Quantcast

Koreans Study Talmud: Is Studying Judaism Good Education?

Fef 2012/07/26 14:49:56
Yes
No
You!
Add Photos & Videos
South Koreans have started studying Jewish laws to mimic the success of the Jewish people. The high standard for education in Korea has led their academic leaders to a new conclusion: "We believe that if we teach our children Talmud, they will also become geniuses."

Jameel reports in the Muqata blog:
Close to 50 million people live in South Korea, and almost everyone is taught the Talmud at home by their parents. "We tried to understand why the Jews are geniuses, and we came to the conclusion that we think it is because they study Talmud," said the Korean ambassador to Israel, Mr. Young Sam Ma. And this is how "Rav Papa" became a more well known scholar in Korea than in Israel.

Wikipedia defines the Talmud: The Talmud (Hebrew: תַּלְמוּד talmūd "instruction, learning", from a root lmd "teach, study") is a central text of mainstream Judaism. It takes the form of a record of rabbinic discussions pertaining to Jewish law, ethics, philosophy, customs and history.
"We tried to understand why the Jews are geniuses, and we came to the conclusion that we think it is because they study Talmud," said the Korean ambassador to Israel, Mr. Young Sam Ma.

Studying the Talmud differs from other texts. The Talmud teaches the core of Judaism -- a religious doctrine based on the word of G-d according to Jews. Koreans appreciate the values within the Talmud as fundamental to a strong family and society. "In the Jewish tradition, family values ​​are important," explains the South Korean Ambassador.

The Talmud compels parents to teach their children. The Talmud existed over 1,500 years before public education and teachers unions, and Koreans consider it the basis for creating "geniuses."

Should more parents, cultures and schools teach Judaism as an academic curriculum? Can you teach Talmud in public schools without violating the First Amendment? Can non-Jews benefit from studying the Talmud?

Read More: http://muqata.blogspot.com/2011/03/talmud-study-no...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Squatch 2012/07/26 20:30:32
    Yes
    Squatch
    +5
    Hard to argue with results. I work with a Korean nurse who grew up in South Korea. She is one of the smartest people you would ever want to meet and a very hard worker.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • alw_ays 2012/08/11 05:32:36
    Yes
    alw_ays
    Actually, that sounds like something I should consider incorporating into my homeschooling.
  • Katherine 2012/07/30 23:04:25
    Yes
    Katherine
    Absolutely. As to the question in the body of this poll, I think all religions should be taught and I don't think it violates the First Amendment in the slightest bit. They contain a history, they contain a philosophy on life, they contain laws and morals.. The more information you have the more choices you have available to you. And it's learning, understanding. I would think this would be a REQUIREMENT, actually. Fits in well with the rest of the courses.
  • sobersouljah 2012/07/28 01:27:17 (edited)
    Yes
    sobersouljah
    NO!!! if it is the Babylonian Talmud -

    The truth about the Talmud ---> http://www.revisionisthistory...


    ~~~Revelation 2:9 ~~~ 'I know your tribulation and your poverty (but you are rich), and the blasphemy by those who say they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan.
  • ✞Knight of Honor 2012/07/27 11:29:32
    Yes
    ✞Knight of Honor
    +1
    Morality is what modern societies need most.
  • POWERSHAKER 2012/07/27 07:33:17
    Yes
    POWERSHAKER
    +1
    Studying other religions can help you understand why people do what they do. It can help you to know their world views on things, too. It's not a bad idea to study other cultures, religions and nationalities.
  • Malachi 2012/07/27 00:04:09
    Yes
    Malachi
    +1
    Yes, but these people ( Koreans ) as well as others miss the whole point of learning Torah, They're studying it for all the wrong reasons....
  • Fef Malachi 2012/07/27 05:33:13
    Fef
    +2
    or maybe they just want their kids to think it has to do with education, but really they want to bring back the traditions and values of family and morality to S.Korea
    kids education traditions values family morality korea
  • Malachi Fef 2012/07/29 19:26:05
    Malachi
    Sounds like they're using psychology,( the end justifies the means/ and a form of deception) morality,traditions,and values, just won't work without God,,God gave Torah to the Jewish people for a purpose, can they keep the 613 laws? if the Jewish people can't keep them, and they have God. what makes Koreans or anyone else think that just living the Torah without him, will succeed? people can't just pick and choose what they want from God's blessings.....
  • Helmholtz 2012/07/26 23:52:41
    Yes
    Helmholtz
    +1
    This reads like an Onion article.
  • clasact 2012/07/26 22:41:43
    Yes
    clasact
    +3
    whatever works I say,and maybe if we all knew a bit more of others we would be more tolerant of others
  • nightcrawler2005 2012/07/26 22:19:13
    No
    nightcrawler2005
    +1
    I'm sure they can put together a proper study in ethics without having to resort to someones religious text.
  • Philo-ThisSpaceForRent 2012/07/26 21:22:16
    Yes
    Philo-ThisSpaceForRent
    +1
    It's probably not going to hurt them any, as long as they don't regard it as the Word of God, just a challenging documentary on Jewish interpretation of the Scripture.
  • Squatch 2012/07/26 20:30:32
    Yes
    Squatch
    +5
    Hard to argue with results. I work with a Korean nurse who grew up in South Korea. She is one of the smartest people you would ever want to meet and a very hard worker.
  • Heisenberg 2012/07/26 20:26:56
    Yes
    Heisenberg
    +4
    Now if they could only get the Jews to read the Talmud we might be making progress.

    *Jews everywhere ask 'what's a 'Talmud?'*
  • ✞Knight... Heisenberg 2012/07/27 11:32:59
    ✞Knight of Honor
    I've often found it interesting that Judiasm is a such a force for morality, but so many "Jews" (not real practicing ones) are so immoral. They really need to start doing this in Isreal.
  • Heisenberg ✞Knight... 2012/07/27 22:53:33
    Heisenberg
    +1
    Jews have the highest rates of secularism.

    Since Judaism is both a religion and an ethnic group you can have large numbers of Jews that do not believe in Judaism.
  • ✞Knight... Heisenberg 2012/07/28 10:17:03
    ✞Knight of Honor
    +1
    "Since Judaism is both a religion and an ethnic group you can have large numbers of Jews that do not believe in Judaism."
    -While they consider themselves "Jews" they are just Israeli Atheists.
  • Heisenberg ✞Knight... 2012/07/30 21:01:53
    Heisenberg
    Interesting question is...can a Jew be a Jew and be an atheist?

    I will let the Jewish scholars argue this one.
  • ✞Knight... Heisenberg 2012/07/30 21:12:12
    ✞Knight of Honor
    +1
    I will argue no. A Jew believes in Judaism. A non-Jew of Israel, is just an Israeli to me.
  • P. Sturm 2012/07/26 20:15:20
    Yes
    P. Sturm
    +5
    I had to read all 25 volumes during second grade at a Christian academy and write a report. The more you learn the better you are at life.
  • George Romney 2012/07/26 18:15:47
    No
    George Romney
    +2
    They're missing the point. An honest work ethic and a strive for family and faith isn't something you get by forcing your kid to read the Talmud as if it were a Math text-book. Asians and Koreans have hard-wired themselves to treat everything in Life as a test that you can create a study-guide for. The idea of figuring things out for yourself and independently learning religions is the cornerstone of a rich and fulfilling life of discovery.
  • MOMMA THOMAS 2012/07/26 18:01:11
    Yes
    MOMMA THOMAS
    +2
    ALWAYS GOOD TO STUDY ABOUT FAITH OR ANYTHING ELSE, YOU THEN WILL ACQUIRE THE ADVANTAGE OF HAVING KNOWLEDGE .....NO MATTER WHETHER YOU OR OTHERS MAY CONSIDER THE SUBJECT GOOD, BAD, RIGHT OR WRONG.
  • Mark 2012/07/26 17:02:51
    Yes
    Mark
    +3
    Like it or not, judaism is an important part of many peoples history. Understanding how they tick is a good thing. Ignorance breeds fear which leads to hatred and harm.
  • thefatguy 2012/07/26 16:33:35
    Yes
    thefatguy
    +4
    Without a doubt studying the Talmud will provide a good education, but I think it is the Jewish culture which stresses the importance of family, tradition, education and hard work that is more important to emulate. I know the above values come from the Talmud but knowledge of a text without changing your culture won't get you any closer to your goal.
  • Lester 2012/07/26 16:31:55
    Yes
    Lester
    +2
    What the Koreans in the story are doing is little more than a belief in magic. But I am a great believer in knowledge, so in general I very much support the study of all cultures and religions in what they can teach about the human condition: and that includes the rich written tradition of rabbinic Judaism.
  • kcandi 2012/07/26 15:46:43
    Yes
    kcandi
    +2
    Studying anything you feel may be important is good.
  • Fef kcandi 2012/07/27 05:35:25
    Fef
    +2
    well, maybe we shouldn't have our kids read everything.... rules for radicals
    they may read it and end up as president. whooops!
  • RogerRover Fef 2012/07/27 14:40:06
    RogerRover
    +1
    One great disciple! (one termer)
  • kcandi Fef 2012/07/27 16:21:06
    kcandi
    Wouldn't wish a presidency on one of my kids.
  • Katherine kcandi 2012/07/30 23:14:24
    Katherine
    +1
    Wouldn't wish him to be an evil one anyway.
  • ETpro 2012/07/26 15:46:36
    Yes
    ETpro
    +4
    It's a great introduction into the history of religion of a large portion of the world, with Jewish, Christian and Muslim religions all worshiping the Abrahamic God.
  • mac9 2012/07/26 15:46:27
    Yes
    mac9
    +3
    Believing in success and having unity by way of family values is great!
  • Racefish 2012/07/26 15:23:09
    No
    Racefish
    +3
    It's not the Talmud, it's the values embodied in the family that contributes to overall success.
  • mikeeonly 2012/07/26 15:17:48
    Yes
    mikeeonly
    +3
    I find it quite interesting. The important thing is that they believe in a higher power
  • john brenni 2012/07/26 15:08:49
    Yes
    john brenni
    +4
    i am Christian but have read parts of the talmud. i think it should be part of christian reading. it is very deep and spiritual. Jewish kids who study the talmud, ortodox mostly, are not on the streets using dope, getting pregnant, locked up or shooting at each other. the talmud should be viewed to use a christian saying...as a shining city on a hill.
  • Anglohebraicus 2012/07/26 15:00:23
    Yes
    Anglohebraicus
    +4
    They're not far wrong: Judaism is one of the best educations available in the world today. I suggest the secret is ACTIVE ENGAGEMENT--with God and all else!
  • DS in Oak Ridge NC 2012/07/26 14:59:40
    Yes
    DS in Oak Ridge NC
    +3
    It couldn't hurt... as my Bubbie would have said...
  • Fef DS in O... 2012/07/27 05:36:05
    Fef
    did she say that right before the bris?
  • DS in O... Fef 2012/07/27 12:37:41
    DS in Oak Ridge NC
    No... she looked at her watch, and said "It won't be long now."
  • CUDDLY BUT STILL CRABBY 2012/07/26 14:55:52
    Yes
    CUDDLY BUT STILL CRABBY
    +3
    Google Jews vs Muslims winning Nobel prizes.

    An overwhelming rout and great reasons for that.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/21 14:38:15

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals