May 19, 2008 06:16PM GMTMay 19, 2008 18:16:42

Question Stats

63 answers
65 comments
raves +8  
Share This Question

Is it fair to criticize Michelle Obama?

U.S. Democratic presidential front-runner Barack Obama says that Republicans should direct their attacks at him and not his wife Michelle. Is it right to criticize her after her "For the first time in my adult lifetime, I'm proud of my country," comment?
Add Image Add Video
resize
Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +32 -7 by TraderJoeFan

Answered NO ----

I find that all the Michelle-bashing reeks of racism. Compare the uproar over her comments--which were completely taken out of context--to the silence regarding Cindy McCain's felony charges (theft and forgery). There's a double standard here. Rich blonde millionaire private plane owners can do/say anthing they want, but God forbid a woman of color says a word.
view thread
Sort By: Raves | Date 1 2 Next » Last » Comments
  • raves     [-] by artorius

    Answered YES ----

    Absolutely. She made the comment about being proud of America for the first time in her life, she has opened the floodgates. Plus, she proves that Ivy League educations cant fix stupid..
  • raves     [-] by grandma

    Answered YES ----

    We have free speech as has been pointed out to me several times by the Liberals so if they can make an opiniion about Bush, Clinton, Reagan, and other First Ladies then why would Michelle Obama be any different? I would like to add this to start ripping her apart for the the way she is a Mother and and her personal life is not acceptable as it is not for Palin, Hillary or others. But to have a disagreement or a view on her words or politics that will affect us is a different altogther to me.
  • raves     [-] by suz

    Answered YES ----

    freedom of speech, we get to say what we want, and if she doesn't like it, she should stay out of the celeberities shadow.http://duliopis.edublo...
  • raves     [-] by princess

    Answered YES ----

    She's campaigning for him, so she's not untouchable to any criticism...just like all other candidate's spouses before him!!!
  • raves     [-] by Bardo

    Answered YES ----

    She is asking for it every time she steps in front of the microphone.
    Not just her, but anyone who is in there position. They step up and speak, and in return, the people will reply. it is the way it goes.
  • raves +1   [-] by Roxie

    Answered YES ----

    She started it!
  • raves +1   [-] by zigzag

    Answered YES ----

    if obama wins(hopefully not) she has to get used to it cause evryone is going to find a joke for her and her husband
  • raves +1   [-] by Bun

    Answered YES ----

    Sure... if you can dish it out you should be able to take it!
  • raves +2   [-] by dynomyte

    Answered YES ----

    As long as she puts herself in the public and puts forth her (Or her husbands?) ideas it is TOTALLY fair to evaluate and critique (criticize) those comments and ideas.
  • raves +2   [-] by kyle

    Answered YES ----

    why wouldnt it be , bill clinton is criticized for almost everything he does these days , it is perfectly fair to criticize michelle!!!
  • raves     [-] by Nicole

    Answered NO ----

    Just because people don't like Barack doesn't mean they have to critsize Michelle. I mean she didn't do anything. She was just married to himm and then he ran for president. So if you want to say she is also bad speak for yourself. Others don't have to listen to what you say. And I say don't blame her.
  • raves +2   [-] kyle replied to Nicole
    Nicole, that may be true, but she has said things that should be criticized as much as it would with any other canadiates wifes!!!
  • raves     [-] Nicole replied to kyle
    well ive heard nothing of it then! i dont go to stuff like that, itd be like im in social studies all over again, speaking english, all im hearing is another language! and it meant i had to try alot harder. wich sukd.
  • raves +4   [-] by Duck

    Answered YES ----

    As soon as she started representing the BHO campaign, then she is fair game just like anyone else in the media spotlight. So yes we can criticize her, and she should think before she opens her apparently big fat mouth.
  • raves +1   [-] Bun replied to Duck
    She's so proud now!
  • raves +4   [-] by Donald Harrison

    Answered YES ----

    Hell yes if she can't take the heat get out of the kitchen.
  • raves +4   [-] by jmendez

    Answered YES ----

    She needs to control the verbal diarrhea coming out of her mouth.
  • raves +1   [-] Bun replied to jmendez
    Ya Baby!
  • raves +4   [-] by beadfulheart ~ KeepTheFire!

    Answered YES ----

    Absolutely. He sent his dogs after Bill Clinton so he could play the race victim and destroy Bill Clinton's well deserved reputation with AAs; they had to take Bill out early and knew it. Then he kept silent when his embedded media dogs went after Chelsea. So if the angry, bitter shrew can't keep her mouth shut she is totally fair game.
  • raves +2   [-] Bun replied to beadfulheart ~ KeepTheFire!
    I noticed this too!
  • raves +1   [-] Roxie replied to beadfulheart ~ KeepTheFire!
    Very good point!
  • raves +7   [-] by chilton

    Answered YES ----

    It goes with the career. She is married to a politcian. It's happened to all of the wives.....maybe it has to do with racism that she is criticized and McCains wife isn't...IDK
    You want your hubby in the White House? Don't whine when people scrutinize and comment. You signed on for it. If you don't want to be misquoted....keep your comments private and stay away from the limelight.
    Their kids should never be treated that way. Ever.
  • raves +5   [-] by coffee man

    Answered YES ----

    The way things are done these days I would say it is. It's just as fair to criticize her for what she says as it is to do so with Bill and his infidelities.
  • raves +6   [-] by Ginny

    Answered YES ----

    I cannot remember a spouse of a public figure NOT getting criticized by "the public" they are considered fair game and pot shots are taken all the time.
  • raves +8   [-] by Mister Six

    Answered YES ----

    It's absolutely fair to bash her. If she's going to make politically-driven speeches on her husband's behalf, then she's open season.

    Every time anybody says anything bad about the Obamas, everybody lines up to act like it's racist...

    Nobody complains when people talk smack about Hillary Clinton's husband...

    If it's okay to criticize Bill Clinton, then why isn't it okay to criticize Michelle Obama?
  • raves +7   [-] by Tracy

    Answered YES ----

    Yes if your husband/wife are in politics, you might as well get used to it.
  • raves +8   [-] by K man

    Answered YES ----

    Yes, but not simply because of that comment.



    Candidates spouses and family should be off limits unless they choose to step up and interject themselves into the campaign. The moment they choose do that, they become part of the process and are fair game for comments/criticism.



    Obama wants to have it both ways - he wants to use her to campaign for him but then declare her off limits for criticism. It doesn't work like that, and a person who is running for the Presidency of the United States should be smart enough to understand something as basic as that.
  • raves +1   [-] Foo Master doesn't like Change replied to K man
    Exactly! She wants to be able to say whatever she wants, and not have to suffer the repercussions. It doesn't work that way. If you can't take the heat...get out of the kitchen.
  • raves +5   [-] by SpecialKrazyK!

    Answered YES ----

    I'm gonna have to say..only for I rag on Bill all the time...but he has more material to work with..unlike her...hmmm....
  • raves +7   [-] by Spider20

    Answered YES ----

    As far as her public comments, yes...........her private life? No.........
  • raves +32 -7 [-] by TraderJoeFan

    Answered NO ----

    I find that all the Michelle-bashing reeks of racism. Compare the uproar over her comments--which were completely taken out of context--to the silence regarding Cindy McCain's felony charges (theft and forgery). There's a double standard here. Rich blonde millionaire private plane owners can do/say anthing they want, but God forbid a woman of color says a word.
  • raves +4   [-] Tracy replied to TraderJoeFan
    excuse me! Hey I love woopie G. But have you ever listened to some of her comments? Most of the time they are straight up the mark, but some people might not like them! And Barbara Jorden...oprah...just to name a few.
  • raves +8   [-] Mister Six replied to TraderJoeFan
    Reeks of racism why? She's making political speeches on her husband's behalf.

    It's no different than when Bill Clinton says something stupid on behalf of Hillary. Is it racist to bash Bill Clinton? Noooooo....

    So if it's okay to talk about Hillary's husband... why is it racist to talk about Barack's wife?
  • raves +3   [-] jmendez replied to TraderJoeFan