Quantcast

Is christmas a pagan holiday?

brother Allie 2012/07/06 17:06:32
You!
Add Photos & Videos

THE TRUTH
ABOUT CHRISTMAS


Most
professing Christians believe that Christmas is one of the most important
holidays. without question, many people blindly follow its observance.
Moreover, they assume that Jesus was actually born on December 25th.
Because we look to Christ as our Savior, it is important to take a deeper look
into his birth. We often hear people say, "Let's put Christ back into
Christmas!" Perhaps we should investigate just how Christ got into Christmas in
the first place.


Most Bible
scholars agree that Christmas is of pagan origin. In his book 4000 Years of
Christmas
, Earl W. Count, Professor of Anthropology at Hamilton College,
explains the origin of the Christmas celebration:


"We do not
know its beginning . . . we do not really know when the Christ child it
venerates was born: or the time and place when Christmas was first celebrated:
or exactly how it was that, over the centuries, a bishop saint of Asia Minor,
and a pagan god of the Germans merged to become Santa Claus."


"although the
Christmas story centers in the Christ child of Bethlehem, it begins so long
before his coming that we find its hero arriving on the scene after more than
half of the time of the story has gone by. Christmas began over 4000 years ago,
as the festival which renewed the world for another year. The 12 days of
Christmas, the bright fires and probably the yule log; the giving of presents;
the carnivals with their floats; their merry makings and clowning; the mummers
who sing and play from house to house, the feasting; the church processions with
their lights and song ”all these and more began three centuries before Christ
was born. And they celebrated the arrival of a new year" (ibid., page 18).


"For that day
[25th of December] was sacred, not only to the pagan Romans but to a
religion from Persia which, in those days, was one of Christianity's strongest
rivals. This Persian religion was Mithraism, whose followers worshiped the sun,
and celebrated its return to strength on that day. The church finally succeeded
in taking the merriment, the greenery, the lights, and gifts from Saturn and
giving them to the "babe of Bethlehem" (ibid., page 27).


"It happened
that the date [December 25th] did fall in the midst of the
Saturnalia. Far from being an invention to compete against Roman and Persian
paganism, the birthday of Christ ran the danger of being swallowed up in pagan
merry making. The [church] fathers tried strenuously to keep Christmas strictly
a churchly celebration. It was part of their unremitting struggle to break the
grip of the pagan gods upon the people. And as they broke, Romans became
Christians . . . but the Saturnalia remained" (ibid., page 28).


"When was
Jesus born? No one knows. December 25th is no more than the
historical date of his birth than is any other" [page 50]. "Christmas, as we
have seen, is of the Mediterranean . . .for the Mediterranean world already had
not merely centuries, but millennia behind it, when Christ was born; and even
the religion which he founded had traveled several centuries before it
discovered its need of Christmas" (page 86).


"Renewal and
rebirth: After 4000 years, the festival that has grown about the birth of the
Christ child remains an affirmation that all things can be made anew" (ibid.,
page 91).


although no
one knows the exact date of Christ's birth, there is evidence that he was not
born in the winter: "And there were in the same country shepherds abiding in
the field, keeping watch over their flocks by night"
(Lk.2:8). This never
could have occurred in the month of December in Palestine. The shepherds usually
brought their flocks from the mountainsides and fields and corralled them no
later than the middle of October to protect them from the cold, rainy season
that followed. The Song of Solomon 2:11 and Ezra.10:9, 13 show that winter was a
rainy season during which shepherds could not have remained in open fields at
night:


"It was an
ancient custom among the Jews of those days to send their sheep to the fields,
and deserts about Passover [early spring] and bring them home at commencement of
the first rain . . .During the time they were out, the shepherds watched them
night and day, . . .The first rains began early in the month of Marchesvan,
which answers to part of our October and November [begins in the middle of
October] we find that the sheep were kept out in the open country during the
whole summer, and as these shepherds had not yet brought home their flocks, it
is a presumptive argument that October had not yet commenced, and that
consequently, our Lord was not born on the 25th of December, when no
flocks were out in the fields by night. On this very ground, the nativity in
December should be given up. The feeding of the flocks by night in the fields is
a chronological fact" (The Adam Clarke Commentary, Volume 5, page 347).


There is no
command in the whole Bible that tells us to observe Christmas. Under the
inspired teaching of Paul and Peter and the other apostles, the Christians of
the first century never observed Christ's birth date. Christmas came to us
through the Roman Catholic Church, which is where it gets its authority as a
religious holiday. According to the Catholic Encyclopedia, which is
published by the Catholic Church: "Christmas was not among the earliest
festivals of the church . . .The first evidence of the feast is from Egypt."


We find this
truth acknowledged further in the Encyclopedia Britannica:
"Christmas [i.e., the Mass of Christ] was not among the earliest festivals of
the church."


The
Encyclopedia Americana
states:


"Christmas, .
. .it was, according to many authorities, not celebrated in the first centuries
of the Christian church, as the Christian's usage in general was to celebrate
the death of remarkable persons rather than their birth . . ." (The communion,
which is instituted by New Testament authority, is a memorial of the death of
Christ.) ". . .A feast was established in memory of this event (Christ's birth)
in the fourth century. In the fifth century, the Western church ordered it to be
celebrated forever on the day of the old Roman feast of the birth of Sol, as no
certain knowledge of the day of Christ's birth existed."


How did the
pagan custom get into the church? Most recognized authorities agree that
Christmas was not observed by the early church for the first two or three
hundred years and that its origin began in the western segment of the Roman
Church in the fourth century A.D.. However, it was not until the fifth century
that the Roman Church ordered it to be celebrated as an official Christian
festival.


The
Schaff-Herzog Encyclopedia:


"How much the
date of the festival depended upon the pagan Brumalia (December 25th)
following the Saturnalia (December 17-24), and celebrating the shortest day of
the year and the "new sun " . . .cannot be accurately determined. The pagan
Saturnalia and Brumalia were too deeply entrenched in popular custom to be set
aside by Christian influence. The pagan festival with its riot and merrymaking
was so popular that Christians were glad of an excuse to continue its
celebration with little change in spirit and manner. Christian teachers of the
West and Near East protested against the unseemly frivolity, while Christians of
Mesopotamia accused their western brethren of idolatry and sun worship for
adopting as Christian the pagan festival."


"The
observance of December 25 (as a Christian festival) only dates from the fourth
century and is due to assimilation with the Mithraic festival of the birth of
the sun" (World Popular Encyclopedia, Volume 3).


"Gradually a
number of prevailing practices of the [heathen] nations into which Christ came
were assimilated and were combined with the religious ceremonies surrounding
Christmas. The assimilation of such practices generally represented efforts by
Christians to transform or absorb otherwise pagan practices" (The Zonderian
Pictorial Encyclopedia of the Bible
, Volume 1, page 805).


"The pagan
symbolism was taken over and, in Christian view, elevated. Jesus became the "sun
of justice" and the "sun of righteousness" (Celebrations: The Complete Book
of American Holidays
, Myers, page 310).


"Our annual
Christian festival (Christmas) is nothing but a continuation under a different
name of this old solar festivity (Saturnalia)" (The New Golden Bough,
Frazer and Foster, page 653).


"Christmas
was generally celebrated in the West only after the triumph of Constantine when
the time of Christ's birth was reckoned with the Day of the Unconquered Sun on
25 December" (From Christ to Constantine, Smith, pages 150-151).


"The
assimilation of Christ to the sun god, as sun of righteousness, was widespread
in the fourth century and was furthered by Constantine's legislation on Sunday,
which is not unrelated to the fact that the sun god was the titular divinity of
his family" (A History of the Christian Church: Revised, Walker, Section
13, pages 154-155).


The Myth
of Nimrod


Nimrod, the
grandson of Ham and the great grandson of Noah, was the real founder of the
Babylonian system of worship and government that continues to thrive throughout
the world.


Ancient
writings speak of Nimrod as the one who started a great, organized world
apostasy against God, which still dominates the world. It is said that he was so
wicked that he married his own mother, Semiramis. After Nimrod was killed, his
mother-wife propagated the doctrine of the survival of Nimrod as a spirit-being.
She claimed that a full grown evergreen tree sprang up overnight from a dead
tree stump which symbolized the resurrection of Nimrod. On each anniversary of
his birth (supposedly December 25th), she claimed Nimrod would visit
the evergreen tree and leave gifts upon it.


Mother and
Child Theme


Through her
scheming and planning, Semiramis became the Babylonian Queen of Heaven, and
Nimrod, under many other names, became the Divine Son of Heaven. Through the
generations, in this idolatrous worship, Nimrod also became the false messiah,
son of Baal, who was the sun-god. In this false Babylonian religious system, the
mother and child (Semiramis and the reborn Nimrod) became chief objects of
worship. This worship of mother and child spread throughout the world. Only the
names varied because of differing languages. In Asia they were known as Cybele
and Diorus. In Rome they were Fortuna and Jupiter. In Egypt their names were
Isis and Osiris. Long before the birth of Jesus Christ, the counterpart of the
Madonna can be found throughout China, Tibet, and Japan.


The following
are explanations of the origins of popular practices and symbols of the
Christmas celebration.


Yule Logs


The yule log
is in reality the sun log. Yule means wheel, which is applied as the
pagan symbol of the sun. Today, professing Christians speak of the sacred
yuletide season. There is nothing sacred about it! The symbols come from the
worship of false gods.


The
Christmas Tree


The Christmas
tree was equally common in pagan Rome and pagan Egypt. In Egypt that tree was
the palm tree and in Rome it was the fir tree. The palm tree denotes the pagan
messiah, Baal-Tamar (Jdg.20:33), and the fir tree denotes the same pagan messiah
under the name Baal-Berith. The mother of Adonis, the sun god and great divine
mediator, was said to have been mystically changed into a tree. And when she was
in that state, she brought forth her divine son.


Mistletoe


"That
mistletoe bough in the Druidic superstition, which was derived from Babylon, was
a representative of the Messiah, "the man of the branch." The mistletoe was
regarded as a divine branch, a branch that came from heaven, and grew upon a
tree that sprang out of the earth. Thus by engrafting the celestial branch into
the earthly tree, heaven and earth, which sin had severed, were joined together.
Thus the mistletoe bough became the token of divine reconciliation to man, the
kiss being the well known token of pardon and reconciliation" (The Two
Babylons
, Hislop, page 99).


The
Encyclopedia Americana says:


"The holly,
the mistletoe and the yule log . . . are relics of pre-Christian times."


Gifts


Many exchange
gifts because the three wise men presented gifts to the Christ child. Did you
know the Bible nowhere states there were three wise men? Did you know those wise
men never appeared at the manger on Christ's birth night; they actually arrived
many months later? They didn't appear at the manger, they appeared at Christ's
house (Matt. 2:11).


although most
people believe that the custom of giving gifts at Christmas is associated with
the men that brought gifts to the child Jesus, the New Standard
Encyclopedia
, Christmas, says:


"In reality,
at least so far as the English speaking people are concerned, it [gift giving at
Christmas] is derived from an old heathen custom."


"The wise men
gave their gifts to Christ, but did not exchange gifts with each other. The
gifts presented to Christ were to a king, because of his royalty, and not
because of his birthday. He was a king, and the people of the East never
approached the presence of a king without a present in their hands" (Adam
Clarke Commentary
, Volume 5, Matt. 2:11, page 34).


The
Christmas Wreath


The use of Christmas wreaths is believed by authorities to
be traceable to the pagan customs of decorating buildings and places of worship
at the feast which took place at the same time as Christmas. The Christmas tree
is from Egypt and its origin dates from a period long anterior to the Christmas
era (Answers to Questions, Frederick gentlemen.
Haskins).


Christmas and
many other holidays have come directly from paganism, but the annual observances
and festivals of Leviticus 23 have come from God and should be observed today by
the children of God. See our study papers about the annual festivals and
commanded observances of God.


Santa
Claus


The name
Santa Claus is actually the corruption of the name St. Nicholas, a Roman
Catholic bishop who lived in the fifth century.


St. Nicholas, Bishop of Myra. . .a saint honored by the
Greeks and Latins on the 6th of December. . .a legend of his surreptitious
bestowal of dowries on the three daughters of an impoverished citizen. . .is
said to have originated the old custom of giving presents in secret on the eve
of St. Nicholas (December 6) subsequently of Christmas and Santa Claus (Encyclopedia Brittanica, 11th Edition, Volume 19,
pp. 648-649).


Kris
Kringle


From the
German people were to come those most universal of Christmas customs: the
Christmas tree, and the portly beneficent Kris Kringle, known as Santa Claus.


Gradually the Presbyterians, Quakers and Puritans accepted
such customs as the Christmas tree, the giving of small gifts and the Christmas
feast. But they spoke violently against the corruption of the Christkindl, (the
Christ Child) into Kris Kringle. After Kris Kringle was fully assimilated, there
was much concern among all religious groups about the non-religious trend of the
holiday (Christmas Day: The Complete Book of
American Holidays
, Myers, pp. 314-316).

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • poet4justice 2012/08/14 15:05:00
    Yes
    poet4justice
    it's started that way and I am trying to convince my Jewish wife christmas is as much as pagan as halloween
  • Monty 2012/08/14 13:26:21
    Yes
    Monty
    all christiananity has derived from paganism
  • poet4ju... Monty 2012/08/14 15:09:43
    poet4justice
    not all
  • Bear 2012/07/31 00:32:07
    Yes
    Bear
    As practiced and observed by most Xtians today, yes.
  • Sean McLain 2012/07/19 15:22:32
    Yes
    Sean McLain
    12/25 is a Pagan holiday. It is also a Christian holiday, a Muslim holiday a Jewish holiday....
  • tjr11 2012/07/13 21:19:36
    No
    tjr11
    It's the day I celebrate (along with millions of other Christians) the birth of Jesus Christ. It matters not one iota to me if he really was or wasn't actually born on the 25th day of December. As for "The Truth About Christmas" and it's volume of minutae...I'm thinking maybe Brother Allie should think about getting a hobby...I'm just sayin':)
  • Barbara 2012/07/12 14:32:54
    Yes
    Barbara
    Yes. Always has been. Always will be. The birth of Christ, who I follow, was in the lambing season, therefore in the spring.
    The Roman church chose December 25th to coincide with the pagan holiday, hoping more pagans would turn to the church and enhance its power.
    Thanks to the pagans we have the beautiful Christmas decorations, with all the greenery and Christmas trees, etc.
    The Bible does not tell believers to celebrate the birth and/or death and ressurection of Christ at any certain times of the year. The Puritans did not observe such holidays, hence the name Puritan. Those who follow Christ should celebrate his birth, death, ressurection and ascension everyday.
  • George Zook 2012/07/11 14:12:48
    No
    George Zook
    this particular astronomical time has held and holds significance for many faiths mostly when one religion supplants another the religion builds it,s churches over the holy sites of the previous faith and changes the dates of it's festivals to dates that match the festivals of the faith it is trying to overwhelm ... I think most have done this? not being a religious historian I may be wrong
  • Call me Mark willya? 2012/07/11 03:57:29 (edited)
    Yes
    Call me Mark willya?
    Show me anyplace in the bible where the word Christmas appears and I'll give you a nickel. Show me anyplace in the bible where it says we should celebrate the day of our savior's birth and I'll give you a dime, Christmas is the old New Year, it's the first day that the sun appears to be moving north again or in the case of Pagans "returning from the underworld"

    Have you been reading fossilized customs???
  • DavidHuddleston 2012/07/11 01:31:38
    Yes
    DavidHuddleston
    Duh!
  • Mark 2012/07/11 01:12:59
    Yes
    Mark
    Considering nothing in Christianity ever took place towards the end of December is kind of a big clue to this fact.
  • bennett.dunn1 2012/07/10 20:39:01
    Yes
    bennett.dunn1
    Pretty much ;)
  • Emily1126 2012/07/10 16:52:36
    Maybe
    Emily1126
    +1
    Perhaps.
    The winter solstace is a pagan holiday. Back then, the christians didn't want anyone to be pagan so they stole the attention away by making "the birth of christ" the 25th. In fact, christ wasn't actually born in the winter.
  • UberAwe... Emily1126 2012/07/20 14:03:25
    UberAwesomeness
    +1
    I think me and my mom are the only Christians who realize that.
  • Headhunter 13 2012/07/10 16:40:30
    Yes
    Headhunter 13
    +1
    Basically every christian holiday and many of it's beliefs come from older superstitions (religions, they are all superstitions). If there was a jesus based on the information given in the biblical book of myths he would have been born in the springtime between the end of March and May
  • Racefish 2012/07/10 16:31:11
    Maybe
    Racefish
    I'd say partly.
  • misterz 2012/07/10 16:05:55
    Yes
    misterz
    Of course!
  • merlinskiss 2012/07/10 14:56:07
    Don't know,Don't care
    merlinskiss
    +1
    But it is like Easter a religious Holiday and as such they should all be removed. Promotes religious preferences by the government.
  • Carlos benoit 2012/07/10 14:37:40
    Don't know,Don't care
    Carlos benoit
    Now that iv'e read this article, I'm not entirely sure anymore, but that does not diminish my belief in (Christ as our savior). So; for the sake of family and custom and my belief, I will continue to celebrate Christ's birth as always.
  • no no 2012/07/10 14:04:28 (edited)
    Maybe
    no no
    NO because it is a celebration with specific rituals and fanfare by those of a certain religious belief. YES, because it was chosen to be celebrated at the same time that a Roman holiday was observed; It was the best timing to get the "infidels "to come over to the other side, and MAYBE because of the two previous statements. So with reference to holiday, maybe, the date or time of the year is and was not an issue, it was about was the celebration (holiday) of christs' mass pagan or not. So the way the question is formed instantly creates a gray area. So its a YES, NO, MAYBE.
  • poet4ju... no no 2012/08/14 15:17:01
    poet4justice
    "chosen to be celebrated at the same time that a Roman holiday was observed;" you meant to say Dictated not chosen
  • no no poet4ju... 2012/08/18 20:00:55
    no no
    No, I meant to say chosen, I just didn't say by whom. It was more of an official decree. But let's not be picky, picky.
  • poet4ju... no no 2012/08/18 20:14:50
    poet4justice
    an official decree is not a choice...it is an enforcement. you can celebrate anything at any given day by choice but not by official decree
  • no no poet4ju... 2012/08/19 12:40:27
    no no
    AS said, "more of an official decree". However. Constantine chose the winter solstice, the pagan new year for the ancient sun worshipers, as the time period to observe Christmas.Constantine having selected December 25 because it was the beginning of the week of celebrations of the rites of Mithra, the sun god of Persia. So he chose, if his choice was dictated, decreed, or shouted within the Roman Senate, it was his choice. So bottom line Constantine chose December the 25th, some three centuries after the birth of Christ to celebrate his birth. Without a play on words, it was his choice.
  • poet4ju... no no 2012/08/19 15:28:51
    poet4justice
    you forgot to mention Hanukkah, which it is holiday of many days and not stationary but it always happen in December, i believe that Hannukkah, and not the pagan god was the precursor to Christmass
  • no no poet4ju... 2012/08/19 19:57:40
    no no
    The Jewish festival of Lights, Hanukkah starts on the 25th of Kislev (the month in the Jewish calendar that occurs at about the same time as December). Hanukkah celebrates when the Jewish people were able to re-dedicated and worship in their Temple, in Jerusalem, again following many years of not being allowed to practice their religion.

    Jesus was a Jew, so this could be another reason that helped Constantine to choose December the 25th for the date of Christmas! At the time of the year, there were other pagan, secular and organized religious activities that might have influenced. But most historians would suggest that it was the winter solstice, the pagan new year for the ancient sun worshipers celebrations and observances, that the early church under Constantine found to be the best time to merge and expand Christian teachings and rituals while gaining acceptance and recruits. Thanks for your interest in my post. I remain respectful of your opinions.
  • Xerxes 2012/07/10 13:40:15
    Yes
    Xerxes
    +1
    The way my family celebrates it, it is. We celebrate all the pagan parts - the tree, the gift giving, the fat man in a red suit who brings toys for kids, the excessive eating and drinking, my family celebrates all of that, none of which is in the bible. We dont do any of the religious stuff - going to church, etc. Best holiday of the year IMO, those pagans really knew how to handle the cold of winter, smart people, our ancestors!
  • Alexander T Steward 2012/07/10 13:34:39
    Don't know,Don't care
    Alexander T Steward
    As long as I get pressies I don't really care.
  • Heat Her 2012/07/10 13:29:06
    Yes
    Heat Her
    Christmas trees are an older than bible tradition. You bring a tree inside your house so the wood spirits have a warm place to spend the winter.
  • Michael Mcconnell 2012/07/10 12:45:52
    Yes
    Michael Mcconnell
    Just like Halloween, it was pagan but now it can be secular, religious or pagan.
  • UberAwe... Michael... 2012/07/20 14:05:28
    UberAwesomeness
    Halloween religous? Since when....
  • gaylehelen 2012/07/10 12:03:06
    Maybe
    gaylehelen
    Biblical scholars believe Jesus was actually born around April. December 25 was taken from a pagan holiday, although I can't remember which one right now.
    As all things religion, it is a matter of one's personal belief. I choose to celebrate the birth of Christ on December 25, because it has been for so long and we do not know his exact birthday.
    I choose to celebrate December 25 because of tradition. I love the religious Christmas holiday, hate the commercial Christmas holiday. My husband and I try very hard not to fall into the commercial trappings of the holiday.
  • drdos1943 2012/07/10 12:00:06
    Yes
    drdos1943
    Jesus could have been born on July 4th, 0006 BCE on a Wednesday...and that is an approximation that is much more valid than December 25th.

    However, the date does not matter, how the Holiday originated does not matter, whether or not it is the date of a Pagan holiday as well does not matter. What does matter is that Christmas is a celebration of the birth of Christ, regardless when that birth occurred.

    Another good example of a Christian-Pagan holiday is Easter...which is the English pronunciation of "Ishtar" (the rite of spring -- fertility). What do you think the idea of rabbits, the Easter Bunny, and all the eggs have to do with the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ?
  • Heat Her drdos1943 2012/07/10 13:26:51
    Heat Her
    +1
    Oh *waves hand* I know what Easter symbols came from. Rabbits are a symbol of fertility and eggs were buried in the ground as a blessing to bring good harvest. But I'm pagan.
  • classic drdos1943 2012/07/10 14:15:04
    classic
    +2
    The egg was an early symbol of Life..

    the tradition of painting hard-boiled eggs during springtime pre-dates Christianity. In many cultures around the world, the egg is a symbol of new life, fertility and rebirth. For thousands of years, Iranians and others have decorated eggs on Nowruz, the Iranian New Year that falls on the spring equinox.

    Some claim that the Easter egg has pagan roots. even the word Easter is said to have to come to us from the “Norsemen’s Eostur, Eastar, Ostara, and Ostar, and the pagan goddess Eostre, all of which involve the season of the growing sun and new birth”

    I cannot think of one Christian ritual that wasnt borrowed from other ancient traditions.....
  • Tom 2012/07/10 11:36:00
    Yes
    Tom
    +1
    It was the Roman holiday for the Festival of Sol, December 25th was the start date and it wasn't over until after New Year's day. So, if you do Christmas, you are keeping a pagan tradition alive.
  • Steve Nixey 2012/07/10 09:24:58
    Yes
    Steve Nixey
    Nimrod was born on Xmas day NOT Jesus as he was born in June
    We have all had the historic wool pulled over our eyes for thousands of years
  • drdos1943 Steve N... 2012/07/10 11:52:34
    drdos1943
    Jesus could have been born on July 4th, 0006 BCE on a Wednesday...and that is an approximation that is much more valid than December 25th.

    However, the date does not matter, how the Holiday originated does not matter. What does matter is that Christmas is a celebration of the birth of Christ, regardless when that birth occurred.
  • Steve N... drdos1943 2012/08/14 13:25:16
    Steve Nixey
    +1
    Ah but the energies can be stolen in high ritual affairs by esoteric secret groups, but as what your meaning is yes your correct if we all look at it with this intent..

    love peace and light
  • Dana 2012/07/10 06:56:07
    Don't know,Don't care
    Dana
    Please.... please do not talk about this holiday yet. A friend is already selling her ornaments on facebook, some stores have actually got decorations up, and I have not recovered from the last one yet.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/22 04:21:12

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals