Quantcast

5 Dead, 15 Missing in Italian Shipwreck: Are You Less Likely to Take a Cruise Given the Costa Concordia Tragedy?

SodaHead News 2012/01/15 02:49:26
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Answer all questions about the cruise line accident in our Costa Concordia quick poll.

100 years after the loss of the RMS Titanic, another luxury cruise ship has now experienced maritime disaster. On Friday the 13th, with over 4,000 individuals onboard, the Costa Concordia ran aground off the coast of Tuscany, flipping the ship on its side and tearing a 160-foot gash in its hull.

costa concordia shipwreck

So far 5 deaths have been reported, over 30 individuals are injured, and 15 others remain unaccounted for—though they may be in hospitals and shelters. Late Saturday night, rescuers found two survivors, one man and one woman, inside the ship after hearing their screams. A third survivor was found alive and onboard early Sunday morning.

The timing is not the only thing that brings back memories of the Titanic tragedy. According to survivors, the chaotic escape from the Costa Concordia could have been pulled straight from the movie. There are reports of passengers running, screaming, falling down stairs, and crawling on their knees in the dark attempting to escape. There were also individuals fighting over lifejackets and others falling or jumping overboard, leading some to suffer from hypothermia.

According to passenger Benji Smith of Boston, a lifeboat crew member instructed those boarding that it was “women and children first,” requiring family members to split up. Many men refused to go along with this plan, resulting in great confusion.

The cause of the wreck is still unknown, but ship’s captain was detained late Saturday and is being investigated under manslaughter allegations, as well as for his decision to abandon ship before many of the passengers were rescued.

Many questions remain: Why did the boat hit a reef to close to the Tuscan island of Giglio? Did a power failure cause the crew to lose control? Did the captain steer the ship in the wrong direction on purpose? Why did it take so long for crew members to tell the passengers that they were in danger?

The Costa Concordia, owned by the U.S.-based cruise giant Carnival Corp., was built in 2004-2005 at a cost of 450 million euros ($570.7 million) at the Fincantieri Sestri shipyard in Italy.

How does this tragedy affect you? Does it make you less likely to take a cruise?

Read More: http://www.cnn.com/2012/01/14/world/europe/italy-c...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Krissy 2012/01/15 04:33:12
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    Krissy
    +1
    Its unlikly to happen often...if it was really dangerous they probably wouldnt have the cruises
  • zbacku 2012/01/15 04:30:42
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    zbacku
    +1
    Heck, been out of work for almost 3 years with no job in sight. A cruise is the last thing on my mind.
  • Waiting in the Wings 2012/01/15 04:19:58
    Yes
    Waiting in the Wings
    +1
    My prayers are with the people. What are the chances that it'll happen to me?
  • Cowboy ... Waiting... 2012/01/15 05:16:32
    Cowboy Tough
    +1
    Slim chance
  • Nadrasta 2012/01/15 04:17:16
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    Nadrasta
    +2
    I went on a cruise once and didn't really care for it. I'd rather have spent less time on the ship and more time on the island we went to. =/
  • Chris D 2012/01/15 04:14:45 (edited)
    Yes
    Chris D
    +1
    stay off those boats!

    titanic
  • I NEED A HORSE 2012/01/15 04:10:10 (edited)
  • Alexandria I NEED ... 2012/01/15 04:56:08
  • michele I NEED ... 2012/01/15 05:15:35
    michele
    +1
    Apparently by some answers on here, they would!
  • Cowboy ... michele 2012/01/15 05:18:49
  • Cowboy ... I NEED ... 2012/01/15 05:18:17
    Cowboy Tough
    +1
    Lol we do get stupid questions on this site sometimes
  • Beat Magnum True Hero 2012/01/15 04:04:27
    No
    Beat Magnum True Hero
    +1
    Only 52% voted "no?" Man people spook easily.
  • Cowboy ... Beat Ma... 2012/01/15 05:20:25
    Cowboy Tough
    if your voteing no that still means you're going on cruises
  • Adam Julian 2012/01/15 03:58:30
    No
    Adam Julian
    +1
    Still beats going on a plane.
  • Eania 2012/01/15 03:48:23
    No
    Eania
    +2
    If you're destined to die, or be injured, or even be involved, than it will happen regardless of where you happen to be.
    Fatalistic? Maybe.
    But it's easier to through life that way.
  • Cowboy ... Eania 2012/01/15 05:21:35
  • Eania Cowboy ... 2012/01/15 08:17:06
    Eania
    Believe it or not, I fail to understand your point.
    is that a good thing or a bad thing to you?
  • jbandff5lover 2012/01/15 03:46:18
    No
    jbandff5lover
    +3
    Meh I went on my first cruise last year and I'm going on one later in May! I'm not less likely to go on another cruise the same way one plane crash doesn't make someone forgoe plane travel forever. Accidents happen sadly =/
  • Cowboy ... jbandff... 2012/01/15 05:22:50
  • **StarzAbove** 2012/01/15 03:45:31
    No
    **StarzAbove**
    +2
    I've been on quite a few cruises and I love them. If I get the chance to go again, I will. Accidents happen all the time with cars, planes and ships.
  • Cowboy ... **Starz... 2012/01/15 05:23:50
  • Axe Grinder 2012/01/15 03:42:51
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    Axe Grinder
    For me personally, a cruise seems like a crappy way to spend a vacation anyway. I love the beach, and the ocean, but I don't want to be stuck out there in the middle of it....and that ladies and gents, is my 2 cents !!
  • The Yogurt Cup 2012/01/15 03:37:35
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    The Yogurt Cup
    Titanic kind of disturbed me... I have a fear if cruise ships now
  • Cowboy ... The Yog... 2012/01/15 05:24:58
    Cowboy Tough
    Lol your fine dont worry about it
  • The Yog... Cowboy ... 2012/01/15 22:18:17
    The Yogurt Cup
    Hmm.. Are u sure???
  • SmithBandit 2012/01/15 03:36:52
    No
    SmithBandit
    the people will be more careful now than ever
  • nofrills 2012/01/15 03:34:10
    No
    nofrills
    getting that sinking feeling.
  • whimsycrat 2012/01/15 03:33:22
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    whimsycrat
    I had a friend describe their cruise as being in really nice prison with very good food. That doesn't appeal to me much. Plus there always seems to be something going on on these cruise ships. Though the news seems to be getting better. Outbreaks of gastrointestinal illness on cruise ships is apparently at a multi-year low.

    http://travel.usatoday.com/cr...

    Only 11 outbreaks compared to 30 outbreaks in 2006. I think 2006 was the year that put the end to any desire to take a cruise that I might have had.
  • luke 2012/01/15 03:25:16
    No
    luke
    +2
    I didn't become so irrationally afraid to fly after 911, I didn't become irrationally afraid to take the subway/public transit after the London bombings, so I'm certainly not going to become irrationally afraid to go on a boat.
  • NPC 2012/01/15 03:21:34
    Yes
    NPC
    +1
    I have taken several cruises and they are over rated.
  • Nicole 2012/01/15 03:19:39
    No
    Nicole
    +1
    O my gosh i ADORE cruises!!!! I've been on many and will go on many more! Lol i LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE cruises! :D
  • Theresa 2012/01/15 03:16:32
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    Theresa
    +1
    Oh boy..now I'll never go on a cruise... Posidon adventure
  • Nicole Theresa 2012/01/15 03:20:57
    Nicole
    I saw that before i went on my first cruise and it never really worried me :/
  • Theresa Nicole 2012/04/11 11:35:09
    Theresa
    Something about the ocean ...even the largest ship..seems like a dot on her surface..and she is a fickle body ..the ocean..sometimes she lies still and smooth and others?? Well she dances and spins and churns ..she is mistress to many but she is frightful to me....I enjoy waves lapping at her shores and even then she will reach out almost without warning and soak my blanket and belongings Lol enough of my musings have a great day Nicole..
  • Aspect of B 2012/01/15 03:13:34
    No
    Aspect of B
    +1
    But it is extremely tragic.
  • TheNightFly 2012/01/15 03:08:31
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    TheNightFly
    Severe motion sickness.
  • louisa 2012/01/15 03:01:55
    I was unlikely to take a cruise in the first place!
    louisa
    I don't like the thought of being on a huge ship, don't know why, just never liked it.
  • Robbb 2012/01/15 02:59:31
    No
    Robbb
    +2
    No. If I thought like that I would have to leave my car parked in the drive as well. and how could I cross the street if I did that.
  • Depsycho 2012/01/15 02:55:35
    No
    Depsycho
    +5
    ONE accident does NOT mean every cruise ship in the area is going to turn over and end horrifically.

    Come on, this is NOT a reason to avoid cruise ships and/or the area this happened to occur in.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

News & Politics

2013/05/21 07:41:44

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals