Should Driving Tests Be Required for Older Drivers to Renew Their Licenses?

mrosen814 2012/08/30 20:16:49
Add Photos & Videos
This past Wednesday, 100-year-old Preston Carter was behind the wheel of his car when it jumped the curb and backed into a group of parents and children outside a South Los Angeles elementary school. Nine children and two adults were injured. Is Preston too old to drive? Should driving tests be required for older drivers to renew their licenses?

SCPR.ORG reports:
In California, the DMV requires drivers over age 70 to renew their driver's license in person rather than via the Internet or by mail. Should the standards be higher?
age 70 renew drivers license person internet mail standards higher

Read More: http://www.scpr.org/blogs/news/2012/08/30/9636/pol...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • exhon2009 2012/08/30 22:15:42
    Yes, starting at age 70
    Many seniors are perfectly safe drivers but there is a group that due to eyesight issues such as macular degeneration have no business being on the road. My father sadly numbered among those. The state didn't do &hit;, it was the kids that stepped in and removed his driving privileges for his safety and the safety of the public.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest

  • Dave 007 2013/01/20 14:57:03
    Yes, starting at age 80
    Dave 007
    If they are driving 15 in a 35 zone, something is wrong.
  • Mj PINKYFINGERDOWN 2013/01/03 23:24:46
  • Frannin 2012/09/15 23:13:07
    Yes, starting at age 70
    I think it would be a good idea since stats show an uptick in auto problems (accidents,
    tickets, etc.) as folks age.
  • Judge P... Frannin 2012/09/19 16:20:58
    Judge Peter Hill
    Are you an insurance industry employee? I ask because of your comment that "stats show..."
    In a certain town the men had twice as many accidents as the women. These figures alone show that a male in this town is a higher risk than a female. But there were 400 men and only 50 women and of that group, 4 men and 2 women had an accident. This additional information indicates that the women are the higher risk (4 times as many men but they had only twice as many accidents). But of the 400 male drivers, 200 were out of town during the period of the study.

    In Saudi Arabia, stats show that the accident rate among female drivers is virtually non existant. Statistically true, but in Saudi Arabia, women are not allowed to drive.

    At a certain College Campus with over 10,000 students in the class of 1990, 25% of the female students married one of their Professors. Sound like a lot of fraternization? But there were only 4 female students in the class of 1990.

    These stories are told to illustrate that statistics can be manipulated to support either side of an argument, or in layman's language, "figures don't lie, liars figure!"

  • Frannin Judge P... 2012/09/19 22:21:33
    Statistics DO show that as folks age their response time slows, their sight is often
    poorer and their hearing is often impaired...simply a part of the life process. Given
    these statistics, I would be willing to sit for a new drivers license check in a few years.
    I do not see what this has to do with insurance, since the folks who were deemed unfit
    to drive, would not be any longer be insured. In effect, this should lower premiums.
  • jt 2012/09/13 12:47:48
    Yes, but only if they fail an eye exam or police, doctor or relatives express...
    all relatives should be concerned
  • MS PRUD 2012/09/09 19:59:55
    No, that's ageist!
    Lets just make it when anyone has a wreck - they have to retake their the driving test when they come due.
  • J v E 2012/09/09 18:06:35
    Yes, starting at age 70
    J v E
    Yes, they should! There is not only a question about their eyesight, but also their ability to cope with driving stress, making a split second decisions, evaluating situation etc. Some older folks are forgetful, they panic, or they are simply too sick to drive or are taking powerful meds that could influence their reaction and comprehension. They might make a sense when you talk to them, are independent and functioning on a daily basis, but they feel lost in the traffic, and have a hard time coping with their own and other drivers ways to drive. Many know that something is wrong with them, but are afraid to admit it and lose independence.
  • William Zimmerman 2012/09/09 03:07:06
    Yes, starting at age 60
    William Zimmerman
    I am 60 and I wouldn't mind taking the test again every 4 years. I think it is more important that we need to take a physical exam to ensure that we are still physically capable of operating a motor vehicle.
  • supercar55 2012/09/09 01:00:46
  • Judge P... supercar55 2012/09/10 17:37:29 (edited)
    Judge Peter Hill
    Just one quick question here: Are you an insurance industry employee? I ask because of your comment that "...Just as there are the young men who break every speed limit on the planet, drive with music turned up loud and show off in car parks doing handbrake turns and powerslides..."

    There are just as many young women who "break every speed limit on the planet, drive with music turned up loud and show off in car parks doing handbrake turns and powerslides..."!

    Fact: Men of all ages have more accidents than women because they drive more miles than women. Number of miles driven is already a factor in setting rates, a factor which would not be affected by prohibiting sex discrimination!

    "Young males have more accidents than young females" is a half truth which the insurance companies use to breed the very popular myth that "young males have more accidents because they show off!"

    Check out my question here:


  • Jezebel 2012/09/08 05:51:53
    Yes, starting at age 70
    There are so many terrible elderly drivers out there. I'm not saying this to offend anyone but I'm saying it because that is a FACT. Most of my near accidents have been because an individual that was above the age of 50 or 60 (or appeared to be) was involved. Motor skills and attention to detail diminish with age, making operating a vehicle a more dangerous occupation.
  • lm1b2 2012/09/07 20:54:02 (edited)
    No, that's ageist!
    That's age discrimination ! Plus the fact we vote,and anyone pushing for it will be voted out of office.
  • J v E lm1b2 2012/09/09 18:13:46
    J v E
    This is a ridiculous and plain stupid statement. If this is an age discrimination , then why 15 or 16 is not an age discrimination to get a drivers license, or 21 to buy and drink alcohol?
  • lm1b2 J v E 2012/09/11 00:11:14
    Hardly a intelligent comparison,i will agree 21 to buy alcohol is discrimination.
  • 1stCEB 2012/09/06 11:20:33
  • Amnah Al-Mushiri 2012/09/06 08:44:01
    Yes, starting at age 60
    Amnah Al-Mushiri
    ABSOLUTELY! for their own safety and ours......
  • barby karring 2012/09/06 07:07:40
    Yes, starting at age 80
    barby karring
    They should be made to take a driver's competence test, at a certain age well after 60-years old.
  • Trans Am man 2012/09/05 23:05:42
  • Joseph ... Trans A... 2012/09/07 03:08:22
    Joseph Mallery
    You're kidding, right?
  • J v E Joseph ... 2012/09/09 18:16:08
    J v E
    ^^^ Probably not! Just not the brightest crayon in the box...
  • J v E Trans A... 2012/09/09 18:15:05
    J v E
    This is a racist comment and has NOTHING to do with the topic!
  • supercar55 Trans A... 2012/09/22 12:31:59
  • Chris 2012/09/05 19:46:55
    No, that's ageist!
    You didn't have the right # of choices. Yes the test should be taken after ~ 5 years of driving for all drivers. Why? Because of all the bad habits people pick up. That way the congestion might get better and also it might be easier to get Sr citizens to take the test if they see other people taking it.
  • Margaret Jacobson 2012/09/05 17:25:17
    Yes, starting at age 60
    Margaret Jacobson
    I can see having an eye exam every 2 or 3 years !! If a relative or police, doctor & family show concern DEFINITELY !! Be aware that some "relatives" want to cause problems with a "noncompliant" family member !! In my mothers' family their is no "real" concern for each other JUST REVENGE for "past slights" from childhood !!
  • SnoweyTiger 2012/09/05 17:06:58
    Yes, starting at age 70
    We know that sight and hearing, vital attributes to have if you are going to operate a motor vehicle, begin to fail as we age and at some point we do not have the ability to operate a motor vehicle safely. Better to catch this before someone gets hurt.

    Yes, this goes against our idea of individual freedom, but when you are behind the wheel of a 4,000 pound chunk of metal you need to be able to tell where the road ends and the sidewalk begins.
  • Elaine Magliacane 2012/09/05 16:25:28
    No, that's ageist!
    Elaine Magliacane
    I see SO MANY bad drivers on the road... EVERYONE should be tested before renewal... and a question added about it is OK TO BACK UP on the expressway if you miss your exit?
  • Chris Elaine ... 2012/09/05 19:48:12
    lmao Are your serious? I feel like taking the bus now!
  • dev_dvj 2012/09/05 15:34:41
    Yes, starting at age 80
    i think around 80 is where i notice old people's cheese start sliding off the cracker. 80 is when i would definitely without a doubt retest a driver.
  • joe mauro 2012/09/05 13:19:37
    Yes, starting at age 70
    joe mauro
    the problem with the eye exam is doctors who are treating seniors for many years just rubber stamp pass them sometimes without an exam,i knew a man who failed the eye test lost his liccense and was killed the same day crossing a street one that he had driven for over 40 years,i live in florida and it is a huge issue here.
  • Chris joe mauro 2012/09/05 19:51:16
    The answer there is to have the Medical license board and the DMV initiate an investigation of the MD if He/She signed a form and then let their unexamined patient on the roads with the rest of us and our families.
  • joe mauro Chris 2012/09/06 02:33:42
    joe mauro
    just what we need more bearuacracy,they cant handle the volume now.
  • P. Sturm 2012/09/05 12:25:03
    Yes, starting at age 60
    P. Sturm
    I have fond memories of hoping I wouldn't die in this car with this driver.
  • Humuslover1492 2012/09/05 12:01:02
    Yes, starting at age 60
    Yes. I can't stand old drivers. They drive so damn slow, and hesitate/pause when maneuvering their vehicles through lanes and intersections.
  • Brandi Angela 2012/09/05 06:52:36
    Yes, but only if they fail an eye exam or police, doctor or relatives express...
    Brandi Angela
    My paternal Grandmother was 84 when she died. Before she got sick (which was about a year before she died) she was in great health and drove fine. When I was 15 and she was 76 I even got some of my driving hours driving with her and when she drove I was never afraid for my life. My maternal grandmother on the other hand is the exact opposite. She is currently 73 and my mother does not let her drive anymore. When I was younger and had to ride with her I was actually scared of her driving it didn't get bad until she approached 60. She drives way under the speed limit, stops at every intersection that does not have a light regardless of the lack of a stop sign or yield sign and swerves on the road a lot. The last time she drove she drove into a ditch. And she still has her license and she hasn't had to take a driving test in years.
  • HK5SBR 2012/09/05 06:31:57
    Yes, but only if they fail an eye exam or police, doctor or relatives express...
  • Airhead 2012/09/05 04:09:26 (edited)
    Yes, starting at age 60
    I've been in 4 accidents since I started driving and in 3 of them I was rear ended by an old man. I see confused old drivers all the time. Some stop in the middle of the road because they missed their turns and some even drive on the wrong side of the road. I've even seen them do 35 going down the highway.
  • Melody 2012/09/05 03:28:37
    Yes, starting at age 70
    Is it ageist to say that an 8 year old shouldn't drive a car? NO
    The fact of the matter is, older people loose some of their alertness. It's a fact of life, get over it and make the road safer!
  • danny 2012/09/05 03:14:39
    Yes, but only if they fail an eye exam or police, doctor or relatives express...
    Maybe they should require everyone age 16 to 36 to sit on an electric seat pad that gives a shock when the driver goes more than 10mph over the speed limit. Bet that would slow 'em down!
  • Judge P... danny 2012/09/05 15:30:44
    Judge Peter Hill
    Maybe they should require insurance industry employees who work for an insurance company that uses any combination of sex age and marital status in setting rates to pay "high greed insurance industry employee" income tax rates which allow them to take home no more than the poverty level income for their families!


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 18 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.


2016/02/08 06:06:54

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals