Quantcast

Should Disney Fire Employees for Texting While Driving?

SodaHead Living 2010/11/15 23:00:00
Related Topics: Car, Movie, Death
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Texting while driving is a serious and potentially deadly problem. But should employees be fired for doing it?

Disney sent out a company-wide memo last week prohibiting employees from sending or reading texts or e-mails while driving company or private cars, Deadline.com reports.

"Failure to comply will lead to disciplinary actions up to and including termination," the memo said.

"Distracted driving," which mainly refers to people using their mobile devices behind the wheel, reportedly caused 5,474 deaths last year.

The Obama administration has prohibited federal employees from texting while driving on government business and banned commercial truck and bus drivers from texting behind the wheel.

Thirty states and the District of Columbia prohibit drivers from texting behind the wheel; at least eight states have passed laws barring drivers from using hand-held cell phones.

We understand getting fined, but if you text while you drive, do you really deserve to lose your job?

Read More: http://www.deadline.com/2010/11/disney-employees-f...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • donedunn 2010/11/15 23:55:42
    Yes
    donedunn
    +10
    Yes. The company has a reputation to keep. You don't want to comply? You are free to look elsehwere for employment. Because what would the headline read? Something like....

    "Disney Employees kills person due to texting fellow Disney employee while driving"

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Jan 2010/12/14 00:51:21
    Yes
    Jan
    Let them go to the race track or set some place up for Them to drive around it together while Texting and Injure Themselves rather than the Innocent Driver! They should have their Drivers License, and Car Taken from Them for Texting. This would be Justified in Definitely save Someones Life!
  • Sahara 2010/12/03 10:23:34
    No
    Sahara
    Yeah fine, texting while driving is wrong. but getting fired for it? Nahhhh
  • Andrew 2010/11/22 21:24:10
    Yes
    Andrew
    It's only common sence not too text and drive and the same time.
  • Miles Edwards 2010/11/21 05:42:07
    Yes
    Miles Edwards
    Don't Mickey arround with our lives!
  • kitkat 2010/11/19 22:52:11
    Yes
    kitkat
    every person should now loose their license for phone use, texting, drinking or other distractive behavior....kids or large pets on lap etc.
  • martman 2010/11/18 18:23:32
    Yes
    martman
    Not only should they be fired, they should be thrown in jail. Anybody who's dumb enough to text while driving should have their license suspended.
  • DeafGary 2010/11/18 07:27:19
    Yes
    DeafGary
    Not only should texting and driving, but also talking n the telephone and driving, should be illegal. Many accidents are caused by people not having their undivided attention on the street!
  • Jaci 2010/11/18 01:07:54
    No
    Jaci
    I don't know why people keep saying it's illegal to text and drive. It's not. You can talk on the phone too. It's up to the drivers discretion and if they trust themselves to be responsible.
  • Susy Jaci 2010/11/18 01:43:38
    Susy
    look at this :What states is it illegal to text and drive?
    Alaska, California, Connecticut, Louisiana, Minnesota, New Jersey, Washington and D.C have a text messaging ban for drivers. got that off this site http://www.chacha.com/questio...
  • martman Jaci 2010/11/18 18:24:35
    martman
    +1
    I hope you wise up before you take someone's life.
  • Kitty132 Jaci 2010/11/20 14:03:35
    Kitty132
    People say it's illegal BECAUSE IT'S ILLEGAL.
  • Andrew 2010/11/18 00:06:45
    Yes
    Andrew
    You really shouldn't be texting while driving anyways, especially while driving a company vehicle. Perhaps the ramifications should be even more severe in order to stop people from doing it, as most people don't really believe they will get caught anyways.
  • SheilaChambers 2010/11/17 20:02:48
    Yes
    SheilaChambers
    Texting while driving is stupid and dangerous! Driving requires all of our attention and much can happen while looking at a little close screen while trying to type out a message and driving on remote "control".
    In many states now, texting or just using a cell phone while driving is illegal!
  • Michael 2010/11/17 19:23:46
    Yes
    Michael
    It's dangerous, and if done in a company car is a liability to the employer. Employers have a right to take steps necessary to increase safety in/on their property (including their vehicles).
  • DDogbreath 2010/11/17 19:22:28
    Yes
    DDogbreath
    People that text while driving or talk on the cell phone while have their heads up their asses.

    people driving talk cell phone heads asses
  • big dipper 2010/11/17 15:48:42
    No
    big dipper
    You have the law. Let the law take action.
  • Dixienc 2010/11/17 11:25:48
    Yes
    Dixienc
    hmmmmmm

    Disney sent out a company-wide memo last week prohibiting employees from sending or reading texts or e-mails while driving company or private cars, Deadline.com reports.

    And why not? They're driving COMPANY cars dangerously if they're doing this so Disney had the right to fire them for it. Disney pays for these company cars and the insurance to keep them on the road so it's their right to dictate what can and can not be done in them.
  • Randice Dixienc 2010/11/17 17:19:50
    Randice
    Note that it says "OR private cars".... Company cars, I can agree with. Private? That's the indiviudal's own business at that point - and the law enforcement's if they get busted.
  • Dixienc Randice 2010/11/17 17:21:44
    Dixienc
    Missed that...BUT if they're in their private car on company time it should still stand. If you use your company time for work business and have an accident you can claim it under Workmans Comp. So it would have to be pretty cut and dried that it pertains only to when on company time even if in your own car.
  • Randice Dixienc 2010/11/18 00:29:12
    Randice
    I could agree with that. The way it is written however is leading one to believe it's anytime... and that's what I'd have an issue with...
  • Dixienc Randice 2010/11/18 08:58:56
    Dixienc
    I see what you mean. If it's written to include anytime they are over stepping their authority a bit. But then there is the fact that texting while driving is illegal in most states. Businesses do have a right to fire you if you're caught breaking the law even if it's on your own time. If I'm not mistaken, Florida is a Right to Work State so you can pretty much get fired for anything they deem inappropriate.
  • Randice Dixienc 2010/11/19 01:40:40
    Randice
    I go back to my initial statement that no one has a "right to a job". I completely get that - and agree with it! I also think however this is opening pandora's box... and I can't help but wonder..... what's next?
  • Brittanye90 2010/11/17 08:59:58
    Yes
    Brittanye90
    +1
    I completely say yes! It is HIGHLY dangerous to mess with your phone at all while your driving. I dont believe in it at all! Im always getting on my fiance for that, If I get a text or call while Im driving I wait until I get to where Im going to check it. & If Im expecting an important call I pull over anywhere that's accessable and check it because it is no text/call worth my life!!!
  • Coco 2010/11/17 08:29:25
    No
    Coco
    Of course not we lost over 20,00000 people and animals of the fires and we do not want crash's because more people will do it and crash and cause a really big problem!!!!!!!!!
  • Kitty132 Coco 2010/11/20 14:06:08
    Kitty132
    1. Use better grammar.
    2. Aren't you saying YES people should get fired??
  • havoc 2010/11/17 08:25:29
    Yes
    havoc
    Yes they should, texting and driving is not only a risk to yourself but everyone around you as well. If the employees are stupid enough to try to break the law and risk a severe accident over a single text then they deserve to be fired.
  • Green 2010/11/17 06:36:45
    Yes
    Green
    +1
    If you break the law, you could also lose your job.

    Why is anyone shocked?
  • Katie~awkward child♥ 2010/11/17 06:24:20
    Yes
    Katie~awkward child♥
    +2
    It's a safety hazard at a park that is always swarming with little kids. Disney very well should fire them if they do that, they shouldn't be doing it anyway.
  • lazarous1967 2010/11/17 05:50:52 (edited)
    Yes
    lazarous1967
    +2
    If you are driving a company vehicle and their rules spacifically bar you from texting, and you get caught texting, then H#LL yes you should be fired you dumb @ss!
    I think it should be legal to pull someone out of their car for texting and beat the crap out of them.
    when you text and drive you endanger everyone on the road including yourself.
    Beating their @sses would be justified as saving a life(s).
    Maybe a jail sentence while we're at it.
  • gingertwin2 2010/11/17 05:36:35
    Yes
    gingertwin2
    As long as they are on the clock or driving a company vehicle. Heck yes!
  • Wasaabi 2010/11/17 05:23:47
    Undecided
    Wasaabi
    +1
    Yes if they are driving a company car.
    No if they are not working. What they do on their own time is their own business ... although I do think it is wrong. It is just not right to have a company or corporation start digging their talons into any of their employees private lives.
  • craneju... Wasaabi 2010/11/17 08:09:31
    cranejumper
    so long as the employee is doing it on there break times and at lunch time if the are talking or texting during work time then nothing is being done
  • JDood 2010/11/17 04:55:08
    Yes
    JDood
    +2
    If a driver is so ignorant as to text while driving, who's to say that he or she would actually make a good employee. If can't control their habit, and any of these texters work in a Disney theme park, they are a potential threat to all of the visitors which would cost Disney a lot of money in damages. Texting while driving, which is normally done while sober, has caused deaths and injuries to the scale of an intoxicated driver. Getting caught should in fact carry the same penalties as a DUI.
  • rosebud 2010/11/17 04:44:13
    Yes
    rosebud
    +1
    even Maria Shriver - Governators's wife found out the hard way, when she had to be told by Arnold to stop texting.
  • Char. Limit 2010/11/17 04:19:53
    Yes
    Char. Limit
    +2
    Not only is it illegal, it's dangerous. I wouldn't trust someone who texted while driving.
  • Illjwamh 2010/11/17 03:27:25
    Yes
    Illjwamh
    If it's in a company car, then yes. You should.
  • JK 2010/11/17 03:18:14
    Yes
    JK
    +1
    You are doing something that has caused over 5,000 deaths over the last year. You are doing in it a car that isn't your own. That makes you a multi-million dollar liability. Hell yeah, you should be fired. I'm tired of idiots on their cell phones making me pay attention for what I am doing, as well as, what they are doing on the road.
  • Randice 2010/11/17 03:14:54
    Undecided
    Randice
    +1
    On one hand it's a private company and they're free to make their own rules - no one is entitled to a job. On the other hand, doctors are the 3rd leading cause of death in the US with an average of 250,000 per year. What's Disney's next policy? No doctor visits?
  • craneju... Randice 2010/11/17 08:06:24
    cranejumper
    +1
    Disney did not make this rule. the state of california did. Disney chose to follow those rules, on stage, back of house and on the streets if you are in a Disney vehicle and that is including seat belts, smoking and so on.
  • Randice craneju... 2010/11/17 12:20:34
    Randice
    The state of CA made the law against texting while driving (civil infraction) - Disney then expanded on that to a firing. (This is like a double jeopardy). I suppose instead of "rules" I shold have said "policy".

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/26 09:08:52

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals