Quantcast

PUBLIC OPINION > American Apparel's Transgender Model Is Great

SodaHead Living 2012/06/19 22:29:32
In honor of LGBT Pride Month, American Apparel debuted its first-ever transgender model, former "America's Next Top Model" contestant Isis King. The Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation praised the clothing company for its decision to include King, and hopes that it will help promote the phrase "Gay is OK." We wanted to know if the public thinks the campaign is a great idea, or just a gimmick.

isis king sodahead

Naturally, this is a controversial issue. We'll leave politics alone in the demographics this time, because it's clearly a determining factor, but in the end most people feel American Apparel's decision to use a transgender model was a good thing. Some respondents were uncomfortable with it, but others saw it as a step forward. One commenter wrote, "People need to not care what someone else's preference is, and worry about something worth while."

The Straight Stats

Homosexual voters were all for the use of a transgender model, as would be expected, but how did straight voters respond? Filtering out the LGBT vote, we found that straight voters were less than thrilled about the ads. It was still close, but 53% of the straight vote suggested American Apparel's use of King was just a gimmick.

Females Are Fine With It

Gender was almost as divisive as sexuality. While men were largely unimpressed with the ad, female voters strongly supported it, with more than two-thirds of the vote in favor. In the past, our polls have shown that women are typically much more comfortable with homosexuality, while men sometimes tend to be grossed out by it.

Older Voters Are Against It

Usually, when there's a stark difference between younger and older voters, the shift occurs somewhere around 45. However, in this case, the age difference was a little bit young. The vast majority of people over 35 voted against the ad, while a large number of voters under 35 were impressed. The difference was enormous -- approximately 43%.

If you'd like to vote on this question, dig deeper into the demographics, or engage in existing discussion about the topic, visit our poll about Isis King. We'd love to hear from you!
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

  • Chris 2012/06/19 23:24:10 (edited)
    Chris
    +11
    trangender gay i son model

    My only issue with this is they were trying to tie homosexuality to transgendered people, not all gay people want to be the opposite sex, that's absurd... most gay people are perfectly happy as nature made them.... transgender is a totally separate issue from sexuality. I don't think someone's sexual preference makes them suddenly want to have their genitals surgically altered. I'm against sex changes, I think people should accept their natural sex... but despite my stance, of course we should accept them as human beings. Similarly, I may not agree with smokers smoking tobacco, but they are still people and deserve respect.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • rylie_love iamco2000 2012/06/21 21:18:56
    rylie_love
    I feel morally obligated to tell the truth as I see it (i.e. crazy bible virgin birhts, noah's ark, etc...). Someone who believes in god is wasting big parts of his or her life, holding back science and love, and giving “moral” support to dangerous extremists.
  • rylie_love rylie_love 2012/06/21 21:19:18
    rylie_love
    but thats just my opinion or something?
  • iamco2000 RawRsaurus 2012/06/21 20:25:55
    iamco2000
    So because I publicly disclose that I am at all religious suddenly I'm a "Bible Thumper" interesting...and apparently it's shallow of me to not accept the sins of another, let alone condone and/or validate them.....hmmm

    I have made no judgement of anyone, as Christians we are called to be as you might say professional fruit inspectors. Is it more loving to call to attention the sins of one that they might turn from their ways and enjoy eternity in heaven or more loving to permit them to continue to their eternal separation from God? One does not make judgement by recognizing a sin, nor does one make judgement by calling another's attention to it.

    To your other misguided point, Jesus did and does care an awful lot about anything that takes the focus of someone away from God, especially wealth. Race had nothing to do with much but he did distinguish between Jew and Gentile alike, and, contrary to what you may believe, he fulfilled the Abrahamic law (in it's entirety, which is more than just the 10 commandments its actually over 600 laws) and would have echoed it's morals (he even stated that he did not come to replace the law but to fulfill it) which included strict penalties against homosexuality as it is an abomination of the creation of man.

    Grace to you, Glory to God!
  • RawRsaurus iamco2000 2012/06/22 00:15:47
    RawRsaurus
    We are people trying to be who we were meant to be. You may view it as a sin, that's fine and dandy with me. But rather than say we're sinners and headed straight for hell, why don't you take a more passive approach? Say, let God be judge and jury.

    As I've stated before. Everyone sins, and all sins are equal. All but one sin can be forgiven. Homosexuals and transgender folk aren't bound for hell like everyone thinks.
  • iamco2000 RawRsaurus 2012/06/22 04:10:14
    iamco2000
    "...who we were meant to be."....sorry, more like "...who we have decided for ourselves that we want to be", not quite the same thing.

    Take a more passive approach? You'd like that wouldn't you? Free from accountability, funny thing about sin; everyone wants to be free to do it and nobody wants to be held accountable. I again state that it is more of a loving thing to bring someone to the understanding of their wrongful and sinful decisions so that they may correct their choices and seek repentance, while they have a chance, instead of waiting to get to judgement where they no longer do. It has been said that the greatest kind of evil is the indifference of good men and backing away when someone has an opportunity to turn their life and destiny toward God instead of a path to eternal destruction would be the most un-Christian thing I can think of. Jesus died on a Cross to pay that wage for you and for me but that gift has to be accepted.

    Just because everyone sins does not mean 1st that they should, 2nd that it's ok, 3rd that you shouldn't be repentant and seek to change your ways and heart with the help of the Lord and 4th be permissive (let alone foster) the active sinning of others.

    Rom 6:23 clearly outlines for us (thanks to Paul) that "the wage of sin is death"....t...



    "...who we were meant to be."....sorry, more like "...who we have decided for ourselves that we want to be", not quite the same thing.

    Take a more passive approach? You'd like that wouldn't you? Free from accountability, funny thing about sin; everyone wants to be free to do it and nobody wants to be held accountable. I again state that it is more of a loving thing to bring someone to the understanding of their wrongful and sinful decisions so that they may correct their choices and seek repentance, while they have a chance, instead of waiting to get to judgement where they no longer do. It has been said that the greatest kind of evil is the indifference of good men and backing away when someone has an opportunity to turn their life and destiny toward God instead of a path to eternal destruction would be the most un-Christian thing I can think of. Jesus died on a Cross to pay that wage for you and for me but that gift has to be accepted.

    Just because everyone sins does not mean 1st that they should, 2nd that it's ok, 3rd that you shouldn't be repentant and seek to change your ways and heart with the help of the Lord and 4th be permissive (let alone foster) the active sinning of others.

    Rom 6:23 clearly outlines for us (thanks to Paul) that "the wage of sin is death"....this is not a physical death by a spiritual death, eternal separation from God.

    Last, you are absolutely right that all sins CAN be forgiven, but this requires a repentant heart, the seeking of forgiveness and the walking away from that sin! Continuing to live in sin unrepentantly and in a way that has been demonstrated by God to be undesired and even echoed by Jesus and later Paul to be an abomination of God's design and will is equivalent to violating the will of God meaning that one who so lives in this way will pay the wage for that sin.

    Grace to you, Glory to God!
    (more)
  • RawRsaurus iamco2000 2012/06/23 04:33:54
    RawRsaurus
    A more passive approach, meaning stop being such a dick. You aren't God. You don't decide what happens to us. Get off the high horse.
  • iamco2000 RawRsaurus 2012/06/23 13:51:08
    iamco2000
    I'm not on a high horse and I am fully aware of my humanness but I am not called as a Saved Christian to sit back and passively watch while others run rampant with sin. My purposes and inspirations here are for the Kingdom NOT worldliness, Your rebuking of my efforts underscores the importance of what I do.

    Grace to you, Glory to God!
  • Smokey 2012/06/20 15:29:02
    Smokey
    +3
    She looks like a woman to me...
  • John Wilkinson 2012/06/20 15:24:30
    John Wilkinson
    That extra long hair may indicate a low IQ.
  • kelly John Wi... 2012/06/20 18:38:24
    kelly
    +1
    What makes you say that?
  • John Wi... kelly 2012/06/21 22:06:44
    John Wilkinson
    Long hair is always in the way and a lot of trouble. Short hair is the way to go.
  • kelly John Wi... 2012/06/26 21:01:43 (edited)
    kelly
    I have long hair and I'm quite happy with it. Also I found your comment slightly offensive. Would you predict that I'm less intelligent because my hair is longer than average?
  • ☠ Live Free Or Die ☠ 2012/06/20 15:08:32
    ☠ Live Free Or Die ☠
    +2
    Meh... I still think those clothes are ugly....
  • Medulla Oblongata 2012/06/20 15:02:16
    Medulla Oblongata
    +1
    Unless you're looking really closely, you can't even tell that Isis King was born a boy.

    And anyway, they couldn't just have her model their own clothes? Last I heard, transgender and homosexuality are two completely different, separate things.
  • Son Of ... Medulla... 2012/06/20 21:11:54 (edited)
    Son Of Anubis™
    +1
    Did she/he have their Adam's apple shaved down? If not kinda easy to tell it's still a guy.
  • rylie_love Son Of ... 2012/06/20 21:30:23
    rylie_love
    +1
    be nice, don't judge, accept, be tolerant :)
  • Son Of ... rylie_love 2012/06/20 21:37:53
    Son Of Anubis™
    +1
    I asked a perfectly logical question.
  • rylie_love Son Of ... 2012/06/20 21:47:02
    rylie_love
    +2
    but you are using "it" and insinuating you don't accept "her" and it comes off quite cynical... by using the pronoun "it", you are judging her...
  • Son Of ... rylie_love 2012/06/20 23:21:31
    Son Of Anubis™
    Fixed it...is it to our liking now?
  • rylie_love Son Of ... 2012/06/20 23:23:10 (edited)
    rylie_love
    +1
    hey, i'm from minneapolis too!!! well st. paul buts its k cause they're twins :)
  • Son Of ... rylie_love 2012/06/20 23:30:27
    Son Of Anubis™
    You're now in Cali? How's things over there...how long you been there for?
  • rylie_love Son Of ... 2012/06/20 23:37:20
    rylie_love
    couple months!! its nice :) i miss my 651/612 though
  • Son Of ... rylie_love 2012/06/20 23:41:02
    Son Of Anubis™
    Yup I'm on the old 612 myself...but weather has been crazy hot here....like 90 yesterday
  • JessicaLynn 2012/06/20 14:38:58
    JessicaLynn
    +4
    People are saying that not all gay people want to change their sex and all that but not seeing the real goodness in this. As this progresses it is opening public doors for the LGBT community. This is a great thing, and I would be honored to support it. It isn't about if Johnny wants to become Sally, it is about making people aware of them and the fact they are not going anywhere. Making people aware that they deserve equality just as any human being on earth. So stop with the picking and complaining. And the model is beautiful. :)
  • RawRsaurus Jessica... 2012/06/20 18:14:55
    RawRsaurus
    +2
    This has probably been the most spot on comment thus far.
  • Jessica... RawRsaurus 2012/06/23 16:31:36
    JessicaLynn
    Thank you.
  • George Zook 2012/06/20 13:41:03
    George Zook
    I didn't think Gay and Transgender are the same thing .... what ever ... if you don't like it don't buy their product
  • RawRsaurus George ... 2012/06/20 18:11:13 (edited)
    RawRsaurus
    +1
    They aren't the same, however, some transgender men happen to be attracted to men, therefore, they identify themselves as a gay transmale. Vice versa for certain transgender females.

    Other than that, transgenders are tied in with the LGBT community. I think that's the only reason they're promoting "Gay is OK."
  • George ... RawRsaurus 2012/06/20 18:25:10
    George Zook
    +1
    it is very confusing in the sexual culture right now ... I think I will just say that the heart wants what it wants
  • MorrowJen 2012/06/20 13:17:07
  • joan.sloane 2012/06/20 12:45:43
    joan.sloane
    This is the first time I have heard about this? I suppose the idea is to draw attention to whatever it is they are selling and this should do the job. Those complaining about the transgender model are not the companies target audience anyway so , I don't see it hurting sales. She looks beautiful and I for one am not concerned about about her transgender background.
  • President Camacho 2012/06/20 12:43:39
    President Camacho
    Sick person in need of help
  • ♩♪♥Vict... Preside... 2012/06/20 14:41:41
    ♩♪♥Victoria♥♪♫
    +1
    What!?!?!?!?!
  • Preside... ♩♪♥Vict... 2012/06/20 15:10:51
    President Camacho
    Self diagnosed transgendere people need medical / psychological help
  • Liberty Preside... 2012/06/20 16:00:46
    Liberty
    +3
    Yeah they need help... In order to deal with the trauma of dealing with people like you.
  • Preside... Liberty 2012/06/20 16:32:37
    President Camacho
    +1
    Open your mind... its a medical problem
  • ancient... Preside... 2012/06/20 21:31:29
    ancientmath
    So "you" say, but you're wrong. Grow up.
  • Preside... ancient... 2012/06/21 00:19:57
    President Camacho
    No...we will cure transgender disorder...its a sad disease like being a leftocrat.
  • rylie_love Preside... 2012/06/21 00:42:35
    rylie_love
    ha, that second part was funny... but transgender isn't curable... i tried... only cure is transition :)
  • Preside... rylie_love 2012/06/21 00:55:01
    President Camacho
    I hope your wrong...many regret the transition years later. It is sad and I only wish people happiness in their own skin

Living

2013/05/24 11:22:30

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals