Quantcast

Who does this more, men or women? You ask a question but don't listen for the answer.

kir 2012/08/05 14:01:00
Men do this more.
Women do this more.
It's about the same.
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Ever have someone ask you something and you give them an answer but they don't act based on that answer and then later on complain that you never gave them one. Is this a woman thing or just a people thing? I don't know.

Hopefully this gets a fair number of votes because I'm curious about what the different Demographics say.
Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • *K'eim*h3reg' *Peh2u *Meg' 2012/08/06 21:04:39
    Women do this more.
    *K'eim*h3reg' *Peh2u *Meg'
    Apparently only six other people had mothers. Men rarely ask the question in the first place, but when they do, it really is because they want an answer. Women ask questions for their own sake. The answer is meaningless. Okay, maybe I'm just a sexist.
  • Tom 2012/08/06 17:17:38
    It's about the same.
    Tom
    Depends who you ask. Me or my wife ;-)
  • Jaroslav Dantes 2012/08/06 12:23:40
    It's about the same.
    Jaroslav Dantes
    Who likes to compete, it means that to other is not reliable. Both go through another ideas on which the particular behavior in the original sense.
  • Nilam 2012/08/06 05:27:25
    Women do this more.
    Nilam
    in my experiences when it comes to an argument or debate with a women, i dont get a word in edgewise......
  • MIRANDDAAA :) 2012/08/06 05:04:08
    It's about the same.
    MIRANDDAAA :)
    It's super annoying. I don't understand why someone would waste my time by asking me a question and then ignore my answer. Talk about being super rude.
  • william raggett 2012/08/05 23:40:11
    It's about the same.
    william raggett
    +1
    And it is very annoying.....
  • ☮ Ron ☮ Paul ☮ 2012! ☮ 2012/08/05 19:02:48
    It's about the same.
    ☮ Ron ☮ Paul ☮ 2012! ☮
    Both my wife and I do this. :)
  • disclaimer 2012/08/05 18:40:59
    It's about the same.
    disclaimer
    My clinically insane grandfather has done this for over thirty years. A lot of elderly people do it, actually.
  • MlssCue =Go Blue= 2012/08/05 18:08:07
    It's about the same.
    MlssCue =Go Blue=
    Depends if I like where he's going with his answer. If I don't like it...I tend to think 'uh huh ok, in one ear & out the other...are you done yet?"
  • Edensasp 2012/08/05 17:59:01
    Women do this more.
    Edensasp
    Based only on my personal experience.
  • rich 2012/08/05 16:45:05
    It's about the same.
    rich
    I think it has a lot to do with family dynamics, and whether or not a person was listened to within their family unit, or ignored, often, because the parents didn't feel that they had to listen to children. Then the kids, never learn to listen to each other because of this level of disrespect, so they grow up with this habit, and take it into interpersonal relationships. At its core, its a respect issue that got muddled along the way, till it is unclear that that is actually what it is. People have to train themselves to be good listeners often. I have found that the 3 second rule works in group therapy. A person is not allowed to respond, until after the other person has finished talking, and they have counted to three. Changes the dynamics, and retrains the speaker and listener.
  • bill.fi... rich 2012/08/06 02:20:26 (edited)
    bill.fife.3
    Sounds like a good plan. Too bad more people never consider any kind of therapy. ("...Me? Why, there's nothing wrong with ME! Now YOU, on the other hand...") Sad isn't it.
    But as I read your description it occurred to me how my experience is a little different, you could even say the opposite. One person in my family, who shall not be named, will ask a question then GLARE at you while repeating "...Huh?", ...HUH??" in your face like you're being interrogated at a police station while under arrest till you give them the response they want. How such people come by the idea that they have a right to treat family members this way then claim THEY are not the reason there is disagreement among said members is frankly beyond be. I am open to suggestions how best to handle such open and blatant rudeness.
  • rich bill.fi... 2012/08/06 11:25:06 (edited)
    rich
    Yes, that's true. Another version of intimidation and control. Not listening is about control, and aggressive listening is also about control. Try this book, because it helps to understand it better, and if I recall, makes some suggestions about how to deal with controlling people (been a long time since I read it, so operating on memory). It is called http://www.amazon.com/Control... . It might be very helpful actually. If it doesn't work well for you, let me know and I'll find another I've seen over the years, but can't call up right now. I usually turn to this one and it works for folks.

    Remember it is rude, but that person has learned it somehow, as the only way they can communicate. A bunch of folks on this thread share this feeling it appears. Anthony Robbins has an excellent discussion about communication styles from his early years, before he got so big and . . . risk taking, I suppose it is. He talked about how he and his wife were from different discussion/argument styles. He was taught that if you were in a discussion, it was the height of insult for you to not stay engaged, and leave the room. You had to stay there, talk, yell, scream and discuss or duke it out, whichever, but to walk away was unforgivable. His wife was taught that if anyone ever got ...

    Yes, that's true. Another version of intimidation and control. Not listening is about control, and aggressive listening is also about control. Try this book, because it helps to understand it better, and if I recall, makes some suggestions about how to deal with controlling people (been a long time since I read it, so operating on memory). It is called http://www.amazon.com/Control... . It might be very helpful actually. If it doesn't work well for you, let me know and I'll find another I've seen over the years, but can't call up right now. I usually turn to this one and it works for folks.

    Remember it is rude, but that person has learned it somehow, as the only way they can communicate. A bunch of folks on this thread share this feeling it appears. Anthony Robbins has an excellent discussion about communication styles from his early years, before he got so big and . . . risk taking, I suppose it is. He talked about how he and his wife were from different discussion/argument styles. He was taught that if you were in a discussion, it was the height of insult for you to not stay engaged, and leave the room. You had to stay there, talk, yell, scream and discuss or duke it out, whichever, but to walk away was unforgivable. His wife was taught that if anyone ever got loud in a discussion, or too animated, you were to leave the room for them to cool down, and not continue. In his words, "You can see why we had a lot of problems resolving things!" If you can still find his series Personal Power I, it is very useful for these sorts of things. Even moreso if both of you listen to it. I first heard it in 1989 I think.

    If the other person has a dissimilar family discussion style, then perhaps you have to identify the differences first, and then see if you can come to an agreement about what common ground would look like. Patricia Evan's book should help with at least the first phase, being identification. Hope this helps.
    (more)
  • bill.fi... rich 2012/08/06 14:04:16
    bill.fife.3
    Very helpful! Thanks.
    Yes the books may help. Lot to read but it never hurts to arm yourself when venturing into enemy territory. Wish I had had all this when the contacts were more frequent & intense and before a lot of the damage had been done. But as always better late than never.
  • rich bill.fi... 2012/08/06 16:40:36
    rich
    Yes, never too late. Basically, human beings are an interesting mess, all of us. We just have to keep trying to get better. Not doing so, is the only real problem. The rest can be worked out usually, with effort. Good luck!
  • Spe168 2012/08/05 16:34:44
    Men do this more.
    Spe168
    +1
    they are usually trying to make their point before they forget ot/
  • geegee 2012/08/05 16:19:42
    Women do this more.
    geegee
    I think women do it more.. They don't want to hear your answer. They just want to act like they are going to listen to you, so they can give THEIR answer and opinion. Women are like that, more so than men, I believe. This is because women talk more than men.. Men are just sitting with the remote in their hand, feeling POWERFUL !!!!
  • OPOA912 2012/08/05 16:04:51
    Women do this more.
    OPOA912
    My experience is that once a woman has made up her mind, no matter what you say isn't gonig to make a difference anyway.
  • rich OPOA912 2012/08/05 16:46:15
    rich
    Really?
  • OPOA912 rich 2012/08/06 16:05:54
    OPOA912
    I said "my experience", maybe different in your experience
  • Don Leuty 2012/08/05 15:39:40
    It's about the same.
    Don Leuty
    It's the answer that gets in the way.
  • Sweet-N-Sour 2012/08/05 15:21:26
    It's about the same.
    Sweet-N-Sour
    Some people are good listeners and some people are narcissistic asses, gender not withstanding.
  • Pamela Perkins 2012/08/05 15:15:05
    Men do this more.
    Pamela Perkins
    Men more, When you ask them something, It's goes in one ear and out the other,
  • Debowman 2012/08/05 14:30:51
    Women do this more.
    Debowman
    always thinkng they know what your going to say anyway
  • bill.fife.3 2012/08/05 14:17:56
    It's about the same.
    bill.fife.3
    +1
    It is a mistake (I think) to see this personality trait as sexually dimorphic. In some localized cases it could well be but overall I think the trait cuts across the gender line.
    There will always be people with longer and shorter attention spans, and greater and lesser degrees of self-absorption. And they make our world better or worse based on these differences.
    The biggest problem that I can see with all this is that all these groups continue to breed.
  • kir bill.fi... 2012/08/05 14:20:30
    kir
    +1
    That's why I asked and included the option of "it's about the same". In my personal experience I've seen it among women more, but that could just be chance.
  • bill.fi... kir 2012/08/05 19:17:30
    bill.fife.3
    It was a general comment with no one in particular in mind other than those responding with the other choices.
  • geegee bill.fi... 2012/08/05 16:24:00
    geegee
    +1
    Low IQ's tend to breed with others with low IQ. You never see a truly intelligent person breed with a person of low intelligence. It just doesn't happen. Attention span has a lot to do with IQ, I have found, as a teacher for many years.. unless the child is a true ADD.
  • Spe168 geegee 2012/08/05 16:39:28
    Spe168
    You are off topic!!
  • bill.fi... Spe168 2012/08/05 19:21:28 (edited)
    bill.fife.3
    Really? She is responding to my comment in support of my statement. Assuming it to be correct then the remarks would be squarely on topic as the original question seeks to explain these behavior traits with different choices offered. If not sex-linked then logic follows with a genetic explanation.
    And if you're following the results the overall trend appears to support this.
  • darlenedoskas1969 2012/08/05 14:17:47
  • kir darlene... 2012/08/05 14:21:23
    kir
    +1
    I don't think that's it.

    Person A: "What should I do with this water bottle?"
    Person B: "It's not good just throw it out."

    Next day

    Person A: "What should I do with water bottle?"
    Person B: ...
  • SA kir 2012/08/05 18:15:32
    SA
    LOL
  • the judgebigdogeagle 2012/08/05 14:11:50
    It's about the same.
    the judgebigdogeagle
    +1
    But for me. it is the buds. I have a friend hwo is helping with a problem.He asks questions,I answer,but he adds three more questions,my answer the same ,And this goes on for 10 minutes. I told him stop busting my chops.
  • KingdomNow 2012/08/05 14:11:29
    Women do this more.
    KingdomNow
    +1
    Hellfire, when I demand answers I had better get answers.
  • FPSRules 2012/08/05 14:06:49
    It's about the same.
    FPSRules
    It depends on the person I suspect and the importance they place on that particular relationship.
  • **StarzAbove** 2012/08/05 14:05:34
    Men do this more.
    **StarzAbove**
  • SA **Starz... 2012/08/05 18:20:13
    SA
    +1
    This morning hubby was making banana fritters and asked me the recipe. I told him(AGAIN) and he said..."That's not how I did it last time." LMAO....oh how I wish he would quit asking me questions to only complain!!! hahaha
  • **Starz... SA 2012/08/05 18:22:58
    **StarzAbove**
    +1
    lol You too?: I get that all the time....it drives me batty!
  • SA **Starz... 2012/08/05 18:28:45
    SA
    +1
    I get the all time favorite saying of men and cooking......"I've been cooking over 50 years now, I know what I'm doing."......hahaha....and they still don't get it right!! heehee

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/20 02:23:04

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals