Question Living

PROOF: Gays are born gay. Your thoughts? Pass this on.

Karl June 17, 2008 23:20:20

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7456588.stm

"Dr Qazi Rahman, a lecturer in cognitive biology at Queen Mary, University of London, said that he believed that these brain differences were laid down early in foetal development. "As far as I'm concerned there is no argument any more - if you are gay, you are born gay," he said. "

Yes

67%

8 votes

No

33%

4 votes

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • Big Love March 16, 2009 23:15:53
    Big Love

    Yes

    Absolutely...
  • skippy November 26, 2008 07:41:31
    skippy

    Yes

    HAHAHA I shall start my gay army now by having gay sex with women!!!lol
  • biprincess17 November 06, 2008 05:12:05
    biprincess17

    No

    idk if this counts for me but when i turned 16 i realized i was bisexual. =]
  • *~Amelie~* August 29, 2008 23:08:06
    *~Amelie~*

    Yes

    It's just the way they are. It's like saying straight people are born straight- well duh. there is a 5% chance that any baby is going to be gay. i think that who we are is mostly determined from birth as well. The whole nature/nurture argument doesn't really fly with me because identical twins/triplets etc have the same genes and the same upbringing and yet they all have different personalities. Mostly, i think you are what you are and very little changes it.
  • Ace~Mr.Giantess~ June 29, 2008 23:38:05
    Ace~Mr.Giantess~

    No

    On one poll you said you used to be bi and now you are gay. So gays aren't born gay because you're sexual orientation changed.
  • shirkie - "In CHRIST I trust!" June 29, 2008 01:04:09
    shirkie -

    No

    First of all, any scientist with a brain in his/her head knows science cannot "prove" anything. There is always evidence to support or reject a hypothesis, never "proof." You learn this in Science 101.

    Second, it has not been successfully demonstrated that one is "born gay." Regardless of the current study mentioned, the consensus of researchers in this field have concluded sexuality is determined half by genetics and half by environmental influences.

    In studies of monozygotic (identical) twins (who have identical DNA), researchers found sexuality was concordant (the same) only 50% of the time. If sexuality was truly based solely on genetics, then individuals with identical DNA should have identical sexuality 100% of the time. Researchers concluded sexuality is determined 50% by genes (nature) and 50% by environmental influences (nurture). This is a classic example of the nature/nurture controversy and how both affect various aspects of our lives.

    That being said, yes, brains are different... But we have no way of knowing if someone is homosexual because their brain is different or if their homosexuality altered their brain structure. Sounds silly? Well, certain physical conditions (mental illnesses, for example) have been shown (again, not "proven" but shown) to act...



    First of all, any scientist with a brain in his/her head knows science cannot "prove" anything. There is always evidence to support or reject a hypothesis, never "proof." You learn this in Science 101.

    Second, it has not been successfully demonstrated that one is "born gay." Regardless of the current study mentioned, the consensus of researchers in this field have concluded sexuality is determined half by genetics and half by environmental influences.

    In studies of monozygotic (identical) twins (who have identical DNA), researchers found sexuality was concordant (the same) only 50% of the time. If sexuality was truly based solely on genetics, then individuals with identical DNA should have identical sexuality 100% of the time. Researchers concluded sexuality is determined 50% by genes (nature) and 50% by environmental influences (nurture). This is a classic example of the nature/nurture controversy and how both affect various aspects of our lives.

    That being said, yes, brains are different... But we have no way of knowing if someone is homosexual because their brain is different or if their homosexuality altered their brain structure. Sounds silly? Well, certain physical conditions (mental illnesses, for example) have been shown (again, not "proven" but shown) to actually alter the structure of the brain. Look what years of schizophrenia do to the size of the brain's ventricles, for example. And no, I'm not equating homosexuality with mental illness, I'm just providing an example about how something physical can change brain structure.

    That being said, I'm bisexual. I believe part of my sexuality is due to genetics (I have a hormone imbalance) and partly due to environment (influences of friends, family, media, societal pressures, etc.).

    To say sexuality, a ridiculously complicated and powerful force of our bodies, is purely genetic OR purely due to environmental influences is attempting to make this issue simplistic and black and white. Sexuality is all about a gray area, and so are the causes behind it.
    (more)
  • misterz June 21, 2008 22:46:45
    misterz

    Yes

    Agree!
  • runningintriangles June 18, 2008 04:10:59
    runningintriangles

    Yes

    Finally, proof that the crazies can't dispute!
  • rafferty June 18, 2008 00:10:24
    rafferty

    Yes

    moderated...
  • kmay June 17, 2008 23:39:02
    kmay

    No

    One opinion - we need more info like this....

    Top 10 Pros and Cons on the Born Gay Debate
    "Is sexual orientation determined at birth?"
    http://www.borngayprocon.org/...
  • xcassieeex June 17, 2008 23:31:11
    xcassieeex

    Yes

    i dont see why it matters in the end.
    theres nothing wrong with gays, whether theyre born that way or not. but if it helps people to have come to this conclusion, then good for them.
  • Karl June 17, 2008 23:21:51
    Karl

    Yes

    (User did not leave a comment)
or
Cancel