Quantcast

Should Airlines Offer Child-Free Flights?

SodaHead Living 2010/11/17 20:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
If you've ever been on a plane, you know this feeling: You settle into your too-tight seat, only to realize that there's a screaming baby or child on your flight.

And then it hits you: it's gonna be a long one.

Childless travelers have had enough of being in this situation, and now they're calling on airlines to begin offering child-free flights, or to rope off “family-only” sections on planes, The New York Times reports.

A survey of 2,000 travelers released by Skyscanner, a fare-comparison site, in August found that 59 percent of passengers support creating special sections on flights for families. Nearly 20 percent are in favor of child-free flights.

“I would gladly pay extra for a child-free flight,” Ian Burford, a frequent flier from Boston who recently started a Facebook group called Airlines Should Have Kid-Free Flights, told the Times. “Or at least if they made it easier when booking a flight to say ‘I don’t want to be seated next to a 1-year-old.’ That would be helpful.”

Critics say parents don't do enough to pacify screaming kids. But parents counter that it's just as bad for them as it is for everyone else, if not worse.

“Do childless passengers really think it’s all gravy when parents can’t calm down their screaming child? It’s just as stressful for the parent as it is for the child and the other passengers, but it’s a fact: kids cry," read a recent post on Madame Noire, a blog for African-American women.

But airline industry experts see very little chance of creating perks for childless fliers during a time of cutbacks (you're lucky if you get a bag of pretzels). We don't really feel all that sorry for cranky fliers, anyway. Remember: You were a screaming baby once, too.

Read More: http://travel.nytimes.com/2010/11/14/travel/14babi...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • boberry 2010/11/18 22:47:07
    Yes, that's a great idea
    boberry
    +7
    Not that I don't love kids... I do, but sometimes you just want to jump to your death thousands of feet below just to escape the ones that parents fail to control. On one of my trips home from back east, I had a kid behind me screaming songs at the top of her 8 year old lungs for 5 hours straight, while dad sat right next to her with his noise canceling headphones, snoring away. I say, sign me up!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • MW121 Faith ~... 2010/11/18 09:45:17
    MW121
    It's not my problem they have kids...Glad airlines don't give them priority..
  • Faith ~... MW121 2010/12/06 17:40:33
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    Who said it was your problem? That's ok, you can just stand in line longer while they get situated.
  • MW121 Faith ~... 2010/12/06 18:24:44
    MW121
    Well, since they don't get priority anymore I don't have to stand longer...
  • Faith ~... MW121 2010/12/07 07:02:05
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    Actually, you do. They reason they were allowed to board early was because it takes significantly longer to situate children. In boarding early, they were already seated when everyone else got on with their belongings stored. Now, you get to stand behind them as they store the stroller, bags, get the toys out, any snacks they might want, and get the kids ready for the flight. In reality you have to wait much longer. You must not travel very much if you don't realize that.
  • MW121 Faith ~... 2010/12/07 13:16:57
    MW121
    I travel a ton, I live in airplanes, will have flown 275K this year, so I have priority since I get upgraded on every flight so I don't wait at all anymore...
  • Faith ~... MW121 2010/12/17 23:28:06
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    Then why in the world do you care if kids get on early to help other passengers move along? And, in reality, you do still wait longer. Whether you're doing it from you seat, or in line. When others have to wait, the whole plane has to wait. Facts are facts.
  • GrumpyCat 2010/11/17 21:58:19
    Yes, that's a great idea
    GrumpyCat
    +2
    Yea its tough for the parents but its the parents choice to have children, not ours. Why should everyone else suffer? You knew what you were getting into. Some people just don't like children and don't find it adorable when a screaming kid can't shut up on a red eye.

    Nowadays you can get kicked off flights for telling a mother to shut her litter up.
  • Faith ~... GrumpyCat 2010/11/18 07:07:00
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    On the other side, it's not the parents choice that you don't like children yet you're on the same flight.
    You think parents like to have their children screaming 35,000 miles up in a steel tube? Like every time the kid calms down they give them a good pinch to get them going again? I don't think so.
  • GrumpyCat Faith ~... 2010/11/20 21:25:43
    GrumpyCat
    "You think parents like to have their children screaming 35,000 miles up in a steel tube" of course not. But once again, it was the parent's choice to have children and travel with them. They knew it was going to happen.
  • Faith ~... GrumpyCat 2010/12/06 17:42:16 (edited)
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    They knew that their child's ears would get plugged? REALLY? You must be joking. It's your choice to fly knowing that there might be a screaming child, your annoyance isn't their problem, you don't have to fly but if you choose to, you might be dealing with a screaming kid.
  • GrumpyCat Faith ~... 2010/12/13 00:04:21
    GrumpyCat
    "It's your choice to fly knowing that there might be a screaming child" If there was another efficent way to get from one side of the world to the other I might agree with that, but this "choice" is usually take an 8 hour flight or a 8 day trip by rail or ship. Not really a choice when you have to get to Denmark from New York with a 5 days notice hmm?
  • Faith ~... GrumpyCat 2010/12/17 23:30:24
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    Guess you're going to be dealing with screaming kids then. If you don't have the ability to plan further ahead than 5 days, there's nothing that you can do. They pay the same for that ticket as you do and there is no reason that you should have priority over them. It is what it is.
  • gingertwin2 2010/11/17 21:57:38
    No, that will never happen
    gingertwin2
    +2
    Kids are one of the hazards of flying. Accept it and move on.
    After having to sit next to an incompetent woman with her infant niece for a 4 hour flight, during which I had freshly pumped breast milk spilt on me and ended up holding the baby for the rest of the flight, I can honestly say I've been through it all.
    But I still got where I was going in one piece so it all turned out fine in the end.
  • Hey Jude, I Feel Fine. <3 2010/11/17 21:48:47
    No, that will never happen
    Hey Jude, I Feel Fine. <3
    I seriously doubt that'd happen. haha
  • ihavewebfeet 2010/11/17 21:44:51
    Yes, that's a great idea
    ihavewebfeet
    +1
    Yes. Yes, PLEASE. Our incredibly hyperactive Britanny Spaniel puppy would be a better flight mate than a screaming 3 year old throwing Cheerios over the seat onto my head (true story).
  • ihavewe... ihavewe... 2010/11/17 21:48:07
    ihavewebfeet
    +1
    Or, at the very least, give the flight attendants the right to tell parents to reel their kids in. I have a child of my own, and he NEVER pulled the obnoxious kid routine on a plane (and I'm not too proud to say he cornered the market on obnoxious at times, but never in public when others were around).
  • luvguins 2010/11/17 21:24:59
    No, that will never happen
    luvguins
    +2
    Charge extra for kids like they do for pets on board, or put them in the back of the plane with their parents.
  • Melizmatic luvguins 2010/11/17 21:27:20
    Melizmatic
    +1
    That probably won't happen either.

    Once again, people with kids generally outnumber people who are childless; too much of a liability for the airlines.
  • Faith ~... luvguins 2010/11/18 07:08:02
    Faith ~American Patriot~
    Yeah right
  • MOMMA THOMAS 2010/11/17 21:24:00
    Undecided
    MOMMA THOMAS
    GUESS IF THEY'RE WILLING TO PAY FOR CHILDLESS FLIGHTS, FINE. CRYING IS A PART OF LIFE...BET THESE PEOPLE WERE REAL BAWL BABIES!
  • serial killer 2010/11/17 21:20:19 (edited)
    No, that will never happen
    serial killer
    +1
    its called a private jet!
  • Handcuf... serial ... 2010/11/17 22:13:59
    Handcuffsntortillas
    +2
    did you mean private?
  • serial ... Handcuf... 2010/11/17 22:46:34
    serial killer
    yea... i get my words mixed up... now i feel like a dumb azz
  • Nonicknameunlessyouknowme 2010/11/17 21:07:21
    Undecided
    Nonicknameunlessyouknowme
    That might be something to offer those who are not good with children or have very short fuses. Personally, I'd be trying to help someone struggling with a baby rather than giving them the evil eye, but I'm a mother and a grandmother and don't mind a fussing child. A fussing child just needs something and on a plane he/she might be having inner ear trouble and toddlers are just needing some room to explore and not having that they need many things to interest their little sponge-like minds.
  • MOJ 2010/11/17 21:02:05
    Yes, that's a great idea
    MOJ
    Just throw them all with the cargo, they will have more space to play that way
  • donedunn 2010/11/17 20:52:23
    No, that will never happen
    donedunn
    +7
    No. Life is not perfect. Get over it and get over yourself. There will be children. There will be drunks. There will be fat people. There will be rude people. There will be disabled people. There will be elderly. And there will be people who think that they are perfect and shouldn't be bothered with everyone who is not.
  • Melizmatic donedunn 2010/11/17 21:28:09
    Melizmatic
    +2
    Great answer.
  • Tucker donedunn 2010/11/18 15:27:08
    Tucker
    +1
    I was getting ready to bitch..... All I can say now is @#*&@@*#% Good answer, glad I looked at your post first. Kudos
  • sabbatha 2010/11/17 20:48:37 (edited)
    Yes, that's a great idea
    sabbatha
    But I don't think it will happen.I had to take my son on a flight when he was about a year old.He was surprisingly quiet most of the time.He didn't have any trouble till his ears popped.He cried for a few minutes and settled down.I was so relieved.It is just as hard for the parents.

    My son is 15 now and my days of listening to screaming fits are over.If I can avoid listening to a screaming baby I would gladly pay extra.(If I had that kind of money,I don't)
  • Melizmatic 2010/11/17 20:46:59 (edited)
    Undecided
    Melizmatic
    +1
    The only way I can see this happening is if there's a HUGE surcharge on specialty air services that only cater to adults.

    Especially considering that people with children outnumber people without.


    In light of the current economy, that doesn't sound very feasible.

    Sure, people can claim that they'd be "happy to pay more, for the convenience," ...until they see that the cost of their already over-priced flight has nearly doubled.

    Then, I bet it'd be a different story.
  • Simmering Frog 2010/11/17 20:45:22
    No, that will never happen
    Simmering Frog
    +1
    netjets

    If you find kids that offensive, charter your own airplane.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/21 12:54:15

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals