Quantcast

Marc Jacobs Hasn’t Spoken to His Immediate Family in 20 Years: Understandable or Awful?

SodaHead Living 2011/12/19 22:10:44
You!
Add Photos & Videos
In a recent interview with Vogue, fashion designer Marc Jacobs admitted that he hasn’t seen or spoken to his immediate family members, his mother, younger brother, or younger sister, in 20 years. In the past, Jacobs has told reporters that his mother is mentally ill and did not take good care of her children, one of the reasons he left home to go live with his grandmother when he was a teenager. Jacobs’s father died when Marc was six-years-old.

Marc Jacobs

Jacobs insists that it’s not “a sad situation,” with his family, but that they just don’t “get along very well.” When questioned further, he revealed that he rejects society’s traditional attitude toward familial affection.

“I hate this idea that you have to love somebody because they are your family,” he said. “Nobody can tell me what I’m supposed to feel and who I am supposed to feel it for. I don’t blame them, I don’t hate them, I just know that I don’t feel love for them. That’s all. And I am not going to make the call or try to stay in touch because society says, But it’s your mother. Oedipus, Schmoedipus.”

And according to the Vogue writer, Jacobs seems to have made a family for himself among his closest friends. Some people admire Jacobs for his unrelenting authenticity and his refusal to force emotion. Others, however, believe that someday he’ll regret his attitude towards his family.

What do you think? Is it understandable or awful that Marc Jacobs hasn’t seen or spoken to his immediate family members in 20 years?

Read More: http://www.vogue.com/magazine/article/marc-jacobs-...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Michael samson 2011/12/20 20:26:15
    Michael
    you are using a different sense of the word love here. Do you love just the body part or the whole person?
  • schjaz Michael 2011/12/20 20:47:36
    schjaz
    don't bother, the guy is a bit twisted.
  • Michael schjaz 2011/12/20 22:02:47
    Michael
    +1
    oh dear. Well there is always hope.
  • samson Michael 2011/12/21 05:18:16
    samson
    i was being sarcastic. I dont choose to love someone or to love women in general, it just happens. just like being happy, you can decide to fake it, but theres nothing like the real thing. so i disagree with you. i am a bit twisted, but oh well.
  • cupcake samson 2011/12/21 21:57:41
    cupcake
    How'd you find that picture of me?
  • samson cupcake 2011/12/22 00:32:45 (edited)
  • cupcake 2011/12/20 16:54:07 (edited)
    Understandable
    cupcake
    +7
    Anybody who answered "awful" doesn't have any ''real'' emotionally devastating experiences with people who are supposed to be THE people to love you unconditionally, *they are supposed to always have your back, *they are supposed to NOT be bullies, *they are not supposed to set you up to fall, set you up to humiliate yourself, set you up to laugh AT you, disparage you, *not supposed to enjoy telling you how funny it was when they told all their friends about what an ass you are, *not supposed to make child abuse jokes about beating you, *not supposed to beat you and then defend their actions as right, *they are not supposed to make you have Post Traumatic Stress Disorder seep into every crevice of your life, *they are not supposed to protect the child abuser who raped you when you were 5,*they are not supposed to scream at you that you were only 5 and you can't remember anything from that age, stop being melodramatic, protecting his career was important not any memory you were not going to have (but absolutely did have) ,* they are not supposed to make you so convinced that if you told them you were raped by your boyfriend and boyfriends best friend at 15 that they were going to blame you, so you let the bf get away with the rape and continued to date him - because you aren't ...


    Anybody who answered "awful" doesn't have any ''real'' emotionally devastating experiences with people who are supposed to be THE people to love you unconditionally, *they are supposed to always have your back, *they are supposed to NOT be bullies, *they are not supposed to set you up to fall, set you up to humiliate yourself, set you up to laugh AT you, disparage you, *not supposed to enjoy telling you how funny it was when they told all their friends about what an ass you are, *not supposed to make child abuse jokes about beating you, *not supposed to beat you and then defend their actions as right, *they are not supposed to make you have Post Traumatic Stress Disorder seep into every crevice of your life, *they are not supposed to protect the child abuser who raped you when you were 5,*they are not supposed to scream at you that you were only 5 and you can't remember anything from that age, stop being melodramatic, protecting his career was important not any memory you were not going to have (but absolutely did have) ,* they are not supposed to make you so convinced that if you told them you were raped by your boyfriend and boyfriends best friend at 15 that they were going to blame you, so you let the bf get away with the rape and continued to date him - because you aren't worth anything better than a sexual abusive boyfriend, *they are not supposed to call you horrible names, names that so painful that no plastic surgeon can erase the scars, *they are not supposed to play the favorite child game where there is no chance of placing anywhere but last place*they are supposed to build you up, show positive genuine sincere interest in you, interest in what you are interested in and why you are interested in, help you find the strength within to face what the world has to dish out, they are supposed to help you see what a wonderful person you are and can be, how you have unique gifts, unique positive characteristics, they are not supposed to make you their emotional, psychological and physical punching bag.
    I understand how Marc Jacobs feels. Do you? Can you?

    pictures of bruised  physically abused children pictures of bruised  physically abused children  divorce
    (more)
  • **Bessie** cupcake 2011/12/20 18:53:39
    **Bessie**
    +1
    You're right.
  • Holy cupcake 2011/12/20 20:25:12
  • Lanikai cupcake 2011/12/20 20:28:21
    Lanikai
    Bravo, I avoid my birth mother for all of those reasons.
  • This is W³ 2011/12/20 16:51:57
    Understandable
    This is W³
    +2
    I didn't speak to my parents for over a year after they refused to meet with my last girlfriend. We have re-established contact since, but only once a month instead of once a week.
  • sky king 2011/12/20 16:49:34
    Awful
    sky king
    +1
    YOU HAVE TO SAY SOMETHING!
  • cupcake sky king 2011/12/21 17:30:11
  • wow-really 2011/12/20 16:34:38
    Understandable
    wow-really
    +3
    I "love" my family, but they make it real hard to LIKE them - a lot...
    I have to come to grips with the fact that while I love them, it's ok for me not to feel guilty about the fact that their constant negativity and drama are toxic, and as such, they are not people I like to be or want to be around often.
    Love and respect are earned, not entitled..
    Guilt trips only work for those that want to jump on board and take that ride.. As for me, thanks, but no thanks. I'll walk.
  • moonchild 2011/12/20 16:25:36
    Understandable
    moonchild
    +4
    You can't pick family and if his family sucks, then I can see telling them to f-off.
  • **Bessie** 2011/12/20 16:22:17
    Understandable
    **Bessie**
    +4
    Absolutely understandable! I have heard the old "blood is thicker than water" thing too many times, where it was totally undeserved.
  • dick **Bessie** 2011/12/20 18:06:40
    dick
    +2
    Hello Sweet thing Merry Christmas! animated christmas party
  • **Bessie** dick 2011/12/20 18:49:54
    **Bessie**
    merry christmas sexy

    Merry Christmas handsome!!
  • Untouched 2011/12/20 16:11:31
    Understandable
    Untouched
    +2
    n that's what i'm going to do too
  • the_old_coach 2011/12/20 15:45:08
    Understandable
    the_old_coach
    +3
    I have a similar situation. It's ok.
  • Treedy 2011/12/20 15:38:50 (edited)
    Awful
    Treedy
    +1
    I don't think he is awful, but the situation is awful. Even in his words, you can feel that there is some hurt there and it's always an awful situation when a person has held hurt in their heart for a very long time without a resolution.
  • ~Jeffi <3 floats~ 2011/12/20 15:38:16
    Understandable
    ~Jeffi <3 floats~
    +4
    my immediate family and i aren't very close at all.. i don't hate them nor do i love them. its just the way of life.
  • Zombiecat~Metalhead4Life 2011/12/20 15:18:54
    Understandable
    Zombiecat~Metalhead4Life
    +4
    I believe that is his business.
  • 10997 2011/12/20 15:04:34
    Understandable
    10997
    +3
    Anyone who voted "Awful" makes me sick
  • Lanikai 10997 2011/12/20 20:30:28
    Lanikai
    Well, go easy there, lots of folks had much better upbringings then a lot of us, so they cannot understand a clean break like this. Both sides need to understand this one.

    Not all families are good families and not all families are worth keeping together.
  • 10997 Lanikai 2011/12/21 02:28:51
    10997
    +1
    I appreciate that your being very understanding to everyone, but it seems to me that voting "Awful" means that they are harshly judging Marc Jacobs for his perfectly legitimate decision. Save for people like the one above who said, "I don't think he is awful, but the situation is awful."
  • Jenna ☮♡ッ 2011/12/20 14:57:52 (edited)
    Understandable
    Jenna ☮♡ッ
    +2
    Some families are just really screwed up. Its completely understandable imo. Blood doesn't mean anything to me - its the personality/behavior that matters and if I wouldn't put up with that crap from a friend, I sure as hell wouldn't put up with it from a family member just because they're "blood related."
  • tatilee(: 2011/12/20 14:51:47 (edited)
    Awful
    tatilee(:
    +1
    I know he says it's not a sad situation but I just can't imagine going through life without my family. It's heartbreaking for me to hear that he has no love whatsoever for his family. But it's his choice I guess. You can't force love
  • Papillon 2011/12/20 14:51:23
    Understandable
    Papillon
    +2
    I said understandable. What I would've said were there an 'other' answer is: IT'S NONE OF YOUR EFFING BUSINESS, SO GET AN EFFING LIFE.
  • Mr Wayne 2011/12/20 13:57:20
    Understandable
    Mr Wayne
    +3
    Who am I to judge him?
  • AnishaTheGenius...WellNotQuite 2011/12/20 13:26:46
    Understandable
    AnishaTheGenius...WellNotQuite
    +4
    Sometimes family needs to be loved from distance if they don't support you or if it cause more harm than good to interact with one another because everyone can't put aside their differences!
  • dandieselonian 2011/12/20 13:19:00
    Understandable
    dandieselonian
    +1
    I dont know this guy but he seems like a guy who knows what he want and thats great.
  • freebirdie 2011/12/20 13:02:41
    Awful
    freebirdie
    +3
    There are not enough details in this story that it really was a horrible childhood--and yet people believe him without question. For all anyone knows, he could've just been a selfish, bratty teen and didn't like to be told 'no' by a loving parent.
    Saying someone has a "mental illness" is a BLANKET statement and can mean lots of things nowadays. Sometimes it means someone has debilitating depression where they are in bed or in the hospital and on meds. Other times it means, 'since you don't agree with me so you must be mental!' I tend to think it's the latter one.
    It couldn't have been that bad if all the children were not removed by authorities or left on their own--and are still in a relationship. How is it he's the only one that left--in his teens. If he hasn't spoken to his immediate family for 20 years, that kind of tells you it's HIS issue--not theirs.
    He hasn't mentioned sexual abuse or anything else, so don't read things into this that aren't there.
  • coach k 2011/12/20 12:58:08
    Awful
    coach k
    +1
    i can't even think about not talking to my sibilings seems weird to me
  • Dickens 2011/12/20 11:55:09
    Understandable
    Dickens
    +3
    ..a fashion designer? I bet THEY cut off contact with HIM...
  • Lanikai Dickens 2011/12/20 20:31:05
    Lanikai
    +1
    With his money and fame, bet not.
  • The Truth 2011/12/20 09:49:18
    Understandable
    The Truth
    +4
    I have family like that myself. Friends are much better than family.. You get to chose them.
  • Jenna ☮♡ッ The Truth 2011/12/20 14:58:55
    Jenna ☮♡ッ
    +3
    Agreed
  • Wyveryx 2011/12/20 09:00:21
    Awful
    Wyveryx
    +3
    Sorry but this is awful. 20 years? So he didn't have the greatest childhood, and I highly doubt that his mother had a great time either, but hey, as long as he got the chance to get away and become a success, why bother with her and his brother and sister? They must have been bad in taking care of him too and were getting all the love.
    I tell you this, I don't give two rats @ss's about this guy, but if all he can say is that he "doesn't blame" them and "doesn't hate" them and that he "doesn't feel love" for them, then he doesn't even know them. In these last 20 years he didn't take one chance to see if things have become worse or better and rebuild his relationship...
    My bet is that if he ever has a family of his own he won't "love" them or "blame" them or "hate" them when they leave because he just doesn't "CARE" about anyone but himself.
  • Dawn Jacquelyn 2011/12/20 08:07:39
    Understandable
    Dawn Jacquelyn
    +2
    I disowned my sister's 4 brats after she died. I couldn't hurt her while she was alive. You do what you have to do and I'm much happier with them OUT of my life.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/24 09:32:03

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals