Quantcast

Is It Worse for Teens to Smoke Pot or Cigarettes?

SodaHead Living 2012/06/11 18:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Here's the good news: Fewer teens are smoking cigarettes. Here's the bad news: More of them are smoking pot. A new study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that only 18 percent of teens said they smoked a cigarette in the past 30 days, but 23 percent said they smoked marijuana in the same time frame.

teens pot

So why are adolescents choosing pot over cigarettes? A study from the University of Michigan found that teens have gotten the message that cigarettes are bad for you, but seem to believe marijuana is less harmful.

Alcohol, however, is still teens' top drug of choice. More than 1 in 3 high school students reported current alcohol use in 2011, and 1 in 5 high school students reported binge drinking, CBS reports. Do you think it's more dangerous for teens to smoke pot? Or cigarettes?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Stoner 2012/06/11 18:08:41
    Cigarettes
    Stoner
    +40
    All causes of death per year 2,436,652

    Cardiovascular diseases 779,367
    Malignant neoplasms 568,668
    Lack of Health Insurance3 44,789
    Drug induced2 37,485
    Suicide 36,547
    Motor vehicle accidents 36,284
    Septicemia (infections) 35,587
    by Firearms 31,224
    Accidental poisoning 30,504
    Alcohol induced 23,199
    Homicide 16,591
    Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) 9,424
    Viral hepatitis 7,652
    Cannabis (Marijuana) 0
    Major marijuana myth: pot use use can be a cause of death. So say many anti-drug warriors, such as Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, who recently wrote to a constituent that "marijuana and other narcotics" can lead to death.

    PotleafAccording to Time magazine, "No one has ever died of THC [marijuana] poisoning, mostly because a 160-pound person would have to smoke roughly 900 joints in a sitting to reach a lethal dose."

    In 1988, DEA Administrative Judge Francis Young concluded, "In order to induce death, a smoker would have to consume 20,000 to 40,000 times as much marijuana as is contained in one marijuana cigarette."

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Jim Ana Hen... 2012/06/18 22:11:48
    Jim
    A pot head. Pot is addictive and is a carcinogen.
  • babygirl Jim 2012/10/04 19:39:47
    babygirl
    +3
    Jim, you're so wrong. Pot isn't addictive.
  • ajracestables1 2012/06/17 17:26:48
    Cigarettes
    ajracestables1
    +1
    Neither is good, pot is illegal but easier to quit, cigs are illegal if the teen is under 18, so both with give the teen issues with the law.
  • marcus armijo 2012/06/16 20:13:37
    Cigarettes
    marcus armijo
    +2
    You don't hear bout people getting cancer from weed but you do hear about weed being a medical treatment.
  • Jim marcus ... 2012/06/18 22:12:19
    Jim
    not proven as a medical treatment.
  • Haley Jim 2012/06/23 16:55:33
    Haley
    +1
    Actually it is, often for people with dietary problems or bipolar disorder. It's a prescription drug. Check your facts, please.
  • babygirl Jim 2012/10/04 19:40:57
    babygirl
    +2
    There it goes again. You're wrong again. It's a medical treatment.
  • Dracocrux 2012/06/16 06:36:55
    Cigarettes
    Dracocrux
    +2
    Pot is bad for your lungs, As are cigarettes. However- people do not smoke a pack of marijuana cigarettes a day. Pot does not have rat poison in it (unless you buy it from some shady guy). Cigarretes can only be smoked. Pot can be smoked, eaten, or ingested via vaporizors. Cigarettes are physically addictive. Pot is as mentally addictive as alcohol, and not physically addictive at all. You can get mentally addicted to literally anything. Computers, television, eating. Many people would say "it's a gateway drug", because that is the study taught in schools and by propaganda. However, an equal amount of studies say it is not a gateway drug, thus they are rendered inconclusive. It may be illegal, but it was only made illegal because it was associated with Mexicans.
  • debhead 2012/06/16 03:08:18
    Cigarettes
    debhead
    +1
    I really don't think either are good for kids. However, I'll say Pot because it doesn't have the harmful additives cigarettes do. It isn't as addicting either.
  • Jim debhead 2012/06/18 22:14:34
    Jim
    Do you know what the pot was grown in, what fertilizer and what insect repellant was used. By the way, neither is good for adults.
  • Haley Jim 2012/06/23 16:57:29
    Haley
    +1
    Good points to consider, but I believe what she's saying is that cigarettes are worse.
  • sRsotcAc 2012/06/15 18:13:36
    Cigarettes
    sRsotcAc
    +1
    Cigarettes are way worse, are you kidding me? They cause lung caner, yellowing of the teeth, and some people have to get a whole cut in their throat and put a device there just so they can try to sound normal when they talk.
  • WatchTheRhythm 2012/06/15 17:42:34 (edited)
    Cigarettes
    WatchTheRhythm
    +1
    Nicotine is one of the most addictive drugs out there... period. And we know what it can do to people. http://upload.wikimedia.org/w... drugs  nicotine  tobacco  cannabis
  • debhead WatchTh... 2012/06/16 03:16:30 (edited)
    debhead
    +2
    Are you serious? Pot is not addicting! I'm 61 and have smoked weed here and there for 40 years. NEVER on a regular basis, never wanted to, never had to. Cigarettes? Started when I was 12 and still haven't totally quit. I hate it! Also, you CAN'T OD on weed. Impossible. You could wreck your car smoking cigarettes too. Lighting it, smoke in your eyes, dropping it in your lap etc. Anything can be addictive if you let it, but Pot is not chemically addictive.
  • Jim debhead 2012/06/18 22:16:02
    Jim
    Weed is a gateway drug. Try reading your own remarks and you just might see what pot has done to you.
  • Haley Jim 2012/06/23 17:00:13
    Haley
    +1
    He started cigarettes first, remember? Based on your assumption that you can conclude the first drug he used was a gateway to every other drug he used and that this one person makes for a full study, cigarettes are the gateway drug here.
  • WatchTh... debhead 2012/06/29 19:40:31
    WatchTheRhythm
    +1
    I agree, but that's why the chart used the word "dependence". Pot is habit-forming, but not anything in comparison to how horribly addicting cigarettes are.
  • Musicluver 2012/06/15 17:24:10
    Cigarettes
    Musicluver
    I think I'm actually kind of in between. Everyone knows that cigarettes are worse for you. But, pot is more ADDICTING, therefore, it usually ends up worse. And yes, it's proven fact that pot is more addicting. So a person who does pot, gets addicted to pot, does it so much, and then they overdose and kill themselves. It's much more common to OD on pot than on the nicotine from cigs. AT THE SAME TIME THOUGH, cigarettes are more likely to cause disease on down the line, and hurt you more in the end. If, that is, you don't die from a car crash while under the influence of pot.
  • Mel Mar... Musicluver 2012/06/17 13:28:10
    Mel Martens
    +2
    One can;t OD on pot. They have to smoke like a trainwreck for days to possibly maybe OD and then it's more of a case they starved themselves of oxygen for too long. It's not physically addictive either, as in one does not get shakes and withdrawal symptoms when they stop smoking it. The addiction is psychological in terms the person enjoys not feeling like crap every single day from pain or bi-polar issues or whatever...pot helps them handle it and live a relatively normal life.
  • Jim Mel Mar... 2012/06/18 22:17:14
    Jim
    One can't OD on cigarettes, so what's your point?
  • Mel Mar... Jim 2012/06/19 20:47:31
    Mel Martens
    +1
    I just stated my point yet it was clearly ignored. Give me a percentage of people who have died through use of cannabis, then give me a percentage who died from smoking tar-filled chemical sticks.
  • SunnyDragon 2012/06/15 15:31:20 (edited)
    Cigarettes
    SunnyDragon
    +2
    The only reason pot is illegal and cigarettes aren't is the government can tax cigarettes. It isn't just the tobacco leaves, its mixed with tar, nicotine, and numerous other dangerous chemicals that get you addicted and kill you just for taste. THC can be grown anywhere while tobacco is a more tempermental plant and is more commonly grown in farms because of it. Its all about money.
  • abby 2012/06/15 14:50:01
    Cigarettes
    abby
    +1
    i've never heard of pot being the main cause of someone's death but i hear of cigarettes killing people all the time.
  • Rebecca 2012/06/15 04:14:51
    Cigarettes
    Rebecca
    cigarettes kill more with lung cancer and stuff like that but both are F*cking disgusting habits
  • Windy 2012/06/15 03:59:30
    Cigarettes
    Windy
    +1
    It is far worse for teens to smoke cigarettes than to smoke pot.

    Cigarettes are addictive to most people who use them, they are also harmful to the health of the smoker, and the more one smokes, the greater the danger of serious health issues and even dying from the use.

    Alcohol damages the brain and the liver and is capable of killing a new user from alcohol poisoning.

    Pot, otoh, is not addictive, does not damage one's health in any way, and even helps improve one's health by regular use, regardless how much or how often one uses the herb. It also helps open the mind to sights, sounds, sensations and other things that all too often go unnoticed to the general non-pot-using individuals. It also has been shown to help curb the use of alcohol and other, more seriously dangerous substances (both licit and illicit).

    I'd much rather have my grandchildren use pot than etiher cigarettes or alcohol, just on the basis of that simple difference in the health issues.
  • chadwr85 Windy 2012/06/15 15:45:56
    chadwr85
    Actually they have proven alcohol doesn't damage the liver unless you drink binge amount 3-4 times a week for a long period of time. Alcohol can only damage the brain in poisoning. And you clearly don't know your stuff because so what if POT is a herb, it still has chemicals in it to make it stronger. Pot CAN cause Cancer because it has mass amounts of Carcinogens, Pot cause lung issues because of the large amounts of tar, and it can be addictive. My Psychology professor is smarter than anyone one hear and you obviously are educated in internet and from friends.
  • Windy chadwr85 2012/06/15 21:11:34 (edited)
    Windy
    +1
    I'll have you know that I'm 68 years old and I've been researching herbs and so-called "illicit drugs" for over 40 years; so I DO know what I am saying. i have done the research because I have always wanted to know all about an herbal or intoxicating substance before I try (or someone I care about tries) it.

    You can't even spell "here" correctly, and you are totally wrong about cannabis causing ANY kind of cancer. I don't believe your psychology professor is "smarter than anyone [here]" tho he may be smarter than you. But just being smart does NOT make one knowledgeable, one has to research, read, and study to become knowledgeable, I have done that concerning cannabis and other herbs. Has your professor?
  • debhead Windy 2012/06/16 03:36:17
    debhead
    +1
    Right on Windy! I'm 61and know exactly what your saying. We, that have lived it, know. I caught the "hear" part too.
  • chadwr85 Windy 2012/06/27 18:30:15
    chadwr85
    right didn't realize this was an english class. We got a grammar nazi here. Instead of providing facts we just state opinions and bash grammar. Why don't you show some of this research? Pot has carcinogens in it so it can in fact cause cancer, it can become addictive but it is a low level of addiction on the addiction chain, and in fact does kill minute amount of brain cells because of the Carbon Monoxide present. Yes someone who has 10 years of college is smarter than everyone on here because nobody on here has that amount of education, especially on DRUGS like the professor! I do think pot should be legalized because of the money that can be made, I do think cigarettes are worse, but smoking anything is bad for you especially if it has CARCINOGENS PRESENT AS WEED DOES! Pot heads ignore that fact and say because it grew from the ground it isn't harmful.
  • Windy chadwr85 2012/07/02 04:51:48
    Windy
    "marijuana smoke also contains cannabinoids such as THC ... which are non-carcinogenic and demonstrate anti-cancer properties in vivo and in vitro"
    http://norml.org/component/zo...

    "While a clear increase in cancer risk was seen among cigarette smokers in the study, no such association was seen for regular cannabis users.
    Even very heavy, long-term marijuana users who had smoked more than 22,000 joints over a lifetime seemed to have no greater risk than infrequent marijuana users or nonusers."
    http://www.foxnews.com/story/...

    "One study performed in Germany showed that marijuana offsets certain cognitive declines in schizophrenic patients. Another study demonstrated that psychotic symptoms predict later use of marijuana, suggesting that people might turn to the plant for help rather than become ill after use."
    "There is no convincing evidence that heavy long-term marijuana use permanently impairs memory or other cognitive functions."
    http://www.drugpolicy.org/fac...

    "Large Study Finds No Link between Marijuana and Lung Cancer"
    http://www.scientificamerican...
    (please note the date of this story and tell me again your professor knows all)
    "marijuana smoke also contains cannabinoids such as THC ... which are non-carcinogenic and demonstrate anti-cancer properties in vivo and in vitro"
    http://norml.org/component/zo...

    "While a clear increase in cancer risk was seen among cigarette smokers in the study, no such association was seen for regular cannabis users.
    Even very heavy, long-term marijuana users who had smoked more than 22,000 joints over a lifetime seemed to have no greater risk than infrequent marijuana users or nonusers."
    http://www.foxnews.com/story/...

    "One study performed in Germany showed that marijuana offsets certain cognitive declines in schizophrenic patients. Another study demonstrated that psychotic symptoms predict later use of marijuana, suggesting that people might turn to the plant for help rather than become ill after use."
    "There is no convincing evidence that heavy long-term marijuana use permanently impairs memory or other cognitive functions."
    http://www.drugpolicy.org/fac...

    "Large Study Finds No Link between Marijuana and Lung Cancer"
    http://www.scientificamerican...
    (please note the date of this story and tell me again your professor knows all)
    (more)
  • gidianedwards97 2012/06/15 01:53:55
    Cigarettes
    gidianedwards97
    to many chemicals
  • chadwr85 2012/06/14 21:14:09
    Cigarettes
    chadwr85
    Cigs are worse but pot is bad too. There will be plenty of idiots on hear saying pot has no side effects. But you can become addicted to pot, pot has the same carcinogens as cigs, pot has carboon monoxide which kills brain cells.
  • Windy chadwr85 2012/06/15 04:02:12 (edited)
    Windy
    You can call people who have more knowledge about cannabis, idiots, but that doesn't make it true. However, as someone who is posting completely inaccurate (and long ago discredited) information about cannabis DOES show you to be an idiot.
  • chadwr85 Windy 2012/06/15 15:42:44
    chadwr85
    Really I am an Idiot? So you are questioning my Psychology professor who has attended 10 years of college and studies the affect of Drugs on the Body and particularly the Brain? I am sure you and every other pot head on hear is more correct than her. Pot CAN cause CANCER because it has CARCINOGENS, Pot CAN be addictive because your body can become dependent and you can have withdraws such as restlessness, anxiety, mood swings. And Pot has Carbon Monoxide in small amounts so when you smoke Pot IT DOES kill some brain cells. Hop off bro and get educated.
  • Windy chadwr85 2012/06/15 21:13:15
    Windy
    PS, not a "bro".
  • Seras S... chadwr85 2012/06/16 22:02:02
    Seras Superstar
    +1
    You're a college student, and yet you don't know the difference between "hear" and "here."
  • Jim chadwr85 2012/06/18 22:20:50
    Jim
    Don't you realize that pot and other drugs has killed their brain cells. You can talk all day and the pot heads will never listen, their brains are fried.
  • babygirl Jim 2012/10/04 19:44:05
    babygirl
    +3
    Jim, you're always wrong. You're talking like that because your minds nothing but hate
  • RoseLyle chadwr85 2012/06/22 17:52:24
    RoseLyle
    One can use pot in capsule form and it does not harm your lungs, in fact it is a good expectorant. Pot is not chemically additive as are cigarettes, they have added addictive chemicals to them so the cigarette companies can continue to make huge profits from them. Cannabis on the other-hand can be physiologically addictive as other substances can be. The people who have to use it everyday in most cases have other problems that need to be addressed.
  • Call me Mark willya? 2012/06/14 20:19:54
    Cigarettes
    Call me Mark willya?
    +1
    Cigarettes killed my mother, and raped my sister.

    Cigarettes are more dangerous because they're legal and therefore easier for kids to get hold of. Marijuana does nothing but cause a euphoric state that lowers inhibitions and the worst side effects include, dry mouth, intense hunger, and a sore face the next day because I was smiling so much the night before that the muscles are sore.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/22 00:43:37

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals