Apr 28, 2008 05:19PM GMTApril 28, 2008 17:19:56

Question Stats

3,509 answers
3,420 comments
raves +145 -78
Share This Question

Should Miley Cyrus have posed topless for Vanity Fair?

Miley Cyrus is speaking out about her 'near nude' shot in this months Vanity Fair. The photo, which was shot by the renowned Annie Leibovitz, shows the 15 year old Disney star topless with a satin sheet covering her chest. Through her publicist on Sunday, Miley attempted to explain herself. "I took part in a photo shoot that was supposed to be 'artistic' and now, seeing the photographs and reading the story, I feel so embarrassed. I never intended for any of this to happen and I apologize to my fans who I care so deeply about." Vanity Fair countered back with their own statement. "Miley's parents and/or minders were on the set all day. Since the photo was taken digitally, they saw it on the shoot and everyone thought it was a beautiful and natural portrait of Miley." So, do you think it was right of Miley to have done the photo?
Add Image Add Video
resize
Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +123 -68 by Gina

Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

Can't believe she did this, she's only 15!
view thread
Sort By: Raves | Date «« First « Prev ... 43 44 45 46 ... Next » Last » Comments
  • raves     [-] by HotStuff_23

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    she's a dumb bitch who cant SING!!!!!!!!!! Disney is going 2 drop her ass & y woulf her parents let her do that she onlt 15 i guess it would b ok if she was grown she looks like she is high on sumthing in that picture
  • raves     [-] K-K replied to HotStuff_23
    Shutup you sound Retarted!!!!!!!!
  • raves     [-] JoeBrosr#1 replied to HotStuff_23
    GO TO HELL!!!! you do sound retarded and your just jealous of her
  • raves     [-] by alw_ays

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    It's the context that makes it questionable.
  • raves     [-] by Rob

    Answered Here's what I think....

    so far now all the Disney women stars have nude pics of them selves on the internet. wat does that tell u?? they just destroyin there rep. that's all. keep ur clothes on. ur only 15.
  • raves     [-] by ♥{[!~*aMaNdA*~!]}♥

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    That is probably the stupidest mistake she could hav emade for her career..She is going to be the next Brittney Spears...
  • raves     [-] by lena

    Answered Here's what I think....

    i think that she is too young to be taking pics like that just yet
  • raves     [-] by wolff

    Answered Here's what I think....

    Is she topless? I can't tell!
  • raves     [-] by zigggy

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    how could she do that she is going to start going down hill, and fast
  • raves     [-] by tatortot

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    if you was famous you would want to do it to and you so it everybody has taken the wrong way its just a picture its no wross than a dress!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • raves     [-] by Donmeister

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    She may do what it is she wants.... if you ask me...(:
  • raves     [-] by Princess Jessiekins

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    but yeah its not the most flattering photo but really shes not doing anything bad at all sooo... wassa big deal?
    it would be a bad example to her fans if it was a porn shot/pose but its not!
    its vanity fair f'christs sakes!
  • raves     [-] by PAWaite

    Answered Here's what I think....

    Who cares?
  • raves     [-] by Carleta Tubbs

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    Yes miley is setting giving a bad example to you young people but her manage at wtyn is making those gigs for her.
  • raves     [-] by Kelly G

    Answered Here's what I think....

    oh my god. Its not like shes naked or anything people, all thats showing is her back. I mean, come on. I think that the real reason behind this is that people are wondering if shes going to go the Brittany Spears route or if shes going to be another Hilary Duff. People have a tendancy to make something out of nothing. Shes 15 years old people, you need to cut her some credit. Teenagers learn from their mistakes.
  • raves     [-] by ktbgz

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    back off peeps, hehe im bored! ♥
  • raves     [-] by kace

    Answered Here's what I think....

    Vanity Fair is an awesome artist and I think that you guys should leave miley cyrus alone till she does REAL damage to her life. *her parents were with her anyways...
  • raves +1   [-] by tl3319

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    looking at a shot of a 15 year old "near nude" is not art it's just wrong....
  • raves +1   [-] by kmay

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    They are not very good either.
  • raves +1 -2 [-] by lacey

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    she is a slut and she has some issues at 15 doing stuff like that and her parents let her they have some big issues to that is inaproprete and she need to stop cuz all her little kid fans now probally want to dress without a shirt cuz they think miley is cool no she is a stupid little slut that shouldnt even do stuff for little kids if she wants to be a slut.i never even liked her and i never will. to me all she is , is a big fat slut.
  • raves     [-] by Meisha|Apocalypse™

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    It's the nicest photo I've ever seen of her. Clearly people have no appreciation for art. >.
  • raves     [-] by stickers

    Answered Here's what I think....

    HOW BOUT YOU GUYS LEAVE MILEY ALONE AND LET HER LIVE HER LIFE!!! YOU DONT CONTROLL HER LIFE ONLY SHE DOS SO JUST STOP MAKING FUN OF HER AND STOP TEASING HER
  • raves     [-] by froggy

    Answered Here's what I think....

    this whole thing is stupid. her parents were there watching anyways! she even appolgized for what she did! has she ever done anything terrible like this before? i think that it doesn't matter! she did one thing and now everyone is saying things about her!!! i think that it is all crap!!!!
  • raves     [-] by bearco

    Answered Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.

    There's more exposed on girls at the beach.Sometimes just walking down the street you can see more.
  • raves   -2 [-] by donnie.darko

    Answered Here's what I think....

    No one should care about miley cyrus shes a stupid piece of shit whose ruined disney.
  • raves +1   [-] by M&M

    Answered Here's what I think....

    I think It was up to her!
  • raves     [-] by shrimpo

    Answered Here's what I think....

    i think that she made a mistake so its totaly ok.and plus, its a really nice shot of her.
  • raves +2   [-] by cassienicole

    Answered Here's what I think....

    It's way too provocative for a 15 year old girl, and even though I hate to say this, but she really is a role model for her young fans. And little girls are already dressing like complete sluts and dancing like what they see on music videos. They don't need any more influence.
  • raves +1   [-] Aingean replied to cassienicole
    I fully agree with you on that!
  • raves     [-] by ibeleveicanfly$

    Answered Here's what I think....

    i dont care unless shes pregnate.
  • raves     [-] by Josse

    Answered Here's what I think....

    It doesn´t look like her on the picture but i don´t think it´s wrong.
  • raves     [-] by ♫•Lemon Squeeze♫•

    Answered No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

    To me I think she is growing up to fast.......But maybe that's what stardom does to you
  • raves     [-] by eq

    Answered Here's what I think....

    i dont like her and many dont. we know shes actully posed nude. shes nude in one photo all over.
  • raves     [-] by my-my