Apr 23, 2008 01:07AM GMTApril 23, 2008 01:07:41
Question Politics - Other
Posted by Wesloco

Question Stats

32 answers
69 comments
raves +2  
Share This Question

Do you feel it is offensive to call Mexican farm workers, “illiterate peasants?”?

Colorado State Representative Douglas Bruce was kicked off of the podium after referring to Mexican farm workers as “illiterate peasants.”
Colorado is facing a serious shortage of people to work the state’s farms and lawmakers want to try a new, innovative program to grant foreign workers temporary visas to come to work on Colorado farms. Once the growing season is over, the workers would return to their home countries.

Representative Bruce argued against the program saying, "I'd like to have the opportunity to state at the microphone why I don't think we need 5000 illiterate peasants in Colorado." Fellow lawmakers found the comment offensive but Bruce refused to apologize for the slur and instead he tried to explain it like this:

“I looked up ‘illiterate’ in the dictionary and it means somebody who is lacking in formal education or is unable to read and write. I don’t think these people who are planning to come over here and pick potatoes or peaches are likely to have much of a formal education. I looked up the word ‘peasant.’ The word ‘peasant’ means a person who works in agricultural fields.”

On an AOL poll 57% of respondents were not offended by the comment while 43% found it offensive.

How do you feel about State Representative Douglas Bruce’s comment?






Add Image Add Video
resize
Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +9   by mikeNOTvick

Answered It's offensive

Any generalization like that shows a lack of intelligence.
view thread
Sort By: Raves | Date 1 2 Next » Last » Comments
  • raves +2   [-] by Kassandra

    Answered It's offensive

    It is a stereotype just like any other.
  • raves     [-] by .....

    Answered Undecided

    moderated...
  • raves +1   [-] Wesloco replied to .....
    Uhh, Dr T, with all due respect sir,:



    And, uhh, by the way, this poll has nothing to with ILLEGAL ALIENS!!!!!

    Furthermore:



  • raves +1   [-] by Jwalden

    Answered I don't have a problem with it

    BUT \
    I do think that it can be percieved in the same manner as 'dumb n=-=-'
    It implies ' ALL' in One big pot.
    The immigration issue should Never be reduced to 'race' or 'education'. It is legal or illegal that needs to be addressed.
  • raves     [-] ..... replied to Jwalden
    moderated...
  • raves +2   [-] by Monique

    Answered It's offensive

    You know, as a Mexican I am not surprised that a white person would say something like that. But I'll tell you this, Mexicans are hard working people and I would like to see that dick do what Mexicans do.
  • raves +3   [-] by MARKY | * HRC-VP *

    Answered It's offensive

    What a dipshit!
  • raves     [-] ..... replied to MARKY | * HRC-VP *
    moderated...
  • raves +3   [-] by sativa

    Answered It's offensive

    This is unacceptable for anyone to say, especially in any position of leadership or power! What a bigot. He needs to spend a few days working the fields with the 57% of ignorant AOL users.
  • raves +3   [-] by Fernando

    Answered Undecided

    Ignorance is the best way to describe this....It is sad that even when in power you happen to look down on minorities...He is just a fucking idiot..there was no need to used the term illiterate peasants...being that he is a state representative he could of acted a little more respectful
  • raves +4 -1 [-] Wesloco replied to Fernando
    We lead by example and if the example we set is to name call others will feel empwered to do the same.
  • raves +1   [-] Monique replied to Wesloco
    exactly
  • raves     [-] ..... replied to Wesloco
    moderated...
  • raves +3 -2 [-] by Janet

    Answered I don't have a problem with it

    Freedom of speech, and he is probably right. I personally don't find it very nice, but we are far too sensitive and politically correct in this country.
  • raves +3 -3 [-] by Palin For Dog Catcher 2012

    Answered It's offensive

    Another ignorant Republican. His President is illiterate as well, but i guess that doesn't bother the dipshit.
  • raves +6   [-] by flutterby ~ aka huckster fan

    Answered I don't have a problem with it

    I would never go to another country and try to work there without learning their language. I find it disrespectful to Americans.
  • raves +5 -1 [-] Wesloco replied to flutterby ~ aka huckster fan
    May be disrespectful Huckster but if they could speak English we probably wouldn't get them as cheap and if you went to work in another country I don't think it would be to do stoop labor like picking tomatoes.

  • raves +4   [-] Fernando replied to flutterby ~ aka huckster fan
    People come to this country for a reason and thats to be able to provide for not only themselves but for their family as well...I dont understand why it would be disrespectful...
  • raves +1   [-] flutterby ~ aka huckster fan replied to Fernando
    If they can come here and work so hard for their families, why not learn the language? That is all I am saying. I just would not do that myself. I do appreciate their hard work though. I don't have as much problem with it out in the fields, but that is not where it stops. The last couple of times I stayed at a hotel, I could not even find a worker that spoke English. Am I being unfair to expect someone to speak my language in my own country?
  • raves +2   [-] Fernando replied to flutterby ~ aka huckster fan
    It is not hard to learn the language....I am not from here....I was born in Mexico and I am very proud of it....guess what...I not only know how to speak it but i can read it and write it very well...no ur not being unfair but at the same time ur not thinking about the equal opportunity that everybody deserves that lives here regardless of how they got here....
  • raves +1   [-] flutterby ~ aka huckster fan replied to Fernando
    Fernando, let me just tell you that I have had close friends that have come to this country from Mexico. I was simply stating my opinion. I respect your opinion as well.
  • raves +2   [-] Fernando replied to flutterby ~ aka huckster fan
    I understand...dont worry I dont get easily offended....
  • raves +4   [-] by Kevman

    Answered I don't have a problem with it

    That's what they are. Tough shit if people who enter the country illegally and drain our resources can't deal with the truth.
  • raves +3   [-] Wesloco replied to Kevman
    Kevman, this is not a poll about illegal immigration. This is about legal temporary workers who get in line to come here legally and pick our crops. Let me ask you this, as it's implied in your graphic, when has Mexico pestered us to put up bilingual signs?
  • raves +1   [-] Kevman replied to Wesloco
    Mea culpa: I screwed up, and am man enough to admit it. As to the
    "Fig of Spain": The Mexican consulate where I live was pushing
    for bilingual signage. Went over lika a fart in church.
  • raves +2   [-] Fernando replied to Kevman
    You wouldnt have reasources if it was not for people who come here to actually work for a living....
  • raves +3   [-] by Dave Sawyer

    Answered I don't have a problem with it

    Sounds like he did his research and the ones offended were just going with their gut.
  • raves +6   [-] by Rockies

    Answered I don't have a problem with it

    Hmm lets see cant speak no English, don't have no green card ???
    I guess it is what it is.
  • raves +1   [-] Wesloco replied to Rockies
    Eagle, I'm not getting at ya'll but I keep repeating myself, this has nothing to do with illegal immigration which I and every American should be against. Bruce was talking about LEGAL Mexican workers not illegals. Does that make a difference to you or do you stand by your statement?
  • raves +5   [-] Rockies replied to Wesloco
    If your legal,, it's all good with me.
  • raves     [-] ..... replied to Wesloco
    moderated...
  • raves +3   [-] by dragonfli

    Answe