Quantcast

Ideally, should mothers stay at home to look after their children?

ANGEL 2012/05/09 03:42:09
Yes, definitely
No.
It depends...
Other thoughts...
You!
Add Photos & Videos
In the age of apparent equality, women are increasingly encouraged to ‘have
it all’, balancing career, children and marriage in order to be seen as
successful. Some feel this is bad for children who are then cared for by others. Others feel
that no harm comes to children if the alternative care is good and that
children may in fact benefit if paid work makes the mother happier and
her work improves the family’s living standards .


Occasionally fathers will also decide to stay home as carers instead of mothers. In many
countries, mothers (and sometimes fathers) have a legal right to
maternity (or paternity leave). The Czech Republic has the longest
parental leave programme, lasting until the children are 2-3 years old
and can be taken by either parent. For UK women this comprises 26 weeks
paid leave and 26 weeks unpaid leave. Recently the British government
has made changes so that this leave can be shared between partners as
the parents see fit. In Sweden, leave is offered to either parent until
the child is 18 months old. The USA does not have a national paid
maternity leave program.


Other options exist, such as protecting the right to ask for part-time work or flexible hours.
However in many families, especially where the mother earns the majority
of the family’s income and may be the only earner , it is financially
impossible for the mother to stop work without considerable state
support, which in most cases doesn’t exist. Many studies point to the
years before a child starts school as the most important in its
educational and emotional development. For this reason, should the
mother be at home, at least until her children start school? Or can
children develop equally well- or sometimes better- with support from
others in addition to their mothers?


What are your thoughts? Ideally, should the mom stay at home to look after her child?



NOTE: This topic brings people to the table commenting on a topic that doesn't depend on whether you are involved in Christianity, Scientology, Judaism, Atheism, etc. There are many polls on SH that divide people and I want to change the tide. You might find that you have more in common with others than you previously thought.
Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • alheri.christopher 2013/01/15 10:11:19
    It depends...
    alheri.christopher
    +1
    Sometimes in life,people get into things, before they fully understand what they have gotten into.

    For a mother who already have kids, and need to go to work to be able to look after them,what choice does she have?

    But for those who are still single and plan to get married and start a family,it is better to have the number of Kids you can look after by staying at home to do so.

    Sometimes things happen along the line that makes a stay at home mom,look for work and thereby making arrangement for someone to look after the kids.

    But if possible, the parents of the kids should take turns to look after the kids.it is not a very good thing for a child to spend most part of the day with a stranger
  • cowboy 2012/05/18 17:51:19
    Yes, definitely
    cowboy
    +1
    If the family can afford it, why not?
  • Cookielane 2012/05/10 11:11:54
    It depends...
    Cookielane
    I'd have given anything to have been able to do just that, however, either parent will do. I prefer to see children cared for more my their parents and less by strangers.
  • Ameera 2012/05/10 05:41:49
    Yes, definitely
    Ameera
    but ideally they need to work as well (if they want to)
  • Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆ 2012/05/10 00:50:20
    Yes, definitely
    Temlakos~POTL~PWCM~JLA~☆
    The raising of the next generation is the most noble career a woman can have.

    Real women understand this.

    But real men know that they have a stake in this, too.
  • XXrawwwrXX 2012/05/10 00:45:49
    It depends...
    XXrawwwrXX
    i think if the mother wanted to, and is able to stay home, they should be able to, just like if the father wanted to stay home.
  • Centrist_Bill 2012/05/09 20:02:10
    Yes, definitely
    Centrist_Bill
    Mother's should raise kids And Fathers should support them. Will it happen?? Not alot of times. I see it all the time.
  • Bastion 2012/05/09 15:37:41
    Other thoughts...
    Bastion
    The mother OR the father.
    Unless there are serious money problems, the value of a parent at home during the pre-school years outweighs additional income, IMO.
  • Cantus_bird 2012/05/09 15:35:50
    Other thoughts...
    Cantus_bird
    Ideally, yes but not all those who have become mothers have been raised on discipline, on structure, didn't have good role models or even have the skills it takes to properly raise children. I think it should be left up to the couple or the parent as to the final decision in that situation. However, if i see more bling or more name brand items on a parent than i see discipline on a child, i think someone needs to reset their priorities as a parent.
  • turtledove123 2012/05/09 14:24:58
    Other thoughts...
    turtledove123
    Ideally women should have the option to do what is best for them without judgement. Some moms would love to be at home, but can not afford to be. For those moms who can afford it, but need to be in the workforce for their own sanity, then so be it. People have to do what they have to do.
  • susan BN-0 2012/05/09 14:23:03
    Other thoughts...
    susan BN-0
    I think It's a personal choice and It's not my place to tell anyone weather to be a stay at home mom or not.
  • lucky 2012/05/09 13:17:47
    Yes, definitely
    lucky
    Ideally YES, but this isnt an prefect world and often finances require both parents to work.
  • FreeDave (US NAVY) 2012/05/09 12:55:12
    It depends...
    FreeDave (US NAVY)
    Ideally it'd be great, if it's what all women wanted. Not all women want to stay home or can stay home and I can respect that it's a choice that a woman has to make for herself, just make sure that the kids get the childhood they deserve and make some time for them.

    I'm about to start a family of my own and my wife-to-be has decided to work part time until I get a higher pay check and then she's going to stay home with our child.
  • Jane 2012/05/09 12:45:43
    It depends...
    Jane
    If that is a persons calling then they should be given that choice. Not every woman is a great parent in the home setting and would prefer to work out side of the home.
  • Brian 2012/05/09 12:21:57
    It depends...
    Brian
    +1
    My wife and I decided to have her stay at home with our youngest son after he was born, it put about a 35,000 dollar hole in our income. But we managed, she still talks about how wonderful a time she had with John for the 5 years she stayed home with him, it helped the other two old siblings as well.
    Would do it over again in a heartbeat, it made a huge difference in John all the way around, very well adjusted is doing phenomenally well in school too, can't say enough good about it.
  • wolf sloan 2012/05/09 12:08:09
    Yes, definitely
    wolf sloan
    Ideally, yes. One parent should.
  • Redneck 2012/05/09 11:40:56
    It depends...
    Redneck
    If finances allow it, it is better for the children.
  • Chris - The Rowdy One! #187 2012/05/09 11:20:57
    Yes, definitely
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    Your anger is welcome.
  • Mike 2012/05/09 11:18:40
    Yes, definitely
    Mike
    Out here particularly, otherwise they will run rampant.
  • crazy:) 2012/05/09 11:03:54
    No.
    crazy:)
    I don't think it matters my dad stayed home with us while my mom works and we got the same attention and care as we wouild if our mom was home...we all turned out pretty okk with out dad being the one to watch us at home though we may have drove him crazy lol
  • Dar 2012/05/09 09:28:51
    Other thoughts...
    Dar
    +2
    It's a choice women make. I've done both. I respect a woman's decision either way.
  • Chukroast 2012/05/09 08:49:53
    It depends...
    Chukroast
    It depends on the ideals of the parents.
  • David William 2012/05/09 08:08:29
    It depends...
    David William
    If the mother wants too, then yes. If the father wants to, then yes. If not, and they can afford to pay someone or have a relative take care of them... also ok.
  • Dagon 2012/05/09 08:04:14
  • Scream 2012/05/09 07:01:11
    It depends...
    Scream
    If they want to...
  • L1 2012/05/09 06:34:19
    It depends...
    L1
    It depends on the couple's and child's needs. Sometimes, it's the hubby who stays home, other times, neither can stay due to financial concerns. Others might be single parents that do not have outside support, and cannot afford to do so.
  • freakoutnow... cuz mom's here 2012/05/09 05:46:07
    It depends...
    freakoutnow... cuz mom's here
    First off the world is far from ideal so addressing the ideal circumstaces of raising a child would mean raising a kid in Paradise which our fallen world is not at all even close to any ideal outcome. Secondly in our world today many familes have to have both parents working in order to make it today. Ideally only one parent would have to work outside the home while the other stays home and takes care of the kids. Even more ideally is when mom is the one staying home taking care of the kids. Even more ideally one takes care of the kids at home while the other works from home. Since this is an unideal world it is up to each family to decide who works and how to deal with who watches the kids.
  • Elisa ✦ Knockout™ 2012/05/09 05:27:33
    Yes, definitely
    Elisa ✦ Knockout™
    +2
    But in my case i'm still in high school and Have both my parents and grandparents and bf to help.
  • YOMOMMA 2012/05/09 05:24:13
    Yes, definitely
    YOMOMMA
    IDEALLY is the key word. My mom stayed home til I was 13. My parents divorced and she had to get a job and we were in school and My brothers started school. It was good while it lasted.BUT this is not a perfect world and Moms have to go to work. It would be good for a mom stays home with her children for their first 10 years.
  • travis103192 2012/05/09 04:49:24
    Other thoughts...
    travis103192
    +1
    Mothers should be able to do what they want and choose their own path. Mothers and other women should have just as many rights as any other person alive. We are all of the same species if anyone didn't know that. Women can stay at home while the father works or vise versa, they can be in the military, construction, mines, run for president, whatever. There is hardly a difference between gender, hormone balance, and our genitals, otherwise we are the same so they can stay at home to watch children as much as a father can. Children really need their parents which everyone should always remember though.
  • Pops 2012/05/09 04:46:34
    Yes, definitely
    Pops
    it's best but sometimes...
  • wtxwoman 2012/05/09 04:44:12
    It depends...
    wtxwoman
    With over half of the marriages ending in divorce, most of the working women aren't doing it for the fun of it or for 'personal fulfillment'. They are doing it to put food on the table and a roof over their kids heads. Most studies say children benefit from their mothers working, besides the monetary one. They are better readers, more independent, and less aggressive than their counterparts.
  • KarenInKenoshaWisconsin 2012/05/09 04:40:07
    It depends...
    KarenInKenoshaWisconsin
    +1
    It's not about ideals, it's about what's right for each family.
  • Metaldane 2012/05/09 04:36:50
    No.
    Metaldane
    I was raised by two working parents if anything it helped me become the individual I am now at 6 I was more independent then most people are at 13 lol and I benefitted from that so thought some people feel otherwise for their own reasons to me as long as the kid and parents love eachother and they find a system that works for them it shouldn't matter who's at home.
  • Arianne 2012/05/09 04:33:37
    No.
    Arianne
    The mother should do what she thinks is best for her and her family. Also the kids of whom both parents work, and the kids where only one does, tend to perform the same.

    And why the mother? I've heard of many house husbands who stay at home and take care of the kids, and raise them just as wll as house wives.
  • Andy Fletcher 2012/05/09 04:27:34
    It depends...
    Andy Fletcher
    +2
    First, I have to say I am against people having children they are not ready to care for. In an ideal world, it would be wonderful for a parent to stay at home for a child's early years. All of the studies I have seen show that this is most effective when it is the mother. The bottom line however, is that having children is a choice. Being that it is a choice, those that make that choice to have children have zero expectation allowed for others to subsidize that choice.
  • Medulla Oblongata 2012/05/09 04:21:44
    No.
    Medulla Oblongata
    I think mothers should do what they feel is right to their standards, not society's.
  • Lily 2012/05/09 04:16:54
    It depends...
    Lily
    Depends, single parent homes generally can not afford to stay home. However, if the U.S. instituted paid maternity leave I think all children would benefit.
  • Bob, the reasonable one 2012/05/09 04:11:43
    Yes, definitely
    Bob, the reasonable one
    in a perfect world, Yes.....however, in today's economic times it's not going to happen for the vast majority of families
  • wtw 2012/05/09 04:11:00
    Yes, definitely
    wtw
    Ideally yes!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/23 09:37:37

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals