Quantcast

Grabbing Food With Your Non-Dominant Hand Makes You Eat Less: Brilliant or Bogus?

SodaHead Living 2011/09/09 21:39:01
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Want to shed a few pounds? It's easy! All you have to do is use your less dominant hand to grab the munchies. Why didn't they tell us this before?!

According to researchers, reaching for a snack with your non-dominant hand while doing something mindless -- like watching TV or a movie -- makes you snack less.

How come? Because when we eat a snack in a specific environment, our brain associates the food with the environment. So when you switch your normal eating game-plan up, it forces the brain to react.

"When we've repeatedly eaten a particular food in a particular environment, our brain comes to associate the food with that environment and makes us keep eating as long as those environmental cues are present," David Neal, study researcher and a psychology professor at the University of Southern California, said.

In an experiment, snackers who ate with their non-dominant hand ate much less popcorn when at the movies than those who ate with their dominant hand.

Do you think this unique way of dieting is brilliant -- or pretty bogus?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Sithslayer 2012/03/10 01:24:57
    Brilliant
    Sithslayer
    You dont use your non-dominant hand all the time when eating. Use non-dominant when eating snacks like popcorn. This way you dont eat as much as you normally would. try this in a movie theater with a friend. Buy them popcorn and see how much they eat. remember length of movie and how much they ate. When you go out to the movies again tell them to only eat the popcorn with their non-dominant hand. Dont tell them why. Now watch as they eat less.
  • Sithslayer Sithslayer 2012/03/10 01:29:38
    Sithslayer
    +3
    ohh and about your non-dominant hand getting better at stuffing your face... Yes, you will eat slightly fast BUT you still have to think about your actions more than if you used your dominant hand.
  • Any 2011/09/13 18:30:10
    Brilliant
    Any
    I have had a similar experience that backs up this claim!

    After spending 2 months living in China, I found that eating with chopsticks is much slower than eating with a fork and knife. Especially for me, someone who is not skilled at eating with chopsticks. Since I ate slower I ended up eating less - I would not shovel food into my mouth mindlessly and I tended to stop long before I reached the 'overfull" point.

    I think that eating with your non-dominant hand doesn't feel like second nature to most of us (much like chopsticks don't feel like second nature to me) and thus the time required to feed yourself increases. Other studies have shown that eating more slowly decreases the amount of food intake - I personally found this to be true in my case.
  • lmnlme1... Any 2011/09/16 22:59:45
    lmnlme10921
    true, but what if you were in China longer? You would probably get better at using chopsticks, and learn to eat faster using them. the same thing could happen to someone using their non dominant hand
  • Any lmnlme1... 2011/09/17 21:23:19
    Any
    Yes! I also made this point (although possibly contradicting my original post) in another reply. I think you make a good point and it certainly is possible to negate all positive effects of eating with the non-dominant hand over time. However, Chinese people I talk(ed) to also say they prefer chopsticks over western utensils because it "slows them down" when eating. And these are people who are adept with chopsticks. You simply get less food in each "scoop."
  • lmnlme1... Any 2011/09/18 01:45:50
    lmnlme10921
    hmm i guess i never thought of this, though it is true. i almost went to China on an exchange trip, but switched schools they year I would have gone.
  • Any lmnlme1... 2011/09/20 17:45:43
    Any
    You should definitely go if you have the chance! (Totally off topic) I love travelling - I went all over Europe as a kid with my dad - now that I'm older I've started branching out to Asia, a little further from home culturally. It's aweeeesome! And if you can go through college study abroad or some other well organized but not overly stifling program.... that's ideal! ::D
  • lawlerskates 2011/09/13 16:48:41
    Bogus
    lawlerskates
    +2
    Why? Because you'll get used to using the other hand and then both hands will be equally as fast at shoving food in your mouth! Yup yup.
  • Any lawlers... 2011/09/13 18:30:59
    Any
    +1
    I agree with this statement. Once your non-dominant hand becomes efficient at feeding you, all of the positive effects will be gone.
  • lawlers... Any 2011/09/13 20:46:44
  • todd 2011/09/13 16:11:48
    Bogus
    todd
    +1
    My guess is that by "researchers" - they had a bored undergraduate student who did this for a research project and probably got a C- on it. That's just ridiculous. People who have eating issues will eat the same with both hands or no hands at all.
  • Stuart 2011/09/13 06:13:42
    Bogus
    Stuart
    +1
    Most people that are overweight have learned to eat with both hands. The only way your hands will keep you from getting fat is if you take them both, put them on the table and push yourself back and away from the food.
  • danny 2011/09/13 04:34:11 (edited)
    Bogus
    danny
    +1
    their are no words for this question so i leave you with confused cat Shareleave confused cat wtf
  • lmnlme10921 2011/09/12 23:24:37
    Bogus
    lmnlme10921
    +1
    this is just like the time they said using a bigger fork will help you eat less. how about a real diet and exercise?
  • ©TransAmTam~Metal Queen \m/ 2011/09/12 22:51:15
  • amoreitaliana56 2011/09/12 22:36:55
    Brilliant
    amoreitaliana56
    imm sooo trying tht!!!
  • samantha wayne<3 2011/09/12 17:58:15
    Bogus
    samantha wayne<3
  • moviebuff 2011/09/12 15:07:16
    Bogus
    moviebuff
    +3
    Your still shoving food in your mouth. This is the dumbest thing I have ever heard. You'd thing these researchers can spend more time finding the cure for AIDS or something
  • Aardfay moviebuff 2011/09/13 02:02:48
    Aardfay
    +1
    Are you spending your time finding the cure for aids?
  • moviebuff Aardfay 2011/09/13 17:56:35
    moviebuff
    Im not a researcher. They are. It just takes common sense. when you eat mindlessly you have the tendency to gain weight. See we didn't need an unnecessary study to know that.
  • Aardfay moviebuff 2011/09/14 01:27:55
    Aardfay
    +1
    And why aren't you a researcher?

    People have different interests. They are interested in researching that kind of thing. It's hypocritical to criticize people for not doing something when you're not doing it either.
  • moviebuff Aardfay 2011/09/14 17:42:52
    moviebuff
    I love it when a simple comment gets twisted into something else. Hey if you want to go ahead and spend money to find out which hand is making you fatter thats your business. I like common sense
  • Aardfay moviebuff 2011/09/15 05:53:50
    Aardfay
    It wasn't twisted x) now I wanna know what you do that's so much better than what they do. And how you spend money. Are you helping people? Are you curing aids? You better be xD
  • moviebuff Aardfay 2011/09/16 20:36:49
    moviebuff
    I have a right to my own opinion don't I? just like you. I'm pretty sure they do other things with their time. I'm talking about this study specifically. I'm sure their nice people. And why do people get their noses out of joint just cuz other people don't agree with them. Get off your high horse slick. You judge just as anyone else. Are you curing AIDS? What are you doing with your time?
  • Aardfay moviebuff 2011/09/21 19:29:01
    Aardfay
    No, I'm not curing aids. It doesn't INTEREST me. Cinema, publicity, psychology, are some of the things that interest me. That's what I study. If you think that anything but curing aids is a waste of time and money then we're both useless x)
  • moviebuff Aardfay 2011/09/22 14:15:32
    moviebuff
    Ok. man, no need to get your panties in a twist. I was being pretty general when I said they should be doing other things like curing aids or something. It wasn't a serious comment, it's to make the point that it's is useless research. Nothing to do with curing a disease. There are other better things to do. That is the point.
  • Aardfay moviebuff 2011/10/04 16:47:28
    Aardfay
    Thank you for clarifying.

    And I can understand that this study doesn't affect your life but it sure is not useless. Little by little we get to understand our bodies better, thanks to "useless research".
  • moviebuff Aardfay 2011/10/05 17:40:45
    moviebuff
    I admit that is true. And go ahead and google "useless research" you will find plenty of conversation worthy topics. Believe me. You will find alot.
  • Any moviebuff 2011/09/13 18:27:04
    Any
    +1
    A psychology researcher, much like you, doesn't have the qualifications to find a cure for AIDS. Or cancer, if that was your next argument.
  • moviebuff Any 2011/09/16 20:42:57
    moviebuff
    No that wasn't my argument but I get what your saying. Just like there are people out there that fund really crappy movies. Why not spend the money on other non necessary things. I gotta right to say what I wanna say. Just like this study: Suicide rates are linked to the amount of country music played on the radio, winner, Medicine, 2004. This my friend is what is called "irrelevant science" or silly science. look it up I ain't the only one that things so.This study got a nobel peace prize.
  • BornToBeWild 2011/09/12 14:52:44
    Bogus
    BornToBeWild
    +1
    It doesn't matter which hand you use to feed yourself, either hand will provide the same amount!
  • Aardfay BornToB... 2011/09/13 02:04:04
    Aardfay
    +1
    Do you really think so? Have you tried that?
  • BornToB... Aardfay 2011/09/13 04:39:58 (edited)
    BornToBeWild
    YES, your going to eat what you want no matter which hand feeds you! Controlled appetite works only if your willing to work it through a proper dietary plan!!
  • Aardfay BornToB... 2011/09/13 05:21:12
    Aardfay
    +2
    Of course. But this study didn't say that. They only concluded that people are not able to grab and eat as much food with their non-dominant hand. They didn't say "hey people, forget your diets, just eat with the other hand and you'll get thin".

    If someone really wants to eat a whole cake, they'll eat it no matter what. But they will not be able to grab the same amount of cake with both hands. One of the hands makes it faster for the cake to disappear than the other.

    But when people are used to finish their lunch at the same time a certain tv show ends, they will feel full at the end of the show, because of the habit. And if one hands makes it slower to eat a certain amount, they may just stop eating as their tv show ends, because they're used to it and their body tells them they're full.
  • BornToB... Aardfay 2011/09/13 22:30:01
    BornToBeWild
    and what about those who are both handed, ambidextrous? another example...three people sitting on the couch, the person in the middle holds a bowl of popcorn, a left handed person sitting to their left and right handed person to their right and each with a drink...which hand do you think the people sitting on both sides will use for grabbing the popcorn while holding their drinks?
  • Aardfay BornToB... 2011/09/14 01:16:13
    Aardfay
    Of course this can't work on ambidextrous.
    And I think that they would use the hand that is closer to the popcorn. But they might use their dominant hand. It depends of what feels easier. I would have to see what people usually do x) Why do you ask?
  • BornToB... Aardfay 2011/09/14 01:46:53
    BornToBeWild
    just trying to prove a point and don't rely on reports like this to be accurately true, that's all.
  • Aardfay BornToB... 2011/09/14 01:56:31
    Aardfay
    I don't see how that case applies to the issue. You're talking about what hand people choose to eat with, and not about the effects of eating with your non-dominant hand.
  • heirsoftheking 2011/09/12 14:25:42
    Brilliant
    heirsoftheking
    If that's the only hand you use, than YES, it'll make you eat less... Works for me.
  • PeeDonkeyPit 2011/09/12 14:09:54
    Brilliant
    PeeDonkeyPit
    +1
    Sure! You'll drop most of it on the floor on the way to your mouth, stick it up your nose, ear, cheek, etc. Until you get good at it...

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/24 21:47:11

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals