Quantcast

Extreme Parenting: To Leash or Not to Leash?

Fef 2012/06/26 02:01:02
Related Topics: Parenting, Kids Leash
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Kids need parents to protect them. And parents need tools to protect kids. But leashes? Kid leashes make make them safer, but putting leashes on humans (big or small) violates some expected cultural boundaries.

“I felt a little funny about it. We were on vacation with my sister-in-law in Seattle. I was juggling a bunch of children and worried about someone running out, and she said ‘Why don’t you put this on your daughter?’ So I did and it just kind of made sense,” said Mother of four and family psychologist Kristen Howerton of New York City.


ABCNews.com reports:It’s becoming almost a common sight–and a great debate for any modern family. To leash or not to leash small children? For parents across the country, there is no middle ground. Mother of four and family psychologist Kristen Howerton of New York City says she was given a safety harness as a gift. “I felt a little funny about it. We were on vacation with my sister-in-law in Seattle. I was juggling a bunch of children and worried about someone running out, and she said ‘Why don’t you put this on your daughter?’ So I did and it just kind…

Read More: http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/lifestyle/2012/06/extr...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • jgh57 2012/06/26 02:07:58
    Leash
    jgh57
    +6
    There is nothing wrong with using a leash. Anyone that thinks so should come and work a few shifts in the ER and see what happens when a child runs out in front of a car. It ain't pretty.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • C-ZAR™,... Robbb 2012/06/28 13:03:12
  • Robbb C-ZAR™,... 2012/06/29 08:17:16
    Robbb
    What with your obvious experience in the way of the behavior of all children. I wil just have to take your word for the acuracy of your statement
    In the meantime I wil just keep thinking the way I do (being able to judge from my experience)
  • Muskoka C-ZAR™,... 2012/06/26 23:33:59
    Muskoka
    Please explain who you do that 100% of the time with a 2 or 3 year old.
  • C-ZAR™,... Muskoka 2012/06/27 01:45:00
    C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT
    They are 2-3 years old, It's not hard, get some backbone and you won't need a leash
  • Muskoka C-ZAR™,... 2012/07/01 02:50:46
    Muskoka
    It has nothing to do with backbone, it is about controlling a child that has no sense of danger.
  • C-ZAR™,... Muskoka 2012/07/01 23:13:52
    C-ZAR™, Emperor of the PHÆT
    Yeah, so toughen up and control your child, stop trying to "be nice" you can "control" them without a Leash, i SEE it all the time
  • ☠ Live Free Or Die ☠ 2012/06/26 04:49:37
    Leash
    ☠ Live Free Or Die ☠
    +2
    It's a hell of a lot better than jerking your child around by the arm when they stray. THAT can cause breaks and dislocations. Child harnesses are perfectly harmless.

    ^^Dislocated wrist from mom keeping me out of traffic!
  • Don Leuty ☠ Live ... 2012/06/26 06:21:45
    Don Leuty
    Whiplash from mom changing her mind ad going to the D-aisle, instead. How about
    hand cuffs and leg irons for variety and special occasions. Contrary to popular belief, children may actually be trained. It becomes much harder after they are adults.
  • Muskoka Don Leuty 2012/06/26 23:36:15
    Muskoka
    +1
    Certainly children can be trained. But 2 and 3 years olds are not as obedient as you might think and safety is more important when they have a mind of their own.
  • Don Leuty Muskoka 2012/06/27 03:24:51
    Don Leuty
    Raised 7 without a leash. My one, and 6 nephews and nieces. Safety is so important that I'm not willing to try to control them with a safety hazard. Two and three are perfect ages because they seek approval so much. They are little sponges at that age, you just have to make certain they soak up the right things.

    If the first word a child learns isn't "No", then you are on the wrong path.
  • Muskoka Don Leuty 2012/07/01 02:55:49 (edited)
    Muskoka
    Just because they learn the word `no`does not mean they obey the word when they are very young.

    Not all situations are safe,.

    I always used to hold my daughter hand until I was at the CNE in Toronto one afternoon when the crowd became extremely dense and started closing in and I could not control the direction I was walking in. I could also feel my daughter hand slipping out of mine. I knew that if I let go of her hand she would be gone instantly and I would never find her in the crowd of thousand of people. It was one of the most difficult hours I have ever spent just trying to hand onto her and
    keep from being seperated from her.

    The next day, I noticed that her entire hand was completely brused and swollen. I had done that to her.
  • Don Leuty Muskoka 2012/07/01 10:17:29
    Don Leuty
    Obviously, your "No" wasn't interpreted the same way as mine. I avoided crowds like the plague. When caught in one, I had the advantage of being a male, using my strength advantage to carry my children.

    Because of my strength advantage, I always let the little ones grasp my pinky or my pants leg. Guess I learned that from Mom. She did a little training to impress the value of holding onto the hem of her dress.
  • Robbb Don Leuty 2012/06/27 09:19:21
    Robbb
    I only use them when I cant get a baby sitter for the night.
  • Don Leuty Robbb 2012/06/28 05:49:32
    Don Leuty
    OK?I?I??
  • blissful 2012/06/26 04:40:00
    Leash
    blissful
    +2
    I know it looks bad to the out-siders looking on, but sometimes like in this case. You feel you don't have a choice. When there is alot of little ones to look-after you honestly can't keep up with all of them. So you do what you thought you would never do and put a safety harness on the little-bundle..
  • Pele Emerging 2012/06/26 04:37:12
    Leash
    Pele Emerging
    +1
    It's the parents' business, not the busybodies around them. I'd rather see a kid leashed and safe than running wild.
  • ☠ Live ... Pele Em... 2012/06/26 23:41:43
    ☠ Live Free Or Die ☠
    +1
    Or parent's jerking their kids arms around like their made of rubber. My mom did that to me and it HURT.
  • Pele Em... ☠ Live ... 2012/06/26 23:53:11
    Pele Emerging
    +1
    I know from experience that a determined child can slip a parent's grip. Just a little inattention on the parent's part and a sneaky slip on the kid's part, and escape! In a strange place and with multiple kids, safety is a bigger deal than what other people might think. It does allow the kids a certain amount of freedom and as you mentioned, no jerked arms.
  • Stef and the City 2012/06/26 04:24:54 (edited)
    Leash
    Stef and the City
    +2
    I don't know about leashing kids but it's worked wonders for my boyfriend and I.
    Edit: All jokes aside, I am not against using a leash for children. As far as I'm concerned, they save lives.
  • Don Leuty Stef an... 2012/06/26 06:33:19
    Don Leuty
    +1
    ...Until some doofis takes a shortcut and tries to walk through the leash instead of around it. Or, the kid shouts, "PUPPY", takes off at a run, hits the end of the leash then succeeds at a synchronized land -- Head, heels and butt at the same time on the tile. Train the child well and it will not depart from the training.

    Keep it simple. Fewer parts, fewer problems and fewer unintended consequences.
  • writing_fanatic 2012/06/26 04:07:10
    Not to Leash
    writing_fanatic
    There should be an "it depends" button. There are certain situations-like safety or overly-hyper children. Or even an independence thing. But if it's because a parent is being too lazy to teach their child right, it would be different.
  • Muskoka writing... 2012/06/26 23:38:10
    Muskoka
    Sorry, but until the child is old enough to actually be thoroughly trained a leash may be necessary. 2 and 3 year olds are rarely 100% obedient
  • writing... Muskoka 2012/07/01 00:34:42
    writing_fanatic
    Right, and I said that. I'm just saying that if the parents are way too lazy to even begin to train them, that's when they're an issue.
  • Zak Smith 2012/06/26 03:59:03
    Not to Leash
    Zak Smith
    +1
    Lazy parenting. My kids are not animals and can be taught not to act terribly or to run off, and since they are kids and tend to forget the rules from time to time, as is natural for kids, I pay attention to them.
  • Kitty 2012/06/26 03:45:38
    Not to Leash
    Kitty
    +1
    'extreme' parenting more like lazy parenting.
  • Muskoka Kitty 2012/06/26 23:38:38
    Muskoka
    Sorry, but until the child is old enough to actually be thoroughly trained a leash may be necessary. 2 and 3 year olds are rarely 100% obedient
  • SlaveWaterNymph 2012/06/26 03:28:22
    Not to Leash
    SlaveWaterNymph
    But i think it is funny, when i put a leash on my collar, for my lifestyle, i get all this hateful glares and what not. and probably someone would come up and say something hateful about it. But you do this to children, it is fine. I just think it is funny, you can be okay with it one way and not another way.
  • volley15 2012/06/26 03:05:29
    Leash
    volley15
    +2
    In some places. I won't take my son on the Metro without him being on his harness leash. I don't want him anywhere near the ledge of the platform. It scares me to death whenever I see little kids run right up to the very edge.

    Then if I know I'm going to be at the mall during a very busy day at peak shopping hours then I'll use his leash then as well.

    I don't use it often. Only when his safety is the most at risk with him being an energetic three year old who likes to run all over the place.
  • Stef an... volley15 2012/06/26 04:30:33
    Stef and the City
    Good for you! It's better to be safe than sorry. I see more and more people using them these days.
  • volley15 Stef an... 2012/06/26 05:17:20 (edited)
    volley15
    +1
    He's normally pretty good about staying with me but there are just some times that I feel better with him basically tethered to me. Especially since he's not the biggest fan of holding anyone's hand; he'll fight it and throw a fit till you just let him walk at your side. Still, he'll dart off if we're not careful.
  • Muskoka volley15 2012/06/26 23:39:15
    Muskoka
    I agree, better safe than have a tragidy.
  • vetogod 2012/06/26 02:52:29
    Not to Leash
    vetogod
    +3
    they are not a damn dog dont be lazy and actually keep track of your kid
  • Muskoka vetogod 2012/06/26 23:40:14
    Muskoka
    Sorry, but until the child is old enough to actually be thoroughly trained a leash may be necessary. 2 and 3 year olds are rarely 100% obedient, they do have minds of their own and can be extremely spontaneous.
  • vetogod Muskoka 2012/06/26 23:47:05
    vetogod
    well then dont be lazy and make and effort to make them listen to you if you let them get out of control what makes you think they will listen to you later? if your a parent bring back spanking and give them discipline i was spanked and yes i have a dark sense of humor but i grew up respecting my father and now i thank him for spanking me cause it taught me some respect and taught me where my place is, if a child gets out of control give them a spank and make them stand in a corner even if you have to hold them there it will teach them whats acceptable and whats not acceptable
  • Muskoka vetogod 2012/07/01 02:57:58
    Muskoka
    Speak for yourself. I was never a lazy parent.

    Not all situations are safe,.

    I always used to hold my daughter hand until I was at the CNE in Toronto one afternoon when the crowd became extremely dense and started closing in and I could not control the direction I was walking in. I could also feel my daughter hand slipping out of mine. I knew that if I let go of her hand she would be gone instantly and I would never find her in the crowd of thousand of people. It was one of the most difficult hours I have ever spent just trying to hand onto her and
    keep from being seperated from her.

    The next day, I noticed that her entire hand was completely brused and swollen. I had done that to her.
  • Mecynogea 2012/06/26 02:49:11
    Not to Leash
    Mecynogea
    +1
    Aaaah I still remember those days when I was hand to hand with my mom...
    Seriously, why leashes?
  • ☠ Live ... Mecynogea 2012/06/26 04:51:26
    ☠ Live Free Or Die ☠
    +1
    Because getting your arm yanked on hurts.
  • Mecynogea ☠ Live ... 2012/06/26 14:48:39
    Mecynogea
    I never had pain in my arm when I was holding my mom's hand, and I don't really think it hurts to the mom either.
  • ☠ Live ... Mecynogea 2012/06/26 23:29:26
    ☠ Live Free Or Die ☠
    Maybe because your mom didn't yank on your arm like it was made of rubber? When I was 4, I was walking beside my mom and I ran toward a busy street. She grabbed my hand and jerked on it so hard that it dislocated my wrist.
  • vetogod ☠ Live ... 2012/06/26 23:48:21
    vetogod
    saved you from getting killed though

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/19 12:26:04

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals