Quantcast

Study Links Spanking to Later Mental Disorders: Is Spanking Ever OK?

mrosen814 2012/07/11 21:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
A study from the American Academy of Pediatrics shows that physical punishment to discipline children, has a strong association with "...increased risks of mental and personality disorders, as well as drug and alcohol abuse."

Though the article points out that spanking does not cause mental health disorders, researchers claim there is a strong correction. The results "send a strong message that spanking should never be used on a child," states Abel Ickowicz, psychiatrist-in-chief at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto.

THEGLOBEANDMAIL.COM reports:
Data doesn’t show that it causes mental disorders, but it does present a statistically significant correlation
spanking

Read More: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/parenting/stud...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • XRenX 2012/07/11 21:50:43 (edited)
    Yes
    XRenX
    +36
    I will. Spare the rod spoil the child. I got spankings (the rare few times I needed them) and I am fine. I am a college student, going back this year...I don't think I am crazy. Oh and I recall the singer P!nk saying she was a bad child and is grateful for the spanking discipline she got, otherwise she'd have gone down another path. Not every study is accurate.

    There was a study about weed damaging brain cells (not that I smoke it) and one about classical music making you smarter...both were proven to be myths. I am sick of all these parents now, being too lenient. Do you think that is good? They let their kids smoke, have sex, disrespect them, HIT them, scream and holler in public, etc. Teach them that YOU are in charge and as a parent, you have every God given right to be. You have more life experience than them of course they may not understand every form of discipline or restriction you put on them even upon an explanation. Look at it this way, say you have tried every form of discipline/help there is, except spanking and if all else failed, what would you do? Try what works and if it does, (and it isn't illegal) use it. We need to stop confusing necessary discipline for abuse.

    DISCIPLINE THEM EFFECTIVELY SOME HOW! We don't need anymore criminals than we have now, be a parent. Thank you.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Rennie Gade 2013/03/26 16:35:23
    Yes
    Rennie Gade
    What about a study on the effects of the withdrawal of affection? That's what I got instead of spankings, and it left me feeling bad about myself as a person rather than simply sorry for what I'd done.

    These anti-spanking studies routinely characterize spanking as abusive. If I'd had my juvenile bottom warmed when I clearly deserved it, I can't help thinking I would've taken a straighter path towards realizing my potential. Actions & Consequences; I didn't have an easy time with that. i needed a few good spankings and I never got them.
  • Pyro-82 2012/08/18 07:15:33
    Yes
    Pyro-82
    +1
    Ther is no LEGIDIMENT study to the claims of ental disorder and violence.
    There is a deffinate line between disciplne and abuse.
    Spankings are givin by cool-headed parents atempting to instill dicipline, ethics, and integrity into their children.
    Abuse is given by angry, out of control, and otherwise irresponsible parents.
    Respect, not hate.
  • Julian O'Leary 2012/08/15 06:31:08
    Yes
    Julian O'Leary
    +1
    I was a very misbehaved boy, I got spanked almost everyday and I deserved each one of them and I was always aware of that. I also knew my parents loved me and they did their job raising me. And I don't have a mental disorder.
    Maybe there are kids who are more susceptible and are not so aware of what's going on and misinterpret things and that leads them to psychological issues. Or maybe they're beaten with violence (which is way different from being spanked).
    This is not 1 + 1 = 2. Studies like this can only establish a correlation between two variables, but the whole thing is much more complex and many factors are involved.
  • Hamilton 2012/08/09 03:51:52
    Yes
    Hamilton
    The studies are BS. For any of you with any background in stats, go look at the sample selection.
  • Monty 2012/07/29 22:24:34
    Yes
    Monty
    in some cases yes.
  • Jack 2012/07/22 01:54:25
    Yes
    Jack
    +3
    Anybody who thinks that a child should never be physically punished, no matter how bad the behaviour, is too irresponsible to even have children.
  • Jack Jack 2012/07/29 22:29:04
    Jack
    +2
    ALSO: Up until a few decades ago, virtually all kids got spanked from time to time; so is the questioner suggesting that, until recently, everyone had a mental disorder?
  • democoach 2012/07/19 02:37:24
    Yes
    democoach
    +1
    studies! yeah well as studies say we need to disciple children in a cerain way, so do kids get more and more roudy, and less respectful! so you and your studies can get lost!

    some kids need spanking some others need different forms!
  • mm61675 2012/07/18 19:34:33
    No
    mm61675
    never been spanked, and never will spank my kids
  • ashlee 2012/07/16 23:27:47
    Yes
    ashlee
    But there is a time, a place, an a limit on spanking.
  • serethiel 2012/07/16 22:33:31
    No
    serethiel
    in some instances it's physical abuse. it teaches children that violence is an acceptable means to an end when all you really need to do is listen and respect others. this study may be utter bull, plenty of studies are, but spanking is never okay.
  • David (oYo) 2012/07/15 21:50:08
    Yes
    David (oYo)
    +1
    I want to smack attractive women's bottoms.
  • thє вluє wαndєrєr 2012/07/15 15:43:09
  • Crystal 2012/07/15 15:28:06
    Yes
    Crystal
    +1
    Maybe if some of these kids got a spanking once in a while when they do something bad. It wouldn't be so many disrespectful kids today.
  • paul 2012/07/15 15:25:51
    Yes
    paul
    Spanking has made me what I am today....... homeless guy
  • Andy 2012/07/15 13:52:51
    Yes
    Andy
    How many did they study??? Maybe what some call spanking is actually Physical Abuse...I can see the correlation there. No enough info to understand this study
  • ed 2012/07/15 12:44:10
    Yes
    ed
    hog wash kids should learn that the parents rule the roost and spanking or not kids will have problems growing up peer pressure is the or one of the biggest,it's not like they are going to get spanked several times a day and most of them who get spanked with grow up to respect their parents more.
  • Bren S. 2012/07/15 11:31:15
    Yes
    Bren S.
    I would say there are many more disorders(mental,behavorial,s... caused by parents trying to be "friends" with their kids.
  • MyJaded... Bren S. 2012/07/15 17:25:28
    MyJadedHeart
    +3
    I would agree.
  • zcberry 2012/07/15 05:44:42
    Yes
    zcberry
    +1
    LOL!!!! Please do not believe everything you read!!!
  • QTKaulitz 2012/07/15 05:39:50
    Yes
    QTKaulitz
    when children get unstable and misbehave intentionally, yes. however, when children are spanked, no matter what they did, it hurts. There was an incident in 2003 where a dad spanked his daughter for wetting the bed. she was only 2... sadly she died in the hospital. Spankings aren't lessons when pain is involved
  • Taxman QTKaulitz 2012/07/15 10:58:31 (edited)
    Taxman
    I believe 2 is too young for a spanking, but I would not confuse spanking with outright child abuse. Personally, we didn't do much of that with our children. A consistent, stable family life will usually raise good kids. My father once said "if they are old enough to throw a tantrum, they are old enough to get a pat on the butt".
  • QTKaulitz Taxman 2012/07/17 03:18:41
    QTKaulitz
    +1
    yeah, i just oppose spankings when and if they turn into beatings. u know, when anger actually fuels the spanking and it actually turns vioent. although I must stress that ppl must be aware of how much or how hard they spank, that's when the mistake for abuse knocks on the door
  • Taxman QTKaulitz 2012/07/17 03:35:09
    Taxman
    +1
    Rule 1 of being a parent--also know how to discipline yourself (self control)
  • Sarah 2012/07/15 03:55:44
    Yes
    Sarah
    +2
    Back then parents disciplined their kids, this is now called abuse
  • no1ymfan 2012/07/15 03:16:02
  • TriumphTom 2012/07/15 03:00:30
    Yes
    TriumphTom
    See how the undisciplined kids act today? See how they grew up? Nothing brings home the point as a good spanking. With my daughter, it took only once.
  • tatilee(: 2012/07/15 01:44:55
    Yes
    tatilee(:
    I was spanked as a child and I'm perfectly fine and have a nice and healthy relationship with my parents. It taught my discipline and respect. But there is a thin line between spanking and abuse.
  • RawRsaurus 2012/07/15 00:33:19
    Yes
    RawRsaurus
    There's a fine line between domestic abuse and being kinky....depending on which cheek you smack.
  • Princess_Peach 2012/07/14 23:30:37
    No
    Princess_Peach
    +3
    Hurting someone weaker then you because you're frustrated and too stupid to think of a way to discipline your child is disgusting. People need to be adults and control their temper. Sickening. I bend over backwards to make sure no pain or harm comes to my baby and people are going out of their way to inflict pain on children. They have mental problems and shouldn't have kids in the first place.
  • daniel wayne 2012/07/14 22:37:10
    Yes
    daniel wayne
    spanking is the only real choice if you cant look or sound threatening. once a child has enough vocabulary to understand why he cant play with the snake or put the screwdriver in the electric outlet (about 3 or 3 1/2), then spanking should only be used as a last resort or if the child gets defiant.
  • Justin.Long 2012/07/14 21:16:27
    Yes
    Justin.Long
    Those studies are very vague for a reason I can do a study that proves those that drive faster hve increased risk for heart attacks but that doesn't necessary mean it causes it

    I was spanked As a child and I'm fine (as fine as one can be these days lol)
  • kobidobidog 2012/07/14 21:05:11 (edited)
    No
    kobidobidog
    KJV ,Revelation 3 >>. 19As many as I love, I rebuke and chasten: be zealous therefore, and repent. That is not As many as I love I will beat the tarnation out of. That teaches that violence is the answer. That is why war, and 911 cured, and why humans are in the Persian Gulf right now.

    King James Version
  • Kim(: 2012/07/14 20:59:02
    Yes
    Kim(:
    Spanking is not a good idea
  • BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROC... 2012/07/14 20:40:31
    No
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    And I don't believe in that old spare the rod Benjamin Franklin, must have said that
  • VenomHalos 2012/07/14 19:12:59
    No
    VenomHalos
    +3
    Spanking does nothing but cause more issues. Anyone that thinks otherwise has clearly been brainwashed by it.
  • Dave The Canuck 2012/07/14 19:01:26
    Yes
    Dave The Canuck
    +1
    Only if the child did something REALLY bad and only as a VERY last resort.
  • Lemonzerozero 2012/07/14 18:53:31
    Yes
    Lemonzerozero
    +1
    I always laugh at witless parents trying to reason with a child who has not learned about boundaries. Using a spray bottle would probably work too.
  • JoeM 2012/07/14 18:45:03
    Yes
    JoeM
    This is a practice that has been used since forever. Dr Ben Spock had realized his error by the time he retired, but no one would listen to him at that point.
    This idea, that corporal punishment is bad, is in great part responsible for the deteriorating morals of society.
  • brian.southworth.921 2012/07/14 18:35:40
    Yes
    brian.southworth.921
    +2
    Omg. A pacive resistant mother that coddles her child causes problems as well. It is all in the method of the delivery. Are you doing it out of anger? Or are you doing it out of discipline. Do you explain why you are spanking your child first or haul of and spank them without correcting words of understanding? Which things are severe enough to warrant a spanking vs. grounding or time out? For instance, popping the hand of a kid that is about to stick their finger into an electrical socket creates a negative reward system within the Childs thinking to ever reach for it again. Is the immediate hurt by parent worse than the death of the child later on? Studies also show that a spanking is less damaging to a child than verbal abuse. The pain can be forgotten where the words can linger.
    But I think we all know the difference between a spanking and a beating.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 29 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/24 10:13:57

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals