Quantcast

Hero Dog Killed by Mistake: What Should the Punishment Be?

SodaHead Living 2010/11/17 16:00:00
Related Topics: Pet, jail, suicide, Movie
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Pretty sad that a dog can successfully battle a suicide bomber in Afghanistan, but can't make it through the weekend at a U.S. animal shelter.

Target, a female shepherd mix who frightened a suicide bomber inside a military base in Afghanistan, potentially saving dozens of soldiers' lives, got loose from her owners last Friday. She was put down on Monday after spending the weekend in an Arizona shelter, msnbc.com reports.

An unidentified employee at the Pinal County facility was placed on administrative leave after euthanizing the dog by mistake, county Animal Care and Control officials said.

Ruth Stalter, the county animal control director, said the shelter works hard to reunite lost pets with their owners and that an investigation had been launched to figure out how the awful mistake was made.

"When it comes to euthanizing an animal, there are some clear-cut procedures to follow," Stalter said. "Based on my preliminary investigation, our employee did not follow those procedures."

Sgt. Terry Young, the distraught owner of the hero dog, said he realized his dog was in the pound over the weekend, but when he went to pick her up on Monday, she had been euthanized.

All we can say is thank you for your service, Target.

Read More: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/40214260/ns/health-pet...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Ali 2011/08/06 17:40:09
    The employee should do jail time
    Ali
    its not right to euthanize for no reason anyway, so definately jail time.
  • JT 2010/11/20 17:28:22
    None of the above
    JT
    The employee has now been fired but now needs to be jailed for destruction of private property, and then turned over to any group who can find a use for the dead body of a sorry excuse of a human being dog catcher who gets pleasure from killing animals. The county should be sued and forced to pay for micro-chipping ALL US Servicemen and Servicewomens dogs for the next decade or more.

    Did this sorry excuse for a animal control person NOT see or hear all of the media on the missing dog or was this just thier way of being cruel to a animal as part of the day to day torture they were paid to do??

    May this person who killed the dog rot in hell !!!
  • boberry 2010/11/18 22:22:14
    The employee should be fired
    boberry
    It was a tragic event for a dog that had such an illustrious history to die in this fashion. I'm surprised by the "accident" because Pinal County is where I license my pooches and they've always seemed to be on top of things. I think some sort of system should be put into place to keep from having another instance like this from occurring, and sadly, yes...I believe the employee should be in the unemployment line. It was a grievous error.
  • Jim 2010/11/18 22:07:49
    The employee should be fired
    Jim
  • domrygel 2010/11/18 21:44:57
    The employee should do jail time
    domrygel
    Euthanisation shoul d avalable for human being and this emplyee should be first in line. Dumbo.
  • bean 2010/11/18 21:31:41
    The employee should be fired
    bean
    fired and made to volunteer at a no kill shelter
  • Jim bean 2010/11/18 22:08:22
    Jim
    Amen !
  • Horse Racer 2010/11/18 21:25:32
    The employee should do jail time
    Horse Racer
    The man should so a whole lot of jail time basically he killed all those soldiers the dog saved.
  • The employee should do jail time
    justinbiebersgirl<3forever!♥♥♥
    awwww i want that person in jail! right now!
  • captkirk999 2010/11/18 20:14:30
    The employee should do jail time
    captkirk999
    Killing a dog is almost as bad as murdering a human. It is not right.
  • Country Gentleman 2010/11/18 19:44:18
    None of the above
    Country Gentleman
    I would bet this employee finds no joy in euthanizing any animal. Imagine them then finding out about the horrible mistake they made. For a while I would bet Hell would feel like a picnic as compared to what this employee feels right now.
  • Horse R... Country... 2010/11/18 21:29:26
    Horse Racer
    then why would they work at a kill shelter in the first place?
  • Sheila 2010/11/18 19:41:02
    None of the above
    Sheila
    What an AWFUL mistake. This should prompt a review of policies and possibly a suspension. If policies were not followed then possible fire the employee. Most of us do not have a job where an error means something dies, but they do. they have a HARD JOB. Face it, would you want to work there??
  • lisa 2010/11/18 19:25:54
    The employee should do jail time
    lisa
    The employee and the assinine neighbor who took him to the pound should be jailed.
  • eNewsAlerts 2010/11/18 19:08:59
    The employee should be fired
    eNewsAlerts
    +1
    While it was probably an innocent mistake, there should be ramifications for an error this large. I think only compassionate people should be working in these shelters who are alert enough not to let this happen. I know that it is difficult that some animals need to be put down, but err on the side of caution at least.
  • Bronx 2010/11/18 18:37:53
    The employee should be fired
    Bronx
    Obviously this employee was as dumb as they come and should be fired but the real story is why do we ever kill any dog in a shelter if there is nothing wrong with them. NO KILL SHELTERS should be allowed in the USA. God bless Target who deserved to live till GOD wanted him.
  • Sheila Bronx 2010/11/18 19:42:16
    Sheila
    Where should their money come from?
  • Imelting! 2010/11/18 17:11:58
    The employee should be fired
    Imelting!
    +2
    The employee who mixed up the paperwork should be fired. I have worked in a shelter and have seen first hand the hundreds of animals euthanized. It can't be helped, but that didn't stop me as an animal lover from feeling angry and sad. This wonderful guy that rescued the dog should have secured his yard no matter what the cost. And let this be a lesson to all, microchip your beloved pets, they can't speak up to say where they live if lost or if they are injured.
  • Bronx Imelting! 2010/11/18 18:39:04
    Bronx
    Great advice Imelting!
  • Rave 2010/11/18 17:02:58
    The employee should do jail time
    Rave
    Fired and jail time for not following procedures and therefore killing an innocent life. When we're dealing with lives, one cannot be this reckless and needs to learn from this mistake.
  • chuck 2010/11/18 17:00:37
    None of the above
    chuck
    do to him what he did to the dog
  • Herbtheman 2010/11/18 17:00:08
    None of the above
    Herbtheman
    It was an accident.
  • PapaBC 2010/11/18 16:16:27
    The employee should be fired
    PapaBC
    +1
    No excuses.
  • snail 2010/11/18 16:03:13
    None of the above
    snail
    +1
    No dogs should be killed at shelters. It's not so much about the individuals involved. If shelters were safe places for lost and homeless pets, none of this would have happened in the first place.
  • Lee Wacker 2010/11/18 14:51:21
    The employee should be fired
    Lee Wacker
    +1
    Animal Shelter employees and "dogcatchers" have far too much power! Why didn't this fool take the time to check the dog's record at the office? At Northern Arizona University a few years ago, a blind student's dog was taken from her own doorstep where she was laying in the sun. About half the football team, and a fair amount of the student body descended upon the shelter, and got the dog back--no fine levied! In Flagstaff, where the NAU incident happened, the "Animal Control" people can even go into a locked, empty home and grab a suspected dog! I have seen these people take a dog, even if his owner is with him, holding the leash! I lost my dog to the same person, but he changed his mind after I faced him, and demanded justice! He tried to take my boyfriend's dog, too, but that was a bad mistake on the dogcatcher's part! My boyfriend knew too many people in high places in town!
    I have heard of far too many incidents like the one in Pinal County! Time to make the Animal Control people, including the ASPCA, toe the line a bit harder!
  • swatfrog 2010/11/18 14:49:28
    None of the above
    swatfrog
    this is all B.S! I live in the next county over and they are killing ALL animals that are brought in. The employee here is just the patsy,doing what he was told ,which is to KILL ALL new animals being brought in, they dont have room for them.and by the way, they did the same thing to my dog. I took her in on a Saturday, called on Wednesday to see how she was doing and I was told the she was put down. I asked why? the reply I got was this," well, maybe she just pissed off the wrong person" This is the real truth about what is really going on. If I had put my dog down,theyd put my in jail or maybe even prison,but THEY murder dogs and cats by the 100S and its ok cause its YOUR tax dollars at work
  • Eipok 2010/11/18 14:03:13
    The employee should do jail time
    Eipok
    +1
    Aren't there laws against animal cruelty? And wasn't that animal cruelty? I mean, what kind of person is like "Oh, a dog! Well, I'm too lazy to search for his owner myself and I don't feel like telling anyone I found him, so I guess I'll just kill him. Hmm, maybe I'll get a snack later. Killing animals with syringes filled with poison sure is hard work, after all. What, between picking up the syringe, prepping the injection site, holding down the animal, and then actually pushing the plunger, I might even break a sweat. I should probably invest in one of those injector guns."
  • MegMayhem 2010/11/18 13:46:07
    None of the above
    MegMayhem
    +3
    The employee should be "accidentally" euthanized.
  • _Fake S... MegMayhem 2010/11/18 13:52:01
    _Fake Smiles Hide The Truth_
    Exactly!
  • Lee Wacker MegMayhem 2010/11/18 14:52:41
    Lee Wacker
    Wish I had thought of that!
  • ToddBHarris 2010/11/18 13:37:46
    The employee should do jail time
    ToddBHarris
    +1
    LOCK EM UP !!!!
  • Always.Bored :P 2010/11/18 13:36:57
    None of the above
    Always.Bored :P
    +2
    The employee should be killed in the same way.
  • mysticmatriarch 2010/11/18 13:32:40
    The employee should be fired
    mysticmatriarch
    This is what can happen when we decide that it is okay to kill living things we have no use for. There is no way to know how many times that has happened.
  • _Fake Smiles Hide The Truth_ 2010/11/18 13:27:10 (edited)
    The employee should do jail time
    _Fake Smiles Hide The Truth_
    +1
    He should be sentenced to Death! & should suffer!
  • Tarkin 2010/11/18 13:25:21
    The employee should be fired
    Tarkin
    +3
    MISERABLE BA$TARD!
  • _Fake S... Tarkin 2010/11/18 13:28:16
    _Fake Smiles Hide The Truth_
    I agree w/ u too!
  • Myrle Hulme 2010/11/18 11:33:08
    The employee should do jail time
    Myrle Hulme
    +4
    Kill the bast***d
  • _Fake S... Myrle H... 2010/11/18 13:27:29
    _Fake Smiles Hide The Truth_
    Agreed!
  • Jay0Byrd 2010/11/18 10:31:32
    None of the above
    Jay0Byrd
    +3
    The person whom did this to Old 'Target' should be euthanized for his mistake, like a butcher-Block table and big sharp "Wilkersonn Sword Machete... as sharp as a razor, bye-bye` Head... Be Headedbutcher-block table sharp wilkersonn sword machete sharp razor bye-bye head
  • Dixie 10 Dog aka nanadixie 2010/11/18 09:29:12
    The employee should do jail time
    Dixie 10 Dog  aka nanadixie
    +2
    Even the Christian bible shows that the ancient Hebrew people had laws that dealt with the death of humans and animals; both life forms were valued in the laws given to the people. Murder is murder, be it the murder of a human or a farmer's favorite cow. This dog was a military hero and someone ended this heroes life because they chose not to follow the shelter's policy of operation standards. That seems to be premeditated action with murder as the result.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 9 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/26 00:29:01

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals