Quantcast

Should Kids Under 13 Be Allowed to Use Facebook?

SodaHead Living 2012/06/05 17:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
It's well known that Facebook does not permit users under 13 years old -- and that many kids find a way to use the social networking site anyway. All that could change, though, now that Facebook is developing technology that would allow kids under 13 to use the site under parental supervision, The Wall Street Journal reports.

kids facebook

According to the WSJ, there are a few possibilities in the works. One would connect
children's accounts to their parents', allowing mom and dad to decide whom their kids can "friend" and what applications they can use.

It does seem incumbent upon Facebook to come up with something, since many kids lie about their ages to get accounts. Last year, Consumer Reports said 7.5 million children under the age of 13 were using the site, including more than five million under the age of 10. And last fall, a study sponsored by Microsoft Research found that 36 percent of parents were aware that their children joined Facebook before age 13, and many even helped their kids to do so.

But given that adults have privacy concerns about Facebook, is the site safe for kids? And could it make them vulnerable to predators and bullies?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Bob P. Clarkson 2012/06/05 20:04:22
    No
    Bob P. Clarkson
    +23
    Adults have no concept of security on the Internet and children of all ages almost universally trust that everyone is as "nice and good" as they are. My now 15 year old granddaughter got on Facebook at 13, and even though her Dad took her off Facebook, she got on under another name using a friend's computer.
    Grandpa has been playing with computers since we were using punch cards, and even though I no longer write programs, I stumble my way through the computer world.
    I established an account as a fifteen year old boy with pictures I borrowed from a neighbors son, then "stalked" her and convinced her to meet me at a mall - it was really safe that way. When she walked in to the food court, she was surprised to see me and acted like she wanted me to disappear before "Steve" got there.
    I showed her the file on her and "Steve" and she was P.O.'d I had spied on her.
    I showed her where her school was, where her best girlfriends lived, where she lived and gave her my "On-line Security" talk.
    She listened as a know-it-all 13 year old listens, which to say is, not at all, and continued to hammer me about "spying" on her. I logged on to Facebook with my laptop, and when I signed in to my Steve persona, she got very quiet. Then I retold her what I had done and showed her how "unsafe" th...

















    Adults have no concept of security on the Internet and children of all ages almost universally trust that everyone is as "nice and good" as they are. My now 15 year old granddaughter got on Facebook at 13, and even though her Dad took her off Facebook, she got on under another name using a friend's computer.
    Grandpa has been playing with computers since we were using punch cards, and even though I no longer write programs, I stumble my way through the computer world.
    I established an account as a fifteen year old boy with pictures I borrowed from a neighbors son, then "stalked" her and convinced her to meet me at a mall - it was really safe that way. When she walked in to the food court, she was surprised to see me and acted like she wanted me to disappear before "Steve" got there.
    I showed her the file on her and "Steve" and she was P.O.'d I had spied on her.
    I showed her where her school was, where her best girlfriends lived, where she lived and gave her my "On-line Security" talk.
    She listened as a know-it-all 13 year old listens, which to say is, not at all, and continued to hammer me about "spying" on her. I logged on to Facebook with my laptop, and when I signed in to my Steve persona, she got very quiet. Then I retold her what I had done and showed her how "unsafe" the Internet was, again.
    Since a number of her friends had "friended" me, and some friends of the real Steve, kind of computer specialists, I showed her how easier it was to track her, and them, using Facebook and Google Earth.
    She was still put out with grandpa when she left, but two days later she took down her Facebook account - and so did two of her friends. She now gives security lectures to her friends that want to know why she doesn't have a Facebook page.

    She now has unlimited minutes on her iPhone, and actually likes it better than Facebook. I'm sure she and all of her friends will have arthritic thumbs when they get older, and I'm sure they will figure out something else that is probably just as dangerous, but parents and grandparents can only deal with what we know.
    Oh, it took her only a week to forgive me, but when she told her dad why she took down her Facebook page, he was bent out of shape for about a month for sticking my nose in. It was "his job" to guide and guard her through to adulthood. When my quick statement about I did what he would have to have hired someone else to do and didn't charge him for my work finally sunk in.
    I was guilty that I usurped his parental job, but I've always been a Type A, so it never even dawned on me to consult him - I just did it to protect my granddaughter.
    I'm not sure I would do it much different, anyway.










    Google.
    (more)

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • marsbluff 2012/06/06 17:39:26
    No
    marsbluff
    +2
    It seems that in today's world, kids are going to find a way to get on Facebook or any other site regardless what we do. There was a time when Facebook was considered an adult social site to communicate with friends. Myspace was the choice of kids. Now, kids are you using Facebook instead. Thus, Facebook has gone to hell.
  • Ashley 2012/06/06 17:34:16
    No
    Ashley
    +4
    It doesn't really matter, anyway. They can lie about their age, but I am totally against Facebook in the first place.
  • Walter ... Ashley 2012/06/06 18:05:17
    Walter Harris
    +1
    their are way to many security loopholes to get around, it is unsafe even for us. I a man and how do I know the lady I'm talking to is even a female much less an adult
  • Ashley Walter ... 2012/06/08 22:45:26 (edited)
    Ashley
    Well, just to clarify some things for you, I *am* a female, but I am *not* an adult. I'm actually a minor. It couldn't be none too hard to get around if people can make so many false accounts and so on and so forth. I'm well aware how unsafe Facebook is, I've witnessed how bad and dangerous it can be firsthand with my dad's Facebook account - the marriage could've ended in divorce over a past girlfriend and porn being sent by strange, nude women over Facebook.

    How do I know you're a man? How do I know I'm not talking to a rapist-murderer? I don't know and I never will know.
  • stevie.luplow 2012/06/06 17:33:10
    No
    stevie.luplow
    +4
    It wass made for COLLEGE students....
  • Paranormal♥Spirit 2012/06/06 17:26:48
    Yes
    Paranormal♥Spirit
    +2
    I don't see why kids like Facebook so much. All these sites on the internet and all they think about is Facebook. It doesn't matter if they allow it or not kids will find a way to get on anyway. Facebook is not even that interesting. Why don't they make a kid version instead?
  • granny 2012/06/06 17:24:51
    No
    granny
    +3
    Their already growing up to fast as it is, they don't need to be on Facebook next. I feel they need a page blog to be popular or part of the group. Now if it's a study group that's a different story, but I don't think it would be used for that purpose.
  • waterlady 2012/06/06 17:23:29
    No
    waterlady
    +3
    Since facebook is being viewed my employers, people should think twice about using it.
  • rosebud 2012/06/06 17:05:16
    No
    rosebud
    +4
    Parents should also stop making "facebook" accounts to show off their babies to everyone.
  • Peace Out 2012/06/06 17:04:31
    No
    Peace Out
    +2
    or cellphones
  • allison newsom 2012/06/06 17:04:17
    Yes
    allison newsom
    +1
    many kids under 13 will alter their age just to get on no matter what their parents say or do but like others have said if they want one it should be for them to chat with schoolmates only for like help with homework or to make plans
  • Merhabi Daham 2012/06/06 17:04:17
    No
    Merhabi Daham
    +1
    My little brother does not need a facebook to talk to his friends, he already spends hours on Google + or whatever that is. Stupid social networking.
  • johnnyg 2012/06/06 17:02:21
    Yes
    johnnyg
    +1
    Mine do.
  • bluedragon30120 2012/06/06 16:58:30
    Yes
    bluedragon30120
    +2
    With the link and it should be lock in private mood. Untill they reach 13 or in my opinion 16
  • bmxschoolbus 2012/06/06 16:57:23
    No
    bmxschoolbus
    +1
    that's why facebook should charge $.50 a month to use it just so you need to use a credit card to pay for it and that would help minimize under age kids using it
  • Saye Saye 2012/06/06 16:48:57
    No
    Saye Saye
    +1
    there are vile adults that parents need to monitor. kids are kids & not mature enougth.
  • Lee 2012/06/06 16:48:37
    Yes
    Lee
    +1
    With today's society kids are texting and use social networking sites anyway. If a child is under 13 and uses facebook, than they should be linked to their parents account. They should friend kids in their age range, and there has to be strict controls to them. However this being said, kids are too reliant upon technology. There has to be a balance between computer time and outdoor activities. Kids have to be more active.
  • Scott 2012/06/06 16:47:58 (edited)
    Yes
    Scott
    +4
    Kids need to learn that they cannot REVEAL too much personal information, so registration would be set-up with pseudo-name (no last names), maybe zodiac sign (no birthdates), school locations only (no addresses) and perhaps a parent approval process with verification of a designated group monitor (eg, meetup.com).
  • sibusiso 2012/06/06 16:42:22
    Yes
    sibusiso
    +1
    I think so
  • Dalvin 2012/06/06 16:41:47
    Yes
    Dalvin
    +1
    With restrictions of course. I think a teen facebook would do the trick maybe. Now that most people are learning to use computers or already know we have the responsibility to make sure that kids in our care aren't in danger while on the computer.
  • Christiaan McPherson 2012/06/06 16:40:39
    Yes
    Christiaan McPherson
    +2
    The right question is should anyone over 13 be allowed to use it.
  • mikeyllo 2012/06/06 16:33:02
    Yes
    mikeyllo
    +1
    They shouldn't use it for the purposes that adults use it for, but if they're using the computer, texting, instant messaging, etc., why not be able to use Facebook to connect with their friends and family. Parents just have to step their game up as we progress with all this technology and do a better job monitoring their children. Limiting their access to that particular site is not going to stop them from growing up and experiencing some of the not-so-great things about life and other people.
  • DDevlin780 2012/06/06 16:32:53
    No
    DDevlin780
    +2
    They should be out playing baseball, soccer, stick ball, anything but sitting by a computer talking to adults all over the world.
  • Josh Robinson 2012/06/06 16:32:45
    Yes
    Josh Robinson
    With the proper filters and adult supervision using Facebook isn't any more harmful than using Google or any other information source. Facebook is harmful to ANY user when they have poor intentions or no parental or content supervision. Of course Obamas kids are banned from Facebook and rarely get to use the internet so there must be something to the argument. Or he doesn't want them to know he signs the deaths of people on a daily basis in pointless wars.
  • Merhabi... Josh Ro... 2012/06/06 17:25:32
    Merhabi Daham
    Well the thing is, can you trust any parent to be computer smart enough to know HOW to prevent their kids from doing inappropriate stuff. The best way is to just say "No facebook" and the enforce that instead of trying to tiptoe around the Internets more graphic parts.
  • Josh Ro... Merhabi... 2012/06/06 17:34:01
    Josh Robinson
    I was thinking more like children can't use it without you next to them if they aren't mature. No kid should have an internet connected computer in their room to begin with.
  • Merhabi... Josh Ro... 2012/06/07 14:36:30
    Merhabi Daham
    Why would a parent be next to their child 24 hours of the day?You can't always watch them, even if the computer is in a living room. So the best strategy is an absolute embargo on the internet in general with a few exceptions.
  • KrSpo Merhabi... 2012/06/07 15:12:38
    KrSpo
    Exactly, bu regrettably this goes directly back to 1970's parenting. It was the beginning of the hands off approach where teh kids were left to more and more find their own thigns to do, then it gets worse in the 80's where mom and dad were more intent on snorting the mortgage payment and throwing a coleco-vision in front of the kids while they ran out and partied..

    Those kids, now parents, are the ones today that are letting little Becky take nekkid pictures of herself with an unmanaged cell phone and shoot them off to her 'on line' friend, and allow little Timmy to play WoW all night long while shooting crystal meth.

    Parenting has become so hands off for most, that I doubt any child will have parents in the next 50 years. The poor little 19 year old will either abort, because the POS boyfriend that got her preggers has moved on to the next girl, or they'll have them and leave them in the hospital, so their 'fun' won't be stopped.

    Yeah it's a rant, but isn't that the way it all seems to be heading?
  • Merhabi... KrSpo 2012/06/08 15:47:25
    Merhabi Daham
    I had good parents. So, sure half of civilization will fall to what you described, but with people who had good parents growing up and were properly educated, i'm sure that the social order will be maintained.
  • Kingbatessr 2012/06/06 16:32:37
    No
    Kingbatessr
    +5
    I think they should at least be 17 or 18 years of age to be able to register to Facebook
  • TombstoneJim 2012/06/06 16:26:14
    No
    TombstoneJim
    +3
    The insanity of thinking that everyone really needs to know if your eating a salad is just that insane.
  • Christi... Tombsto... 2012/06/06 16:45:06
    Christiaan McPherson
    I just had a breakfast salad. It was nice
  • Tombsto... Christi... 2012/09/10 22:38:53
    TombstoneJim
    Christine - Breakfast Salad...now that is original thought - did facelessbook help you arrive at that witicism?
  • RyanHayes 2012/06/06 16:24:20
    No
    RyanHayes
    +1
    Too young in my opinion and they don't really need one anyway
  • KrSpo 2012/06/06 16:22:21
    No
    KrSpo
    +1
    not just no, but HELL no
  • katelynn 2012/06/06 16:21:26
  • kmsarvis314 2012/06/06 16:20:20
    Yes
    kmsarvis314
    +1
    People over 13 shouldn't use facebook.
  • poetdog7 2012/06/06 16:19:38
  • Jane Santos 2012/06/06 16:19:25
    No
    Jane Santos
    +1
    Cause what if they was talking to an adult online and didn't know and let them know where they live at that's why they are kidnapping and killing my daughter don't have a Facebook. .
  • Ms.Scorpio 2012/06/06 16:17:16
    Yes
    Ms.Scorpio
    +2
    My 10yr old has a facebook page. I am on it more than her. She only likes to play the games. I monitor it constantly, she doesn't see any friend request or messages. I check everything. And if I thought there was some shady stuff going on I would delete her page asap.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/20 02:15:48

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals