Quantcast

Should Kids Under 13 Be Allowed to Use Facebook?

SodaHead Living 2012/06/05 17:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
It's well known that Facebook does not permit users under 13 years old -- and that many kids find a way to use the social networking site anyway. All that could change, though, now that Facebook is developing technology that would allow kids under 13 to use the site under parental supervision, The Wall Street Journal reports.

kids facebook

According to the WSJ, there are a few possibilities in the works. One would connect
children's accounts to their parents', allowing mom and dad to decide whom their kids can "friend" and what applications they can use.

It does seem incumbent upon Facebook to come up with something, since many kids lie about their ages to get accounts. Last year, Consumer Reports said 7.5 million children under the age of 13 were using the site, including more than five million under the age of 10. And last fall, a study sponsored by Microsoft Research found that 36 percent of parents were aware that their children joined Facebook before age 13, and many even helped their kids to do so.

But given that adults have privacy concerns about Facebook, is the site safe for kids? And could it make them vulnerable to predators and bullies?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Bob P. Clarkson 2012/06/05 20:04:22
    No
    Bob P. Clarkson
    +23
    Adults have no concept of security on the Internet and children of all ages almost universally trust that everyone is as "nice and good" as they are. My now 15 year old granddaughter got on Facebook at 13, and even though her Dad took her off Facebook, she got on under another name using a friend's computer.
    Grandpa has been playing with computers since we were using punch cards, and even though I no longer write programs, I stumble my way through the computer world.
    I established an account as a fifteen year old boy with pictures I borrowed from a neighbors son, then "stalked" her and convinced her to meet me at a mall - it was really safe that way. When she walked in to the food court, she was surprised to see me and acted like she wanted me to disappear before "Steve" got there.
    I showed her the file on her and "Steve" and she was P.O.'d I had spied on her.
    I showed her where her school was, where her best girlfriends lived, where she lived and gave her my "On-line Security" talk.
    She listened as a know-it-all 13 year old listens, which to say is, not at all, and continued to hammer me about "spying" on her. I logged on to Facebook with my laptop, and when I signed in to my Steve persona, she got very quiet. Then I retold her what I had done and showed her how "unsafe" th...

















    Adults have no concept of security on the Internet and children of all ages almost universally trust that everyone is as "nice and good" as they are. My now 15 year old granddaughter got on Facebook at 13, and even though her Dad took her off Facebook, she got on under another name using a friend's computer.
    Grandpa has been playing with computers since we were using punch cards, and even though I no longer write programs, I stumble my way through the computer world.
    I established an account as a fifteen year old boy with pictures I borrowed from a neighbors son, then "stalked" her and convinced her to meet me at a mall - it was really safe that way. When she walked in to the food court, she was surprised to see me and acted like she wanted me to disappear before "Steve" got there.
    I showed her the file on her and "Steve" and she was P.O.'d I had spied on her.
    I showed her where her school was, where her best girlfriends lived, where she lived and gave her my "On-line Security" talk.
    She listened as a know-it-all 13 year old listens, which to say is, not at all, and continued to hammer me about "spying" on her. I logged on to Facebook with my laptop, and when I signed in to my Steve persona, she got very quiet. Then I retold her what I had done and showed her how "unsafe" the Internet was, again.
    Since a number of her friends had "friended" me, and some friends of the real Steve, kind of computer specialists, I showed her how easier it was to track her, and them, using Facebook and Google Earth.
    She was still put out with grandpa when she left, but two days later she took down her Facebook account - and so did two of her friends. She now gives security lectures to her friends that want to know why she doesn't have a Facebook page.

    She now has unlimited minutes on her iPhone, and actually likes it better than Facebook. I'm sure she and all of her friends will have arthritic thumbs when they get older, and I'm sure they will figure out something else that is probably just as dangerous, but parents and grandparents can only deal with what we know.
    Oh, it took her only a week to forgive me, but when she told her dad why she took down her Facebook page, he was bent out of shape for about a month for sticking my nose in. It was "his job" to guide and guard her through to adulthood. When my quick statement about I did what he would have to have hired someone else to do and didn't charge him for my work finally sunk in.
    I was guilty that I usurped his parental job, but I've always been a Type A, so it never even dawned on me to consult him - I just did it to protect my granddaughter.
    I'm not sure I would do it much different, anyway.










    Google.
    (more)

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Darth V... james.g... 2012/06/07 01:32:56
    Darth Vader.BN-0
    +2
    It's meant for teens and up.
  • daize james.g... 2012/06/07 01:53:04
    daize
    +1
    It's ment for teens too. That's why it's 13+
  • Rafaela... james.g... 2012/06/07 02:21:41
    Rafaela Kane
    You are wrong it's for both kids and adults also teens
  • ☆FritzW☆ 2012/06/07 00:48:29
    No
    ☆FritzW☆
    +2
    Predators are alive and not so well, but sadly present throughout the online world we live in. Children have to be supervised and by their parents only. Facebook is dangerous to adults let alone children. I see many adults use Facebook the wrong way and lose jobs or have to live with embarrassing statements, etc. A child doesn't have the same supposed level of common sense an adult should and it's just too dangerous sadly. Online enterprises must protect themselves as well. It's a sad and dangerous world these days.
  • Chuck 2012/06/07 00:44:18
    Yes
    Chuck
    +1
    Parents in their 30's and 40's are using language that parents in the 1940's and 1950's and before would never dream of using so consequently the kids now days have heard and probably repeated as much as they could possibly read from being members of Facebook. Our society is everything goes. Why not admit it and quit being a bunch of hypocrites. Personally, and IF I had my say about it a whole lot of adults (well, so-called) would be prosecuted for some of the foul language they use in public for anybody to hear.
  • Deborah... Chuck 2012/06/07 05:41:40
    Deborah Donnison
    If you want to put people in jail for saying foul language, then what would you do to a sexual predator who stalked and raped a child that they found online?
  • Chuck Deborah... 2012/06/07 11:31:49
    Chuck
    I'd just have to kill the SOB!
  • TortoiseWrath 2012/06/07 00:37:21
    No
    TortoiseWrath
    +3
    Neither should kids over 13, or adults, for that matter.
  • Deborah... Tortois... 2012/06/07 05:42:42
    Deborah Donnison
    I agree...facebook is overrated.
  • ahboni 2012/06/07 00:30:21
    Yes
    ahboni
    +1
    I prefer let them do it and have the new control than have them lieing about it
  • Deborah... ahboni 2012/06/07 05:37:39
    Deborah Donnison
    Do you have kids?
  • ken fusion 2012/06/07 00:19:56
    Yes
    ken fusion
    +1
    with proper parental supervision
  • Lola 2012/06/07 00:11:29
    Yes
    Lola
    +1
    I think that kids should have a face book because they want action and talk
  • bailmint 2012/06/07 00:06:42
    Yes
    bailmint
    +2
    im 11 and i go on all kinds of chat stuff. i know all my internet safety. Ive had people ask me my location and i just clicked x on the screen. U know, i hate when adults just say we don't know anything about internet safety, thats not fair to us, sometimes kids know more than their parents and if any of you want to add a bad comment 3 words I DONT CARE! If you comment bad on this i will simply click x so don't waste ur time trying to make me feel bad cuz i don't care. Thanks to everyone who said yes!!
  • mimi je... bailmint 2012/06/07 00:09:16
    mimi jericho
    +1
    No, kids don't know more than their parents. Internet safety isn't just about clicking out of a screen when something bad happens.
  • Lola bailmint 2012/06/07 00:12:27
    Lola
    Yeah u write
  • Darth V... bailmint 2012/06/07 01:36:47
    Darth Vader.BN-0
    +1
    If you knew internet safety, you would know that just by being on the website they can get all of you information. You do not know as much as your parents about the internet. I learned the hard way when I was twelve and a Pedophile got my information and called my father. You don't know half of what you think you do.
  • Deborah... bailmint 2012/06/07 05:33:11
    Deborah Donnison
    Sweetie, it's very rare that you see an eleven year old smarter than their parents. To make that statement just shows us your true age and your mental capacity....just the kind of statement that a preditor looks for on web sites.
  • Yukari ... bailmint 2012/06/13 21:15:25
    Yukari Sato
    This is the reason that parents need to be there when their kids are learning about internet safety. I can see you are trying to be as safe as humanly possible, but if you were truly aware of the dangers of those kinds of people, you would also report that behavior to your parents, especially if they constantly do it. Make sure your parents know if you are being stalked or harrassed on the internet, because such a person may not just leave it on-line if they got your address through your IP Address, and clever people can. IT's not that hard.

    Think about it, people even mess with other people's credit cards through the internet from a one time legit buy with your favorite big time companies like Amazon.com. Amazon is not the bad guy, but someone lurking around, waiting for the easiest target to exploit who sends some credit information over the net, grabs the numbers and passcode, and that's it! Yes, even though Amazon tries to keep their site secure, the bad guys are constantly making new programs to break the codes, and Amazon can only defend against what it knows is there, which means at least one person is attacked before they know to put up more securities.

    This is the same with chat rooms with baddies! They are lurking, waiting for the one kid that is not being watc...
    This is the reason that parents need to be there when their kids are learning about internet safety. I can see you are trying to be as safe as humanly possible, but if you were truly aware of the dangers of those kinds of people, you would also report that behavior to your parents, especially if they constantly do it. Make sure your parents know if you are being stalked or harrassed on the internet, because such a person may not just leave it on-line if they got your address through your IP Address, and clever people can. IT's not that hard.

    Think about it, people even mess with other people's credit cards through the internet from a one time legit buy with your favorite big time companies like Amazon.com. Amazon is not the bad guy, but someone lurking around, waiting for the easiest target to exploit who sends some credit information over the net, grabs the numbers and passcode, and that's it! Yes, even though Amazon tries to keep their site secure, the bad guys are constantly making new programs to break the codes, and Amazon can only defend against what it knows is there, which means at least one person is attacked before they know to put up more securities.

    This is the same with chat rooms with baddies! They are lurking, waiting for the one kid that is not being watched by his or her parents, and that person willl be the one that will be attacked. Just keep that in mind as you use the chat rooms, and make sure your parents know where you go, and if anyone unpleasant bothers you more than once. That is a big part of being safe on the internet.
    (more)
  • SueAmazon 2012/06/07 00:05:48
    Yes
    SueAmazon
    +1
    They already are on facebook and have been for awhile. They should be taught safe behavior on and off line. Nothing is private once you share it on/off line. the only difference is you have the whole world as your audience online where as you just have the local idiots offline. Of course, at least online the bad guys aren't private either.
  • Yukari Sato 2012/06/06 23:46:54
    Yes
    Yukari Sato
    +1
    I see no difference for a kid 13 or 10 to use the internet or facebook. What I do think is important however, is that if a kid learns about it at age NINE, is they are more willing to listen to their parents' advice and instructions. That means parents can actually teach them to use it SAFELY!

    I think if parents are teaching their kids to use the internet, and their parents set up the facebook page for their kids, and are fully able to access the child's page and personal settings to make sure they are as safe as possible, they will not only have full responsibility and accountability for what their kids do, but they will have another way to check up on who their chilren are friends with.
  • Nancy Scott 2012/06/06 23:09:27
    Yes
    Nancy Scott
    +1
    They already are so I do not understand how anyone is saying no. They are on it.
  • Larre 2012/06/06 22:51:36
    Yes
    Larre
    +1
    If the parents say its OK, and they are there to watch their kid's Facebook page, then it's OK by me.
  • Joy 2012/06/06 22:38:14
    No
    Joy
    +2
    i dont think kids 13 should use facebook
  • Linda 2012/06/06 22:32:38
    No
    Linda
    +5
    With child molesters on the rise,unless the parent is watching there child,it's not safe.My granddaughter is 10 years old her mother is with her.My grandson is 13 yrs.old Parents need to keep a close eye on your children while they are on the internet and useing Facebook.It's so sad and scarry every time a baby or a child go's missing,I pray that my grandchildren are safe.I pray for my daughters too!!
  • Tennessee3501 2012/06/06 22:22:44 (edited)
    Yes
    Tennessee3501
    +2
    However, that is a decision that should be made only by the parents of each family!
  • Larre Tenness... 2012/06/06 23:01:25
    Larre
    +1
    Indeed.. Also remember that Facebook has genealogy options as well. One can put on a profile who's dad, who's mom, brothers, sisters, uncles, nephews, etc. So, it can be a family affair. Just know by experience using Facebook to connect with family.
  • sharonjohnson 2012/06/06 22:17:05
    No
    sharonjohnson
    +3
    I don't think it is suitable for children of such young age
  • stevmackey 2012/06/06 22:12:43
    No
    stevmackey
    +3
    I do not think that should be under 18. Also that applies to SodaHead also. There is too much adult information on both of the sites for a child.
  • APLWONK 2012/06/06 22:09:57
    No
    APLWONK
    +2
    No one should use FACEBOOK as long as Zuckerberg, Inc, fail to adhere to their promise(s) to keep information private and secure. If people want to communicate with friends, there is always the telephone!
  • Jacob Blink 2012/06/06 22:06:21
    No
    Jacob Blink
    +2
    Yes they should be allowed to use facebook but with strict restrictions aswell. We can't say a total no to them, unless and untill we quit facebook then it would be fair to them too.
    I think yes but with supervision from a senior/parent,etc...
  • ☆stillthe12c☆ 2012/06/06 22:04:07
    No
    ☆stillthe12c☆
    +2
    But should be up to their parents.
  • Lucy Krueger 2012/06/06 21:50:11
    Yes
    Lucy Krueger
    +3
    I voted "yes" because there's no "depends" option.It depends on the child.I've had a Facebook since I was 12, and i'm now 14.If the child is smart enough to not give important information to strangers, I don't see why he/she shouldn't have Facebbok.
  • Sarah Alexander 2012/06/06 21:48:49
    Yes
    Sarah Alexander
    +1
    They still have accounts, just change their age; it's fine as long as they keep their profiles private and friend only people they know/limit personal information posted.
  • Victoria Medina 2012/06/06 21:45:57
    Yes
    Victoria Medina
    +2
    Why not because the adults that use it 15% of them act like 13 year olds anyways soo what's the.difference
  • SOUL4REAL 2012/06/06 21:31:06
    No
    SOUL4REAL
    +2
    Yes and No,yes if the parents are supervisioning them. No because this is how children run into pedophlies. Protect your children or you are putting them in harm way.
  • Brian 2012/06/06 21:26:09 (edited)
    Yes
    Brian
    +2
    In the way described, i.e. through an account monitored by parents, absolutely. Kids should be taught how to safely use social networking. It's being fully integrated into society and they're going to have to interact with it at some level eventually.

    Simply scaring kids away from it like gramps did in the top comment is a hideous approach. That's just going to make them distrust their family and hide everything.
  • Beth F B 2012/06/06 21:24:26
    No
    Beth F B
    +2
    I voted no. Because kids do not have the smarts not to fall for the tricks that the pedofiles pull to get their information and learn everything about them in order to get them to come to a location and kidnap them to rape or murder them.
    My best friend is an undercover cop who poses as a 10 yr old kid who befriends any kid on FB or message boards, he convinces them that he's one of them that they basically give him all of the information he would need to kidnap the child. When he gets enough proof, he goes to the child's home and tells the parents what their child did online and the child finds out who their friend really is and for the most part they're shocked and the parents take action in order to keep their child safe by monitering what they do online by keeping the computer in the living room or the dining room where they can see what their kid is doing.
  • Boo 2012/06/06 21:17:01
    No
    Boo
    +3
    Certainly not without adult supervision.
  • democoach 2012/06/06 21:15:23
    No
    democoach
    +2
    kids need to be able to comunicate with kids and other person to person, at a young age otherwise they will always be socially awkward

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/20 03:23:25

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals