SodaHead Celebrates Green Week

Blogs Mollydolly's

Another Blow For Battered Women:



Another Blow For Battered Women: Health Insurers Deny Coverage for Victims
Care2.com

One in four women will experience some form of domestic violence in their lifetime.

Twenty to thirty-five percent of emergency visits are made by women as a result of domestic violence.

These are startling statistics, but what's even more shocking is the fact that abuse can be labeled by health insurance companies as a "pre-existing condition" as a means to deny battered women coverage.

While the majority of states have laws in place to prohibit health insurers from doing this, eight states including Idaho, Mississippi, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Wyoming and the District of Columbia do not. In these states it is legal for health insurance companies to deny victims of domestic abuse coverage.

What's worse is that the fear of being denied health insurance silences many victims from reporting violence, trapping them in abusive relationships. For women with children, the risks are greater. Losing insurance for a mother often denies her children coverage unless she remains with her abusive partner.

While there has been no recent research of how often battered women are denied coverage, an informal survey by the Senate Judiciary Committee subcommittee staff (1994) found that eight of the 16 largest U.S. insurers used domestic violence as a factor in deciding whether or not to offer insurance coverage and how much to charge.

The last thing that a battered woman should have to worry about after suffering abuse is not having health insurance, especially with the prevalence of violence that exists today. It is incredible to me that abuse victims must endure so much – even worrying about receiving the proper care after surviving abuse – but their abusers get off scot-free in terms of their coverage? Why aren't the partners who inflict the abuse denied coverage or given higher rates? Isn't their abuse the reason for the added doctor visits and multiple trips to the ER? Why must women take the added blow? How is this just?

We need a health care system that does not discriminate against women, but one that defends and protects women when they need it most. Luckily, top House Democrats agree and pledged to incorporate a ban on the practice in the healthcare reform legislation moving its way through Congress. "Think of this," House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said. "You've survived domestic violence, and now you are discriminated [against] in the insurance market because you have a pre-existing medical condition. Well, that will all be gone."

I certainly hope so, but unfortunately domestic violence isn't the only "pre-existing" condition that discriminates against women. Be sure to to check out Care 2's "Being a Woman Is Not A Pre-Exisiting Condition" for more information on ridiculous circumstances that discriminate against women and RH Reality Check for a round up of other related blog posts.

ridiculous circumstances discriminate women rh reality check related blog posts

What can you do to help?

* Become part of the "I Am Not A Pre-Existing Condition" campaign and sign / tweet their petition!
* Sign the Service Employees International Union's petition telling Congress to stop their discriminatory practices against women!
* Have a twitter or facebook account? Change your profile picture to the image created by the National Women's Law Center to support change!
* Write Congress and remind then that women need health reform that meets their needs too!

I am not a "pre-existing" condition and neither are you! Have your voice heard today and show women that you've got their back.

remind women health reform meets pre-existing condition voice heard women
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Top Comment
  • +3 raves Jay October 16, 2009 18:30:08
    Jay
    This is just another reason why we need health insurance reform in this country and why we need a PUBLIC OPTION!
    View thread
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • +1 raves
    Stella Blue October 19, 2009 16:28:05
    Stella Blue
    Molly...you know how tough this one is for me....working as a DV crisis intervention counselor for over 8 years now and no two stories have been alike. Number of incidents has greatly increased during this economic climate. Victims are so void of self worth and believe they can fix it. With tears falling from her blackened eye a small voice often says I'll talk to him and I'll try to do better so he doesn't get mad.......he loves me............

    He sure does...he loves her to death.
  • +2 raves
    Mollydolly Stella ... October 19, 2009 19:56:31
    Mollydolly
    It just breaks my heart how we keep thinking it's something we've done.
  • +3 raves
    Jay October 16, 2009 18:30:08
    Jay
    This is just another reason why we need health insurance reform in this country and why we need a PUBLIC OPTION!
  • +3 raves
    Tea in the Harbor October 16, 2009 17:55:01 (edited)
    Tea in the Harbor
    Insurance companies should be required to cover not only the physical damage these women suffer, but the mental damage that so often accompanies it. The potheads in our prison system should be replaced with the abusers. Our refusal to deal with family violence as a criminal act is a tacit approval of the assaults.

    Most criminal sentences include restitution to the victim, I see no ethical argument as to why this should be treated differently. As a criminal act, and one where the damages to the insurance companies is easily quantifiable, they should be afforded the right to sue the abuser for damages, but not to deny treatment. I would go further and encourage women to sue for pain and suffering, I doubt any jury would ever deny such a claim.

    I am not aware of any law that would prevent this practice, and I believe that if an insurance company made the effort to set the legal precedent they would not only recoup their losses, but make a marked improvement in the way our society deals with a tragic event that happens far too often.
  • +2 raves
    Brenda October 15, 2009 23:31:32
    Brenda
    This is just plan stupid... Kick the woman down Thanks Molly for the share
  • +2 raves
    rebmama October 15, 2009 22:19:14
    rebmama
    I do not approve of current healthcare legislation, but in ANY event, these women need to be taken care of!
  • +2 raves
    MickeyRenee~ October 15, 2009 21:08:19
    MickeyRenee~
    This is ridiculous.
  • +1 raves
    SABLE October 15, 2009 20:43:40
    SABLE
    I don't believe it should be considered a pre-existant condition the first time but if the woman goes back for more knowing her spouse is violent then I can understand the insurances need to put their foot down. A woman has to get help and remove herself from an abusive situation.
  • ricky SABLE October 15, 2009 21:42:20
    ricky
    exactly. pple need to understand that insurance does not mean someone is paying for everything u do or want, they're security for the occasional thing that may come up.
  • +2 raves
    Mollydolly SABLE October 15, 2009 21:52:53
    Mollydolly
    I think that's easy for us to say. Some of these women have been conditioned from childhood that they derserve this kind of treatment. I think if this is the case then Insurance cos. should fund education and emotional treatment to help the women climb out of that hole. What bothers me is that the Insurance cos don't want to take responsibility for their neglect. They know that the domestic abuse thing is a revolving door and would rather ignore the causes by not even dealing with the effects.
  • SABLE Mollydolly October 16, 2009 01:36:34
    SABLE
    It's up to the doctor to recommend counseling and then the Insurance Co will fund it but it's also up to the woman to get the counseling and follow what the counselor recommends. Many woman don't want help or are afraid to get it.
  • +1 raves
    Jay Mollydolly October 16, 2009 18:33:23
    Jay
    Women, that watched their mother's, being abused by their fathers, learn to think that it's normal, and to be expected, when their mothers allowed it by staying in the abusive relationship. So it's kind of a self perpetuating situation, or a viscious circle.
  • +2 raves
    Mollydolly Jay October 18, 2009 17:15:40
    Mollydolly
    believe me I know how that goes. My father was verbally abusive and it took me 10 years to realize that my ex was too. It was so familiar it seemed normal. really felt good to be able to finally break that chain and I can understand how hard it would be for some women to be totally trapped in the abuse.
  • +1 raves
    Jay Mollydolly October 18, 2009 17:20:00
    Jay
    Yes, and no one should have to live like that.
  • +1 raves
    Brenda SABLE October 15, 2009 23:28:11
    Brenda
    Have you ever been in these women's shoes before or have you ever been stalked by your X and had the shit kicked out of you.. People shouldn't be so judgemental on these women, if the cops would do there damn job maybe a lot of this wouldn't happen. But what the hell there just stupid woman that deserve this and should be kicked to the curb when the hospitals won't take care of them and there is no coverage I don't mean to be rude to you but until you walk in there shoes You don't know
  • SABLE Brenda October 16, 2009 01:41:04 (edited)
    SABLE
    There's not enough cops for all the women who are hurt by their spouses or boyfriends. These women need to remove themselves from the abusive partner but instead go right back. Insurances wouldn't cover car accidents if you kept getting into them. They'd finally drop your coverage. Believe me as a nurse who has cared for these ladies in the emergency room, I sympathize, but they won't press charges and then go back and then shortly afterward, we see them again with injuries worse then before. I guess I just can't understand their reasoning about going back when there are so many shelters to help them. And I never called these women stupid. I know they are scared but they need to get help.
  • +1 raves
    Brenda SABLE October 16, 2009 08:06:56
    Brenda
    When the cops turn the ass holes loose and they come looking for them what does that tell you?? Women are not respected nor taken seriously. They claim there are laws for women but are there not enforced??? No not till the woman is either is killed or some one else.
    Oh and by the way what about those people who have a heart attack you treat them once and the second time because they didn't follow the Dr's orders you don't treat them. All people should be treated and taken care of.
  • +1 raves
    SABLE Brenda October 17, 2009 16:26:30
    SABLE
    Hopefully the new reform will help with that.
  • +1 raves
    Brenda SABLE October 20, 2009 19:49:05
    Brenda
    I hope so Sable!!! Hey you have a great week
  • +2 raves
    SABLE Brenda October 20, 2009 21:39:39
    SABLE
    Same to you>

About Me

Mollydolly

Mollydolly

OR, US

June 17, 2008 19:47:56

has a new love named Moses

View complete profile

or
Cancel