Quantcast

LIVING: Grandma Slaps Foulmouthed Teen: Should She Have Gone To Jail For It?

Theresa Collier, a 73 year-old grandmother, was arrested and sent to jail after slapping her 18 year-old granddaughter across the face. Collier had invited her granddaughter, Felicia, to her home to use her computer; the troubled teenager had recently been expelled from Catholic school in Massachusetts - after cursing at a nun - and is currently working towards completing her senior year online. When Collier insisted one time too many that her granddaughter remain focused on her studies, the trouble began.

“She kept repeating the F-word to me, about the whole family. She just went on and on and I just got so upset, I got up and slapped her across the face,” she told a local television news station in Tampa Bay. After the heated altercation, the 18 year-old called the police, who cuffed the stunned grandmother and carted her off to jail, where she spent the next 24 hours. Police officer Lt. Mike Loux explains, “Legally she’s 18-years-old, so while I understand the difference between corporal punishment on a child for using poor language, this is an 18-year-old child. If an officer on scene finds probable cause to arrest a person, because they’ve committed domestic battery, then our policy is a mandatory arrest of that person.” Collier has suffered enormous stress throughout the ordeal, as has her husband Walter. “My wife of 52 years went to Catholic Parochial school,” he tearfully explained, “went to church, she’s a good strong Catholic and raised four kids and no one ever spoke to her like that.”

WATCH



You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • SpOoKs! 2011/08/08 20:41:50
  • youarenotlistening 2010/07/30 16:34:25
    youarenotlistening
    If anyone slaps me, they are going to jail. I think she did the right thing, but shouldnt have been cursing anyone.
    There is no excuse for domestic violence. The family wasnt all that loving , it seems anyway.
    Seems that all that 'parochial ' school didnt count for much besides abuse.
    Now she is being treated badly by everyone and guilt tripped.
    sick family, praise god.
  • Pastor 2010/07/10 20:46:12
    Pastor
    police are out of control, this is what caused the child to use foul speech, just wait they will kill the ploice next. if children don't respect the elderly(themselves) the will say and do anything. i'm sure that cop was brought up on the back of a broom handle. lol
    cops protect the guilty and serve the innocent people with punishment
  • ⚜Ellen⚜ ☼True American Patr... 2010/06/20 00:45:49 (edited)
    ⚜Ellen⚜ ☼True American Patriot ☼
    NO! ....... Grandma should NOT go to jail over this.

    I can't imagine my son talking to me that way. He asked my permission to say the word 'crap' once because he was angry about something.

    I'd like to slap the girl that did this to her Grandma. She was not only vulgar, but she punched her own Grandmother after she was slapped for being vulgar and disrespectful to her... and then proceeded to call the police on her Grandmother.

    I'd be writing that lil' bee-otch outta my will.

    Hugs to you Grandma! ♥
    disrespectful proceeded police grandmother writing bee-otch outta hugs grandma hearts
  • LatashaHarrison 2010/06/10 00:31:14
    LatashaHarrison
    +3
    Nothing about this situation is good. I really love the last photo comment. I can't honestly say that i would have reacted any differently than the grandmother did in her shoes. The girl is now legally an adult and yet the lesson that she just learned is that she can go anywhere and say or do anything without suffering any consequences. What happened to her grandmother's right not to be abused, verbally or otherwise, in her own home? I am really having a hard time understanding how the police could justify arresting one and not the other. does the fact that the granddaughter is now 18 mean that she can legally terrorize people who try to help her? i f the grandmother is anything like mine, she is trying her hardest to keep the peace and love her grandchildren. she would rather put up with the disrespect than lose all contact with the grandchild that she love despite everything. My heart and prayers are with her.
  • Zozo 2010/06/09 21:45:13
  • words t... Zozo 2010/06/10 02:45:28 (edited)
    words to live by
    The government has intruded too much in the lives of people. As a nation we have become spirtually pluralistic and have rejected Jesus Christ and the Bible as our foundation of faith and living. Our country has outlawed the Ten Commandents in schools and in our court houses. States are legalizing homosexual marriages and in some states our pre-school children are exposed to transgender teachers. We are not allowed to open our mouths because we can be charged with a hate crime if we protest. Then abortions are legalized, but a parent who wants to raise their child that they chose to keep has to walk on egg shells if they want to slap it's bottom and teach them respect. In my state a few years back a parent was arrested for slapping his son. He went to jail and when he got out he told news reporters, 'I will not let my child stand up and tell me he will call the cops and holler child abuse.' He will not dare my authority as a parent to raise him as I see fit, and neither will a court of law. II'm prepared to correct my child and raise him to adulthood. If it means spending week-ends in jail so be it. He will not get in my face and dare me to touch him....he received a thunderous applause from the crowd. Hang in there...The Bible say's, 'spare the rod, spoil the child.'
  • Zozo words t... 2010/06/11 01:05:26
  • words t... Zozo 2010/06/11 15:28:21
    words to live by
    I do not approve of violence. Most times if you correct a child in anger and swat them, it proves nothing. There is enough anger in people just dealing with daily life. Good answer. You sound like a wonderful Dad...
  • Zozo words t... 2010/06/11 20:39:20
  • words t... Zozo 2010/06/12 20:07:27
    words to live by
    Wonderful, Mother then.
  • Anthony Gemma 2010/06/05 13:31:13
    Anthony Gemma
    Join the discussion! Leave a comment.
  • Lorrie Lehnerz 2010/06/03 16:27:34
    Lorrie Lehnerz
    +1
    i hope that grandmother never lets that grandchild back in her life , what a waste of time that 18 year old is. i hope she has better grandkids. maybe she should spend more time with the ones who love her.
  • Edward 2010/06/03 15:25:47
    Edward
    This 18 year old piece of garbage should have been punished and not the grandmother. How could she call the cops to have them arrest her grandmother who did her a favor by helping her to complete school from which she was expelled due to her own fault.
  • Alison 2010/06/02 11:12:40
    Alison
    NO!!!!!!!!!! i don think the granny deserves to go to jail! It is the teenager's fault! she is so rebellious!!
  • Patriot 2010/06/01 23:29:49
    Patriot
    Join the discussion! Leave a comment.
  • Patriot 2010/06/01 23:27:23
    Patriot
    Join the discussion! Leave a comment.
  • Patriot Patriot 2010/06/01 23:43:54
    Patriot
    +1
    This world has continuously resorted to they quick fix. it doesn't work! This girl child needs to have all priviledges revoked,i.e. driving, cell phone, games of every kind , tv, mall priviledges, socializing with any other than scooling which is online doe to her inability to co-habitate the planet with others. This society has been raising and breeding monsters and letting them loose on the world with no boundries, no rules and no balance or sence of them selves. get a clue people these children can not raise themselves. and the child wellfare coalition wants to keep it being a problem and not have a solution as that would put them out of work. who did they learn from? why the education system which has long ago found out that keeping you in school and tied to student loan indenture and fear has kept the majority of people tied to the goverment trough.. WAKE UP!!! take responcebility for yourself and those you bring into this world. You have powerfull tools if you would only use them. one thing I've learned about Cathoholics is that where ever you find three or four you will find a "fifth" lol. Maybe its time to stop poisoning ourselves and our children and stop letting our children be abused by government, churches , and the wealthy. OUR CHILDREN ARE NOT FOR SALE!
  • ARkey 2010/05/26 18:43:23 (edited)
    ARkey
    +1
    DEAR words to live by,

    WOW! My, my, my...really?

    REALLY! I think a good "hard" jap-slap accross the nose by the grandmother to the granddaughter would have given her granddaughter two things to really live for...a day when she could forget it...and a day she could get it straighten out! Heh, heh, heh. No, to be scripturally correct, she should have used a "rod" on the granddaughter and perhaps the granddaughter's mother.
  • words t... ARkey 2010/06/10 02:54:17 (edited)
    words to live by
    I was trying to lighten the situation with my caption, NOT! Hey, this world is in a horrible state of affairs. I don't believe in abuse, but If I was disrespected by a foul mouth kid I was raising, I'd probaly have slapped her twice!
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 88 Next » Last »

About Me

SodaHead Living

SodaHead Living

CA, US

2010/04/12 23:56:57

View complete profile

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals

The Latest From SodaHead

Living

Food