Quantcast

Is It Worse for Teens to Smoke Pot or Cigarettes?

SodaHead Living 2012/06/11 18:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Here's the good news: Fewer teens are smoking cigarettes. Here's the bad news: More of them are smoking pot. A new study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that only 18 percent of teens said they smoked a cigarette in the past 30 days, but 23 percent said they smoked marijuana in the same time frame.

teens pot

So why are adolescents choosing pot over cigarettes? A study from the University of Michigan found that teens have gotten the message that cigarettes are bad for you, but seem to believe marijuana is less harmful.

Alcohol, however, is still teens' top drug of choice. More than 1 in 3 high school students reported current alcohol use in 2011, and 1 in 5 high school students reported binge drinking, CBS reports. Do you think it's more dangerous for teens to smoke pot? Or cigarettes?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Stoner 2012/06/11 18:08:41
    Cigarettes
    Stoner
    +40
    All causes of death per year 2,436,652

    Cardiovascular diseases 779,367
    Malignant neoplasms 568,668
    Lack of Health Insurance3 44,789
    Drug induced2 37,485
    Suicide 36,547
    Motor vehicle accidents 36,284
    Septicemia (infections) 35,587
    by Firearms 31,224
    Accidental poisoning 30,504
    Alcohol induced 23,199
    Homicide 16,591
    Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) 9,424
    Viral hepatitis 7,652
    Cannabis (Marijuana) 0
    Major marijuana myth: pot use use can be a cause of death. So say many anti-drug warriors, such as Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, who recently wrote to a constituent that "marijuana and other narcotics" can lead to death.

    PotleafAccording to Time magazine, "No one has ever died of THC [marijuana] poisoning, mostly because a 160-pound person would have to smoke roughly 900 joints in a sitting to reach a lethal dose."

    In 1988, DEA Administrative Judge Francis Young concluded, "In order to induce death, a smoker would have to consume 20,000 to 40,000 times as much marijuana as is contained in one marijuana cigarette."

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Opinion8ed 2012/06/14 19:41:15
    Cigarettes
    Opinion8ed
    +1
    Some say pot is 9 times worse than cigarettes. But how many people smoke two packs of cigs a day versus five joints a day. I've smoked weed before and one or two joints at most is the max. Likewise, people on weed don't tend to commit other crimes on weed. I think the good from pot outweighs the bad. Plenty of "bad" things are legal. I'd bet the benefit/cost ratio on weed is better than alcohol or cigarettes.
  • Watermusicranger 2012/06/14 18:13:30
    Cigarettes
    Watermusicranger
    +1
    Cigarettes are the gateway drug.
  • Buffalobill91 2012/06/14 16:45:01
    Cigarettes
    Buffalobill91
    +3
    the medical community has spoken tons of times on this issue and how bad cigarettes are for anyone... and how not so bad pot is for anyone... regardless of age
  • DavidK 2012/06/14 16:11:29 (edited)
  • Windy DavidK 2012/06/15 04:12:49
    Windy
    +2
    People understand that pot doesn't cause cancer because they've seen and read the reports from science showing that it not only does NOT cause cancer, certain forms of cannabis can actually cure some (pehaps all, they are not yet done testing and there are numerous forms of cancer it has not yet been tested against). They've seen the patent the uS gov holds on pot and its neuroprotectant ability. And they've read the report that the fed gov has known about its effect on cancer since 1974 which was discovered by the gov's own paid for university research. Just because you have not seen those reports does not mean you should be going around and posting completely incorrect propaganda anywhere.
  • DavidK Windy 2012/06/15 05:20:43
    DavidK
    yea, what do the experts know........
  • Windy DavidK 2012/06/15 21:17:09
    Windy
    BTW, not all weed smokers smoke tobacco, many do not, many also have smoked tobacco in the past but have quit the cigarettes and still smoke cannabis. Do the research yourself instead of compounding the lies and errors of the prohibitionist progandists by repeating their propaganda.
  • DavidK Windy 2012/06/16 04:57:38
    DavidK
    why smoke at all?!?!?!?
  • Gothpirate 2012/06/14 15:37:18
    Pot
    Gothpirate
    +2
    I meant to click on cigarettes
  • willet.makeit 2012/06/14 13:44:00
    Cigarettes
    willet.makeit
    +1
    To me..marijuana is a sacrament... I have been smoking it just about everyday since 1966. Cigarettes however are by taste alone a dead end street leading to your demise. Go ahead and leave half of your life in the ash tray... Painful way to die that doesn't have to be this way... Quit ( if you can ) today...
  • The I 2012/06/14 12:05:25
    Cigarettes
    The I
    This is easy. Cigarettes are made with a lot of chemicals. But the rule of the day is still all things in moderation. Even too much water can kill.
  • Windy The I 2012/06/15 04:14:57
    Windy
    It is impossible to ingest enough marijuana to die from its effects, regardless if one is eating it or smoking it.
  • DavidK Windy 2012/06/15 05:21:44
    DavidK
    ingesting too much air or water call kill you but too much weed can't huh...........
  • Windy DavidK 2012/06/15 21:19:36
    Windy
    Because there is no way one could ingest enough cannabis in a short enough time to cause death, research it. Lordy but people are lazy, they do not want to do the hard work of actually looking something up, google makes it easy, but apparently there are a lot of people who won't even put out that much effort.
  • DavidK Windy 2012/06/16 04:59:12
    DavidK
    who would be that stupid to digest it in the first place?!?!?!?!?
  • The I Windy 2012/06/21 06:41:18
    The I
    One mass can only hold so much mass of another. Rethink that idea after you come off the effects of marijuana.
  • The Libertarian 2012/06/14 07:07:21
    Cigarettes
    The Libertarian
    +1
    Actually, I think alcohol is the worst problem, but I still think the Europeans have it right. No age limits!
  • Lordy :D 2012/06/14 06:10:07
    Pot
    Lordy :D
    At least with cigarettes, you know where you are. My 80 year old grandmother has been smoking cigarettes for 60 years and she's the picture of health. My 20 year old cousin was hit by a car and severely injured whilst under the influence of marijuana.
  • The I Lordy :D 2012/06/14 12:07:09
    The I
    Beer can have the same effect. But the real problem is not the substance but human judgement.
  • Lordy :D The I 2012/06/15 03:58:30
    Lordy :D
    Touche.

    Though I think such easy accessibility to pot, cigarettes, and alcohol is, too, a real problem.
  • fitz Lordy :D 2012/06/14 15:52:56
    fitz
    Was your cousin at fault for being high or was she tested and found under the influence? Out of my Mom's five sisters, the three that smoked cigarettes required oxygen up to their death; the two remaining sisters and my Mom never smoked. Two of the three dead sisters were younger than the living sisters. Smoking killed their lungs; plain and simple.
  • Lordy :D fitz 2012/06/15 03:52:09
    Lordy :D
    She couldn't call the police both because she was afraid that she'd get in trouble and because her phone didn't survive the collision. It wasn't until another driver stopped and called her father and he took her home.

    I'm not saying that cigarettes are good. I'm using my grandmother as an example because she's still out and about. It's not that both aren't bad--it's just that cigarettes don't impair judgment the same way pot does. Both are addictive, but it's like pot makes one so mellow that they just can't react to the same reality as the rest of the world. I think that that, in the short term, is much more dangerous than lung failure that occurs after years of use....
  • fitz Lordy :D 2012/06/15 13:57:20
    fitz
    Driving while under the influence of prescription drugs, illegal drugs, or alcohol is absolutely wrong. However, driving under the influence of pot causes the user to be paranoid which makes the driver more cautious since you are more aware of the effects and impairment. You also are less inclined to drive because of the paranoia. Alcohol, on the other hand, causes many drivers to be careless and much less aware of their impairment which results in higher speed crashes and recklessness.
    Moderation is the key. People who have one or two drinks a day live longer than tea totallers. Check it on the internet if you dont believe. Obviously, over drinking has serious ill effects. Pot has numerous medical benefits and, again, under the right conditions and in moderation, has virtually no known ill effects. And don't underestimate the terror of not being able to breathe as far as cigarettes are concerned. A good friend of mine (was a heavy smoker) is only 58 with good family genes and he has to stop twice walking into work (about 150 yds). His skin is beginning to discolor.
  • debhead fitz 2012/06/16 08:27:07
    debhead
    Pot has NEVER made me paranoid. Paranoia is a state of mind. If you think your doing something wrong or over think what your high is going to be like the more likely you'll get paranoid. I rather see people "high" and "addicted" to living a happy and productive life. No pot, no cigarettes, but then that wasn't the question.
  • fitz debhead 2012/06/16 21:08:45
    fitz
    Have you driven high? When I'm approaching a red light and it seems to take 5 minutes, I become a little nervous and I'm very aware of the fact that I'm not 100%. Haven't you ever seen the Cheech & Chong movies? They are arrested for going too slow. That's what I'm talking about. If I'm sitting at home, that's a different story. When you're drunk, you lose awareness and are more daring for all the wrong reasons.
  • Lordy :D fitz 2012/06/16 20:01:41 (edited)
    Lordy :D
    But these are average teenagers we're talking about. Do they really need pot? Are there any medical benefits that they can possibly receive? Yes, cigarettes are bad. Yes, they are addictive, and yes there is the very real risk that people will smoke themselves to death. But pot isn't absolutely necessary for teenagers--anymore so than alcohol or cigarettes. It pisses me off when people say that "just because pot doesn't give me any serious side effects I can smoke it."

    People who smoke cigarettes already know that it's bad for them. They know about the kind of side effects, they know that there are very real risks that come with smoking cigarettes--I don't think you can escape the anti-smoking campaign in any channel anymore. But all I'm seeing about pot is how the side effects are minimal--you just a little high, then fall asleep. Not as bad as cigarettes, right?

    Yeah, well, anyone who has a family member who has smoked marijuana knows that it isn't just the pothead who gets hurt--it's the people who're stuck with them because they love them. It's the people who're stuck supporting them, because they're high off their ass, the people who're stuck taking care of them because they've become mentally unstable or injured like my cousin was or have become useless because they've sm...

    But these are average teenagers we're talking about. Do they really need pot? Are there any medical benefits that they can possibly receive? Yes, cigarettes are bad. Yes, they are addictive, and yes there is the very real risk that people will smoke themselves to death. But pot isn't absolutely necessary for teenagers--anymore so than alcohol or cigarettes. It pisses me off when people say that "just because pot doesn't give me any serious side effects I can smoke it."

    People who smoke cigarettes already know that it's bad for them. They know about the kind of side effects, they know that there are very real risks that come with smoking cigarettes--I don't think you can escape the anti-smoking campaign in any channel anymore. But all I'm seeing about pot is how the side effects are minimal--you just a little high, then fall asleep. Not as bad as cigarettes, right?

    Yeah, well, anyone who has a family member who has smoked marijuana knows that it isn't just the pothead who gets hurt--it's the people who're stuck with them because they love them. It's the people who're stuck supporting them, because they're high off their ass, the people who're stuck taking care of them because they've become mentally unstable or injured like my cousin was or have become useless because they've smoked pot since they were kids and have therefor never grown the incentive the grow up and get a job.

    You know, I'm rereading a lot of these articles and the majority of the people who say that pot is alright are the ones smoking it. I know how they say that pot isn't very addictive, but I just got to thinking how these people are willing to fight so hard for its legalization--isn't that a form of addiction? Here in Cali, it's perfectly legal to smoke pot if you have an actual medical excuse--what more does anyone want?
    (more)
  • Mark El... Lordy :D 2012/06/16 15:40:16
    Mark Elliott
    Wow. You're ignorant. Read more.
  • Lordy :D Mark El... 2012/06/16 19:21:28
  • anne.k.... Lordy :D 2012/06/14 21:12:33
    anne.k.murphy
    +1
    Really? What kind of screwed up logic is that? It was neither your cousin's fault nor the marijuana's fault that someone hit him or her. That person would have hit your cousin regardless of whether or not your cousin was high, and the marijuana probably made them mellow enough to save their life. I drank three beers and was driving home, and a woman didn't see me and made a left-turn into my car. Does this make it my fault or the beer's fault that she hit me? Of course not! So don't blame the pot for something the pot has no control over...
  • Lordy :D anne.k.... 2012/06/15 03:32:37
  • DavidK Lordy :D 2012/06/15 05:22:57
    DavidK
    +1
    Sadly, the potheads are too dumb to see the risk factors. Its Gods way of filtering out the stupid!
  • Lordy :D DavidK 2012/06/16 20:39:45
  • DavidK Lordy :D 2012/06/17 05:06:55
    DavidK
    You have nothing to prove to anyone but yourself! Using pot, alcohol cigarettes or anything else to decrease stress and to cope, is fooling no one but themselves. What happens when the pot effect wears off?!?!? Right back where you started. Your "masking" the problem, NOT solving it. Why bother? here's why...........
    Drivers who consume cannabis within three hours of driving are nearly twice as likely to cause a vehicle collision as those who are not under the influence of drugs or alcohol. increased variability in lane position such as taking a curve too tightly or too loosely and longer decision times, leading to slower responses to driving situations.
    Loss of coordination – People who use weed have diminished motor skills and have a hard time being able to do even the simplest tasks. At no point while under the effects of weed should you operate heavy or dangerous equipment or attempt to drive. Many people feel that their ability to drive is unchanged while under the effects of weed, but this is completely false. Your perception of your abilities may not change, but that has no bearing on reality.

    Short-term Memory and Learning – While experiencing the effects of weed, users will have a much more difficult time recalling short-term memories. This also greatly affects the a...







    You have nothing to prove to anyone but yourself! Using pot, alcohol cigarettes or anything else to decrease stress and to cope, is fooling no one but themselves. What happens when the pot effect wears off?!?!? Right back where you started. Your "masking" the problem, NOT solving it. Why bother? here's why...........
    Drivers who consume cannabis within three hours of driving are nearly twice as likely to cause a vehicle collision as those who are not under the influence of drugs or alcohol. increased variability in lane position such as taking a curve too tightly or too loosely and longer decision times, leading to slower responses to driving situations.
    Loss of coordination – People who use weed have diminished motor skills and have a hard time being able to do even the simplest tasks. At no point while under the effects of weed should you operate heavy or dangerous equipment or attempt to drive. Many people feel that their ability to drive is unchanged while under the effects of weed, but this is completely false. Your perception of your abilities may not change, but that has no bearing on reality.

    Short-term Memory and Learning – While experiencing the effects of weed, users will have a much more difficult time recalling short-term memories. This also greatly affects the ability to learn as much of the learning process is dependent on your brain’s ability to form memories. If you are in a situation where you need your mind’s full capacities such as when going to school, it would be wise to shy away from the effects of weed as you will not get much out of it. This will most likely not pose any mortal danger to anyone, but it can still be very irresponsible if not used at appropriate times.

    Problem Solving – This is another one of the negative effects of weed that greatly affects your mind’s ability to function correctly. While under its influence, users will find they have a difficult time reasoning and solving otherwise simple problems. This is another one of the effects of weed that most likely wouldn’t cause yourself or anyone major harm but could be very detrimental in your ability to perform well in places like work or school.

    Increased Heart Rate – Shortly after using weed, the user will experience a jump in heart rate much like a physically demanding activity would. While this is not strikingly dangerous to a healthy heart , it is cause for concern for people who suffer from heart diseases where keeping their heart rate down is a necessity.

    Anxiety and Paranoia – These effects of weed are going to vary greatly from user to user. Some regular users who suffer from anxiety say using weed helps alleviate their anxiety while others say it greatly increases the severity of the anxiety and can often induce panic attacks. Paranoia is also very common, but is often relatively minor if existent at all. You may have thoughts like the cops could show up at your door at any moment, but you probably won’t find yourself building a bomb shelter for your imagined collapse of mankind.

    I can go on and on but potheads usually want to avoid the facts until its too late. If you want a "normal" future, QUIT NOW!!!!!
    (more)
  • cudlow Lordy :D 2012/06/16 11:50:56
    cudlow
    Thank you Lordy. Pot and all illegal drugs make people behave irrationally. There are laws against drunk driving for just that reason. Cigarettes will kill you and you are stupid if you don't quit that habit. But illegal drugs kill others - your example of motor vehicle deaths being the most common way. If we were serious about making this a better country, we would not jail those who sell that poison to kids (and others) - we would hang them from the nearest tree immediately after conviction!
  • Lordy :D cudlow 2012/06/16 20:41:00
    Lordy :D
    +1
    Hanging people who sell drugs is a tad bit extreme, don't you think?
  • cudlow Lordy :D 2012/06/23 12:16:53
    cudlow
    Shooting works just as well!
  • Dino420 2012/06/14 05:57:32
    Cigarettes
    Dino420
    +2
    Cigarettes Kill.. Plain and Simple. Marijuana is a HARMLESS plant, The reason it is Illegal is because the Multi-Million dollar pharmacutical corporations will take a Serious Hit if/when Marijuana is Legalised. Who's going to want to pay for Highly Addictive Perscriptions when a Herb does the Same thing if not Better, Costs Less, Non-Addictive and helps People... If they could turn around and Prohibit Aloe-Vera they would... Better business for Polysporin.....
  • cannosays 2012/06/14 05:15:04
    Cigarettes
    cannosays
    Quite simple really pot has been used as a medicine and many other uses for thousands of years and is totally natural. Cigarettes are the complete opposite they were just another tool invented to promote disease and sickness to help keep population numbers down.
  • The Lib... cannosays 2012/06/14 07:11:25
    The Libertarian
    +1
    False! Tobacco was used in many ceremonies by native American cultures, and picked up by Europeans who settled in North America.
  • Mel Mar... The Lib... 2012/06/14 11:32:03
    Mel Martens
    +3
    Tobacco yes...not cigarettes that contain the following additives.

    Ammonia: Household cleaner.
    Arsenic: Used in rat poisons.
    Benzene: Used in making dyes, synthetic rubber.
    Butane: Gas; used in lighter fluid.
    Carbon monoxide: Poisonous gas.
    Cadmium: Used in batteries.
    Cyanide: Lethal poison.
    DDT: A banned insecticide.
    Ethyl Furoate: Causes liver damage in animals.
    Lead: Poisonous in high doses.
    Formaldehyde: Used to preserve dead specimens.
    Methoprene: Insecticide.
    Maltitol: Sweetener for diabetics.
    Napthalene: Ingredient in mothballs.
    Methyl isocyanate: Its accidental release killed 2000 people in Bhopal, India, in 1984.
    Polonium: Cancer-causing radioactive element.

    There's over 500 more, but you can google that lot. Tobacco and weed are plants, cigarettes are not.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/06/20 09:52:26

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals