Quantcast

Would you break the law to save a loved one?

emo ♥ Яenju 2012/02/10 05:41:27
Related Topics: Law
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Leslie Hope 2012/05/17 15:27:03
    ya
    Leslie Hope
    ...but then, I break the law in order to have a relaxing evening. Puff puff pass!! ;-)
  • Red_Horse 2012/05/15 08:49:33
  • Claybern 2012/05/14 23:08:23
    ya
    Claybern
    You betcha.
  • sammanilla 2012/05/14 17:36:04
    ya
    sammanilla
    Sure! I've risked my life to save loved ones.
  • JuliaLoren 2012/05/14 17:18:49
    ya
    JuliaLoren
    id break the law no problem if someone was endangering someone i love (INCLUDING MY PETS!!)
  • none 2012/05/14 16:05:27
    ya
    none
    No question about it.
  • Charles E 2012/05/14 15:49:53
    ya
    Charles E
    In a heartbeat, short of killing another person.
  • Justin.Long 2012/05/14 15:34:38
    ya
    Justin.Long
    Unless it's likebreaking them outt prison to which they are guilty of a crime but then again it depends on the crime as well lol
  • Diana 2012/05/14 15:16:19
    ya
    Diana
    Sure I would if it was to save a loved one.I don't think that would be important at the time.
  • SteveMarine- JLA 2012/05/14 14:02:17
    ya
    SteveMarine- JLA
    Yes depending on the situation... But most likely yes. Laws are needed to maintain a decent world...how ever our government has gone law crazy and some laws are just stupid in every way.... As a former sheriff deputy I've had to lock people up for stuff I just couldn't agree with.
  • MandaLynne 2012/05/14 13:55:30
    ya
    MandaLynne
    Without hesitation
  • BrianD3 2012/05/14 11:25:55
    ya
    BrianD3
    depends on the law
  • patriot88000 2012/05/14 07:20:40
    ya
    patriot88000
    If it is a law that harms someone or causes harm to people, especially a loved one then it is a badly written law that not only needs to be broken, violated and ignored, it also needs to be Nullified and Voided out by either a Jury or Legislatures who have the insight to correct the errors made by other Legislatures before they got elected.
    We have many badly written laws here in the united states and probably around the world as well, and just because a legislature writes and passes a law does not make it a good law. Laws that harms or causes harm to people need to be Nullified by either other Legislatures or Juries on a case by case basis if necessary.
  • VIC 2012/04/30 16:15:50
    Undecided
    VIC
    It depends of the person and the law!
  • patriot... VIC 2012/05/14 07:27:43
    patriot88000
    No, if the law causes harm to people it is a badly written law and that type of law needs to not only be violated it needs to be Nulllified or Repealed by either other legislatures or a Jury in a court of Law. In a courtroom when a Jury deliberates the Jury actually has more power and authority over a law then the Judge does because the Jury has the power to actually Nullify a Law and over-ride the lawmakers Judges just have the power to implement punishment of people who violate the law and get caught. If a Jury Nullifies the Law in a particular case in a courtroom the Judge is bound by their decision and does not have the authority to over-ride the Juries decision. That is the reason why Judges do not tell the Juries about all of their actual option in deciding a case. Judges don't want the Juries to know about their power of using Jury Nullification.
  • VIC patriot... 2012/07/05 10:25:14
    VIC
    Thank you for the informations. I meant that some acts are unforgivable and it depends if the beloved one is guilty or not, if is a crime or isn't.
  • Josh Stephens 2012/04/26 04:42:41
    ya
    Josh Stephens
    +1
    No question
  • katy.isodo 2012/04/24 16:15:02
    Undecided
    katy.isodo
    Depends on both the loved one.. and what type of law I'd be breaking.
  • patriot... katy.isodo 2012/05/14 07:30:35
    patriot88000
    It doesn't matter to me, if a law harms somebody it is a badly written law that needs to not only be violated it needs to be Nulliified or Repealed. Period. We do not need Laws that harms or causes harm to people there are to many badly written laws in our so- called civil society today to begin with.
  • katy.isodo patriot... 2012/05/15 14:00:16
    katy.isodo
    That being said - there are some laws which do help society, and are there for a reason. I'd also say that if you have a problem with the law - focus on getting the law changed. Breaking a law simply because you disagree with it does not make you right, you are committing a crime. In the end it's not going to help anyone if you are charged with someone and end up in jail because you dislike the way things are currently - if you want change, promote it positively.
  • patriot... katy.isodo 2012/06/17 01:59:17
    patriot88000
    Is Traveling without a license a crime, answer no. Why because Traveling is a Right, and lawmakers have without the authority to do so turned this Right of Travel into a State sanctioned Privledge so they can create a revenue source by forcing people to Purchase a Drivers License from the state, a revenue source that the State is not entitled to receive.
    Most travelers do not realize this when they apply for a Drivers License. Drivers are legally defined a a person who transports products or people for a living, that means that most people who just transport their person or personal property are not legally classified as Drivers, but are just Travelers. A drivers license is not necessary for most travelers, yet the States charge a fee for a Drivers License without telling people they already have a Right to freely travel and the States use coersion to force people into purchasing a Drivers License when it is not necessary. This is fraud and deceptive Practices by the State. Now are these bad laws or not. You tell me. Are the states guilty of deceptive practices by doing this? Judges in almost every state have already stated the mode of travel is irrevelant, from a Horse drawn Buggy to a car, Pick-up Truck , motorcycle it doesn't matter what the mode of travel is.
    All one has...
    Is Traveling without a license a crime, answer no. Why because Traveling is a Right, and lawmakers have without the authority to do so turned this Right of Travel into a State sanctioned Privledge so they can create a revenue source by forcing people to Purchase a Drivers License from the state, a revenue source that the State is not entitled to receive.
    Most travelers do not realize this when they apply for a Drivers License. Drivers are legally defined a a person who transports products or people for a living, that means that most people who just transport their person or personal property are not legally classified as Drivers, but are just Travelers. A drivers license is not necessary for most travelers, yet the States charge a fee for a Drivers License without telling people they already have a Right to freely travel and the States use coersion to force people into purchasing a Drivers License when it is not necessary. This is fraud and deceptive Practices by the State. Now are these bad laws or not. You tell me. Are the states guilty of deceptive practices by doing this? Judges in almost every state have already stated the mode of travel is irrevelant, from a Horse drawn Buggy to a car, Pick-up Truck , motorcycle it doesn't matter what the mode of travel is.
    All one has to do is look up Traveling Right Vs-Privledge and one can see the many court decisions verrifying the Right to Travel is our natural Right and the Legislatures do not have the authority to take a Right and turn this Right into a State Sanctioned Privledge. If many more people were aware of this, we could force the State Legislatures to stop this practice and stop violating our natural laws.
    (more)
  • katy.isodo patriot... 2012/06/17 13:39:10
    katy.isodo
    I don't see how the right to travel automatically gives you the right to drive without a licence. There are many means of travel which do not require said licence - on top of the fact that a licence in one state will work in any other state as long as it's not expired. The licence serves more as a tool of judging a persons ability to drive, testing medically, as well as actual capability - but also regulates the registration of vehicles, and forces people to have insurance in case of accident protecting both self and others. Not to mention it provides a means for courts to restrict those that abuse it. And frankly, traveling is not a 'right'. We are blessed in this country and are privileged to be able to freely move from place to place - it is not so in many areas of the world.
    Having said all of that - if it's a law that you truly disagree with, work on changing it. Breaking that law simply because you disagree with it is taking a risk. Some judges might agree with you, but many won't.
  • patriot... katy.isodo 2012/06/23 14:29:58
    patriot88000
    I am sorry for you that thinking that Traveling is not a Right but is a State sanctioned Privledge. If you don't know your Rights, then you won't know when they are being violated.
    Please tell me again. If you were not forced by coersion using the police with the threat of a fine or a jail sentence to spend the $20-$30 or whatever it costs in your state that the State is not entitled to for a State sanctioned Drivers License every 4-6 years or whenever your drivers license expired in your State, that you would voluntarily donate this money to your state just for the claimed privledge to travel in your State is that correct, or would you prefer to actually exercise your Right to Travel freely.

    If the State could charge you a $20-$30 fee for just walking down the sidewalk, would you also willingly pay this fee and actually believe it is a fair, just, or lawful fee, or would you be willing to learn about your Rights and file a lawsuit against the State for charging an unlawful tax or fee upon the citizens and attempt to get this unlawful law repealed or reversed?
  • katy.isodo patriot... 2012/06/23 21:04:16
    katy.isodo
    I agree that traveling is a right - we are free to do so in America. What I said and meant - which you clearly didn't understand, was that just because traveling is a right in the US, does not mean driving a motor vehicle is. There are means of travel that do NOT require a licence - walking, biking, etc.
    I would compare this to.. having to have a licence to fly an airplane. It's a means of travel, but just because it's a means of travel doesn't automatically give you that right.
    I personally agree with drivers licences though I admit that a lot of it could be done better. The cost could be lowered until it only basically covers it's own fees. However it does enable those who abuse the right through drunk driving, or reckless driving to have consequences. And what of those that refuse to drive with insurance? Accidents happen - often leading to life altering injuries which cost hundreds of thousands of dollars or more.
    While I do not like taxes, I do not agree with where all the money goes - I also know that they help pay for many of the programs and benefits we have as American citizens. As an example - one of the leading causes of death on the planet is simply not having access to clean water. Those of us blessed to be in America for the most part - do not need to deal...
    I agree that traveling is a right - we are free to do so in America. What I said and meant - which you clearly didn't understand, was that just because traveling is a right in the US, does not mean driving a motor vehicle is. There are means of travel that do NOT require a licence - walking, biking, etc.
    I would compare this to.. having to have a licence to fly an airplane. It's a means of travel, but just because it's a means of travel doesn't automatically give you that right.
    I personally agree with drivers licences though I admit that a lot of it could be done better. The cost could be lowered until it only basically covers it's own fees. However it does enable those who abuse the right through drunk driving, or reckless driving to have consequences. And what of those that refuse to drive with insurance? Accidents happen - often leading to life altering injuries which cost hundreds of thousands of dollars or more.
    While I do not like taxes, I do not agree with where all the money goes - I also know that they help pay for many of the programs and benefits we have as American citizens. As an example - one of the leading causes of death on the planet is simply not having access to clean water. Those of us blessed to be in America for the most part - do not need to deal with this issue.
    I know my rights - I also know how to pick my battles and would prefer raising a stand over something much larger than needing a drivers licence.. such as the current foster care system.
    (more)
  • patriot... katy.isodo 2012/06/26 15:52:05
    patriot88000
    As many of the State Supreme Court Justices have stated in most of the states, Traveling is a Right, not a State sanctioned Privledge, and as such they have also stated in their summeries about the Right to Travel issue the mode of Travel is irrevelant. Horse and Buggy, car, pick-up truck, motorcycle, it really doesn't matter.
    This is still a Right and the States using coersion and fear rake in millions of dollars they are not entitled to from charging a fee for selling those state sanctioned Privledges, It is our absolute Right to use the roadways freely to transport our persons and our private property, the only people that can legally be charged a fee are the people who use the roads for a living these people such as Truck Drivers, Bus Drivers, Taxicab Drivers ect.. must purchase a Drivers License because the use the roads or highways for Commercial Activity, all other Travelers just use the highway for pleasure and are not required to purchase a Drivers License.

    As far as the issue of not having clean water, that is the fault of the EPA itself, the EPA when they issue a fine to a Corporation, they only issue a fine of about $25,000 per citation, that fine makes if financially feasable for the Corporation to continue dumping because that fine is less then the Corporation...
    As many of the State Supreme Court Justices have stated in most of the states, Traveling is a Right, not a State sanctioned Privledge, and as such they have also stated in their summeries about the Right to Travel issue the mode of Travel is irrevelant. Horse and Buggy, car, pick-up truck, motorcycle, it really doesn't matter.
    This is still a Right and the States using coersion and fear rake in millions of dollars they are not entitled to from charging a fee for selling those state sanctioned Privledges, It is our absolute Right to use the roadways freely to transport our persons and our private property, the only people that can legally be charged a fee are the people who use the roads for a living these people such as Truck Drivers, Bus Drivers, Taxicab Drivers ect.. must purchase a Drivers License because the use the roads or highways for Commercial Activity, all other Travelers just use the highway for pleasure and are not required to purchase a Drivers License.

    As far as the issue of not having clean water, that is the fault of the EPA itself, the EPA when they issue a fine to a Corporation, they only issue a fine of about $25,000 per citation, that fine makes if financially feasable for the Corporation to continue dumping because that fine is less then the Corporation earns in 1 day of profits, so to the Corporation would rather pay the fine and continue polluting our water system then actually incirr the costs of cleaning up and properly disposing of their waste products. In other words our EPA depatrment is a sham and actually works with and for the Big Corporations.
    (more)
  • katy.isodo patriot... 2012/06/27 00:09:50
    katy.isodo
    I suppose we'll have to agree to disagree at this point. Though when you are hit by a drunk driver who does not have a licence - or insurance, and have severe injuries which keep you from working and may even cap out your own insurance - perhaps you'll remember your former thoughts on the matter.
    The system is broken, the money that goes into it is misplaced, but there are aspects of it that keep us as citizens safe. And when it comes down to it, you as a human being are born with very few 'rights'. The things we have in this country are blessings, not by birth entitlements. If you don't like the way the government in this country is run, work in a positive manner to change it - or take a look at how any other country works.
  • patriot... katy.isodo 2012/07/11 10:43:12
    patriot88000
    So are you saying a plastic card with your information on it will stop you and protect you from being hit by a drunk driver? A drunk driver can hit you whether he/she has a drivers license, and insurance or not.
  • katy.isodo patriot... 2012/07/14 02:57:27
    katy.isodo
    True - but it is the reasoning behind the licence system to begin with. If people want to break the law - they can and will, no matter how many laws or systems you make. This doesn't make the system broken, it's just human nature.
  • Timetraveler 2012/04/24 13:40:01
    ya
    Timetraveler
    +1
    I have and I will!! I don't subscribe to the police notion that it's OK not to tell on a crooked cop, but it;s wrong if you harbor a family member Hypocrites all!
  • SillyPunk-RockGirl 2012/04/24 11:37:47
    ya
    SillyPunk-RockGirl
    +1
    of course :)
  • jenna 2012/04/24 10:51:51
    Undecided
    jenna
    am not sure
  • patriot... jenna 2012/05/14 07:39:18
    patriot88000
    +1
    What are you not sure about? If a loved one is being harmed by a badly written law then it is not only your right but your duty to help or save your loved one from being harmed by that law. If that means breaking or violating a badly written law to do so, then the law itself is bad not your loved one or yourself for breaking or violating the law. These type of laws need to be Nullified or Repealed so your loved ones or other people will not be harmed by these laws. You might not have much of an impact on your Legislatures in getting a law Repealed , but you can have a great inpact on getting the Law Nullified in a court of Law by a Jury. Jury Nullification is legal and recognized by all 50 states and the Juries actually have the power to correct the effects of a badly written law on an individual who has been caught violating or breaking that law when they deliberate and decide on the fate of the Defendant by using Jury Nullification the Jury can get the Defendant off very easily by voting Innocent of all Charges.
  • POWERSHAKER 2012/04/24 07:21:01
    ya
    POWERSHAKER
    +1
    Yes. Of course, saving their life would have to be the reason.
  • learning2walkagain 2012/04/24 05:39:11
    ya
    learning2walkagain
    Naturally
  • Max7 2012/04/24 03:50:45
    no
    Max7
    I love my family dearly, and I did my best to teach my children right from wrong and to abide by the law. I've even gone as far as trying to do likewise where my grandchildren and great-grandchildren are concerned. My mother God love her is 93 and she pretty much keeps her nose clean, and personally, breaking the law is not something that I entertain, and I am too, too, too old to go to jail.
  • patriot... Max7 2012/05/14 07:43:12
    patriot88000
    What if the law itself was a badly written law and harmed or caused harm to people especially a loved family member. I Think it would not just be your Right but your Duty to if need be violate the badly written law in order to save a loved one. Just because a lawmaker writes and passes a law does not make it a fair, just, or good law. Laws that harm or cause harm to people need to be Nullified or Repealed before loved family members or other people are harmed by that law.
  • Max7 patriot... 2012/05/14 18:28:07
    Max7
    There is always a "right" and logical way to handle matters, breaking the law is harmful. I love my family, but if they break the law, the consequences is on their shoulder. Moral support I'd be there for them. All of us have a charge to keep concerning keeping the law.
  • amazinggrace 2012/04/24 03:04:36
    ya
    amazinggrace
    +1
    yeppers
  • Melody 2012/04/24 02:55:49
    ya
    Melody
    +2
    In a heart beat
  • Amy.[: 2012/04/24 02:31:14
    ya
    Amy.[:
    +1
    in a way.... yes

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/21 11:23:22

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals