Quantcast

Study Links Spanking to Later Mental Disorders: Is Spanking Ever OK?

mrosen814 2012/07/11 21:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
A study from the American Academy of Pediatrics shows that physical punishment to discipline children, has a strong association with "...increased risks of mental and personality disorders, as well as drug and alcohol abuse."

Though the article points out that spanking does not cause mental health disorders, researchers claim there is a strong correction. The results "send a strong message that spanking should never be used on a child," states Abel Ickowicz, psychiatrist-in-chief at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto.

THEGLOBEANDMAIL.COM reports:
Data doesn’t show that it causes mental disorders, but it does present a statistically significant correlation
spanking

Read More: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/parenting/stud...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • XRenX 2012/07/11 21:50:43 (edited)
    Yes
    XRenX
    +36
    I will. Spare the rod spoil the child. I got spankings (the rare few times I needed them) and I am fine. I am a college student, going back this year...I don't think I am crazy. Oh and I recall the singer P!nk saying she was a bad child and is grateful for the spanking discipline she got, otherwise she'd have gone down another path. Not every study is accurate.

    There was a study about weed damaging brain cells (not that I smoke it) and one about classical music making you smarter...both were proven to be myths. I am sick of all these parents now, being too lenient. Do you think that is good? They let their kids smoke, have sex, disrespect them, HIT them, scream and holler in public, etc. Teach them that YOU are in charge and as a parent, you have every God given right to be. You have more life experience than them of course they may not understand every form of discipline or restriction you put on them even upon an explanation. Look at it this way, say you have tried every form of discipline/help there is, except spanking and if all else failed, what would you do? Try what works and if it does, (and it isn't illegal) use it. We need to stop confusing necessary discipline for abuse.

    DISCIPLINE THEM EFFECTIVELY SOME HOW! We don't need anymore criminals than we have now, be a parent. Thank you.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Vieuphoria right-c... 2012/07/12 14:54:56
    Vieuphoria
    +2
    The Irony here is astounding.
  • Faith ~... Vieuphoria 2012/07/12 15:51:13
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    +1
    How many children do you have?
  • Sass Faith ~... 2012/07/12 15:53:24
    Sass
    And...what are their ages????
  • Faith ~... Sass 2012/07/12 16:01:34
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    Was that meant for me?
  • Sass Faith ~... 2012/07/13 17:59:31
    Sass
    No, it was for Vieuphoria.
  • Vieuphoria Faith ~... 2012/07/12 15:58:49
    Vieuphoria
    +1
    I have none. Because I know i'm not able to sustain them at this point. Unlike people who think it's cool to hit kids whenever they see fit.
  • Faith ~... Vieuphoria 2012/07/12 16:02:35
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    +1
    If you don't have kids, you don't know what you're talking about.
  • Vieuphoria Faith ~... 2012/07/12 16:13:13
    Vieuphoria
    +1
    I was a kid. I think that counts.

    If you can't be a decent parent without having to physically assault your child, then you aren't doing it right.
  • Sass Vieuphoria 2012/07/13 18:00:30
    Sass
    Come back little man when you have children of your own, say about when they hit the sassy years.
  • Vieuphoria Sass 2012/07/13 18:47:46 (edited)
    Vieuphoria
    +1
    I won't have children until i know I'm a good enough parent not to have to resort to such barbarism on my own children :) Unfortunately it seems many do not do themselves and their future children the same service.
  • zbacku 2012/07/12 14:06:54
    Yes
    zbacku
    +2
    Another useless study done by the Liberal Elite. I would bet that 90% of the American public over the age of 20 has been spanked. Some of the greatest men and women in the history of our country have been spanked when young.
  • sockpuppet 2012/07/12 13:56:41
    No
    sockpuppet
    +2
    Didn't know how to answer this one...

    To me, it's always seemed more effective to try to explain the consequences of a given action than to intimidate a child with physical force. I've always had good luck with this approach before, but I've never had kids of my own to be responsible for 24/7, so I could be totally naive about this. I was never spanked, and I seem to have learned the lessons I needed to survive, though.
  • Sass sockpuppet 2012/07/12 14:41:27
    Sass
    Dearie, try as you might, you cannot REASON with a child, they simply do not have the mental intellect to reason like an adult does. But you go ahead and explain away, then let me know just how that works out for you : )
  • sockpuppet Sass 2012/07/12 15:23:12
    sockpuppet
    +2
    Worked alright for my folks... and it's worked for me in the past.
  • Faith ~... sockpuppet 2012/07/12 15:58:49
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    Whith OTHER'S children. You SHOULDN'T be spanking other people's kids, and kids certainly react differently to people that aren't their parents. I have always had permission to spank my friend's children, but have never had the need to.
  • sockpuppet Faith ~... 2012/07/12 16:14:44
    sockpuppet
    +3
    OK... I wasn't spanked, and I turned out alright.
  • FullMetal Shorty 2012/07/12 13:46:29
  • Ichiban... FullMet... 2012/07/12 14:08:10
    Ichiban Otousan
    i remember seeing that on youtube...very sad to see what they did to that lady. I am not against spanking, I just would rather not do it....i don't remember my dad ever doing it to me...but he was a big man anyway...that was scary enough!
  • Jake Blanton 2012/07/12 13:43:51
    Yes
    Jake Blanton
    +4
    The problem we have these days is that not ENOUGH of the kids are having to answer for their actions by being spanked!
  • ☆Hitler was a community org... 2012/07/12 13:41:45
    Yes
    ☆Hitler was a community organiz☆
    +2
    the wooden spoon solves a lot of childish nonsense...we used to call it "time out" to throw the child protection Nazi's off
  • RoseyRhod 2012/07/12 13:36:53
    Yes
    RoseyRhod
    +7
    Kid is about to run into traffic, or stick a fork in a light socket, or put their hand in a fire. A quick whack on the butt and telling them NO in no uncertain terms, followed by an explanation that they can understand, lets them know that they must never do what they were about to do.
    You've warned the kid several times to stop doing what s/he is doing. Kid does not stop. Tell them if they do it again, they'll get a spanking.
    I can count on one hand the number of times I spanked my son. It's not something that should be done for every indiscretion, but sometimes it's called for. I'm not talking about beating the tar out of someone using a belt or a switch. Just an open handed swat on the bottom.
  • missa RoseyRhod 2012/07/12 14:26:42 (edited)
    missa
    +2
    i use to have to go outside and pick my switch off the tree!
  • Kruzer RoseyRhod 2012/07/12 14:47:53
    Kruzer
    +2
    We share the same parenting style. After the 3rd time it's not telling..it's begging..I will not beg my child to behave correctly it is a demand that must be met end of story.
  • Becky Kruzer 2012/08/07 11:49:08
    Becky
    IF this is your CHILD, DEMANDING is ridiculous.
  • BrianD3 2012/07/12 13:18:17
    Yes
    BrianD3
    +6
    spoiler alert!! Not spanking leads to spoiled, entitlement expecting liberals
  • Becky BrianD3 2012/08/07 11:49:31
    Becky
    NOT!
  • BrianD3 Becky 2012/08/07 11:59:44
    BrianD3
    says someone who ought to be spanked
  • Phil 2012/07/12 12:48:22
    Yes
    Phil
    +4
    In my various jobs working with the public I have seen kids who don't get spank act like unruly monsters who turn into unruly teenagers and I can only guess will be unruly adults.
  • Gavin 2012/07/12 12:35:05
    Yes
    Gavin
    +3
    Nothing wrong with it, it's good and works most of the time.
  • rhstarr 2012/07/12 12:31:41
    No
    rhstarr
    +4
    That was suppose to be yes. There are some kids that need spankings. I see nothing wrong with it. And I dont think it is linked to any kind of mental or personality disorder. I grew up with my grandparents, and they spanked. I think they should bring spanking back into the schools.
  • JCD aka... rhstarr 2012/07/13 05:27:29
    JCD aka "biz"
    Not in schools. I was whipped in elementary school for boys by this young female teacher who clearly enjoyed punishing the boys. My parents moved me to another school.
    Allowing teachers to spank/whip the kids attracts sadistic people to the teaching profession.
    I was also whipped when I was hazed in college, and I hated it, especially when there were "guests" around.
  • rhstarr JCD aka... 2012/07/13 14:30:24
    rhstarr
    When they did spankings in our schoool, they called the parents. And there was two witness there at the time as well. I wouldnt say it, but there are alot of kids out there that have no respect. And sometimes I feel like the parents just dont care.
  • JCD aka... rhstarr 2012/07/13 14:40:34
    JCD aka "biz"
    +1
    Thank you.
  • Becky rhstarr 2012/08/07 11:51:56
    Becky
    And spanking is respectful?????? That is CRAZY
  • Bill 2012/07/12 12:27:45
  • GlennDiamant 2012/07/12 12:23:26
    Yes
    GlennDiamant
    +1
    Only if kids do something particularly bad, like steal.
  • Torchmanner ~PWCM~JLA 2012/07/12 12:07:30
    Yes
    Torchmanner ~PWCM~JLA
    +7
    It has worked for thousands of years.

    People who don't spank their children don't really care for their well being. The non-spanking parents are usually the ones who are eager to dump their children off on others and want public school to have classes year round.

    Pro 13:24 He that spareth his rod hateth his son: but he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes.
  • Kruzer Torchma... 2012/07/12 14:49:22
    Kruzer
    +1
    Glad I'm not the only one that sees this going on as well!
  • Dave**Gay for Girls** 2012/07/12 12:02:01
  • DizziNY 2012/07/12 11:15:21
    Yes
    DizziNY
    +5
    I'm not into that whole spare the rod thing but sometimes a kid needs their butt whoppped to teach them how to behave.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/21 07:56:18

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals