SodaHead Celebrates Green Week

Question Religion

Christians: Do You Celebrate Halloween the "Traditional" Way?

♥Nicole~M♥ October 31, 2009 21:48:52

All of my Christian neighbors wont have halloween parties, wont let their kids trick or treat and wont let them dress up. They have fall harvest get togethers at church instead with just games and candy. So I was wondering if there are Christians out there that celebrate it the traditional way with dressing up in costumes, trick or treating, decorating their house and having halloween parties.
Yes because...
No because...
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Comment
  • +6 raves Scars Remain (aka Vicki) October 31, 2009 22:28:32
    Scars Remain (aka Vicki)

    No because...

    My youngest is now 15 years old. When he was young enough to celebrate it the traditional way, we still didn't.
    I found harvest parties to be safer and a more enjoyable venue for my children.
    The one I would take them to, was at a ranch, where we were served hot dogs, chips, and soda. We also had pony rides, horse or tractor drawn hayrides, inflatables, rock climbing walls, etc.
    It appealed to all ages, not just those under 14 years old.

    http://www.holyghostwienerroa...
    View thread
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • Cesare B. November 14, 2009 07:35:34
    Cesare B.

    No because...

    I do not celebrate Halloween at all. The games and candy is what we do for Thanksgiving.
  • Whitese7en "by JESUS blood ... November 02, 2009 08:36:38
    Whitese7en

    No because...

    We don't celebrate it or recognize it in any way in our home.
  • PixelJunkie November 02, 2009 03:37:39
    PixelJunkie

    No because...

    This year I put a paper facade on my house to make it look like the WH, well sort of. I wore an 0bama mask and when the kids came to the door looking for treats, I took theirs.
  • Magic Twanger November 01, 2009 23:18:24
    Magic Twanger

    Yes because...

    I am not legalistic, it is a night for fun. I don't judge on the matter of all hallows eve.
  • myssabz November 01, 2009 21:22:42
    myssabz

    Yes because...

    Even though my family and I are Christian I had never heard that it was not a Christian holiday until a few years back. So Yes, we/I have celebrated it the traditional way as well as at church and private parties. We do it with the right spirit of loving and giving and sharing joy.
  • jer1five November 01, 2009 17:08:33
    jer1five

    No because...

    When my kids were little we did in a limited way - only went to houses of friends and did the fall festival kind of things at our church. Now I just hide in my house with the lights off and hope no one comes to the door.
  • ldavidson88 November 01, 2009 17:06:00
    ldavidson88

    Yes because...

    My family enjoys it together, in LOVE...
    We take control over Evils that day, by making fun of it...simple.
  • kmay November 01, 2009 16:32:11 (edited)
    kmay

    Yes because...

    It depends on how you treat it ---------- teaching your kids the significnce of all Holidays --------- what they mean and don't mean. Keep it's emphasis on the spriritual, allowing the fun side. Fall harvest seems to be more secular.

    A Short History....

    "All Saints Day traces its beginnings to the latter part of the third century AD. It was originally known as All Martyrs Day to honour those who had died for their Christian faith, but it was later extended to include all the faithful departed. At first All Saints Day was celebrated on the first Sunday after Pentecost. Though the Eastern Orthodox Church continues to observe it on this date, the Western (Catholic and Protestant) denominations moved it to the first of November. The term “saint” should be explained in more detail. Strictly speaking, the “saints” refer to all baptized members of the Church, living or dead.

    All Saints Day coincides with Halloween (literally a contraction of “All Hallows Evening,” the evening before All Saints, “hallow” being an Old English word meaning “holy”). Halloween is somewhat controversial from a Christian perspective. Some Christians consider it merely a secular holiday to be enjoyed by children and adults who want to dress up for the occasion.

    All Saints Day hasn’t been contaminated...

    It depends on how you treat it ---------- teaching your kids the significnce of all Holidays --------- what they mean and don't mean. Keep it's emphasis on the spriritual, allowing the fun side. Fall harvest seems to be more secular.

    A Short History....

    "All Saints Day traces its beginnings to the latter part of the third century AD. It was originally known as All Martyrs Day to honour those who had died for their Christian faith, but it was later extended to include all the faithful departed. At first All Saints Day was celebrated on the first Sunday after Pentecost. Though the Eastern Orthodox Church continues to observe it on this date, the Western (Catholic and Protestant) denominations moved it to the first of November. The term “saint” should be explained in more detail. Strictly speaking, the “saints” refer to all baptized members of the Church, living or dead.

    All Saints Day coincides with Halloween (literally a contraction of “All Hallows Evening,” the evening before All Saints, “hallow” being an Old English word meaning “holy”). Halloween is somewhat controversial from a Christian perspective. Some Christians consider it merely a secular holiday to be enjoyed by children and adults who want to dress up for the occasion.

    All Saints Day hasn’t been contaminated by the commercialism that has affected Christmas and Easter (holidays that I nonetheless love for their religious significance and emphasis on family). All Saints Day connects all the saints, of today and yesterday. Therefore it deserves to be celebrated.'

    from: With Good Reason
    (more)
  • Gun665 November 01, 2009 15:28:51
    Gun665

    Yes because...

    Well, if I had kids I would.
  • +1 raves
    Firekitty~ IS GIVING THANKS... November 01, 2009 15:27:08
    Firekitty~ IS GIVING THANKS AND MAKING CHRISTMAS CRACKLE~

    Yes because...

    Yes we do. It is all for fun... I did it as a kid and my kids do it too.
  • Attila November 01, 2009 15:12:41
    Attila

    No because...

    I don't celebrate it in any way, never have. My kids didn't and so far have not done so with my grandkids.
  • dreamwriter12 ➷in grammar I... November 01, 2009 15:11:11
    dreamwriter12 ➷in grammar I trust➷

    Yes because...

    Dressing up and going door to door asking for candy isn't evil to me. It's just letting kids have a bit of fun. I completely understand and respect others who disagree with me though.
  • Doc Ock November 01, 2009 13:28:13 (edited)
    Doc Ock

    No because...

    It's just harmless fun and not a day to worship Satan-and I am a Christian!
    (HIT THE WRONG BUTTON)
  • +1 raves
    jessiesgirl4463 November 01, 2009 08:21:51
    jessiesgirl4463

    Yes because...

    Im not sure if it's "traditional" but we usually have a fire and roast marshmellows, the kids dress up and get candy. Or they do the "trunk or treat" at the church. This year a large group gathered for the trunk or treat, our fire was rained out. In my group of little ones we had a fire ant, a prom queen and little bo peep and the kids had a blast!
  • xphile November 01, 2009 07:46:40
    xphile

    Yes because...

    Being scared is fun!!! However, I am about to have a baby so things will change. No more parties!! :( Now I will be buying decorations and costumes and going trick or treating with my child.
  • +1 raves
    Carl November 01, 2009 07:18:19
    Carl

    Yes because...

    a lot of churches and other volunteer organizations are having traditional Halloween parties. Costumes are encouraged, some have games, etc. Several churches in our area have set-up "trunk or treat" parties - usually located at a school, or church parking lot.
  • LeeVee- "This is NOT White ... November 01, 2009 06:37:30
    LeeVee-

    No because...

    It was an "idol" holiday to my wife and I before we were saved. We celebrated with large multi-keg parties at our home. It was bigger than Christmas, Easter, or Thanksgiving. Our oldest can barely remember the last time we had halloween at our home. We don't think it's wrong, just wrong for us. When our children were old enough (in their early teens), we explained to them fully, why we choose not to participate and gave them their choice. Now in their 20's, they have never chosen to participate in halloween, but do volunteer and dress up for Harvest Festivals at their or our church. I am an extremely Blessed man.
  • +2 raves
    ~1seahawksfan~ November 01, 2009 06:01:54
    ~1seahawksfan~

    Yes because...

    it's fun!! We do not go worship satan or anything. We dress up, trick or treat, decorate and I went to a party last night. Didn't make my faith in my Lord waver a bit!! But to each his own!!
  • +1 raves
    devontae jones November 01, 2009 04:55:19
    devontae jones

    No because...

    We sacrifice small candies.
  • ~1seaha... devonta... November 01, 2009 06:02:11
    ~1seahawksfan~
    lol
  • +1 raves
    Grey November 01, 2009 04:51:09
    Grey

    Yes because...

    IOh I love Halloween! I am a Christian and I love Christmas and it's meaning. But Halloween is such a great time for dressing up and putting skeletons and spooks on the porch and just kind of tempting the spirits.....LOL
  • +2 raves
    Linkums November 01, 2009 03:57:38
    Linkums

    Yes because...

    Yes, and all of the Christians I know personally (almost all of my friends and family) do as well.
  • +2 raves
    brunetbomb November 01, 2009 03:39:35
    brunetbomb

    Yes because...

    Yes. I decorate our house and we go trick or treating and have fun.We're not doing anything wrong and I see no harm in it.
  • +1 raves
    asalways just ed November 01, 2009 03:37:51
    asalways just ed

    Yes because...

    It a holiday made up to make money for retailers. Kids like it It goes no futher.Lets get on with our lifes a say none of my friends. They are freaks the. Christamas falls in line retailers.


    oh to much

    as always

    just ed
  • +1 raves
    rightside November 01, 2009 02:39:48
    rightside

    Yes because...

    When I first became a Christian, I thought it would be terrible to let my kids do this.
    Now, Trick or treat is just a fun way for the kids to rob from their neighbors!
    Nothing wrong with it.
  • +2 raves
    beagamer November 01, 2009 01:30:47
    beagamer

    Yes because...

    Not sure what traditional is. We usually have about 100 people over and we all get stupid drunk. This year was a bit different so we didn't do it. Oh yea, everyone dresses up really cool.
  • +1 raves
    Phyl *In God i Trust* November 01, 2009 00:55:22
    Phyl *In God i Trust*

    Yes because...

    The little kid's dress up to get candy, I hand out candy. Kid's don't go door to door as much as they did when i WAS LITTLE.
  • +1 raves
    N.Carolyne November 01, 2009 00:49:22
    N.Carolyne

    Yes because...

    For most kids, Halloween is just a night to dress up like a superhero and get gobs of free candy. They don't understand the origin behind it and don't care. It's been so commercialized by society that it doesn' t mean much anymore, like Christmas. So I see no reason not to let my kids trick or treat.

    I will however teach them the true meaning of Christmas, but see no reason to explain Halloween. They'll find out later on when they've outgrown it.
  • +1 raves
    Jo November 01, 2009 00:36:10
    Jo

    Yes because...

    I let my kids dress up, but not as anything evil.
  • Ace~Mr.Giantess~ November 01, 2009 00:35:00
    Ace~Mr.Giantess~

    No because...

    Never was interested.
  • +1 raves
    mach-1 November 01, 2009 00:34:12
    mach-1

    Yes because...

    Trick or treat for candy is fine and play dress up.
    It is when you represent evil or glorfiy it that it become wrong...Keep it simple and there is no harm in it.
  • +1 raves
    Shell November 01, 2009 00:29:26
    Shell

    No because...

    My Children are grown. Most churches have harvest parties and give out safe candy and treats. I do give out candy for trick or treaters because I know it's safe. I don't decorate for this Holiday!
  • +1 raves
    Ken November 01, 2009 00:08:41
    Ken

    Yes because...

    Costumes and candy for the kids is a fun thing, as long as you make it no more than that.
  • +3 raves
    Freed ~ If The Son makes yo... October 31, 2009 23:50:57
    Freed ~ If The Son makes you free, you are free indeed

    No because...

    Without a doubt, the harvest festival is one of the most notoriously popular church events of the year. Orchestrated to thank God for food and farmers, these festivals bring entire congregations together for fellowship and fun.

    1. Play dress up [adults too] and possibly have a prize for each catagory.
    Bible character; or doctors, ballarina, prince and princess.
    Or as all Saints Day [Nov. 1] Many alternatives for ghost and witches.
    >>>>Play games; bob for the apple; hand out treats can include the gospel message
    >>>>3. Provides a safe and fun enviornment

    2. Have Trunk or Treats.
    >>>Line up cars in the Church parking lot with trunks filled with candy.
    >>>This can be done in neighborhoods as well.
    >>>Possible wear Biblical costumes.
    >>>Hand out tracks.
    >>>Another safe alternative.

    3. Carve pumpkins with Christian symbols.
  • +3 raves
    Marlow ... Freed ~... November 01, 2009 00:37:40
    Marlow ~ Let There Be Light
    Cool. :)))
  • +3 raves
    Freed ~... Marlow ... November 01, 2009 00:38:04
    Freed ~ If The Son makes you free, you are free indeed
    Thanks!
  • +1 raves
    chaoskitty123 October 31, 2009 23:48:13
    chaoskitty123

    Yes because...

    Almost everything associated with Christianity is tainted by bloodshed and violence from the beginning to the end of the Bible. For me, Halloween is more like the pagans celebrated believing that the realms of the living and the dead were closer than at any other time in the year. Much of the pagans holidays and rituals survive into the modern era in every single Christian holiday... in fact, without the pagan element there would be no Christian holidays because all that's left is Judaism. Christianity is a western religion and while most peoples in the world have had Christianity introduced, it has always been different than Judaism and most non westerners change it by mixing in their own culture.

    In fact, the Puritans and other groups who wanted to restore Christianity to it's roots suffered greatly because they stripped Christianity of it's western element making them as foreign to mainstream Christian thinking as Islam and Judaism. What makes Christianity work is that it absorbs other faiths and beliefs and those who try to purify it or strip it of these elements tend to leave such a bland lifeless faith as to be depressing and meaningless to would be adherents. As has been said many times, if this is what Heaven as to offer me for all eternity, death is a blessing and He...



    Almost everything associated with Christianity is tainted by bloodshed and violence from the beginning to the end of the Bible. For me, Halloween is more like the pagans celebrated believing that the realms of the living and the dead were closer than at any other time in the year. Much of the pagans holidays and rituals survive into the modern era in every single Christian holiday... in fact, without the pagan element there would be no Christian holidays because all that's left is Judaism. Christianity is a western religion and while most peoples in the world have had Christianity introduced, it has always been different than Judaism and most non westerners change it by mixing in their own culture.

    In fact, the Puritans and other groups who wanted to restore Christianity to it's roots suffered greatly because they stripped Christianity of it's western element making them as foreign to mainstream Christian thinking as Islam and Judaism. What makes Christianity work is that it absorbs other faiths and beliefs and those who try to purify it or strip it of these elements tend to leave such a bland lifeless faith as to be depressing and meaningless to would be adherents. As has been said many times, if this is what Heaven as to offer me for all eternity, death is a blessing and Hell a reward. groups like the Jehovahs witnesses carry on some of those traditions most Christians resist and resent. I am an Agnostic Christian but if what these people represent is what Heaven has to offer... I would prefer something else. Halloween is just a fun time to exorcise your demons and for one day of the year just let yourself go having a little fun with the darker side of life.

    To be brutally honest, with all the false prophets and sin in the churches of all faiths today... the real question might be better asked if the devil can still appear as an angel of light and speak the word of God, maybe we have been worshiping the wrong God as the devil is God of this world and all worldly things which preachers, priests and men of religion covet most.

    So go out, get some candy and have some fun... if there is a God in Heaven, he won't fault you for that if he knows your heart is pure and that for most of the year you are living a good life. Only a wicked person would think otherwise and let's face it, they won't fault a priest for having mansions and cheating on their wives with prostitutes but will get angry about kids dressed as ghosts or cowboys... I think they have their priorities mixed up and they're the ones damned to hell rather than the rest of us.
    (more)
  • +3 raves
    Joleen October 31, 2009 23:32:06
    Joleen

    Yes because...

    I don't see much difference between what our family does and what they do at church fall festivals even though we dress up in costumes and trick and treat in the neighborhood for candy. We've had Halloween parties too where the kids play games,etc. I don't understand why some people think that the exact same behavior is alright as long as it's in church but it's a sin everywhere else. I don't get it.
  • +3 raves
    Freed ~... Joleen October 31, 2009 23:52:11
    Freed ~ If The Son makes you free, you are free indeed
    It sounds like you do a great job of teaching your children to have fun in a safe way and without goblins and witches.
  • +3 raves
    Joleen Freed ~... October 31, 2009 23:54:32
    Joleen
    I do. We do have a few rules like that. No costumes that symbolize evil and a few things about decorations. Thanks for understanding.
or
Cancel