Should We Legalize Heroin?
- November 10, 2009 18:33:38
- Read all 176 opinions
Legalization of marijuana is a hot topic at the moment, but what about heroin? Opium, from which heroin is created, has been illegal in the United States since 1909, in Australia since 1908, and in 1924, the league of nations got together and banned it for personal recreational use outright throughout much of the civilized world. But why?
Well, opium is a heavily addictive drug favored by laymen and poets alike for its ability to send the user into dream like other worlds in which day to day concerns and cares are washed away.
The poet Collins, a notable opium addict who eventually died from years of opiate abuse, wrote of opium based Laundnum “I have had six delicious hours of oblivion; I have woken up with my mind composed; I have written a perfect little letter… – and all through the modest little bottle of drops which I see on my bedroom chimneypiece at this moment. Drops, you are darling! If I love nothing else, I love you!”
Great American writer, William Burroughs, friend of Jack Kerouac and a man famous for his literary contributions such as 'Junky' and 'Queer' and infamous for accidentally shooting his wife dead, was an opium addict for much of his life. He had this to say on the subject, “Junk is the ultimate commodity, the merchandise is not sold to the consumer- the consumer is sold to the merchandise”
So should we legalize heroin? It does occasionally kill people, but so do cars, and kittens, if you try to swallow them whole.
Before you answer that, let me come clean. This has been something of a trick question, because in many places heroin and indeed, opium are legal. Many of our modern day painkillers are still derived from opium, and even heroin is used some countries as a pain reliever, though it is not supplied under the name heroin. In the UK, patients experiencing severe pain may be prescribed diamorphine, which is another name for heroin.
Now here is the interesting thing. Diamorphine, aka, heroin, is indeed regulated for legal medical use in many countries around the world. It is also, according to The Lancet medical journal, the most dangerous, addictive, and harmful drug out of the top twenty commonly used drugs, including cocaine, methamphetamine, alcohol, street methadone, tobacco and ketamine. Yet it is still quite alright for a doctor to prescribe heroin in Hong Kong, the UK, Canada, and the Netherlands.
If we accept that heroin, the most dangerous drug in the world bar none has a place in the doctor's arsenal, then how can we continue to enforce a ban on marijuana, which by the assessment of The Lancet, causes less physical harm than tobacco and alcohol, two drugs which are legal throughout most of the world?
Personally, I think all drugs should be entirely legal. If adults want to spend their lives wallowing in their own filth as crack addicts, then I do not see why that should be a criminal offense. If they commit crimes whilst under the effect of drugs, then they should be charged with those crimes and the fact that they chose to become crack heads or junkies should not be a mitigating factor.
We baby people far too much in society, treating them like weak minded infants too stupid to make choices for themselves. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know that poking a needle full of opoids between your toes is a bad idea. It's not a secret that drugs are addictive, make you sick and eventually destroy your mind and body. If people know this and chose to do them anyway, that is their choice.
Instead of parading the drug addicted as scum of the earth and locking them away for much of their natural lives, what if we used those resources, the countless millions of dollars spent prosecuting and incarcerating people who have done nothing wrong apart from consume a substance, to support, educate and perhaps elevate the lives of those so deeply mired in misery that the prospect of soberly facing real life each day is impossible?
Legalize the lot, tax the lot, and stop criminalizing large portions of the population for no reason whatsoever.
Well, opium is a heavily addictive drug favored by laymen and poets alike for its ability to send the user into dream like other worlds in which day to day concerns and cares are washed away.
The poet Collins, a notable opium addict who eventually died from years of opiate abuse, wrote of opium based Laundnum “I have had six delicious hours of oblivion; I have woken up with my mind composed; I have written a perfect little letter… – and all through the modest little bottle of drops which I see on my bedroom chimneypiece at this moment. Drops, you are darling! If I love nothing else, I love you!”
Great American writer, William Burroughs, friend of Jack Kerouac and a man famous for his literary contributions such as 'Junky' and 'Queer' and infamous for accidentally shooting his wife dead, was an opium addict for much of his life. He had this to say on the subject, “Junk is the ultimate commodity, the merchandise is not sold to the consumer- the consumer is sold to the merchandise”
So should we legalize heroin? It does occasionally kill people, but so do cars, and kittens, if you try to swallow them whole.
Before you answer that, let me come clean. This has been something of a trick question, because in many places heroin and indeed, opium are legal. Many of our modern day painkillers are still derived from opium, and even heroin is used some countries as a pain reliever, though it is not supplied under the name heroin. In the UK, patients experiencing severe pain may be prescribed diamorphine, which is another name for heroin.
Now here is the interesting thing. Diamorphine, aka, heroin, is indeed regulated for legal medical use in many countries around the world. It is also, according to The Lancet medical journal, the most dangerous, addictive, and harmful drug out of the top twenty commonly used drugs, including cocaine, methamphetamine, alcohol, street methadone, tobacco and ketamine. Yet it is still quite alright for a doctor to prescribe heroin in Hong Kong, the UK, Canada, and the Netherlands.
If we accept that heroin, the most dangerous drug in the world bar none has a place in the doctor's arsenal, then how can we continue to enforce a ban on marijuana, which by the assessment of The Lancet, causes less physical harm than tobacco and alcohol, two drugs which are legal throughout most of the world?
Personally, I think all drugs should be entirely legal. If adults want to spend their lives wallowing in their own filth as crack addicts, then I do not see why that should be a criminal offense. If they commit crimes whilst under the effect of drugs, then they should be charged with those crimes and the fact that they chose to become crack heads or junkies should not be a mitigating factor.
We baby people far too much in society, treating them like weak minded infants too stupid to make choices for themselves. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know that poking a needle full of opoids between your toes is a bad idea. It's not a secret that drugs are addictive, make you sick and eventually destroy your mind and body. If people know this and chose to do them anyway, that is their choice.
Instead of parading the drug addicted as scum of the earth and locking them away for much of their natural lives, what if we used those resources, the countless millions of dollars spent prosecuting and incarcerating people who have done nothing wrong apart from consume a substance, to support, educate and perhaps elevate the lives of those so deeply mired in misery that the prospect of soberly facing real life each day is impossible?
Legalize the lot, tax the lot, and stop criminalizing large portions of the population for no reason whatsoever.
Top Opinion
-
macnamera killjoy November 11, 2009 20:34:08+7"Personally, I think all drugs should be entirely legal. If adults want to spend their lives wallowing in their own filth as crack addicts, then I do not see why that should be a criminal offense. If they commit crimes whilst under the effect of drugs, then they should be charged with those crimes and the fact that they chose to become crack heads or junkies should not be a mitigating factor."
Exactly.
About Me
Recent Posts
Hot Questions on SodaHead
-
What Was the Best Season Finale?
-
Who's the Meanest Reality TV Judge?
-
Hottest Woman on Maxim's Hot 100 List?
- View more slideshows »
The Latest From SodaHead
Living
-
UGG Australia Unveils Bridal Boots: Gross or Great?
Here comes the bride ... and she's wearing boots. UGGs, to be specific. Are you OK with it?
-
Battle of the Catsuits: Who Wore It Better, Fantasia or Chaka Khan?
Did you catch the "American Idol" finale? By now, you've heard that Phillip Phillips was crowned the winner, but that's not the only thing causing buzz.
Food
-
Do You Eat Late at Night?
According to a recent study, weight loss may be less about what you eat and more about when you eat.
-
Chipotle-Style Indian Food Growing in Popularity: Would You Try It?
What Chipotle did for Mexican food, restaurants like Bombay Bowl are doing for Indian cuisine.







Kristian Brandreth
kbrandreth@arialasvegas.com
A person who would compare heroin and it's use to mass murder, genocide and slavery most certainly demonstrates intellectual and moral bankruptcy, and an inability to understand that the very basic, fundamental difference between a malum in se law and a malum prohibitum law.
z.s.... mass murder, genocide and slavery should is also be legal. :'D
I would like to see some of you people who are so dead said against drugs and the people who use them, call them names, traeat them like dirt, but what would u do if it hit home? what if u had to take an opiate some day for a pain medication? For years? and then u too could be one of those poor souls in the streets being treated like scum.
I know of many of those scums, so called, that started off as respectable people of the norm in society. After years of prescribed meds, then taken off because of the laws making doctors afraid to keep prescribing, they ended up in the streets buyin gthe dirty street versions, having to do crime to get the money, and Need i say more?
I say legalize them for the ones who have already become addicted. We don't kn...
I would like to see some of you people who are so dead said against drugs and the people who use them, call them names, traeat them like dirt, but what would u do if it hit home? what if u had to take an opiate some day for a pain medication? For years? and then u too could be one of those poor souls in the streets being treated like scum.
I know of many of those scums, so called, that started off as respectable people of the norm in society. After years of prescribed meds, then taken off because of the laws making doctors afraid to keep prescribing, they ended up in the streets buyin gthe dirty street versions, having to do crime to get the money, and Need i say more?
I say legalize them for the ones who have already become addicted. We don't know yet what damage it may have caused them in their minds, bodies, etc, to make them not be able to stop. and frankly who cares. teh bottom line is, help them now to live a normal life with their children, families, and friends without beidng treated like lost souls.
I only say this.IF YOU ARE IN PAIN, A DOC GIVES U OPIATES RO LONG TIME, THEN U ARE CUT OFF BECAUSE OF LAWS MAKING IT HARD ON THE DOCS, WHAT WILL U DO? DO U REALLY THINK IT IS SO EASY TO JUST GO INTO A REHAB AND GET CURED? IF IT WAS, DON'T U THINK IT WOULD HAVE WORKED FOR THE MANY PEOPLE WHO ARE SICK ALEREADY. EVEN IF IT DOES WORK FOR A FEW, THEY EITHER HAVE TO GO TO MEETINGS FOR THE REST OF THEIR LIVES, OR WHY NOT JUST GIVE THEM MEDS LIKE EVERY OTHER DISEASE ON THE EARTH?
WHY DOES A DRUG ADDICTED PERSON HAVE TO SUFFER MORE THAN OTHERS WITH OTHER DISEASES TO GET THEIR MEDICATION. GO TO A CLINIC EVERY D;AY FOR METHADONE, AS AN EXAMPLE. HOW HUMILIATING. I HAVE SEEN DOCTORS IN THOSE LINES, DON'T U THINK THEIR TIME COULD BE USED FOR BETTER USE.
AND FOR THE FEW WHO ABUSE THEIR RIGHT, SO WHAT. THEY WILL GET CAUSGHT EVENTUALLY AND LOSE THEIR RIGHT. IN OTHER WORDS, GIVE ALL PEOPLE MEDS THAT THEY NEED NO MATTER WHAT IT IS.
AND TO SAY THAT ONLY OPIATES, AND SUCH ARE ADDICTING, HA! TRY TAKING SOME OF THE SO CALLED BETTER DRUGS FOR PAIN OR DEPRESSION. I HAVE WITH MY OWN EYES SEEN MORE WORST DETOXES OFF OF NEURONTIN, PAXIL, ZOLOFT, PROZAC AND I COULD LIST A WHOLE BUNCH OF OTHERS. WHY DO THEY GET PEOPELE SICK IF THEY STOP TAKING THEM? WHY DO U THINK?
THINIK
WHY
there's never been any deaths caused by cannabis and the only harm it can cause happens if it is smoked, so vaporization / ingestion doesn't cause harm - nor is there any proof of any physical dependence. I'd like to know where you got that graph from.
I agree that people who do have addictions shouldn't be treated like criminals, but patients. yet this isn't a good analogy since many patients in america become addicted to their legally prescribed heroin (percocet & oxycodone).
just as seriously harmful pharmaceuticals are taken off the market, so should highly addictive and damaging drugs be removed from society.
give heroin addicts treatment at hospitals without the threat of incarceration, but I draw the line at making heroin available at 7/11.
let's start in steps, first re-legalize cannabis and we'll see how many people still want to do meth.
Really?