Question Religion

Would this mean God doesn't exist?

Twisted Jesse November 07, 2009 05:40:13

If their were other intelligent beings somewhere out in the universe wouldn't that kind of prove God doesn't exist? I would think so because if Jesus died for our sins who died for theirs? Or would they have their own bible with different books and a different Jesus?
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Answer
  • +2 raves nightlight November 07, 2009 15:18:13
    nightlight
    We don't need to find other intelligent beings "somewhere out in the universe" to know that God doesn't exist. There's already no proof that he does exist.
    View thread
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Answers
  • ♥♥_pinklover19_♥♥
    prove first their existence before questioning God's existence..

    only the humans are the intelligent beings created by God.,
  • Twisted Jesse
    I'm not questioning his existence. Its just a fun thought I had a while ago
  • +1 raves
    emem November 09, 2009 12:51:56
    emem
    there isnt any proof that he DOES exsist. Because he DOESN'T exsist.
  • Twisted... emem November 09, 2009 21:01:15
    Twisted Jesse
    There also isn't any proof showing that he doesn't exist either.
  • +1 raves
    seathan... Twisted... November 09, 2009 22:02:59
    seathanaich
    The same can be said for unicorns and fairies. This is not a comparison that I would want to invite if I believed in a god.
  • Twisted... seathan... November 09, 2009 22:04:48
    Twisted Jesse
    True however its hard to prove something is there when he doen't want to show proof of himself.
  • seathan... Twisted... November 09, 2009 22:06:11
    seathanaich
    I agree. It's odd that some people claim their god doesn't want to show "him"self, while other believers of the same god claim that that god has done so. Makes it a bit confusing for those of us on the outside, looking in. Cheers.
  • +1 raves
    God's Child November 09, 2009 00:18:43
    God's Child
    The Bible says nothing about angels needing to be saved.

    Deuteronomy 29:29 (New International Version)
    29 The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things revealed belong to us and to our children forever, that we may follow all the words of this law.
  • Twisted... God's C... November 09, 2009 03:01:30
    Twisted Jesse
    I did not imply on meaning angels just like another type of being on another planet.
  • +1 raves
    God's C... Twisted... November 09, 2009 13:18:11
    God's Child
    show me one ounce of proof that there is life on other planets. Impossible!!!! The X Files is not proof.
  • Twisted... God's C... November 09, 2009 21:02:30
    Twisted Jesse
    Well I can't and I'm not saying there is silly. Its just something to think about don't take it as seriousness because thats not what I'm doing it was just something fun to think about with all the possibilities.
  • +1 raves
    God's C... Twisted... November 09, 2009 23:37:25
    God's Child
    It is a good "what if" question. If there is, I hope they are more intelligent then us.

    And No, that would not make the Jesus myth look silly. I would fall under this verse in the Bible.
    Deuteronomy 29:29 (New International Version)
    29 The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things revealed belong to us and to our children forever, that we may follow all the words of this law.
  • +1 raves
    seathanaich November 07, 2009 23:10:08
    seathanaich
    Yes, other planets with life on them makes the Jesus myth look even more silly than it already does.

    And if you count up the number of stars in the sky, it's pretty likely that there is some other planet where intelligent life evolved . . .
  • Twisted... seathan... November 08, 2009 05:53:16
    Twisted Jesse
    Jesus myth? So you are saying Jesus was a myth even though he has been proven to of existed?
  • +1 raves
    seathan... Twisted... November 08, 2009 19:07:38 (edited)
    seathanaich
    I was unaware that the existence of the Jesus character had been proven. Proof is only usually possible in things like math. In most fields of study, and in law, it is evidence which is the standard by which claims are evaluated. If there is any evidence for the Jesus character, this must be very recent news I haven't read yet. What's your source?
  • Twisted... seathan... November 09, 2009 21:08:36
    Twisted Jesse
    As soon as I can find it I will let you know. I read about it somewhere. They said he was a real man, he existed. So I will just have to get back to you on this sorry.
  • +1 raves
    seathan... Twisted... November 09, 2009 22:00:57
    seathanaich
    No problem - it's hard to copy everything that you will end up needing at some point. Cheers.
  • Twisted... seathan... November 09, 2009 22:03:06
    Twisted Jesse
    Yeah and I kind of agve up searching for it I got bored so I guess you win haha
  • seathan... Twisted... November 09, 2009 22:04:48
    seathanaich
    No - I don't "win". I am being genuine when I say that I understand how hard it is to remember to save a copy of everything you find interesting. Cheers.
  • +2 raves
    nightlight November 07, 2009 15:18:13
    nightlight
    We don't need to find other intelligent beings "somewhere out in the universe" to know that God doesn't exist. There's already no proof that he does exist.
  • +1 raves
    mrigor nightlight November 07, 2009 19:07:14
    mrigor
    But there is high certainty that it doesn't exist. No proof can be provided for non-existence.
  • nightlight mrigor 1 day ago
    nightlight
    I didn't say that there was no proof for God's non-existence as I would never try to prove a negative because that's impossible. What I did say was that there is no proof for God's existence.
  • +1 raves
    Yukkione "In Science We Trust" November 07, 2009 15:10:12
    Yukkione
    It's estimated that there are approximately 10,000 Earth like plants in just our galaxy.Given the number of galaxies in this Universe it would stand to reason that there is a lot of life out there. of course if a God created this Universe then it would have created all the life in it... it might not have made all that life the same. Maybe he made some species without sin. All speculation though. Personally I do not believe in the concept of sin or original sin. But it's fun to think about.
  • +1 raves
    Captain Sticky November 07, 2009 14:19:56
    Captain Sticky
    It depends on if they're as screwed up as we are.
  • +1 raves
    Fundy November 07, 2009 12:17:09
    Fundy
    Your logic is flawed you are assuming that our sin would apply to them. If they were sinners then they would need a savior, it is entirely possible God would provide. But why assume that they would be sinners? Why not instead assume that they resisted temptation and never experienced original sin, thus never breaching their relationship with the Father?
  • Twisted... Fundy November 08, 2009 05:49:36
    Twisted Jesse
    Well if you were to read further on to what else I was saying with others I said that to. And its not logic at all it was just a random thought that came to mind I'm not really trying to disprove God just wondered it.
  • +1 raves
    Fundy Twisted... November 08, 2009 06:54:01
    Fundy
    I wonder about stuff like that too. Mind just wanders around. When I was younger I use to wonder if we were like an ant far for God.
  • +1 raves
    @rancidchick_17 November 07, 2009 09:46:00
    @rancidchick_17
    good qestion . i have no idea what it would mean
  • +2 raves
    Death November 07, 2009 09:40:50
    Death
    They would probably know the difference between 'their' 'there' and 'they're' at least.
  • +1 raves
    Twisted... Death November 08, 2009 05:47:43
    Twisted Jesse
    Haha sorry I didn't even realize that thanks I'll fix the description
  • +2 raves
    WTF, Liz. November 07, 2009 07:17:58
    WTF, Liz.



    that just happened.
  • Twisted... WTF, Liz. November 07, 2009 08:16:34
    Twisted Jesse
    Lmao what does this have to do with anything hahahaha if I could give you more than just 1 rave I'd give that 100 lol
  • +1 raves
    WTF, Liz. Twisted... November 08, 2009 00:25:30
    WTF, Liz.
    nothing. I just choose the most opposite video of the question.

    Kicks and giggles, and maybe some name calling...
  • +1 raves
    Bobbie November 07, 2009 06:15:38
    Bobbie
    God created all, including the universe, He is well aware of other intelligent beings, if there are other worlds, because he would have created them. Interesting movie called "Enemy Mine". Humans and aliens at war. One human, one alien crashed on uninhabited planet. Shorten the story by saying they became friends, learned to communicate. The alien was reading a book and when the human asked him to translate he started reading "In the beginning..." It was the Bible. God is not limited to earth as he created the entire universe.

    Interesting question because if there is other life elsewhere, did they have their Eve who ate the forbidden fruit? Or did they not commit an original sin and live harmoniously with total love and worship of God, in which case God would be walking among them as he did with Adam in the Garden of Eden--in which case there would have been no need for the saviour to come and die for their sins that they may be saved. Or, was there a different original sin--without a forbidden fruit?? And if it were a perfect world, is Satan there also, as he is here, trying to inject evil into that civilization, lure the faithful from God?

    Very, very interesting question. I would like to see other replies on this also. What massive possibilities--this could test the imagination to the hilt! Thank you Jesse.
  • Twisted... Bobbie November 07, 2009 06:20:23
    Twisted Jesse
    I wondered the same about Eve and all kinds of other things would they have the same events or completely different ones its sounds pretty crazy. And your welcome =)
  • +1 raves
    frere November 07, 2009 06:04:52
    frere
    Does it say anywhere in the bible that humans are the only sentient beings in the universe? Really, I don't know.
  • Twisted... frere November 07, 2009 06:07:38 (edited)
    Twisted Jesse
    Nope it doesn't say it anywhere that I know of so who knows.
  • +1 raves
    frere Twisted... November 07, 2009 06:10:04
    frere
    Then probably not.

    Hell, sin might even be an exclusive human thing.
  • Twisted... frere November 07, 2009 06:11:47
    Twisted Jesse
    Yeah maybe their Eve didn't screw up and they stayed perfect lol
  • +1 raves
    Captain... Twisted... November 07, 2009 14:19:13
    Captain Sticky
    Now THAT'S a great point! Did Sformlat eat the growlf?
or
Cancel