Aug 13, 2008 05:15PM GMTAugust 13, 2008 17:15:20
Posted by rjbudke

Question Stats

313 answers
263 comments
raves +13  
Share This Question

Should Pluto be a planet?

I know I'm a little late to the game on this one, but I just wanted to know what everyone else thought about last year's revelation that Pluto isn't really a planet. What do you think? Should it be? (for the record I'm talking about the celestial body and not Mickey's dog... I'll be here all week folks)
Add Image Add Video
resize
Loading Loading...
Top Comment
raves +5   by Fef

Answered No

Let's not insult the real planets by calling Pluto one for nostalgia's sake.

"The debate came to a head in 2006 with an IAU resolution that created an official definition for the term "planet". According to this resolution, there are three main conditions for an object to be considered a 'planet':

1. The object must be in orbit around the Sun.
2. The object must be massive enough to be a sphere by its own gravitational force. More specifically, its own gravity should pull it into a shape of hydrostatic equilibrium.
3. It must have cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit.

Pluto fails to meet the third condition, since its mass was only 0.07 times that of the mass of the other objects in its orbit (Earth's mass, by contrast, is 1.7 million times the remaining mass in its own orbit). The IAU further resolved that Pluto be classified in the simultaneously created dwarf planet category, and that it act as the prototype for the plutoid category of trans-Neptunian objects, in which it would be separately, but concurrently, classified.""
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...
plutoid category trans-neptunian objects separately concurrently classified httpen wikipedia orgwiki

Pluto doesn't cut it. We'd have to start classifying other objects as planets.
view thread
Sort By: Raves | Date 1 2 3 4 ... Next » Last » Comments
  • raves     [-] by Tom

    Answered Yes

    It was a planet for a long time, and shouldn't be demoted.
  • raves     [-] by minsy

    Answered Yes

    yeah is shpuld be a planet & the size does not matter
  • raves     [-] by jiggy

    Answered Yes

    it's all mostly arbitrary anyway. why not?
  • raves     [-] by iowastate

    Answered Yes

    it has been in all the textbooks as a planet for too long to change now.
    don't confuse the issue .
  • raves     [-] by Jman

    Answered No

    Its more like, a blue wonderland with no life.
  • raves     [-] by mavericky

    Answered No

    Pluto is smaller than our moon. There is no way it should be considered a planet.
  • raves     [-] by Ragweed

    Answered Yes

    Who the hell are scientists to say whether or not it's a planet.
  • raves     [-] mavericky replied to Ragweed
    Um... They are the ones who say whether something is a planet or not. Who else would do it?
  • raves +1   [-] Ragweed replied to mavericky
    ...aparently my sarcasm is lost on you.
  • raves     [-] mavericky replied to Ragweed
    LOL, sorry. I was wondering :-)
  • raves +1   [-] Ragweed replied to mavericky
    It's alright. Happens to the best of us.
  • raves     [-] by AlcoholicTaytay

    Answered Undecided

    its a dwarf planet should be good enough, who really cares besides the guy that discovered it
  • raves     [-] by mae'nwlybyngnghymruheddiw

    Answered Undecided

    It makes no difference to me whether or not a chunk of rock 5,763,920,000 km from Earth is a planet. Should it?
  • raves     [-] by Earnheart

    Answered Yes

    Yes , Because it has been for as least my 60 yr's
  • raves     [-] by CoffeeBean

    Answered Yes

    Damn...I thought it was already one and I learned that in high school!
  • raves     [-] CoffeeBean replied to CoffeeBean
    oh...and another thing...how are they going to renege on Pluto being a planet after all these years. What difference does it make to change a planet and distort science books and confuse the hell out of 4th graders! Give me a break!
  • raves     [-] by r3volutionary

    Answered Undecided

    who cares... sorry but if their a nemesis planet x coming our way we have bigger things to worry about and if u think it's a hoax think again it was documented by tha Egyptians, tha Azteks, oh yeah and tha Sumerians which is might I add present day Iraq
  • raves     [-] mavericky replied to r3volutionary
    Have you been reading Alexander Sitchen's books?
  • raves     [-] by jake

    Answered Yes

    fasfs
  • raves     [-] by mike

    Answered Yes

    Damn...Hef makes for a good argument...but, this is our solar system...I say we vote the little guy in......SodaHeads for the Plutos Rights
  • raves     [-] by Rondolce

    Answered No

    Doesn't meet the definition. Still, dwarf planet's OK.
  • raves +1   [-] by Loreli

    Answered Undecided

    No, he's a dog!
    undecided dog
  • raves +1   [-] Cadmon replied to Loreli
    lol thats not right
  • raves +1   [-] Loreli replied to Cadmon
    I guess we're the only 2 that thought I made a funny....
  • raves +1   [-] Cadmon replied to Loreli
    Is that what that was?
  • raves +1   [-] Loreli replied to Cadmon
    Bring it on pal, I can take it. Just try'n to light up the mood is all.
  • raves +1   [-] Cadmon replied to Loreli
    There you go makin me smile again........shame on you.
  • raves +1   [-] Loreli replied to Cadmon
    Better yet, let's take it outside! lol!!
  • raves +1   [-] Cadmon replied to Loreli
    boxing boxing
  • raves +1   [-] Loreli replied to Cadmon
    Whatever!! lol!!!
  • raves     [-] Cadmon replied to Loreli
    So are we still going outside?
  • raves +1   [-] Loreli replied to Cadmon
    Sure, let me get my numchucks first.
  • raves     [-] Cadmon replied to Loreli
    I must warn you first, they will have no effect on my hard head.
  • raves +1   [-] Loreli replied to Cadmon
    I go for the knees baby....
  • raves +1