Quantcast

Should Kids Under 13 Be Allowed to Use Facebook?

SodaHead Living 2012/06/05 17:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
It's well known that Facebook does not permit users under 13 years old -- and that many kids find a way to use the social networking site anyway. All that could change, though, now that Facebook is developing technology that would allow kids under 13 to use the site under parental supervision, The Wall Street Journal reports.

kids facebook

According to the WSJ, there are a few possibilities in the works. One would connect
children's accounts to their parents', allowing mom and dad to decide whom their kids can "friend" and what applications they can use.

It does seem incumbent upon Facebook to come up with something, since many kids lie about their ages to get accounts. Last year, Consumer Reports said 7.5 million children under the age of 13 were using the site, including more than five million under the age of 10. And last fall, a study sponsored by Microsoft Research found that 36 percent of parents were aware that their children joined Facebook before age 13, and many even helped their kids to do so.

But given that adults have privacy concerns about Facebook, is the site safe for kids? And could it make them vulnerable to predators and bullies?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Bob P. Clarkson 2012/06/05 20:04:22
    No
    Bob P. Clarkson
    +23
    Adults have no concept of security on the Internet and children of all ages almost universally trust that everyone is as "nice and good" as they are. My now 15 year old granddaughter got on Facebook at 13, and even though her Dad took her off Facebook, she got on under another name using a friend's computer.
    Grandpa has been playing with computers since we were using punch cards, and even though I no longer write programs, I stumble my way through the computer world.
    I established an account as a fifteen year old boy with pictures I borrowed from a neighbors son, then "stalked" her and convinced her to meet me at a mall - it was really safe that way. When she walked in to the food court, she was surprised to see me and acted like she wanted me to disappear before "Steve" got there.
    I showed her the file on her and "Steve" and she was P.O.'d I had spied on her.
    I showed her where her school was, where her best girlfriends lived, where she lived and gave her my "On-line Security" talk.
    She listened as a know-it-all 13 year old listens, which to say is, not at all, and continued to hammer me about "spying" on her. I logged on to Facebook with my laptop, and when I signed in to my Steve persona, she got very quiet. Then I retold her what I had done and showed her how "unsafe" th...

















    Adults have no concept of security on the Internet and children of all ages almost universally trust that everyone is as "nice and good" as they are. My now 15 year old granddaughter got on Facebook at 13, and even though her Dad took her off Facebook, she got on under another name using a friend's computer.
    Grandpa has been playing with computers since we were using punch cards, and even though I no longer write programs, I stumble my way through the computer world.
    I established an account as a fifteen year old boy with pictures I borrowed from a neighbors son, then "stalked" her and convinced her to meet me at a mall - it was really safe that way. When she walked in to the food court, she was surprised to see me and acted like she wanted me to disappear before "Steve" got there.
    I showed her the file on her and "Steve" and she was P.O.'d I had spied on her.
    I showed her where her school was, where her best girlfriends lived, where she lived and gave her my "On-line Security" talk.
    She listened as a know-it-all 13 year old listens, which to say is, not at all, and continued to hammer me about "spying" on her. I logged on to Facebook with my laptop, and when I signed in to my Steve persona, she got very quiet. Then I retold her what I had done and showed her how "unsafe" the Internet was, again.
    Since a number of her friends had "friended" me, and some friends of the real Steve, kind of computer specialists, I showed her how easier it was to track her, and them, using Facebook and Google Earth.
    She was still put out with grandpa when she left, but two days later she took down her Facebook account - and so did two of her friends. She now gives security lectures to her friends that want to know why she doesn't have a Facebook page.

    She now has unlimited minutes on her iPhone, and actually likes it better than Facebook. I'm sure she and all of her friends will have arthritic thumbs when they get older, and I'm sure they will figure out something else that is probably just as dangerous, but parents and grandparents can only deal with what we know.
    Oh, it took her only a week to forgive me, but when she told her dad why she took down her Facebook page, he was bent out of shape for about a month for sticking my nose in. It was "his job" to guide and guard her through to adulthood. When my quick statement about I did what he would have to have hired someone else to do and didn't charge him for my work finally sunk in.
    I was guilty that I usurped his parental job, but I've always been a Type A, so it never even dawned on me to consult him - I just did it to protect my granddaughter.
    I'm not sure I would do it much different, anyway.










    Google.
    (more)

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Nabael 2012/06/06 03:45:46
    No
    Nabael
    +2
    No, they post far too much stupid stuff to have the privilege to be able to use it:
    12 year old failbook
  • beach bum 2012/06/06 03:30:24
    No
    beach bum
    no
  • Queenieverse 2012/06/06 03:25:06 (edited)
    No
    Queenieverse
    +1
    The same goes for children should not be allow to have sex at 13 as well! It's against the law for children to drink, or smoke & they have to be over eighten to do that, still to have sex by the time they are 10 years old, that don't seem to be against the law at all!!! Where's the logic in that...the same illogical situations continues to occured with other things, so we can take this poll & many will say no but whose really listening to anything good that's being said...children will continue to do as they please because a lot of parents are too soft with them or too busy to take note of the going ons in their children's life to bother much!!! When the world is full of irresponsible adults for children to emmulate then you can be sure, children will continue to do as they please no matter what!!!
  • sodabox 2012/06/06 03:23:38
    No
    sodabox
    +3
    Kids should NOT interact with strangers over the internet, EVER. If you don't know this you have never been in a chat room.
  • Azrael-In GOD we trust 2012/06/06 03:17:52
    No
    Azrael-In GOD we trust
    +2
    Social networks should restrict use to 18 and older, because sometimes junior high and high school kids do stupid/write stupid things that they don't know is wrong. Consequences can be devastating; whereas, an adult should know better. Even as an adult, sometimes the consequences can be devastating, in this BS PC world.
  • Aly Hart 2012/06/06 03:15:24
    No
    Aly Hart
    +1
    What would they even have to talk about anyway? "LMS if u go to bed later than 9pm"
  • Katte_bellaqva 2012/06/06 03:09:56
    No
    Katte_bellaqva
    I don´t think so... the should have what use to be called a normal life, give´em facebook they´ll be the whole day at the pc, lap, phone... they should go out and play with other kids have real human contact no facebook... and if this is not a good enough reason we have to consider the risk that it represent for kids... and sometimes even for adults...
  • <3!Shell Dawg!<3 2012/06/06 02:58:27
    No
    <3!Shell Dawg!<3
    personally i got facebook when i was 11 but now that im older i think kids shouldnt be getting it at that age because some dont even now wat its about
  • Horace 2012/06/06 02:44:41
    No
    Horace
    In and age where we are so very informed about the dangers of child predators using mediums like the internet, why would anyone think that it would be a good idea for children to post their personal information including photos and means to contact them on the internet behind privacy settings specifically designed to keep parents out?
  • janet 2012/06/06 02:44:20
    Yes
    janet
    This is a new age and just like back in the day Rock and Roll was the devils music the internet seems to scare people.
    My grandson at age 4 can get on line and do his own thing as my daughter keeps a close eye on him while he is one line.
  • RoseyRhod 2012/06/06 02:32:16
    No
    RoseyRhod
    +1
    No. Hell, from what happened to me, I don't know that I'd want anyone under 18 using it. Nasty, nasty social site, although the pages feature is very useful. There are some really mean-spirited people out there. A young kid shouldn't be having to deal with that kind of crap.
  • Happy 2012/06/06 02:31:12
    Yes
    Happy
    I joined at 14, maybe 15 and the main reason i use Facebook is for school, it would be really helpful for a student...
  • Torchy 2012/06/06 02:17:43
    No
    Torchy
    +1
    Most adults can't figure out how to use social networking sites responsibly and safely. Most adolescents have enough problems with their self-worth hinging on their internet persona as well. Enough. I don't think it should be available until one is 16 -- managing who you are online can be as tricky as learning to drive, so the age seems appropriate.
  • RoseyRhod Torchy 2012/06/06 02:33:53
    RoseyRhod
    +2
    I'm glad we didn't have the Internet when I was in junior high. I was bullied mercilessly as it was. With that added ability to be as evil as humanly possible, those kids might have pushed me over the edge into being a statistic.
  • Torchy RoseyRhod 2012/06/06 03:46:38 (edited)
    Torchy
    Agreed. I was bullied in middle school too (not high school -- I got boobs and lost my glasses and grew a really b!tchy spine), but had Facebook been around then, I probably wouldn't have turned out okay. We all have to learn to put up with stupid people and mean people, even as adults. But we also need to have a time out from that sort of thing. We need to be able to say "Well, okay, I'm the outcast here -- but I have a loving family and they don't need to invade my home. I can invite only those I like and who like me into my home." Having Facebook at that age just invites the bullies home and allows no stress relief.
  • brittneylalaa 2012/06/06 02:12:43
    No
    brittneylalaa
    +1
    I don't know why some parents think its cool to allow their kids to have a facebook. My youngest friend is ten who is my cousin-in-law. I once got into to some heat with her family because of a comment I made about kids getting on my nerves. The thing is, I might be talking about things that I may not want a 10 year old to see. At the same time I can't delete her either. Parents need to consider that as well when they let kids on facebook.
  • Alexander Roman 2012/06/06 02:09:27
    No
    Alexander Roman
    +1
    Heck no ! They don't need that in their life
  • xxx 2012/06/06 02:04:12
    No
    xxx
    +4
    I think no one under the age of 17 should really be on it. And that's on the internet in general lol.
  • endthefed.soundmoney 2012/06/06 01:52:51
    No
    endthefed.soundmoney
    +2
    not until at least the kids turn 18.
  • Jules 2012/06/06 01:44:03
    No
    Jules
    +1
    Facebook is honestly too dangerous of a site for 13 year olds to use. I understand that they want social experiences like everyone else, BUT that's what aim and yahoo! messenger are for, those baby steps BEFORE you are mature enough to handle Facebook and understand it completely.
  • veronica 2012/06/06 01:40:29
    No
    veronica
    there to young if there not 13 and up
  • Cee 2012/06/06 01:13:19
    No
    Cee
    No.

    Facebook can be dangerous for those who aren't mature enough.
  • belle 2012/06/06 00:54:34
    No
    belle
    +3
    Parents need to take responsible for their kids internet happenings. Facebook needs to make the age higher not lower.
  • acacia86 2012/06/06 00:53:24 (edited)
    No
    acacia86
    +1
    no, they shouldn't. But that being said, kids need a place where they feel safe to talk to others. Like it or not, online provides a degree of anonymity, which can at times make things easier to talk about.



    When I was 14, I was in a very bad place, mentally and emotionally. I couldn't focus on school work, didn't sleep or slept too much, I'd either lose my appetite completely or eat like I'd never seen food before. I started hearing voices telling me to kill myself.



    I saw how hard my Dad worked at his job, and on top of that he had his ex wife (my mom) to handle, as well as an ill mother (alzhiemer's), my grades kept getting worse, my weight fluctuated, I'd go for stretches of time where I got maybe an hour of sleep a night if I was lucky, most of the time I just spent my time watching the numbers on my alarm clock change as the night went on.



    At 14, I desperately wanted to tell someone what was happening, but I was so scared to say anything. I needed to talk to someone who understood, and I saw a tv commercial that described most of what I'd been feeling. So I went online, took a depression test at a website (which no longer exists) called feelingblue.org and when I saw the results I felt even worse. I had all the symptoms. So great, I have a possible diagnosis and no one ...















    no, they shouldn't. But that being said, kids need a place where they feel safe to talk to others. Like it or not, online provides a degree of anonymity, which can at times make things easier to talk about.



    When I was 14, I was in a very bad place, mentally and emotionally. I couldn't focus on school work, didn't sleep or slept too much, I'd either lose my appetite completely or eat like I'd never seen food before. I started hearing voices telling me to kill myself.



    I saw how hard my Dad worked at his job, and on top of that he had his ex wife (my mom) to handle, as well as an ill mother (alzhiemer's), my grades kept getting worse, my weight fluctuated, I'd go for stretches of time where I got maybe an hour of sleep a night if I was lucky, most of the time I just spent my time watching the numbers on my alarm clock change as the night went on.



    At 14, I desperately wanted to tell someone what was happening, but I was so scared to say anything. I needed to talk to someone who understood, and I saw a tv commercial that described most of what I'd been feeling. So I went online, took a depression test at a website (which no longer exists) called feelingblue.org and when I saw the results I felt even worse. I had all the symptoms. So great, I have a possible diagnosis and no one to talk to. Telling someone you're mentally ill is almost as tough as telling someone you're gay. There's always the fear of rejection, of not being believed, and the illness its self makes that fear even more intense because of the negative thoughts in your head that try as you might, you can't block out and ignore, "everyone hates you." "no one'll listen, you're not worthy enough." "you're never going to be anything, so why would anyone waste their time with you and your stupid problems?" "they'll just tell you that you're being weak and spoiled and to grow up."



    So I searched 'depression support', and found an online community, which again no longer exists called 'Wing of Madness'.



    I never gave away my address, met up with anyone online. I stayed as annonymous as someone possibly can on the internet. They were there for me through my diagnosis, getting treatment going, and a few non-depression related hardships over the past 11 years.



    If I needed someone to talk to who understood what it was like, I had the other online member give me their phone number, and blocked mine from showing up on caller ID when i'd call them, if I called them collect, I'd use my screen name to identify myself. Even if they asked for my real name, a simple, "i don't feel comfortable giving that to you" sufficed. Many times if it hadn't been for that support network, I would've ended my life.



    All of that said, I was always more mature and responsible than most people my age.
    (more)
  • midnigh... acacia86 2012/06/06 01:57:20
    midnight-chaos
    i hate it when people think sucide is the only way out of a problem. if i was in a situation like yours i would have ranaway, more like moved out to a barren place-- at the extreme bad situation. like the mountains. and i might go to visit my family every 6 months. ( i need to stop daydreaming LOL :D )
  • RoseyRhod midnigh... 2012/06/06 02:36:36
    RoseyRhod
    +1
    It's good that you're able to be that strong. Not everyone is. Please do not condemn others for their feelings. Suicide is a very complex issue. People who commit suicide are not "weak" or "stupid" or "crazy." What they are is so desperate and filled with anguish that they cannot see another alternative.
  • midnigh... RoseyRhod 2012/06/07 22:41:48
    midnight-chaos
    i know! im not saying they are weak or stupid or crazy, and most of the time its not there fault its just way humans are. what im trying to say is forget bad times and make things work your way because you have the power to LOL. i think you took my comment the wrong way. but im not much offended so....:)
  • acacia86 midnigh... 2012/06/06 18:53:14
    acacia86
    and that sort of response is exactly why I was scared to tell anyone. Being viewed as 'weak', 'dramatic' or 'stupid'. I felt cornered, isolated, alone, and that no one around me wanted to hear it or even cared. I knew my Dad cared but again, he worked a lot, I didn't want to burden him with it (that's what I felt like, a burden).

    Even worse was people who'd say, "You think it's bad now? wait til you're an adult."

    Or the infamous: "it's called being a teenager. Quit being a drama queen."

    Those sort of comments turned me into a metaphorical ostridge with my head in the sand, and did nothing to help me out of this eternal funk I found myself in. If I hadn't found that place online, I would've died. I can guarantee it. If not from suicide than from simply not being able to force myself to eat anymore. I didn't feel worthy of food, affection, love, nothing positive. Since starting an SSRI for PTSD and a mood stabilizer for my mood swings, I recovered. I wouldn't have had the courage to seek help without the support I found online.
  • midnigh... acacia86 2012/06/07 22:49:54
    midnight-chaos
    well im glad you found support online. im sorry my comment offended you, even though it was not made to . :)
  • RoseyRhod acacia86 2012/06/06 02:39:24
    RoseyRhod
    I'm glad you were able to find that network and they helped you.
    Our little page isn't quite that good, but if you do have a Facebook account (as I said in my comment above, the pages feature is useful) please feel free to join us at Dreams of Madness and Delight.
    I hope that things are going better for you these days.
    https://www.facebook.com/page...
  • acacia86 RoseyRhod 2012/06/06 19:29:41 (edited)
    acacia86
    I would, except as I mentioned in a different poll, I use FB to keep in touch with my family, and I wouldn't want them knowing. They never knew that I joined Wing of Madness.

    I am doing better these days, I went to college, started a career, and I now have roommates who are non-judgemental and have experience being mentally ill themselves. No issues between us as long as everyone takes their meds/goes to therapy, whichever the case may be for their treatment. :)

    thank you for the invite though.
  • blissful 2012/06/06 00:53:20
    No
    blissful
    I personally don't think that they should. Their minds are too impressable for such grown-up communication..
  • Aspect of B 2012/06/06 00:44:31
    Yes
    Aspect of B
    "According to the WSJ, there are a few possibilities in the works. One would connect
    children's accounts to their parents', allowing mom and dad to decide whom their kids can "friend" and what applications they can use."

    This sounds like a perfectly valid, safe way to go about this. I'm fairly certain most 13-year-olds already have a facebook profile anyway, which makes this chance a little redundant, but I digress. With the kids' actions being monitored by the parents--as it should be, at that age--I don't see the problem if they feel they are ready to handle it.
  • bye 2012/06/06 00:44:31
    No
    bye
    +2
    And they shouldn't be given cell phones either.. LIKE SERIOUSLY? Their 13 !
  • ♥Co0KiE M0nsTeR♥ 2012/06/06 00:40:52
    Yes
    ♥Co0KiE M0nsTeR♥
    How do kids get in contact with other kids that don't have phones
  • Sayer Stewart 2012/06/06 00:39:14
    Yes
    Sayer Stewart
    They're going to use it anyway.
  • LaiLaiHart 2012/06/06 00:35:05
    No
    LaiLaiHart
    +4
    if your not even allowed to stay up past 8:30, why should you be allowed to use facebook? young kids are not mentally mature enough to handle a facebook profile, most adults cant handle it because they are not mature enough at their age. They are too young, and should someone say the wrong thing to them, the rate of pre-teen suicide will be at an all time high. kids, stick to playing video games and watching tv, because with the stupid decisions that my generation has already made, we dont need another generation of stupid to follow too close behind.
  • midnigh... LaiLaiHart 2012/06/06 01:58:42
    midnight-chaos
    LOL but true :D
  • LaiLaiHart midnigh... 2012/06/07 00:43:03
    LaiLaiHart
    lols and like no offense to 13 year olds, but if full grown adults cant act mature on fb, then you know most 13yos cant do it yet.
  • Mrs Reckless 2012/06/06 00:20:50
    No
    Mrs Reckless
    No, but they will do anyway. It's a fact of life, age restrictions DO NOT WORK. Iv done everything that has an age restriction, apart from sex, when I was under that age. Every kid does whether the parents know it or not. Yes, it's not safe there are pedo's everywhere, but that doesn't mean that parents should lock their kids in the house, wrap them in bubble wrap and never let them outside where they might get hurt.

    Now, I have NO common sence WHATSOEVER. But I am smart enough not to give out personal details, and parents should trust their kids, but still keep an eye on what they're doing. Not looking over their shoulder every second they're on the Internet, just once or twice a fortnight check what sites they've been on, who they've been talking to and what they've been saying. Or that's what I'd do.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/06/20 01:14:07

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals