Should you breast feed your co-worker? ( Dr. Izzat Atiya, head of Al Azhar University's Department of Hadith issued a legal decree for this )
Back in May 2007, Dr. Izzat Atiya, head of Al Azhar University's Department of Hadith, issued a fatwa,
or Islamic legal decree, saying that female workers should "breastfeed"
their male co-workers in order to work in each other's company.
According to the BBC:
He said that if a woman fed a male colleague "directly
from her breast" at least five times they would establish a family bond
and thus be allowed to be alone together at work. "Breast feeding an
adult puts an end to the problem of the private meeting, and does not
ban marriage," he ruled. "A woman at work can take off the veil or
reveal her hair in front of someone whom she breastfed."
Atiya based his fatwa on a hadith—a
documented saying or doing of Islam's prophet Muhammad and subsequently
one of Sharia law's sources of jurisprudence. Many Egyptians naturally
protested this decree—hadith or no hadith—though no one could really
demonstrate how it was un-Islamic; for the fatwa conformed to the
strictures of Islamic jurisprudence. Still, due to the protests—not many
Egyptian women were eager to "breastfeed" their male coworkers—the
fatwa receded, and that was that.
However, because it was never truly rebutted, it kept making comebacks.
For instance, three years later in 2010, a high-ranking Saudi, Sheikh Abdul Mohsin al-Abaican issued a fatwa
confirming that "women could give their milk to men to establish a
degree of maternal relations and get around a strict religious ban on
mixing between unrelated men and women." But unlike Atiya's fatwa, "the
man should take the milk, but not directly from the breast of the woman.
He should drink it [from a cup] and then [he] becomes a relative of the
family, a fact that allows him to come in contact with the women
without breaking Islam's rules about mixing."
Now, a report titled "Kuwaiti Activists: Husband Breastfeeding from Wife not Prohibited," published earlier this month by Arabic RT (see also Garaa News)
opens by announcing that "The adult breastfeeding fatwa has returned
once again to the spotlight, after Kuwaiti Islamic activists supported
the adult breastfeeding fatwa issued by the Egyptian Salafi, Sheikh
Jamal al-Murakbi [different from Al Azhar's Sheikh Atiya]. This time
around, the Kuwaitis examined the adult breastfeeding fatwa in the
context of relations between a man and his wife."
While the Kuwaiti sheikhs all essentially agree that the activity is
not strictly forbidden according to Sharia—only "disliked" (literally makruh)—they are divided over the particulars:
- Sheikh Nazim Misbahi, head of the Fatwa Committee of the Islamic
Heritage Revival Society in Kuwait, supports the decree, agreeing that
"it is not forbidden [haram] for a man to breastfeed from his wife."
- Sheikh Bassam al-Shatti, a Sharia professor, specifies: "If the
husband deliberately sucks to obtain milk from the breast of his wife,
this is forbidden; however, if it happens unintentionally during
foreplay with his wife, then there is no problem—though it is disliked
according to the four schools" of Sharia.
- Sheikh Sa'd al-Anzi stressed that "if the man, while being intimate
with his wife, sucks her nipples, it is nothing, considered foreplay;
but if the milk reaches his mouth, he should spit out—even if goes down
in his stomach," i.e., vomit.
Consider for a moment the significance of these Islamic edicts:
whether women "breastfeeding" coworkers (Egyptian fatwa, 2007), whether
men drinking female breast-milk in a cup (Saudi fatwa, 2010), or whether
Kuwaiti minutiae concerning bedroom foreplay—all these fatwas are
reminders of the inescapable strictures of Sharia law; while these
sheikhs offers various circumstances and interpretations concerning
"adult breastfeeding," they are all confined to the words of the prophet
This is precisely why, despite all the claims that Islam is
perpetually being "misunderstood"—by terrorists, by
"Islamophobes"—understanding what Islam commands and forbids is actually
quite a simple matter: along with the Koran, determine what the prophet
said in canonical hadiths.
It is, after all, no coincidence that the above mentioned Kuwaitis,
like Sheikh Misbahi, were members of the delegation that recently went
to ask Saudi Arabia's Grand Mufti about Islam's position on churches in
the Arabian Peninsula: the same source that compelled the Grand Mufti to
declare that all churches must be destroyed, is the same source that advocates "adult breastfeeding": Muhammad and his teachings. All very straightforward, really.
Raymond Ibrahim is an Associate Fellow at the Middle East Forum and a Shillman Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center.
See Votes by State