Quantcast

Shouldn't we as adults make the decision whether to consume trans fats or not instead of having the government ban them?

Chef 2007/02/27 23:27:02
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The Trans Fat Controversy
Trans fats are on their way out of the American diet. Trans fats are created when vegetable oils are partially hydrogenated, a process that retards spoilage and allows the oils to be used in a number of industrial food processing applications. Some trans fats occur naturally in some vegetables and dairy products, but it is the trans fat that is used in cooking oil, and for baked goods like bread and cookies, that has gotten the attention of nutritionists and food activists.

A wide cross section of medical opinion blames trans fats for the lowering of blood levels of HDL (the good cholesterol) and an elevation of LDL (considered the bad cholesterol), leading to hardening of the arteries and coronary problems. The federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) estimates the average America eats 4.7 pounds of trans fats every year. Both the United States Department of Agriculture and the Department of Health and Human Services have warned against trans fat.

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Kelsea 2007/03/09 01:36:52 (edited)
    Undecided
    Kelsea
    +5

    we all very well know that many americans dont give a rats behind about what they are consuming. which is why we face the issue of obesity. i feel that i am going to take care of my body to the best of my ability up until the day i die. i will not live with the mindset " im going to die anyway". so i feel even though as an adult we should make the decision on our own , the government is the only way anything will be fixed. If it were up to us as adults instead of the governements PROTECTION about many other situations life as we know it would more or less be shot to hell....so it shouldnt be up to the governement but since humans overall are so helpless , there needs to be some guidance towards whats right and wrong for us....

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • J Montana~POTL~PWCM~JLA 2011/02/17 15:51:20
    Yes
    J Montana~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    yes
  • concerned 2008/05/04 04:50:48
    Yes
    concerned
    because some of us eat them all our life and have no effect from them
  • joanie baloney 2007/10/25 21:45:25
    Yes
    joanie baloney
    there is no question that trans fats are bad. Should food manufacturers try to find an alternative? Yes. Should the "Food Police" come in and control what we put in our own bodies? ABSOLUTELY NOT! It is not the governments job to protect us from ourselves! It is their job to protect us from outsiders. Quite frankly I am tired of the "Word Police" and the "Thought Police" (hate crimes bill).

    I have a right to free speech and anything I ever say will offend some and not offend others. Americans need to suck it up if they are offended by words. I hear stuff all the time that offends me but that doesn't mean that which offends me should be banned.

    Hate crimes... murder is murder is murder. It should make no difference if someone is murdered because they were protecting their home and family or they were murdered because of race, religion, or sexual orientation. That is a crime of thought. If one kills because they hate a certain group, they should pay the same penalty as the one who kills in the act of robbery or rape. It is unconstitutional the think we can hold someone to a higher standard because of what they were thinking.

    The government is way too involved in our personal lives!
  • fan424 2007/10/24 05:14:49
    Yes
    fan424
    We should be informed of the dangers, but there's not very much government banning I am in favor of.Glad to see you're here, Chef.
  • Patrick 2007/07/22 17:47:32
    No
    Patrick
    +1
    If the government can regulate tobacco then it should be able to regulate transfats which are just as dangerious to the individual. I know I know 2nd hand smoke is supposed to be bad but as a victum of hardning arteries, two heart attacks and a stroke, the first thing my doctor asked me if I smoked and second warned me about transfats. When my heart rate dropped below 40 BPM he ok'd my smoking until I could get the pacemaker installed. Now my heart will keep beating even if I spring a leak or am just brain dead (may be the case now)...........
  • CaptainMorgan 2007/07/09 20:06:05
    No
    CaptainMorgan
    Trans fats are awful, why would anyone want to consume them? These puppies actually revert back to a solid (their natural state) once they get into your system and cause waxy buildup in your arteries, which is perfect if you want a heart attack. Overall, I read that they're responsible for around 30,000 premature deaths every year. You'd be an idiot to WANT to consume something like that.

    And besides... it's not like restaurants tell you up front whether their food has trans fats or not. Half the restaurants out there don't provide any nutritional information what so ever. Some do, but most don't. How are you supposed to choose or not choose when you have no idea?

    And on the subject of choosing... apparently most of the people in this country have no idea what they're doing when it comes to nutrition. With all of the obese people in this country, apparently someone needs to tell Americans how to eat. What's so wrong with being healthy?
  • sweetpeachie 2007/06/24 21:31:45
    Yes
    sweetpeachie
    +2
    Next, they'll be telling me that I can't smoke. After that, they will tell me that I can't drink. What's next? Being able to tell me what I can and cannot do inside my own car? Inside my house? In my yard? When does the restriction stop?

    Smokers know the risks of nicotine, and the addictive factors of it. People who drink on a daily basis know the effects that alcohol can have on the liver, heart, etc. , if they drink too much. It is a conscious adult's decision to eat whatever they want, when they want, however they want. I agree that it is a great health risk, but I also understand that a "law" governing the product that we, as a people consume on a daily basis, is not a rational one. We're all free-thinking adults who have the right, BY CHOICE, to consume whatever food we feel the need to consume. If the government is policing our food, what do you think is going to stop them from policing the rest of what we do?
  • True~Male 2007/06/16 14:35:33
    Yes
    True~Male
    +1
    IF WE KILL OURSELFS AT AN EARLY AGE --LESS IMPACT AND LESS COSTLY TO OUR SOCIETY AS A WHOLE
  • meangreen3 2007/06/07 21:04:39
    Yes
    meangreen3
    +1
    People are not held accountable for their own actions. They can smoke then sue the cigarette companies. They can sue because coffee is hot, or cause fast food makes them fat. You are responsible for your own actions. If you choose to eat junk, your not going to be healthy. If you exercise and eat right you might get hit by a bus while jogging but you will leave a nicer looking corpse. The government is having enough issues doing the smallest things like pass an immigration bill or decide on the war they should not have to determine what you eat, how many burgers you shove down your throat, or how many hours of TV your allowed to watch.
  • Heather 2007/06/06 21:14:30
    Yes
    Heather
    Why shouldn't an adult have the right to decide what goes into his or her body? We don't need this kind of paternalism.
  • Evan 2007/06/06 17:46:19
    No
    Evan
    +1
    Ask yourself this, if you never knew they were changing to safer-lower fat oils, would you have noticed a difference? If its safer, I'm glad the government is banning the fatter choice. I just wish this would've come on a more important issue, like smoking!
  • kimmpossiable 2007/06/06 05:07:09
    No
    kimmpossiable
    +2
    THATS APART OF OUR RIGHTS.. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH, AS ADULTS WE PICK AT THE STORE WHAT WE WANNA BUY TO EAT AND COOK.. OUR COUNTRY IS BUILT ON CHOICES. IT'S MY CHOICE IF I WANT TO EAT TRANS FAT OR SATURATED FAT OR WHAT EVER...
  • tmr 2007/05/31 20:07:29
    Yes
    tmr
    +3
    The government has decided that we are all a bunch of young children incapable of taking care of ourselves. They have taken it as their right & duty to protect us from ourselves. It scares me to think what they will ban next.. This is waaaaaaaaaaaaay too much government interference.
  • jenni 2007/05/31 07:30:56
    No
    jenni
    +1
    I like having a wider variety of healthier food choices. I'm hoping the more choices there are, the cheaper healthy foods will be in the future.
  • meg 2007/05/30 04:01:26
    No
    meg
    +1
    obviously we are all too stupid to be making important decisions like this for ourselves. probably because most people don't think that what they put into their body every day is a serious decision.

    i think we should try to preserve our freedom and individual rights, but it isn't a simple matter of the actions of an individual that have no effect on anyone else. the ramifications of national health is tremendous. think about how much you have to pay for health care (you could be getting that money that your company has to pay for your benefits). how we eat affects so many things, i don't even think we fully comprehend the extent of it.

    what about that fat tax people were talking about before? we have a tax on tobacco... and that way, people could still make a choice, right? or how about we give incentives to people who eat healthy and exercise?

    we need to take better care of ourselves!
  • SMH 2007/05/16 02:19:50
    Undecided
    SMH
    +1
    Wow this is quite a question because hydrogenated oils do clogg your arteries and cookies, processed foods from processed meats to hamburger helper, mac and cheese and on and on have partially hydrogenated oils and most restaurants use the cheapest oils. Why do we want to do this to ourselves on a regular basis? I like to eat out sometimes too, what I do is drink a lot of lemon water and drink apple cider vinegar on a regular basis just because it's good for so many other things. If big Pharma and the FDA are trying to get our Doctors to write us prescriptions for herbs, vitamins and other supplements, then they should do us the favor by taking the bad oils out of the restaurants. It's up to us to take our health into our own hands the Doctors (most) and the FDA care about money. It's always about the money. But that would be a good thing for them to do because I am sure they won't being doing a lot of good things for the public in the food arena. SMH
  • Chef SMH 2007/05/16 14:11:10
    Chef
    +1
    Wow, you are very knowledgable. Are you working in the field as well?
  • blackbearzzz 2007/05/05 00:32:02
    Yes
    blackbearzzz
    +2
    I think if people want to distroy themselves, go for it. But as they are going down hill dont take tax money out of my paycheck to pay thier med. bills.
  • highlatte 2007/05/02 23:24:58 (edited)
    Yes
    highlatte
    +3
    Geez, the government has enlisted the food police now! Somebody, please, make them to go away. If someone is so dumb they can't read a label or ask a question regarding what is in a product (the info is available today), I and others should not have our choices diminished because of said dummies. More Socialist/Commie bs. Stop trying to control the behavior of others, usually the ones who defend the Rosies of the world for their free speech rights, but you don't mind telling folk what to eat. Do you understand that hypocrisy?
  • Chef highlatte 2007/05/03 04:56:03
    Chef
    +1
    I like your view on that.
  • Ozzy 2007/04/30 11:29:39
    Yes
    Ozzy
    +3
    I believe that what adults want to put in their bodies is their business and the government has no say in what they want to do.
  • Gussie 2007/04/21 04:25:16
    No
    Gussie
    +1
    unfortunately it takes the forcing of an issue to make big enough changes to make people wake up and be responsible. i don't like being told what to do, but i like it when the places i'm eating at are being made to cook responsibly, since when i place my order, i don't ask for an ingredient list first. as a nurse, i see the results of that ignorance in the american people. there Has to be some control here somewhere. and we aren't doing it for ourselves.
  • Fef 2007/04/14 01:06:44
    Yes
    Fef
    +2
    Consumers will move the market faster than getting politicians to agree on the regulations to implement. And the gov't will likely make mistakes in implementation. Vote with your wallet!
  • OracleBrad 2007/03/13 20:43:10
    No
    OracleBrad
    +3
    The problem is that adults are not able to make that decision, either because the lack information or due to a lack of choices when dining out. The argument for allowing adults to make the choice is analogous to the arguments against mandatory seatbelt and helmet laws. Healthcare costs have spun out of control and it is an appropriate use of government to reasonably mitigate factors which exacerbate health problems.
  • Gussie OracleBrad 2007/04/21 04:28:46
    Gussie
    +1
    yeah, and since the insurance companies OWN america now, including our govt., then of course they don't want to pay one red cent more than we can bleed out of them. your last sentence is dead on!!
  • Kelsea 2007/03/09 01:36:52 (edited)
    Undecided
    Kelsea
    +5

    we all very well know that many americans dont give a rats behind about what they are consuming. which is why we face the issue of obesity. i feel that i am going to take care of my body to the best of my ability up until the day i die. i will not live with the mindset " im going to die anyway". so i feel even though as an adult we should make the decision on our own , the government is the only way anything will be fixed. If it were up to us as adults instead of the governements PROTECTION about many other situations life as we know it would more or less be shot to hell....so it shouldnt be up to the governement but since humans overall are so helpless , there needs to be some guidance towards whats right and wrong for us....

  • Lori 2007/03/09 00:12:37
    No
    Lori
    +2
    Obviously too many people are incapable of making wise decisione even when it affects their health so seriously. Too often taxpayers pay the medical bills for the obese that cannot work.
  • Gussie Lori 2007/04/21 04:33:15
    Gussie
    +1
    taxpayers are also carrying the burden of the huge, and growing, number of people without medical insurance because they can't afford it anymore. so our insurance costs go even higher to make up for the hospitals/dr's that aren't getting their money out of those with no insurance. so, in essence, taxpayers are paying for americas obesity. so yeah, as a taxpayer, i would like govt to take some control here.
  • SocialCred 2007/03/08 06:52:01
    Yes
    SocialCred
    +2
    As long as trans fats are disclosed it should be up to consumer. In fact, many argue that in some applications the trans fats products are tastier!
  • 134 2007/03/08 02:57:23
  • Futureman 2007/03/07 02:35:14 (edited)
    No
    Futureman
    +1
    The government should protect us from evil corporate empire. Most people don't have the free time to be able to check the facts behind trans fats. The fda should never have let anything like this on the market in the first place.
  • Peter 2007/03/05 15:47:47
    Yes
    Peter
    Most people know that trans fats or any fatty food is not good for you whether you are an adult or a child. You hear it every day, I think you should be a make up your own mind. Just like to choose to smoke or not to doing either will shorten your life
  • Suny 2007/03/05 15:15:53
    No
    Suny
    +1
    most adults don't know what transfats are, and obesity is costing, indirectly, tax payers millions. This was a great idea.
  • Michael 2007/03/03 06:50:19
    No
    Michael
    +1
    Why use them if manufactures don't have to. I often think that few choices make for better choices. Let's take this choice away from the consumer...they are the beneficiaries of this anyway.
  • mfdave 2007/03/02 18:04:40
    Yes
    mfdave
    +1
    But I also believe that more advertising dollars go into "unhealthy" foods than "healthy" ones. And that is wrong. But the government shouldn't have laws on what we should and shouldn't eat.
  • Butch Cassidy 2007/03/01 19:49:47
    Yes
    Butch Cassidy
    +1
    I have taken as a custom to fixin more salubrious nourishment. Instead of cake frosting and boiled tallow, I eat pancakes fried in pork drippins.
  • Danale 2007/03/01 03:35:50
    Yes
    Danale
    +3
    Let's hear it for freedom! I know what's good and bad for me I don't need the government tell what to eat.
  • Tabby 2007/02/28 18:24:09
    Yes
    Tabby
    +2
    Yes, but will we?
  • Boopie 2007/02/28 07:05:37
    Yes
    Boopie
    +2
    Ideally, adults should be monitoring their own health, including cholesterol levels, blood pressure, any diseases they may be genetically predisposed towards, etc.
  • John 2007/02/28 05:13:01
    Yes
    John
    +1
    However, most people don't care about what they're eating but how good they taste :)

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/26 03:03:56

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals