Quantcast

New Study Says Antibacterial Soap May Damage Muscles: Do You Use the Stuff?

SodaHead Living 2012/08/20 00:12:02
You!
Add Photos & Videos
According to a new study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, triclosan—a common antibacterial substance—can result in muscle impairment in both humans and animals.

Triclosan was originally developed in the 1960s to prevent bacterial infections in hospitals. These days it is commonly found in hand soaps, toothpastes, mouthwashes, kitchen utensils, toys, and bedding. Many manufacturers add the ingredient in order to convince consumers that their product will kill harmful bacteria. However, the substance may actually do more harm than good.

“Triclosan is found in virtually everyone’s home and is pervasive in the environment,” said lead author Isaac Pessah. “These findings provide strong evidence that the chemical is of concern to both human and environmental health.”

With the potential risk of muscle impairment, including cardiac function, we may find ourselves switching over to conventional soap and water. And according to the FDA, there is little evidence that antibacterial soaps with triclosan end up killing germs any better than the traditional stuff.

Antibacterial Hand Soap

Read More: http://blogs.smithsonianmag.com/science/2012/08/tr...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • mblack 2012/08/20 03:47:07
    No
    mblack
    +6
    Bacteria is good for you. I took microbiology way before use of antibacterial soaps became common practice so I never bought into it.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • ««Gingey, the Master Debate... 2012/08/20 03:46:25
    No
    ««Gingey, the Master Debater of Þ|-|Дэ†»»
    +2
    Antibacterial soap is no good. Almost no one who works in health care uses it.
  • Bibliophilic 2012/08/20 03:39:24
    Yes
    Bibliophilic
    +1
    I'm a germophobe.
  • Man_Bear_Pig 2012/08/20 03:29:18
    Yes
    Man_Bear_Pig
    If people told you that showers caused cancer would you stop bathing? Imagine what your life would be like if you listed to every new "study" that came out.
  • Jiorgia Man_Bea... 2012/08/20 05:39:35
    Jiorgia
    +2
    anti bac is unnecessary in day to day life, it is not akin to bathing, infact you are actually better off without it, not just because of this study but also because of other studies that show it kills off good bacteria along with the bad, making you more likely to get sick, not less.
  • Bulanova (Team Hargitay) 2012/08/20 03:29:17
    No
    Bulanova (Team Hargitay)
    +2
    I like bacteria, to a certain degree. They keep my immune system boosted.
  • wtxwoman Bulanov... 2012/08/20 04:10:33
    wtxwoman
    VERY good point!
  • Noobcake 2012/08/20 03:18:12
    Yes
    Noobcake
    +1
    When it is the only soap around - I carry a small bottle of that no-water-needed anti-bacterial cleanser in my handbag for that reason. Maybe I will switch to carrying around "baby-wipes" as they're not anti-bacterial, obviously.
    bottle no-water-needed anti-bacterial cleanser handbag reason switch carrying baby-wipes anti-bacterial
  • - deciphering dreams - 2012/08/20 03:14:59
    Yes
    - deciphering dreams -
    +1
    W/e , just about everything today is bad for you Biohazard
  • ehrhornp 2012/08/20 02:48:25
    No
    ehrhornp
    I was advised not to use the stuff as it tends to be hard on the skin.
  • Tastentier 2012/08/20 02:36:15
    No
    Tastentier
    +3
    The only antibacterial product that I use is mouthwash. All other antibacterial items (soap, garbage bags, detergents etc.) only put unnecessary evolutionary pressure on germs and might lead to more resistant new strains.
  • M.C Tastentier 2012/08/20 02:39:59
    M.C
    look out you mentioned evolution.
  • Bulanov... Tastentier 2012/08/20 03:31:19
    Bulanova (Team Hargitay)
    +2
    The antibacterial craze is going to bite us soooo hard. Why would anyone need an anti-bacterial garbage bag? Why would anyone need to disinfect the part of the toilet bowl so far back that you can't even see it and can barely reach it? We're all going to be in trouble some day because of this craze.
  • Tastentier Bulanov... 2012/08/20 03:59:50 (edited)
    Tastentier
    +2
    It might already have started to bite us. I read that the developing immune systems of infants require a certain amount of pathogens in the environment. Children who grow up in an extremely sterile environment are more prone to allergies, asthma and various auto-immune diseases. One hypothesis also links autism to a lack of early germ exposure.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...
    Quote: "The hygiene hypothesis is supported by epidemiological data. Studies have shown that various immunological and autoimmune diseases are much less common in the developing world than the industrialized world and that immigrants to the industrialized world from the developing world increasingly develop immunological disorders in relation to the length of time since arrival in the industrialized world."

    Coming to think of it, this might be the reason that infants put everything into their mouth, including the occasional handful of dirt or sand. They're instinctively training their immune system. This article seems to support that (it also mentions triclosan-containing soap):
    http://www.thepunch.com.au/ar...

    This could also be a reason that pet owners are statistically healthier than people without pets. Children who grow up with pets will likely also be healthier than other children.
  • Bulanov... Tastentier 2012/08/20 04:14:38
    Bulanova (Team Hargitay)
    +2
    That's exactly the reason children put things in their mouths: to introduce bacteria early and beef up to it. It's also why they eat boogers. Sometimes I think the more advanced we get, the dumber we become.
  • Pikachu 2012/08/20 02:13:08
    Yes
    Pikachu
    I thought it meant just regular hand soap for some reason?
  • The Doctor's Rose♥ 2012/08/20 02:07:26
    Yes
    The Doctor's Rose♥
    Sometimes
  • ruru 2012/08/20 01:53:58
    No
    ruru
    +1
    Usully Ivory bar soap.
  • Sodahead Founders are Fascists 2012/08/20 01:29:00
    No
    Sodahead Founders are Fascists
    +2
    I'm not a surgeon.
  • Aerok 2012/08/20 01:23:21
    Yes
    Aerok
    +1
    Yes and this survey seems pretty sketchy at best.
  • Jiorgia Aerok 2012/08/20 02:03:04
    Jiorgia
    +2
    the smithsonian wouldn't be telling us about it unless it had been successfully peer reviewed.
  • Aerok Jiorgia 2012/08/20 02:28:33
    Aerok
    meh its just more senseless fear-mongering. Practically EVERYONE knows SOMETHING that will end up either killing or damaging them...skip the anti-bac and get sick or use it and have muscles degenerate? Man
  • Jiorgia Aerok 2012/08/20 05:35:41
    Jiorgia
    +1
    in a hospital or with actual first aid yeah use anti bac, it will help, but day to day dont use it, it kills off the good bacteria too, in turn making you more likely to get sick.
    If you just use normal soap and warm water, you will be absolutely fine.
  • SOUL4REAL 2012/08/20 01:20:11
    No
    SOUL4REAL
    +1
    No,I don't use antibacterial hand soap. I use plain old hand soap!
  • Jiorgia 2012/08/20 01:19:05
    No
    Jiorgia
    +3
    Just use normal soap and hot water.
    I dont buy in to the sterilised generation.
  • Linnster 2012/08/20 01:10:51
    No
    Linnster
    +6
    I don't know whether it harms muscles or not. I don't use it because I think it's a waste of money and it kills off good bacteria that your body uses to fight infection.
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/20 04:15:27
    wtxwoman
    +1
    I completely agree. I have one son-in-law that washes everything to death including himself, 2-3 showers a day and clothes that have been worn for an hour. One daughter was washing all the veggies in that spray they sell for that. I looked at the ingredients and it was mostly water and vinegar. I told her to mix her own. She usually does that with all her cleaners. We are allergic to a lot of chemicals. I don't wear perfume or use scented anything. I am almost never sick with colds and stuff.
  • Linnster wtxwoman 2012/08/20 04:58:59
    Linnster
    I'm like you - I can't remember the last time I was really sick and it's probably been three years since I've had a cold. I don't even wash my veggies and fruit when I bring it home from the market!
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/20 06:13:32
    wtxwoman
    +1
    I don't, either, unless I have company for dinner. Other people seem to frown on that. As much as the supermarket sprays them, I figure they are pretty clean by the time I get them. I used to grow my own, but it's hard to do when there is only youself. My daughter that lives here in town would take fresh veggies if I picked, cleaned, prepared, and handed them to her!
  • Linnster wtxwoman 2012/08/20 12:39:51
    Linnster
    +1
    LOL ... it's even harder to grown your own when you live in an apartment building in NYC!
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/21 02:38:04
    wtxwoman
    +1
    What about container growing if you have a balcony? I've always thought the tops of the buildings should be planted in something.
  • Linnster wtxwoman 2012/08/21 16:37:07
    Linnster
    +1
    My neighbor and i tried growing tomatoes. As soon as they were green, someone stole them. Not doing that again.
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/21 17:24:51
    wtxwoman
    +1
    If you have a protected place where you can let them vine, you can get more tomatoes. Put them in a well drained 5 gallon bucket and after they are about a foot tall take all the suckers off except let two vines grow up. Keep them tied and keep the suckers pinched off. They only take a gallon of water a day. Add your fertilizer to the water. I've had them grow over 16 feet tall. One year I harvested the last tomatoes after Thanksgiving on the roof of my house. It is 12 feet high.
  • Linnster wtxwoman 2012/08/22 18:46:32
    Linnster
    +1
    We grew them in the backyard at my sister's house and got a great crop. Growing them in an urban area where there is no protection is out of the question now. I'm not going to make that much effort for someone else to enjoy. Thanks for the tips.
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/23 03:38:59
    wtxwoman
    +1
    You are welcome. I had a commercial greenhouse with 740 tomato plants when my husband had that stroke. I learned more about tomatoes than I ever wanted to or knew was possible. Now, I grow a few things in a 7' X 10' fiberglass tank to keep the ground squirrels and rabbits from eating everything.
  • Linnster wtxwoman 2012/08/23 12:25:56
    Linnster
    +1
    Wow, that's a lot of tomatoes. I'm sure you know a great deal about them. Sorry about your husband. We didn't have much trouble with the squirrels. Someone told us to use dried blood in the hole we dug for the plant and to plant marigolds around them. We were fortunate - we didn't lose any tomatoes to the wildlife. :)
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/23 15:20:35
    wtxwoman
    +1
    I might try the dried blood. The marigolds didn't work for me. I ended up with marigolds all over my yard for a few years. They are prolific little suckers!
  • Linnster wtxwoman 2012/08/23 16:15:10
    Linnster
    +1
    We only had a few marigolds, but they never proliferated that much.
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/24 04:05:39
    wtxwoman
    +1
    Evidently, they like the heat and sun. I'm being innudated by lantans now and all from a potted one that I thought was dead!
  • Linnster wtxwoman 2012/08/24 13:20:38
    Linnster
    +1
    OMG - I had no idea what lantana was and when I looked it up just now, I realize I bought four plants for containers outside the front of my apartment building. They get full sun virtually all day and these plants have grown to be huge. It's too cold to keep them out come winter, but I'll bring them in and see if I can keep them going on a windowsill. I don't have sun, so I doubt they'll do well. I also bought "nerve" plants to put in the containers. I've had them in the house and they didn't do very well, but outside in the sun, they're doing as well as the lantana. I had no idea they could get that big!
  • wtxwoman Linnster 2012/08/24 16:39:23
    wtxwoman
    +1
    Mine did not only get big, it has babies and more babies. At last count, I have over 24 and several are as big as momma, now. They are good for keeping mosquitos at bay.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/22 11:27:32

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals