YouTube refuses to remove Mohammed movie clips - Telegraph: Agree?

by Heisenberg Posted 2012/09/13 19:27:22

Related Topics: Google, Film, Movie, Technology, Country, UK, Protest, Anti, Countries, Mocking, Blocked, 620, YouTube

132 votes
Read all 176 opinions
Lightning Report View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Agree	108 votes	82%
	Disagree	24 votes	18%

TELEGRAPH.CO.UK reports:
YouTube will not remove a film clip mocking the Islamic Prophet Mohammad that
has been blamed for anti-US protests in Egypt and Libya, but it has blocked
access to it in those countries.

prophet mohammad blamed anti-us protests egypt libya blocked access countries

prophet mohammad blamed anti-us protests egypt libya blocked access countries

+11

Add a comment above

Billyk75 2012/09/13 19:30:00

Agree

+7
Youtube shows a lot of videos mocking all religions.
>> See Replies

More polls by Heisenberg

sonofason to Rooka 2012/09/14 01:23:40
sonofason to Rooka 2012/09/14 01:23:54
Rooka to sonofason 2012/09/14 15:20:31

that was not what i wanted to discuss in the beginning but i will say it anyways and take the blows. first, Israel urged America against Iran, Syria, Iraq, Palestine,Afghanistan, and Sudan, Egypt now. Iran is the control of hesb'allah, it is allies with Syria, and it has weapons that is threatening for Israel and now the US is thinking about attacking Iran. when Iraq went and attacked Kuwait, full of petrol, and all countries went crazy Israel kept saying Iraq has nuclear and destructive weapons so the US invaded Iraq and burned it down to the ground, killed sadam hussein, killed a million of the Iraqi population and it turned out there were no nuclears or anything and they said sorry we found nothing but we achieved democracy and got rid of Saddam for the Iraqis. Palestine is conquered by Israel because Israel has that belief (or was hoping) to have Palestine as their land when Brittan promised it that Palestine will be theirs (in the early 1940s) and Britain, France, and the US continued to provide Israel with weapons to help it invade Palestine and that is how Palestine is now conquered. in the 9/11 the towers were hit because the US kept helping Israel with all needs necessary to conquer Palestine and Palestine was dyyying and no one was helping so the Qaeda ended up hitti...

that was not what i wanted to discuss in the beginning but i will say it anyways and take the blows. first, Israel urged America against Iran, Syria, Iraq, Palestine,Afghanistan, and Sudan, Egypt now. Iran is the control of hesb'allah, it is allies with Syria, and it has weapons that is threatening for Israel and now the US is thinking about attacking Iran. when Iraq went and attacked Kuwait, full of petrol, and all countries went crazy Israel kept saying Iraq has nuclear and destructive weapons so the US invaded Iraq and burned it down to the ground, killed sadam hussein, killed a million of the Iraqi population and it turned out there were no nuclears or anything and they said sorry we found nothing but we achieved democracy and got rid of Saddam for the Iraqis. Palestine is conquered by Israel because Israel has that belief (or was hoping) to have Palestine as their land when Brittan promised it that Palestine will be theirs (in the early 1940s) and Britain, France, and the US continued to provide Israel with weapons to help it invade Palestine and that is how Palestine is now conquered. in the 9/11 the towers were hit because the US kept helping Israel with all needs necessary to conquer Palestine and Palestine was dyyying and no one was helping so the Qaeda ended up hitting the towers, which if you think about it is just fair after the mass killings in Palestine, either way both people killed in both countries were innocent people that had nothing to do with anything but maybe you should blame you're own leaders for that not ours. sudan, it got divided into 2 halves because in the war between Egypt and Israel in 1967 when Israel was hitting Egypt and destroying it the Egyptian army escaped to Sudan for shelter AND by dividing Sudan the south side of Sudan may build dams to prevent the Nile from reaching Egypt and making it die in drought. again America, Europe, and Israel provided the south side with info and weapons that made them stronger than the west side. and now Israel is trying to overtake Sinai from Egypt and disrupt our president Morsy and they are the ones behind this movie trying to degrade Islam and so far they are doing a great job as Zionists in trying to ruin the relationship between the east and west.
(more)

reply
sonofason to sonofason 2012/09/15 01:04:04
sonofason to Rooka 2012/09/14 01:24:43
sonofason to Rooka 2012/09/14 01:20:59
Rooka to sonofason 2012/09/14 15:20:39

no, it says fight those who fight you and thats exactly what we do every time you humiliate our religion, prophet, or kill millions of our people we fight back ONLY when someone starts.
Verse 2:190
Yusuf Ali:
Fight in the cause of God those who fight you, but do not transgress limits; for God loveth not transgressors.
Zohurul Hoque:
And fight in the way of Allah against those who fight with you, but do not transgress. Certainly Allah does not love the aggressors.
T. J. Irving:
Fight those who fight against you along God's way, yet do not initiate hostilities; God does not love aggressors.
T.U. Hilali-M. Khan:
And fight in the Way of Allâh those who fight you, but transgress not the limits. Truly, Allâh likes not the transgressors. [This Verse is the first one that was revealed in connection with Jihâd, but it was supplemented by another (V.9:36)].
M. Pickthall:
Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors.
M.H. Shakir:
And fight in the way of Allah with those who fight with you, and do not exceed the limits, surely Allah does not love those who exceed the limits.

http://www.qurantoday.com/Baq...

reply
pdt_ski to Rooka 2012/09/16 17:16:55

Thank you for the quotations.

reply
sonofason to sonofason 2012/09/15 01:06:22
sonofason to Rooka 2012/09/14 01:25:35
Rooka to sonofason 2012/09/14 15:20:46

+1
again! i said i have close christian friends and that i suggested mocking you're Jesus to help you imagine the feeling of being disrespected; but i didn't which makes me better than you. honey i don't care what you think of me just as i am sure you don't care what i think of you i am just defending my religion :)

reply
audie to Rooka 2012/09/14 02:30:25

+3
Give me a brake, I know people that have lived in muslim countries and they threated Christians as third rate citiciians.

reply
Rooka to audie 2012/09/14 15:37:22

mm i can't give you an answer because i don't know where that is. anyways, lifestyle, education, and class have a huge effect on how some Muslims would treat you. if i was a tourist going to third world countries i would have known what their social norms are ( in terms of clothing maybe), have a guide with me, not walk around in low class areas and keep in mind that not all people are open minded. or that is what i would do if i was going to Germany for example, which is well known among Muslims for its extreme racism and so i wouldn't even go there from the first place. the idea is that not all are alike and it depends on social factors that appear from clothing or anything really.

reply
sonofason to audie 2012/09/15 01:07:31
pdt_ski to Rooka 2012/09/14 04:57:45

+3
Have you seen The Life of Bryan? It is a Monty Python film mocking the life of Jesus. It is technically blasphemous but it still exists.

reply
David (... to pdt_ski 2012/09/14 08:36:01

+2
It's bloody funny too.

reply
Rooka to pdt_ski 2012/09/14 15:23:12

+1
hehe it would be crazy if its a christian who made it. i am not convinced why someone who is following a religion with his/her spirit not just saying yeah i believe would mock their own religion if you say i believe that religion then that means that you also respect it. i mean they are following that religion they are making fun of so are they laughing at themselves or what.......you get why muslims get angry and are supposed to get angry regardless of those people who went and burned down KFC in Lebanon(completely irrelevant to the movie) or something ,not sure, don't mind them because there are jokes about them on fb by other Muslims 2 for being irrelevant. but just the idea of someone making fun of our religion, and its not the first time it happens, is just outrageous and for us to just sit there with our mouths shut is mad and means that maybe if we are OK with it then we should become Christians or atheists or whatever instead. you know what i mean?

reply
pdt_ski to Rooka 2012/09/14 16:11:39

+2
Members of (at least most) of Monty Python cast are Christian, so they were lampooning their own religion - laughing at themselves.

I do agree with you that religion should be respected because, well, that is part of humility and reverence - making fun of it degrades it until it becomes a catch phrase.

Thanks for the insight into how normal people in these areas look at the extremists - kind of how we in America look at Neo Nazis.

reply
kobidob... to pdt_ski 2012/09/16 06:51:48

+1
Jesus is God. Had he not forgiven those that hung him on that tree no one would be around.

reply
pdt_ski to kobidob... 2012/09/16 17:20:36

+1
Yes.

reply
Bibliop... to Rooka 2012/09/14 15:44:46

Jesus wasn't so bad of a guy- it's the OT God that's the problem imho.

Also he's mistaking Muslims (a religious group) for radical Islamist factions (terrorists)

reply
flrdsgns 2012/09/13 23:56:44

Disagree

When people die because of a video, time for the video to be removed.

reply
David (... to flrdsgns 2012/09/14 08:36:30

+1
No it's time for the people to be removed.

reply
Azrael-In GOD we trust 2012/09/13 23:40:37

Agree

+2
Why should a few of THEM determine what the rest of us in the world does?

reply
Seraph O. Storms 2012/09/13 23:28:14

Agree

+1
But doesn't Youtube usually comply with tyrannical governments?

reply
kobidobidog 2012/09/13 22:42:05

Agree

+3
Bravo Youtube for allotting evil to be seen as the evil Islamic religion is. World should take note. All war is as destructive as rioting Muslims. To be soul wise the world needs to repent. There needs to be an organized effort to have the Muslims, and all to confess their sins to such other being specific not generalistic in nature.

reply
Kalgalath to kobidob... 2012/09/16 05:29:22

reply
kobidob... to Kalgalath 2012/09/16 06:38:34 (edited)

The wayward Christian persecutes the same people Muslims persecute. I am for the ones that are persecuted. That means I am separate from both in spirit. Muslims need to put down their mental weapons. It is like spy verses spy. I am looking down observing the folly of both. The atheist see it too but on a different level of consciousness.

reply
Kalgalath to kobidob... 2012/09/16 07:10:29

athiests see the foolishness of all gods.

We are all athiests. It is simply a matter of degree.

The same way you don't believe in Odin, or Vishnu, or mithra, or the great Juju on the mountain, or the great juju under the sea, or Baron Semedi...true athiests just take it one god further than most.

reply
Mike 2012/09/13 22:41:02 (edited)

Disagree

That's the problem idiots abound. The internet allows them a place to express their abnormal thinking throughout the world. Whats worse, other idiots believe the rhetoric and then put it into action. Hitler would have been in his glory............. He'd owned the world, apparently we are that nieve............... .

reply
Arya 2012/09/13 22:36:32

Agree

+6
Why should they remove that video? Youtube posts videos that are offensive to a great number of people. If you dislike them, then don't watch them. Free Speech is still alive and it should never be infringed upon, even when it angers or offends people! Political correctness can go to hell!

reply
David (... to Arya 2012/09/14 08:37:13

+2
Here, here.

reply
evangelism_vision 2012/09/13 22:27:43
Matt Fo... to evangel... 2012/09/13 23:09:08

+1
Didn't you mean to click "agree", judging by your opinions?!

reply
David (... to evangel... 2012/09/14 08:38:19

+1
Here, here.

reply
cuzzbuzzla 2012/09/13 21:55:34

Agree

+2
Just because some deny others free speech, in the name of God, no less, doesn't mean we have to.

reply
skyster 2012/09/13 21:52:28

Agree

+4
The video did NOT cause the barbaric events. They attacked us because they hate us.

reply
rocker1446 2012/09/13 21:45:12

Agree

+4
To bow down to the barbaric threats of these extremists would be completely against everything our Constitution stands for.

reply
none 2012/09/13 21:33:57

Agree

+3
Why should they, we have freedom of speech in our country, too damn bad if violent sub-human Islamic barbarians don't like it.

reply
jgh57 2012/09/13 21:33:06

Agree

+3
Why should they remove the truth.

reply