Jimmy Page VS. Eddie Van Halen VS. Tony Iommi VS. Carlos Santana

Question Music

Jimmy Page VS. Eddie Van Halen VS. Tony Iommi VS. Carlos Santana?

by CesarRockoon/GodSoccer&RokNRol Posted October 27, 2009 04:01:09

28 answers
Read all 31 comments
+7 raves

3rd round

Answers
Results
Recommend This

Top Comment

+2 raves Sarah Films the Clouds October 27, 2009 19:08:10

Answered: Tony Iommi-Black Sabbath,Heaven & Hell
Oh. FUCK.
I can't believe I'm subjecting myself to this impossible question.
All are bloody brilliant, but I'm choosing Tony Iommi because he was with Black Sabbath and they invented metal. Pretty much. Meaning... they were the most revolutionary of the four listed groups/artists.
View thread

Sort By

Most Raves
Least Raves
Oldest
Newest

text size

Comments

Kane Solamon 3 days ago

Answered: Carlos Santana-Solo
2 more are missing of this list ok 3 joe satriani and Jimmy Hendrix and B.B.King. but of the provided id have to sy carlos is consisstantly making love to his guitar more then the other's.
CesarRo... to Kane So... 1 day ago

they are on othe polls
Grogan is a gun 7 days ago

Answered: Tony Iommi-Black Sabbath,Heaven & Hell
Just a legend.. What else can i say lol
Riley November 12, 2009 17:44:25

Answered: Carlos Santana-Solo
Lol Carlos Santana
johnnyg November 02, 2009 03:06:51

Answered: Eddie Van Halen-Van Halen
when Van Halen came out everybody went nuts over Eddies playing.
Go†em Morgo†h October 30, 2009 20:56:03

Answered: Eddie Van Halen-Van Halen
Eddie!!!!!!!!
devafaire October 29, 2009 01:58:51

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin

he is the best!
Peace~Luv~Music (in Clairni... October 27, 2009 20:58:18

Answered: Eddie Van Halen-Van Halen
ROCK ON

JUMP FOR VAN HALEN

Go Ahead Jump!
CesarRo... to Peace~L... October 27, 2009 23:11:34

ok I will
Peace~L... to CesarRo... October 28, 2009 21:59:18

lol
+2 raves
Sarah Films the Clouds October 27, 2009 19:08:10

Answered: Tony Iommi-Black Sabbath,Heaven & Hell
Oh. FUCK.
I can't believe I'm subjecting myself to this impossible question.
All are bloody brilliant, but I'm choosing Tony Iommi because he was with Black Sabbath and they invented metal. Pretty much. Meaning... they were the most revolutionary of the four listed groups/artists.
+1 raves
CesarRo... to Sarah F... October 27, 2009 23:13:04

I think Led Zeppeling was as revolutionary as Black Sabbath
john brenni October 27, 2009 12:10:28

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin
Not a Pretender on the list.
CesarRo... to john br... October 27, 2009 23:13:23

What do you mean
john br... to CesarRo... October 28, 2009 22:53:45

i mean they are true guitarist not fakes who use too much smoke and mirrors so to speak. pretender means a pseudo virtuoso.
CesarRo... to john br... October 28, 2009 23:04:16

ok
Mindy October 27, 2009 10:41:14

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin
I had a hard time choosing between Santana and Jimmy Page. But I'll say Jimmy Page
CesarRo... to Mindy October 27, 2009 23:14:07

ok
hope you don't get a headache
Tommy Trend October 27, 2009 04:29:24

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin
Jimmy Page
+2 raves
Jackie October 27, 2009 04:28:04

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin
Jimmy Page, with all due respect to Eddie.
+1 raves
XENON23 October 27, 2009 04:20:55

Answered: Carlos Santana-Solo
Jimmy was always the weak link in Led Zep. John Paul Jones wrote most of the songs and did more work. Page was just a cheap stand in. I saw him with the firm and he did the same solo with the same light show that I so him do in 77 with led zep.
+1 raves
Tommy T... to XENON23 October 27, 2009 04:30:51

very interesting!
+1 raves
XENON23 to Tommy T... October 27, 2009 04:39:22

It was a real let down for me but at that Firm show all the players were well known except the bass player and after much fan fair for the first three they gave the bass player his solo and at first no one clapped or anything but by the end he had everyone standing. He was very good. Sad that I forgot his name.
+2 raves
Jackie to XENON23 October 27, 2009 04:37:07

You obviously don't know your history about Zeppelin. I agree with you that JPJ didn't get the credit he deserved, but he was not the backbone of Zeppelin, Page was. If any member of Zeppelin got more credit than they deserved it was Robert Plant..only because his voice was the sound, Page was the mastermind of the Zeppelin sound. Any true fan knows that.
XENON23 to Jackie October 27, 2009 04:45:18

You are just very very wrong...and I have seen all of them both with led zep and solo. you should redo your rock math and stop worshiping a 2nd rate guitar player.

By the way JPJ's solo act played all his new stuff from that time and the Led Zep music. JPJ played jimmy's parts better than jimmy...Because he wrote them.
+1 raves
ken to XENON23 October 27, 2009 04:58:45

I disagree. I've studied many of the live performances on tape and dvd and can't remember a missed note in any of them. If you don't like Zeppelin that's one thing, but cheap stand-in? Ridiculous.
XENON23 to ken October 27, 2009 05:05:23

Yep...He was a cheap stand in and the live tape prove it....but Who really cares.
+1 raves
ken October 27, 2009 04:05:57

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin
Jimmy Page was and still is the best of all time. Those other fellas and hundreds of others are great as well. They're just not as great as Page.
+1 raves
Raine ♥RainBows_SkiTlezS_Ju... October 27, 2009 04:05:40

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin

Them or Carlos.....
+2 raves
tammerz/zɹǝɯɯɐʇ October 27, 2009 04:05:21

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin
They're all great, I can't deny, but Mr. Page takes the blue ribbon.
+2 raves
The Ultimate $@v@ⓖë ┠┨ℹ☧☧ℹë... October 27, 2009 04:02:12

Answered: Jimmy Page-Led Zeppelin
I love them all, but I LOVE Jimmy.