Quantcast

Eating Meat May Cause Cancer: Believable or Bogus?

SodaHead Living 2011/05/23 17:51:20
You!
Add Photos & Videos
WebMD reports that yet another everyday item could be killing you, and this time the culprit is meat.

According to a recent study by the American Institute for Cancer Research and the World Cancer Research Fund, reducing your intake of red meat and processed meat could significantly reduce your risk for colon cancer.

When this advice is combined with other diet and lifestyle changes -- such as consuming less alcohol, boosting fiber intake, exercising, and maintaining a healthy body weight -- it could prevent 45% of all colon cancer cases, or more than 64,000 cases of colon cancer each year, the report states.

So we'll go ahead and add that to the list of things that are sure to kill us, right next to alcohol and the sun.

Read More: http://www.webmd.com/colorectal-cancer/news/201105...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Munster 2011/05/24 07:14:56
    Believable
    Munster
    +11
    At this rate, breathing can cause cancer. Live life, eat steak and potatoes, be happy.

    rate breathing cancer live life eat steak potatoes happy steak and potatoes

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • JuliaLoren 2012/03/25 19:28:55
    Believable
    JuliaLoren
    with all the hormones, lack of medical care, terrible feed, and horrible conditions the animals deal with, you'd have to be pretty ignorant to think the meat would be very good for you...
  • Starchild 2011/10/05 11:00:24 (edited)
    Believable
    Starchild
    If you'd watched the new film "Forks Over Knives", you wouldn't be answering bogus. There's actually a LOT of evidence of meat-eating causing cancer and many other health problems.

    forks over knives
  • Tan Tan 2011/06/16 00:33:40
    Believable
    Tan Tan
    Anything & Everything leads to either good or bad. I'de rather live happy doing what I want. Even if I die younger than Im suppose to. You could die tomorrow just by accident. There are ways to prevent & be safe but as long as you don't over do things then it might just work out enough to where your life was a good life. I don't do drugs or drink alcohol and I don't live dangerously, Im no health nut either but Im comfortable & content. So good medicine is to have fun & live happy!
  • rh mlo 2011/06/14 21:59:58
    Believable
    rh mlo
    in the book in defnse of food by michael pollan, his philosophy was to eat food, not too much and the keypoint mostly plants!!
  • Jess Dollface 2011/06/09 02:23:30
    Believable
    Jess Dollface
    +1
    Most meats end up rotting in the colon because humans aren't made to digest meat. Another reason why I love veggies!
  • linlin 2011/06/08 21:15:14
    Believable
    linlin
    There's so much added to meat-in terms of colors,hormones, antibiotics. Farmed fish have a lot of pollutants and even antibiotics(and ocean fish have mercury, etc,) Vegetarianism is your best bet!
  • waynelaboy 2011/06/03 16:29:56 (edited)
    Believable
    waynelaboy
    by positioning your answers the way you do i can tell that you want a favorable outcome on certain questions that you are for or against. but keep on eating meat and you'll be at the doctors. then again that's part of the reason you're there now.
  • Dramarama 2011/05/31 23:48:58
    Believable
    Dramarama
    +1
    I quit eating all meat except seafood and poultry years ago for exactly this reason
  • disclaimer 2011/05/29 01:37:19
    Bogus
    disclaimer
    +1
    Bogus until I hear real proof. Colon cancer isn't that common anyway.
  • linlin disclaimer 2011/06/08 21:18:58
    linlin
    Um.....colon cancer is right up there-one of the top 3 cancers for men-google it and you'll see!
  • sml 2011/05/28 14:05:55
    Bogus
    sml
    Its a fact - life KILLS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! We ALL die sooner or later so we might as well enjoy it while we can!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Skip 2011/05/28 02:59:41
    Bogus
    Skip
    Everyone dies. You can't avoid it. You might as well enjoy the taste of meat while you can.
  • HBO 2011/05/27 23:12:14
    Bogus
    HBO
    Oh lord...what next ? They're always saying this and that raises your risk of cancer, but this and that lower your risk, so shouldn't everything we eat be cancelling each other out ? It's really simple...try to live healthy and hope you stay that way. If you do that and you still get cancer, well then nothing you did probably would have caused it or prevented it. But if your body and mind is healthy and strong I would think you would have a better chance of fighting it.
  • lu lu 2011/05/27 16:25:53
    Believable
    lu lu
    Believable my late husband was a heavy meat eater no veggies & he died of colon cancer
  • havoc 2011/05/27 09:28:14
    Believable
    havoc
    Some preservatives in meat such as Sodium Nitrate are known to cause cancer so there could be some truth to this.
  • Tony 2011/05/26 22:03:07 (edited)
    Believable
    Tony
    YES. AND IGNORANCE "IS" THEREFORE A WEAPON OF MASS DESTRUCTION. ignorance weapon mass destruction
  • InuyashaLover:D 2011/05/26 19:06:23
    Believable
    InuyashaLover:D
    My mom can't eat much meat cause it might cause her cancer to happen again... I'm a proud Flexatarian
  • martin28 2011/05/26 16:25:41
    Believable
    martin28
    +2
    With all the crap fed to animals, it's no surprise cancer is caused when you eat the animal.
  • RobinPeta 2011/05/26 14:49:58
    Believable
    RobinPeta
    So people believe their cancerous guts over serious scientific studies? Some people are just stupid.
  • SarahAnne 2011/05/26 11:55:22
    Bogus
    SarahAnne
    Well I don't each that much meat, and anyway, not long ago we were told to eat lots of red meat so we can stay healthy, now they've changed their minds?!
  • handeman 2011/05/26 04:47:50
    Bogus
    handeman
    Life causes cancer, deal.
  • trudy.padden 2011/05/26 02:55:55
    Bogus
    trudy.padden
    +2
    THEY SAY EVERYTHING CAUSES CANCER..WE MIGHT AS WELL B IN A BOX EATING Paper ALL DAY TO NOT GET CANCER
  • smidget101 2011/05/26 00:08:08
    Believable
    smidget101
    +4
    if this is actually true then i am REALLY glad that i am a vegetarian ^.^
  • gidianedwards97 2011/05/25 23:37:25
    Believable
    gidianedwards97
    Believable , why because cow eat grasses and legumes and look what happens to then they grow so much muscle and we as humans from frothe from the mouth over them. So what if we ate what they eat maybe the same could happen to us.
  • angel 2011/05/25 23:23:14
    Bogus
    angel
    i eat meat every day but it depends on how old it is and how well it's cooked!!!
  • martin28 angel 2011/05/26 16:28:51
    martin28
    +1
    So you can cook the chemicals out of a cow that has been eating chemical saturated food all it's life?
  • DPT 2011/05/25 22:49:21
    Bogus
    DPT
    +1
    Right... and smelling flowers gives you nasal cancer, and cow farts cause global warming. When are the anti-capitalistic, environmentalist, animals rights whackos going to get off this nut-job claim!?
  • Ozzyboy 2011/05/25 22:38:19
    Bogus
    Ozzyboy
    Peta sent this story in didn't they?
  • COMALite J 2011/05/25 15:42:56
    Believable
    COMALite J
    The key words here are red and processed meat. They’re loaded with known carcinogens, from the hormones and antibiotics force-fed to beef cattle to make them grow more meat, to the nitrites and nitrates used in processed luncheon meats such as ham, salami, Spam®, pepperoni, etc.
  • Brenda777 2011/05/25 15:15:52
    Bogus
    Brenda777
    +1
    The key word here is "MAY" cause cancer. Since they don`t know what sets off cancer cells to grow, why give meat a bad rap. If that is the case, then about 75% of the country population is or will be stricken with cancer from eating red or processed meats. One week certain food or item is good for you, the next week that same mentioned is found detrimental to your health. Live in moderation is about the best one can do for themselves and stop reading medical studies or as Mark Twain said, "don`t read medical books you could die from a misprint."
  • T 2011/05/25 14:57:02
    Believable
    T
    Too much of anything is bad for you. The question is how much meat it takes to cause cancer.
  • RobertChristopherLaity 2011/05/25 14:21:03
    Believable
    RobertChristopherLaity
    Man was never meant to be carnivorous. Our diets started with nuts,vegegies,fruits,....no meat.
    Homo Sapiens evolved into eating meat. Eating meat is not the culprit but the amount we eat.
    The practice of Charring meat on a BBQ Grill also is involved. That causes the processing of toxic subtances that are carcinogenic. Meat is not "sure to kill us" however,it may if we aren't cautious as to how it is prepared and concerns about portions. Meat takes a while to digest. If our diets are deficient in fruits,vegetables,nuts and grains (Fiber),our GI track will harbor undigested meat in it for days.. Fiber helps the GI tract move the food we eat along. Nutrients are absorbed in the body AS it PASSES through. The body is a remarkable creation.If we keep it in good operating order it will serve us well. Exercise,stress reduction,healthy eating.,all contribute to our general health and welfare. BTW,cells in our bodies reproduce continuously.Some of those cells become cancerous,on a daily basis. Cancer is not dangerous if one has a healthy immune system. On a daily basis our immune system sends out Macrophages on daily ssignments and missions. A macrophage attack on cancer leaves the errant cells defenseless. It is when errant cancerous cells get a foothold that cancer becomes dangerous. A healthy body and mind is the key to survival and the key to defeating diseases of all kinds,including cancer.
  • COMALite J RobertC... 2011/05/25 15:37:16 (edited)
    COMALite J
    +2
    Man is omniverous. We are naturally hunter-gatherers. We have cuspid (“canine” — interesting word, that) and bicuspid teeth (specialized for tearing flesh), which mainly carnivores have. We also have molars (specialized for grinding fiber and nuts), which mainly herbivores have.

    Moreover, predator animals almost always have their eyes on the front of their heads, while prey animals almost always have their eyes on the sides of their heads, and both for good reason: the predators need to watch the prey in front of them and be able to judge the distance for a pounce, etc., and thus need the stereooptical depth perception. Prey need to be able to see all around them, seeing a potential attack coming from any direction.

    Note that this even holds true for reptiles and birds as well as mammals. Hawks and eagles? Eyes in front. Robins, sparrows, ducks, and the like? Eyes on the side. Predatory snakes? Eyes toward the front. Lizards, garden snakes, chameleons, and other reptilian prey? Eyes on the side.

    Look in the mirror. Where are your eyes? Thought so.

    Also, meat is the primary source of cyanocobalmin (aka Vitamin B 12 ), without which we die of aplastic anemia. A less-severe deficiency causes all manner of less serious but still devastating illnesses and conditions. The...
    Man is omniverous. We are naturally hunter-gatherers. We have cuspid (“canine” — interesting word, that) and bicuspid teeth (specialized for tearing flesh), which mainly carnivores have. We also have molars (specialized for grinding fiber and nuts), which mainly herbivores have.

    Moreover, predator animals almost always have their eyes on the front of their heads, while prey animals almost always have their eyes on the sides of their heads, and both for good reason: the predators need to watch the prey in front of them and be able to judge the distance for a pounce, etc., and thus need the stereooptical depth perception. Prey need to be able to see all around them, seeing a potential attack coming from any direction.

    Note that this even holds true for reptiles and birds as well as mammals. Hawks and eagles? Eyes in front. Robins, sparrows, ducks, and the like? Eyes on the side. Predatory snakes? Eyes toward the front. Lizards, garden snakes, chameleons, and other reptilian prey? Eyes on the side.

    Look in the mirror. Where are your eyes? Thought so.

    Also, meat is the primary source of cyanocobalmin (aka Vitamin B12), without which we die of aplastic anemia. A less-severe deficiency causes all manner of less serious but still devastating illnesses and conditions. There are a few viable plant sources of cyanocobalmin, but they do not grow worldwide, but only in a few places. Cyanocobalmin is not the only such meat-specific vital nutrient, either. Thus, it cannot be claimed that a meatless diet is natural for our species, since it would be impossible to fulfill it everywhere on Earth without some sort of technology (and transportation of foodstuffs from distant climes counts as technology).
    (more)
  • Skip RobertC... 2011/05/28 03:08:54
    Skip
    How is it that you say; "Homo Sapiens evolved into eating meat" and then you said; "The body is a remarkable creation". Which is it, a creation or an evolution? And how do you know that man was never meant to be carnivorous?
  • Lucia 2011/05/25 14:11:29
    Believable
    Lucia
    +2
    I don't understand why this is even a poll. Reading the comments here, it seems that people are just deciding what they would like to believe. Major confirmation bias. Unless someone has an objection to the methodology used in conducting the study, they aren't really in a position to argue with the results. What is it about the way the study was conducted that leads you to believe it is bogus? You aren't convincing anyone when you say, "Oh everything gives you cancer, this is more crap." Really? What does that mean? That's your opinion. Your unfounded opinion versus a legitimate study. Yeah...
  • Leeaqua 2011/05/25 13:58:45 (edited)
    Believable
    Leeaqua
    Too much of anything is no good except maybe money !
  • BlazeEagle 2011/05/25 09:42:21
    Bogus
    BlazeEagle
    Meat isn’t the problem, An personal assumption of mine is that the problem is more likely the additives & other artificial substances fed to livestock that gives meat a bad reputation among certain circles.
  • MAss_inferno 2011/05/25 09:26:26
    Bogus
    MAss_inferno
    +1
    nowadays evrything causes cancer, we cant walk dwn the street without gettin it
  • DiJohnny 2011/05/25 07:36:23
    Bogus
    DiJohnny
    +1
    It depends on if you're talking about processed, and treated meat with growth hormones, and what they're fed...
    Best to get organic, free range, and grass fed beef, chicken and pork.
  • nancy 2011/05/25 05:32:30
    Believable
    nancy
    +3
    This is true and has been common knowledge for quite some time.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 13 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/24 22:16:35

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals