Quantcast

Should Restaurants Charge Customers a Fine for 'Food Wastage'?

SodaHead Living 2012/05/18 18:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
We'll admit it: Sometimes our eyes are a little bigger than our stomachs. But we don't expect to pay extra just because we're feeling a little full! The Kylin Buffet, a Chinese restaurant in England offering an all-you-can-eat buffet -- has posted a notice warning customers of a $32 for "food wastage" fine, The Daily Mail reports.

wasted food

One mom was told she had to pay the fine after she, her 10-year-old son and 6-year-old niece left two onion rings, a piece of shrimp toast and a spring roll on their plates.

"After we had our starters, we went up for our main course. But a member of staff came over and asked if we weren’t going to eat the food on our plates, and said we would have to pay an extra $32 to cover food wastage costs," Beverley Clark told the Mail. "I was furious and said we were already paying $28 for three meals, but the staff kept checking if we had eaten the food. In the end I wrapped it up in a [napkin], and put it into my bag when they weren’t looking, so it looked like we had eaten it."

After Clark complained, the restaurant deducted about $5 from her bill. "In the end I didn’t have to pay the extra charge, but it felt as though they were trying to rip me off," she said.

Sam Fung, manager at the Kylin Buffet, is standing behind the policy. "I accept that my staff should not have spoken to the family about the food on their plates more than once. However, they left a lot of food from the buffet on their plates and we have to charge for wastage of food," Fung told the Mail.

Now, we don't know how it is in England these days, but in America, you're often given way more food that you could possibly eat. And we also have a growing obesity epidemic ... if anything, restaurants should pay you for NOT finishing your food!
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • chariotdrvr14 2012/05/21 20:12:17
    No
    chariotdrvr14
    Nah. If you're paying for the whole meal then it's no one's business what you do with the whole of it. And forcing people to eat their plate is one way to encourage obesity....which needs no encouragement at all from anyone.
    But it is a pity what people waste.... on a number of fronts.
  • Airhead chariot... 2012/05/21 21:09:02
    Airhead
    They are talking about buffets.
  • chariot... Airhead 2012/05/22 18:03:17
    chariotdrvr14
    I know and it doesn't matter. I've been to the ones in Nevada... gawd, those things were like temples of gluttony. The very idea of it is promoting waste. I still have nightmare images in my head of watching the stools in one of them straining under the weight of these enormously overweight people sitting there like pigs at a trough. Point is though, as I said further down this thread... (because once it's on your plate, it's yours) if they want to control waste then they should just offer smaller plates and one plate per person.
  • MayaAngelou0524 2012/05/21 20:09:28
    No
    MayaAngelou0524
    That's crazy! $20.00? WOW!
  • Kelly Yung MayaAng... 2012/05/21 20:27:38
    Kelly Yung
    +1
    technically it's $32, it's £20, 20 pounds in dollars is 32 dollars, but for 20 pounds you can buy 2 meals here (UK) (probably 3 in some places)
  • MayaAng... Kelly Yung 2012/05/21 20:40:38
    MayaAngelou0524
    Oh wow! And I guess I wasn't paying attention to the sign :D.
  • Kelly Yung MayaAng... 2012/05/21 20:48:19
    Kelly Yung
    +1
    it's ok :) thankfully it isnt in the US cus it would be more, it can be confusing because of the dollars/pounds thing :)
  • joni perkins 2012/05/21 20:04:53
    No
    joni perkins
    Techniqually if they ate all the food that food is gone and they wouldn't have to pay but didn't eat it the food is still going to be gone just as if they ate it that why it makes no since to charge
  • BERYL 2012/05/21 20:01:21
    Yes
    BERYL
    +1
    This usually only applies in restaurants which have a fixed charge for "all you can eat". I think in this case they were being a bit picky, but a lot of Chinese Restaurants are now charging for waste. They don't mind if you eat all you want, but there is no point in being greedy. It is quite simple to go up for 2nd helpings if you have room - or 3rd helpings like my "skinny as a whippet" grandson.
  • chariot... BERYL 2012/05/21 20:14:00
    chariotdrvr14
    Yeah, if they're so worried about the waste they should just offer their customers smaller plates.
  • Airhead chariot... 2012/05/21 21:10:31
    Airhead
    +1
    Yeah i'm sure that would work...
    ಠ_ಠ srsly?
  • Brendan Byrne 2012/05/21 19:56:04
    Yes
    Brendan Byrne
    These are normally restuarants where the customer, NOT the establishment chooses how much they eat. an all you can eat buffet for example.
  • DANNY59 2012/05/21 19:47:40
    Yes
    DANNY59
    +2
    It drives me crazy when perfectly good food gets thrown away. I know on TV shows they use fake food, and drinks as props, but it still gets me frustrated to see the person walk away from a full drink or plate of food. I have to remind myself it's fake, that's how passionate I am against wasting stuff. I don't know if a fine is proper, since the people who waste will still do it at home, but something should be done to stop our wasteful ways.
  • Autumn 2012/05/21 19:46:08
    Yes
    Autumn
    +2
    Let me explain though: If you have two onion rings and a spring roll on your plate, no biggie. If you have a whole plate of food practically uneaten, then a SMALL fine seems somewhat fair. People prepare this food so it's eaten, and throwing away wastage does take away money. Maybe an extra $3 or something along those lines. That's fair.
  • LisaWay... Autumn 2012/05/21 19:52:35 (edited)
    LisaWay☮JUST MARCH HOME
    +1
    No, because we already paid for the food. It's paid for, the restaurant made a profit, the employees get paid, no money is taken away from anybody in there. This charge afterward IS stealing, and from properly paying customers. Everyone else gets to take all the food they want as well, for the same price.

    What the restaurant is doing here seems to me to be as the flip side of a person who loads up in pockets or big purse to take more food home. That is cheating the honor system, which system is defined by the restaurant. At a buffet, we are only supposed to eat what we can there, and nobody gets to carry out leftovers. They encourage everyone to pile on with the buffet style to get more bang for your pound. (That's why I myself don't do expensive buffets-- I can never eat that much at one sitting, so it's not discount to me.) What the restaurant is doing here is CHEATING their own honor system-- an interesting twist on the old "bait and switch". Nope, I'm not buyin' it. Nice try, restaurant boy. lol
  • Autumn LisaWay... 2012/05/21 20:11:23
    Autumn
    OK, OK, Geez! Sorry! Don't attack me!
  • LisaWay... Autumn 2012/05/21 21:35:57
    LisaWay☮JUST MARCH HOME
    So Sorry, I was not attacking you. I didn't mean to attack anybody, but I was putting all the responsibility on the restaurant because they are cheating you and me and everybody. That's all. Please accept my apology for seeming combative toward you!
  • LisaWay... Autumn 2012/05/21 21:54:53
    LisaWay☮JUST MARCH HOME
    ps: I had actually gone back & stricken that entire 2nd paragraph, and pasted it separate above, as general comment. But the SH edit here obviously did not take. I won't erase now, since I've replied, but like you said, no biggie. I actually picked this question today for fun. Didn't mean to sound so serious. lol. I hate to get replies strike me as unexpected attack too. So, sorry again.
  • Ozzyboy LisaWay... 2012/05/21 22:40:33
    Ozzyboy
    +1
    You don't know much about how restaurants operate, do you? Otherwise you would not claim that, it's paid for, the restaurant made a profit, the employees get paid, no money is taken away from anybody there. Stock piling food on a plate and then walking away
    is a disgusting waste and a huge loss to the restaurant and other patrons. I don't do buffets either, but my daughter is in the restaurant trade and you need to learn more about it before you make such ridiculous claims.
  • Autumn Ozzyboy 2012/05/24 00:58:07
    Autumn
    Let's all be friends now! YAY! :)
  • nightowl 2012/05/21 19:45:21
    No
    nightowl
    +1
    Duh...no, in any case, at any level. This moronic business owner will be out of business soon.
  • Slade Rockwell 2012/05/21 19:44:11
    Yes
    Slade Rockwell
    +2
    Under certain circumstances like at buffets sure. I see people pile 5 plates of food on ONE plate (I guess walking back to the service line to get more is just too much work) and leave half uneaten. This is PERSONAL irresponsibility and should be addressed.
  • Professor Wizard 2012/05/21 19:43:38
    No
    Professor Wizard
    In this time of too many fat people - - The restaurant should be fined for putting too much food on the plates.

    If food is often left on plates - - it is either too much food, or lousy tasting food - - and the restaurant should either put less, or make it taste better.
  • Airhead Profess... 2012/05/21 21:12:21
    Airhead
    They are talking about buffets here.
  • Profess... Airhead 2012/05/21 21:38:05
    Professor Wizard
    Yea.. I caught that after I posted... Yet - I have left "Bad Stuff" in my plate a few times from buffets.. if it is bad, I am not going to eat it. I would not be happy to be fined for not eating crappy food!
  • Airhead Profess... 2012/05/21 21:48:35
    Airhead
    Everywhere here the buffets are starting to do this. If you tell them there was something wrong with the food quality they let it slide.
  • Ron in Oregon 2012/05/21 19:43:28
    No
    Ron in Oregon
    I see that it is a Chinese buffet and I remember where a server dropped a pan of food on the floor and scraped it up and put it on the line.
  • Lyle 2012/05/21 19:42:50
    Yes
    Lyle
    In a restaurant that serves you, I would say certainly not; however this was a buffet. I have seen people in buffets pile their plate high and leave most of it after they decided it wasn't what they wanted. If I were running a buffet I would be just as frustrated as Fung.
  • nicesteve 2012/05/21 19:42:07
    No
    nicesteve
    There might be certain items in some dishes that might not be edible for health or
    religious reasons while the rest of the dish is perfectly healthy and koshire. Only charge
    those few who intentionally and overtly "stockpile" their plates and then waste the food,
    not even requesting a doggie bag. Those individules do need to be addressed somehow.
    As for the rest of us, we're not purposefully wasting food, and therefore don't deserve to
    be sanctioned for the same in any way whatsoever. Let the remainder of us be.
  • AkiKaza 2012/05/21 19:41:58
    Yes
    AkiKaza
    meant to click no. gah.
  • overzero 2012/05/21 19:41:47
    Yes
    overzero
    Yes, but it should be proportional to the cost of the meal and the percentage wasted. I also think the restaurant should be fined for serving food that is inedible.
  • RobertChristopherLaity 2012/05/21 19:40:26
    No
    RobertChristopherLaity
    Many restaurants SERVE bigger portions than one should actually eat in one sitting. One PAYS for that food. It belongs to them. While wasting food should be avoided,where is the
    problem with taking the food that one cab't eat,home with you? Ever hear of "Doggy Bags"?
  • Airhead RobertC... 2012/05/22 04:43:33
    Airhead
    Ever hear of "buffet", like the type of restaurants we are talking about?
  • jeepsrule98 2012/05/21 19:36:55
    No
    jeepsrule98
    Restaurants should pay a fine for trying to make everyone an obese fat-ass, which is a oxymoron but i don't care. The food industry should pay fines for marketing products that are full of calories that are bad for our waste lines, bad for our hearts and bad for our blood sugar. Marketing products that are high in sugar, fat and salt will be the demise of our country if we're not careful. Watch what you eat and get some exercise it will save your life.
  • JamieTh... jeepsru... 2012/05/21 20:04:38 (edited)
    JamieThompson
    Yes, i understand your reasoning, but a company has the right to buy what they want, and sell at any price, if people will eat it, they will sell it. Its up to the people to not eat the crap.
  • kristina.wilson17 2012/05/21 19:36:17
    No
    kristina.wilson17
    no I already bought the food that means its mine, not mine AND the restaurants, its just mine and if I don't eat it all then who g.a.f.!!! Its already mine and what if I threw it away because it tasted like crap I shouldn't have to pay for the chef to not do his/her job
  • williamefrench 2012/05/21 19:25:51
    No
    williamefrench
    good lord what stupid question
  • Airhead william... 2012/05/22 04:44:24
    Airhead
    There are no stupid questions...
  • firelooker 2012/05/21 19:18:50
    Yes
    firelooker
    Sounds like a plan to me. Wate not want not.
  • lovelygoddess101 2012/05/21 19:17:44
    Yes
    lovelygoddess101
    Meant to click "no." Stupid ads at the top push my screen down as I click. I'm starting to think it's a conspiracy lol XD

    Back to the subject at hand, if I've already paid for it, then I shouldn't have to pay again.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/25 06:41:35

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals