Question Music

Which "band" is MORE amazing ~ My Chemical Romance OR The Black Parade?

gerards_my_bitch October 04, 2007 19:57:29

I have been pondering this but i know what I THINK about it.....
 MCR
The Black Parade
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Comment
  • +3 raves helena October 10, 2007 18:32:28
    helena

    MCR

    i miss the old MCR, i really do.

    dont get me wrong, i LOOOVE the black parade, with all of my heart.

    but i MISS, like i fucking MISS the old MCR and like when you guys played stuff off bullets.

    ^-^

    PS: the breakfast monkey rulles!
    View thread
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • frankiie July 09, 2008 18:48:00
    frankiie

    The Black Parade

    BOTH but this one has matured and developed a unique sound
  • Tiffany February 09, 2008 07:13:08
    Tiffany

    MCR

    My Chemical Romance
    The Black Parade wasnt always going to be around but it was great while it lasted.
  • •Ant¤inette• December 09, 2007 11:19:29
    •Ant¤inette•

    MCR

    I love My Chemical Romance and their altered ego’s ^♥^
  • +1 raves
    <--That guy November 09, 2007 14:10:53
    <--That guy

    MCR

    Aren't they the same band?
    You can disregard my vote. I don't have an opinion; I just wanted to make a comment.
  • ImNotOk October 30, 2007 05:18:43
    ImNotOk

    MCR

    Hmmm since this is obviously just a "clever" way to ask which do you like better, MCR's new stuff or old stuff, i will answer like i always do, both are genius. I love everything they do. They are simply a great, unique band. The fact that they have such a huge range, that they can do something so different than anything they've done before and it's enough for someone to compare them to being a completely different band, speaks for itself.
  • Haushinku. October 21, 2007 21:13:02 (edited)
    Haushinku.

    The Black Parade

    In terms of "amazing", I think The Black Parade has the ability to literally 'take your breath away'. MCR were the above average Rock band that made you think about issues in the world (Skylines & Turnstiles, The Ghost of You).
    Both are amazing in my eyes >_<

    & yes, GO THE BREAKFAST MONKEY!! <3

    & for the person below me, when Gerard says "WE ARE THE BLACK PARADE!", man, he sure does MEAN IT! >_
  • Celi October 21, 2007 08:14:25
    Celi

    MCR

    Ummm MCR is the band..... The Black Parade is there third Album. Three Cheers for sweet revenge was there second album and Life on the Murder scene was there first album....Personally I love them all. They all have their own kinda sound but they are all spectacular
  • Yoyoguy October 20, 2007 18:14:52
    Yoyoguy

    MCR

    Oh dear me this is a debate that causes so much crap nowadays. I love MCR to death and i personaly believe that Three Cheers, and Bullets are their greatest Albums but I also love TBP.

    Have you noticed the great division of fans? people who loved MCR in the past are fueding with the new blood fans who just got into TBP, I don't blame them though because i can't stand the people who say MCR's old music sucked so they deserve the discrimination other than that i get along with any other fan of MCR as long as they respect their Past, Present, and Future work.
  • mcr_grkm October 20, 2007 10:19:41
    mcr_grkm

    MCR

    mm mcr cuz i love their old stuff too i love tbp but 3cheers and i brought u... too
  • Aliv October 18, 2007 21:52:33
    Aliv

    MCR

    I have to say MCR....I mean I love the black parade but mcr is the band i fell in love with
  • Shazzy October 18, 2007 19:43:19
    Shazzy

    MCR

    Mcr ov course
  • halloween_nini October 15, 2007 01:02:29
    halloween_nini

    MCR

    what?? xD
  • +1 raves
    char October 12, 2007 10:51:06
    char

    MCR

    mcr were mcr before they were the black parade. and so they are the real heroes =]
  • carma9 October 11, 2007 06:24:02
    carma9

    MCR

    MCR, really can't choose,love the persona of the Black Parade so dramatic/theatrical, but you can't have one without the other!
  • +3 raves
    helena October 10, 2007 18:32:28
    helena

    MCR

    i miss the old MCR, i really do.

    dont get me wrong, i LOOOVE the black parade, with all of my heart.

    but i MISS, like i fucking MISS the old MCR and like when you guys played stuff off bullets.

    ^-^

    PS: the breakfast monkey rulles!
  • +1 raves
    Sammy October 10, 2007 18:26:07
    Sammy

    MCR

    MCR made the black parade and I don't know why everyone thinks they have changed so much and class the Black Parade as a differnent band! They are amazing
  • alvingrrl October 10, 2007 16:49:42
    alvingrrl

    The Black Parade

    I love them both, but I got introduced first to the Black Parade. i heart them!
  • frerard_mcr October 10, 2007 10:02:46
    frerard_mcr

    MCR

    because if it wasnt for them the black parade wouldnt be here and they wouldnt be able to write the songs they did if they hadnt had faced the expericenes they had....
  • Lucy Noir October 10, 2007 08:26:23
    Lucy Noir

    MCR

    By far. Especially first album.
  • CJ October 10, 2007 03:52:16 (edited)
    CJ

    MCR

    I can't vote...But I voted for MCR becuse thery are the fire behind TBP...Both My Chemical Romance and The Black Perade are so amazing.I had seen both of them in concert.I love MCR they are the greatest.And The Black Parade Cd and there music is WOW!!! so I would have to say BOTH.
  • Shawn October 10, 2007 02:25:59
    Shawn

    MCR

    Thats hard to decide they were both amazing
  • Jessi October 10, 2007 02:09:04
    Jessi

    MCR

    Aren't the same people. I think so. So both but MCR is all the way.
  • ViiCKYiiERO<3 October 09, 2007 16:05:55
    ViiCKYiiERO<3

    MCR

    Their First Albums Were So Awesome! I Like The Black Parade But Their First 2 Albums Were The Best..So I Gotta Go With The Old MCR :] xoxoxox
  • thewickedrobot October 09, 2007 01:22:05
    thewickedrobot

    MCR

    Naw TBP is kinda... "Out there"? You understand.
  • Summer October 09, 2007 00:42:55
    Summer

    MCR

    I only pick MCR cause technically they are the black parade.Don't get me wrong though the black parade rocks!
  • Bah1980 October 09, 2007 00:24:03
    Bah1980

    MCR

    Too choose, too choose.....I love them sooooo
  • Sam October 09, 2007 00:21:40
    Sam

    MCR

    i luv them better b4 they changed...still a huge fan though

    xo SAM
  • toonicetammy October 07, 2007 15:06:04
    toonicetammy

    MCR

    I know they reinvented themselves to be TBP but they are still Gerard, Frank, Bob, Mikey and Ray! NO MATTER WHAT!
  • real36 October 06, 2007 02:54:58
    real36

    MCR

    What kind of ques is that!? They are the same to me. Just a little diff,but the same also. I know its strange to say ,but its true, they are the same.MCR is MCR AND The Black Parade. I cannot choose between them cause they are the same!
  • Stevie The Strange October 06, 2007 00:06:49
    Stevie The Strange

    The Black Parade

    TBP is more "amazing" because it's purposly theatrical, dramatic, naughty, flamboyant and over-the-top.
    But MCR is more intense, violent, underground and vivid.
  • Celeste-o-bot 9000 October 04, 2007 22:19:13
    Celeste-o-bot 9000

    MCR

    Even though they are the same people, there is a difference somewhat. I go with MCR because I fell in love with them first =]
  • +1 raves
    Hola October 04, 2007 21:30:18
    Hola

    MCR

    I am more familiar with them but i bet The Black Parade has amazing songs too.
  • chris October 04, 2007 21:15:25
    chris

    MCR

    They are both the same to me though.
  • Cacheman October 04, 2007 20:02:20
    Cacheman

    MCR

    I LIKE THE SONG THO
  • +1 raves
    gerards_my_bitch October 04, 2007 19:59:06
    gerards_my_bitch

    MCR

    cos thats who they are.

    and theyll always be those messed up little guys for me.

    xxxxxxxxx
or
Cancel