Quantcast

Rebecca Bargy Suffocates Husband in Sex Game: Does Bargy deserve jail time?

Creamy July 13, 2009 23:55:21
Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
Rebecca Bargy does not deserve 18 months for suffocating James Bargy
I think Rebecca Bargy...
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Rebecca Bargy, 26, was sentenced to 18 months in prison for suffocating to death her 29-year-old husband James Bargy. Bargy was convicted of negligent homicide for tying up and gagging James Bargy in a sex game before leaving their mobile home for 20 hours to have sex with another man she had met on-line.

Did Rebecca Bargy deserve 18 months in prison for suffocating to death her husband James Bargy to death?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Kari July 15, 2009 07:46:58
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Kari
    +2
    Well, if they wanna do that stuff together than that is their business, but it was a biiiiig mistake to gag him and then leave him like that for 20 hours. His death is her responsibility, in my opinion.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Blueheart August 13, 2009 20:27:59
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Blueheart
    better then 3 years
  • theshleepybear July 27, 2009 17:00:51
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    theshleepybear
    Is a freakin idiot
  • Alisa July 17, 2009 18:46:44
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Alisa
    This is a real WTF? case
  • La July 17, 2009 15:05:08
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    La
    uh yes? she left him tied up for 20 hours while she fucked someone else, that makes her a murderer in my eyes.
  • silly123 July 17, 2009 05:06:43
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    silly123
    ummmm idk who that is, and i think.......... IDK STOP ASKING ME QUESTIONS!!!
  • rach9990 July 17, 2009 04:04:59
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    rach9990
    I think she could have untied him... I doubt that's enough time for letting someone die!
    And it doesn't matter if "she didn't know it would kill him" or "it was an accident", that was just plain STUPID!!!!!!!!!
  • TeeHee July 16, 2009 18:56:30
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    TeeHee
    ... just got a bit too kinky. :D
  • MegMayhem July 16, 2009 02:23:14
    Rebecca Bargy does not deserve 18 months for suffocating James Bargy
    MegMayhem
    she deserves to be in prison a lot longer than that! she decieved her partner, than left him there (him probably suffering) for 20 hours, and while she was getting busy with another man, her husband was left there, struggling, suffering, and suffiocating,
  • oh my science July 16, 2009 01:38:24
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    oh my science
    looks 14 in that pic
  • _Rebekah's Shadow_ July 15, 2009 22:37:44
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    _Rebekah's Shadow_
    Is plain stupid, I don't know whether she deserves time, or at least that much but she sure does deserve to be slapped
  • khaliah July 15, 2009 21:46:09
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    khaliah
    wow, this is ackward ,hmm.well i dont think she desrves 18 months or any jail time for killing her husban in a sex game it was just a really bad accident.um but she should get jail time for leaving him tied up and then went and had sex with a nother man,that was just really dumb.she should have known better.
  • Hobbit July 15, 2009 21:12:15
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Hobbit
    Should stay in there longer. If you tie someone up for 20 hours you are negligent. But it could be something else too because she did it so she could go have sex with someone else. So he would have starved to death instead. (I know it takes longer than that to starve, I am being metaphoric)
  • Polaris 1 July 15, 2009 20:17:54
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Polaris 1
    I don't know, an experience I had with a drug addicted woman makes me wonder. In 1999 I stayed a few months with a married couple I'd known for a few years. They had a beautiful lake house with enough room for 10 people to live comfortably. It only took about a week for me to notice that the wife was a walking talking pharmacy, I'm not kidding, she had everything from Advil to Xanax. To make a long story short, to say we didn't get along would be the biggest understatement of the century. Two weeks after my stay started I decided to leave around mid December, and I informed her of my decision that night. She pleaded with me to stay for her big New Years Eve party and I reluctantly agreed. On New Years Eve night she was mixing me rum and cokes , and after about 3 I stopped because my head was spinning. An hour later I was in bed passed out to the point that my brother tried to wake me three times and failed. When I woke up the next morning my brother was sitting in a chair next to the bed freaking out and screaming, " That bitch tried to murder you bro, I swear she did". Evidently my brother walked into my room around midnight to see her yanking a pillow away from my face. She told him she was playing around trying to get me to wake up for the fireworks. I couldn't tell you what happ...'''
    I don't know, an experience I had with a drug addicted woman makes me wonder. In 1999 I stayed a few months with a married couple I'd known for a few years. They had a beautiful lake house with enough room for 10 people to live comfortably. It only took about a week for me to notice that the wife was a walking talking pharmacy, I'm not kidding, she had everything from Advil to Xanax. To make a long story short, to say we didn't get along would be the biggest understatement of the century. Two weeks after my stay started I decided to leave around mid December, and I informed her of my decision that night. She pleaded with me to stay for her big New Years Eve party and I reluctantly agreed. On New Years Eve night she was mixing me rum and cokes , and after about 3 I stopped because my head was spinning. An hour later I was in bed passed out to the point that my brother tried to wake me three times and failed. When I woke up the next morning my brother was sitting in a chair next to the bed freaking out and screaming, " That bitch tried to murder you bro, I swear she did". Evidently my brother walked into my room around midnight to see her yanking a pillow away from my face. She told him she was playing around trying to get me to wake up for the fireworks. I couldn't tell you what happened, they could have lit off a nuke in the back yard and I wouldn't have known it. My brother to this very day swears it was attempted murder, and if it was, she got away with it. And I have to admit , if she'd succeeded, there's a good chance she would have gotten away with it. I suspect the drinks were spiked with Xanax. Poor Mike, he mixed drugs with alcohol and passed away in his sleep. I moved out a few days after the incident and never looked back.
    (more)
  • Kenyon July 15, 2009 20:01:58
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Kenyon
    I need more details to this case because something is missing for her to get jail time.
  • Fryin Ryan July 15, 2009 19:59:12
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Fryin Ryan
    +1
    yes if she left him dead in the bed to have sex with another man of corse!
  • Zena July 15, 2009 19:00:01
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Zena
    I think it's hard to tell.. she did tie him up... only to leave him and go to another man. its kinda sketchy but i think im leaning on guilty.
  • BGIRL_ROX July 15, 2009 15:26:12
    Rebecca Bargy does not deserve 18 months for suffocating James Bargy
    BGIRL_ROX
    in fact, i think it should be longer...
  • Mad Hatter love <3 July 15, 2009 14:49:38
    Rebecca Bargy does not deserve 18 months for suffocating James Bargy
    Mad Hatter love <3
    it's not like she did it on purpose. It was a sex game they both consented to it so really she didnt murder him (ina sence.)
  • Torchy July 15, 2009 14:24:04
    Rebecca Bargy does not deserve 18 months for suffocating James Bargy
    Torchy
    They were both adults, there was no intent of murder, I'm assuming he consented to being tied up and gagged, it was merely an accident and a kinky one at that.

    I think she's pretty low for doing that then then going to screw someone else, but that's on her own conscience and not technically illegal.
  • ghosst00 July 15, 2009 08:10:42
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    ghosst00
    This is a hard choice, they were both consenting adults, and obviously had an open marriage, but there was a death due to negligence.

    18 months is a fair sentence, but I bet she only does 12 or less.
  • Kari July 15, 2009 07:46:58
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Kari
    +2
    Well, if they wanna do that stuff together than that is their business, but it was a biiiiig mistake to gag him and then leave him like that for 20 hours. His death is her responsibility, in my opinion.
  • bean July 15, 2009 04:32:27
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    bean
    +1
    shouldn't play sex games
  • Connie July 14, 2009 22:58:15
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Connie
    I think maybe she needs drug rehab????
  • 661 July 14, 2009 21:42:54
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    661
    +1
    She deserves some time, you don't start a game and don't finish it. bargy deserves 18 suffocating james bargy death deserves game finish
  • sara July 14, 2009 18:14:55
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    sara
    +1
    I think it's iffy. I mean if she tied him up w/out him consenting, then yeah I guess you could book her for something like involuntary manslaughter, but if he consented then that's pretty IDK, b/c he agreed to it and she didn't intend on killing him...this is all so freaking weird and stupid. WHY ARE YOU PEOPLE SO FREAKING STUPID???!!!
  • Texas Johnny July 14, 2009 17:50:14
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Texas Johnny
    ...should have had a paper bag put over her head during the aforementioned incident and not a plastic one over her hubby's head
  • amy July 14, 2009 17:24:31
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    amy
  • Gaara's black love July 14, 2009 17:00:43
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Gaara's black love
    +1
    She's wak! Yet another lunny for the lunny bin... Who gags and tys up there husband suffocating him, to have sex with a nother man?!
  • Connie Gaara's... July 14, 2009 22:57:13
    Connie
    A nymphomanic????????????
  • Constance*sick to death of ... July 14, 2009 16:23:35
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Constance*sick to death of idiots*
    +1
    it's not murder, but it is negligent homicide - or involuntary manslaughter - depending on where you live.

    She's a moron and a skank, but this wasn't deliberate, and he allowed himself to be tied up - and really one assumes he knew her - given that whole married thing - so he contributed to the debacle.
  • meg July 14, 2009 16:03:31
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    meg
    +1
    I think she deserves it I mean how do acccidentally suffocate someone without knowing it????
  • CheapShaeds July 14, 2009 15:57:44
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    CheapShaeds
    +2
    If she had been there to continue playing the "game" it would have been different. But she left, she may have been trying to kill him!
  • LisaSmith July 14, 2009 15:47:32
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    LisaSmith
    +1
    If you decide to play games like this the safety of the person who is helpless has to be your top priority. If she had went to the bathroom or something I would say no she should not be charged but she left him for 20 frickin hours. She should be horse whipped before serving her 18 monthes.
  • DarlingClarissa July 14, 2009 15:23:44
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    DarlingClarissa
    +1
    That's one dirty woman... I bet she smells like an ashtray. She looks like common trash.
  • Party Boy [A7X Bat] July 14, 2009 15:21:08
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    Party Boy [A7X Bat]
    +1
    first off, she's a total whore
  • Cyde_dish July 14, 2009 14:41:43
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Cyde_dish
    +2
    what a hooker. i'm gonna kill my husband and then bone another man while his lifeless shell of a body is all tied up? and she's getting away with it by only getting 18 monts? fuck that.
  • ~Pro-Fetus Anti-Liberal Ant... July 14, 2009 14:35:33
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    ~Pro-Fetus Anti-Liberal Anti-Atheist~
    +1
    Yes because it sounds like it was intentional homicide to me. She may have tied him up because she wanted to go cheat on him. Maybe it wasn't a 'game' at all. It sounds sick and suspicious to me.
  • milliana0523 July 14, 2009 14:13:37
    I think Rebecca Bargy...
    milliana0523
    +2
    You would think she knew when to stop. Like at the part where he stops gagging or making funny noises. You're instincts should tell you...."OK, let me check on him". But hers didn't....Accident? OOPS. Not calling for help till after she finishes getting her "freak on" (20 hours later)....BIGGER OOPS. Jail time for neglecting the accidental death of your husband to get your "freak on"? YES....
  • ABCD1234 July 14, 2009 13:25:57
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    ABCD1234
    What kind of name is Bargy?
  • Lil fairy vamp July 14, 2009 12:03:27
    Rebecca Bargy deserves 18 months or more for suffocating James Bargy to death!
    Lil fairy vamp
    and thats kinda funny in a twisted kind of was.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.
Loading map...

Living

May 25, 2012 07:03:53