Quantcast

Woman Wakes Up With Foreign Accent: Is It Real or Fake?

SodaHead Living 2011/05/06 17:20:09
You!
Add Photos & Videos
This story will make you think twice about going to the dentist.

Karen Butler had oral surgery that required anesthesia 18 months ago. Sounds pretty routine, except when she woke up, the 56-year-old lifelong Oregon resident had an Irish-Scottish-British accent, with notes of Australian and South African.

"It’s like a chameleon voice," Butler told the "Today" show on Thursday. "And I can’t make it be something that it isn't. You can pretend to have a southern drawl and talk like John Wayne; I can’t."

Butler appears to be suffering from foreign accent syndrome, which affects only about 100 people worldwide. It's usually brought on by a stroke, brain injury or, in some cases, a tumor.

While some people suspect Butler is faking, she and her husband are actually enjoying the ailment.

"We’ve had more fun with this than anything else," Glen Butler told "Today."

Do you think Butler's the real deal? Or is she faking it for attention?

Read More: http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/42912831/ns/today-to...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • mummum 2011/12/16 17:32:10
    Fake
    mummum
    +1
    oh please.
  • tony 2011/05/20 04:23:35
    Real
    tony
    it happened to madonna!
  • Alex Oger 2011/05/12 19:08:32
    Fake
    Alex Oger
    but maybe she 's haunted by a restles spirit or several of them like possesion ?
  • JWoods0417 2011/05/10 21:54:15
    Fake
    JWoods0417
    Shut up lady, you're a clown.
  • Mike lewis 2011/05/09 13:51:35
    Real
    Mike lewis
    IT'S REAL IF IT IS NANCY GRACE WAKING UP WITH A MAN'S ACCENT (AND MORNING TIMBER)
  • Raithere 2011/05/09 13:11:42
    Fake
    Raithere
    Certainly the brain is very complicated and all kinds of strange things can occur. But it does seem to me that the odds that she is faking it are far greater than the odds that she has an inexplicable neurological condition for which the only symptom is that she has some bizarre accent.

    And since they relate the condition to having a stroke it would be negligent not to perform diagnostic tests to determine whether she has actually had one or not as she could be at risk of having another.
  • Leia-Lou 2011/05/09 12:16:34
    Fake
    Leia-Lou
    Oh LOL!!!
    I'm going to get off the plane in Calgary and all of a sudden have a Canadian accent... I'll blame it on the fact I fell asleep as we flew across the boarder... But shhhhhhh, don't tell anyone... lol
  • MG-42 2011/05/09 12:04:56
    Fake
    MG-42
    The bitch will write a book next week telling how when she floated around spouting foreign languages. Can her!
  • Michael Hertel 2011/05/09 10:01:01
    Real
    Michael Hertel
    But impossible to know for sure. Humans are complicated in ways we have only just begun to notice much less understand.
  • Myrle Hulme 2011/05/09 05:36:23
    Fake
    Myrle Hulme
    As I have'nt heard her and a accent is easy too fake. Does she say she has been taken over by a boogyman:)
  • Knight Of Blood 2011/05/09 04:07:48
    Fake
    Knight Of Blood
    some people just love to get attention.
  • BrokenArrow 2011/05/09 04:05:52
    Fake
    BrokenArrow
    I wokeup this morning thinking I was the key member of SEAL TEAM 6 that off'ed Bin Laden. Problem is I woke up a 37 year old woman, 5'7" 121 lbs with bad knees. Damn it was a cool dream. Didn't make it real.....
  • METALheadMom 2011/05/09 03:08:00
    Fake
    METALheadMom
    +1
    PEOPLE WILL DO ANYTHING FOR ATTENTION.....
  • FantasyAuthor 2011/05/09 02:46:13
    Real
    FantasyAuthor
    +1
    Mostlikely it is real but I don't know that for sure.
  • Papillon 2011/05/09 02:25:25
    Fake
    Papillon
    +1
    Oh c'mon.
  • Person 2011/05/09 01:44:06
    Fake
    Person
    +1
    I mean, it c o u l d be real... it's just probably not.
  • toosweet 2011/05/09 01:27:36
    Fake
    toosweet
    +2
    But the lazy eye is real for sure.
  • Papillon toosweet 2011/05/09 02:40:07
    Papillon
    +2
    Could be glass...
  • toosweet Papillon 2011/05/09 02:48:51
    toosweet
    +2
    Good point pete.
  • Seeker of Truth - War Wizard 2011/05/09 01:18:02
    Fake
    Seeker of Truth - War Wizard
    +1
    Her accent sounds like it keeps changing slightly, like she's working on keeping it up.
  • AngelDeath of Darkness *-_-* 2011/05/09 00:49:11
    Fake
    AngelDeath of Darkness *-_-*
  • tandra88 2011/05/09 00:08:05
    Real
    tandra88
    +2
    Nyeh...I just don't get that everybody is saying it's a British accent. Obviously, it's an Irish-Australian mix with a little bit of English. Not just straight English.
  • deadlyangel21 2011/05/09 00:07:06
    Real
    deadlyangel21
    +1
    It is real. but if it wasn't what could it really hurt?
  • Papillon deadlya... 2011/05/09 02:41:17
    Papillon
    It's embarrassing for those around her, don't you think?
  • deadlya... Papillon 2011/06/12 22:23:34
    deadlyangel21
    I think if they really loved her they'd get use to it.
  • Papillon deadlya... 2011/06/14 04:20:58 (edited)
    Papillon
    +1
    Yeah...if they can get used to Madonna changing her accent to fit her current beau, then I guess that woman's family can get used to her affected change of accent.
  • LadyBGood 2011/05/09 00:05:51
    Real
    LadyBGood
    +1
    I don't know but I did see something like this on TV before. It seems to be a real fluke...oxymoron but what else can it be?
  • ★earthbound_misfit★ 2011/05/08 23:35:23
    Real
    ★earthbound_misfit★
    +1
    I don't think she could keep it up that long if it was fake. And it seems like a pretty weird thing to fake.
  • Recruit 2011/05/08 23:20:48
  • LadyBGood Recruit 2011/05/09 00:03:25
    LadyBGood
    LOL gads I have missed your wit! Glad to have you back!
  • Recruit LadyBGood 2011/05/09 00:11:36
  • Kristen Jareth 2011/05/08 22:19:28
    Real
    Kristen Jareth
    +1
    But even if it wasn't, who cares?
  • Iddylu 2011/05/08 21:34:26
    Real
    Iddylu
    +2
    It seems like a pretty random thing to fake.
  • john doe 2011/05/08 21:30:57
    Real
    john doe
    +1
    could be fake, the human mind is far from being understood.
  • missnamecaller 2011/05/08 21:00:44
    Real
    missnamecaller
    +2
    Real or fake it sounds perfect and I think her new accent suits her well.
  • MeganST 2011/05/08 20:55:21
    Fake
    MeganST
    +1
    Maybe she had a really strange dream but I doubt it.
  • Maria 2011/05/08 19:43:46
    Real
    Maria
    +1
    If she's faking it, then she's doing a hell of a good job.
  • Lesleya 2011/05/08 19:23:50
    Real
    Lesleya
    +1
    The brain is a mysterious thing sometimes. I do believe it's possible.
  • TheDumbBlondie 2011/05/08 19:02:14
    Fake
    TheDumbBlondie
    +1
    Oops I meant to click yes, i do think its true it would be very hard to fake for that long and constanly.
  • IsolatedIncidents 2011/05/08 17:22:15 (edited)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 9 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/19 04:44:44

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals