prices will come down -- but if I were a cruise person this would make me less likely
  • ConLibFraud 2012/01/15 20:32:14
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    ConLibFraud
    +1
    Cruise Ship! Come On! You are begging for disaster and tragedy!!!
  • Beverly L Ottney 2012/01/15 20:24:35
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    Beverly L Ottney
    +1
    Would only trust a Military Transport Ship or an Aircraft Carrier. Took a Military Transport Ship to Hawaii, and a family day out to sea on the Dwight D Eisenhower and a family day out to sea on the US Independency.
  • Wendy 2012/01/15 20:22:13
    No
    Wendy
    +1
    Although with some crazy people killing their other half on some cruises, you do only live once so I would take a cruise anyday.
  • theresa rodriguez 2012/01/15 20:15:51
    Yes
    theresa rodriguez
    i don't think cruises are not all that safe anyway. because of being isolated, your more prone to contagions, for some of the time your in international waters where laws don't apply. and if there is an emergency, your at the mercy of the crew.
  • KendraTaylor 2012/01/15 20:13:37
    No
    KendraTaylor
    +1
    I'm a bit confused by a section of the article. Why would the captain have manslaughter charges against him when it's human nature to think of survival. Would it be great if he was a good sumaritan and helped everyone to the life boats, calmed what-surely would've been a huge group of hysterical passengers, yes, but is it mandatory to stay on a boat that's sinking and forget about the necessity to live? No. Also, why in the world would the captain steer the boat in the wrong direction...on purpose.
  • Tommy KendraT... 2012/01/15 20:19:56
    Tommy
    +3
    He deliberately beached the ship to minimise loss of life. Had he not done this, the fate of this ship would have been more akin to that of the Titanic.
  • susan Tommy 2012/01/15 21:59:51
    susan
    Good point, Tommy. The captain of the ship I was on in Antarctica when it hit a rock did the same. He moved the ship nearer the shore just in case.
  • Tommy susan 2012/01/15 22:37:05
    Tommy
    +2
    I'm sure it's training they never think they'll need to use! Poor guy carries the can for this - all part of the job I suppose.
  • KendraT... Tommy 2012/01/16 13:35:36
    KendraTaylor
    Oh, that's good then! Hopefully that argument will be brought up if charges of manslaughter are against him. Thank you for giving me that tid bit of information!
  • Tommy KendraT... 2012/01/16 15:16:37
    Tommy
    +1
    Why the sarcasm? He almost certainly will be charged with manslaughter. I am sure we have all made mistakes in jobs and in life but if you are a ship's captain, an airline pilot, a surgeon or an air-traffic controller (list not exhaustive) - one mistake can have catastrophic consequences.
  • KendraT... Tommy 2012/01/17 02:06:50
    KendraTaylor
    +1
    But what is his mistake? And I wasn't being sarcastic, I meant it when I said thank you.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/19 18:27:49

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals