Quantcast

Do You Believe That Animals Held In Captivity Can Be Safely Released In The Wild?

Little Angel 2012/05/07 18:56:14
Yes, this is a safe thing for tamed animals...
No, this is not a good idea...
Undecided
None of the above
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Marmaris, Turkey (CNN) -- For more than a year,
experts have been at work in a quiet cove on the Aegean Sea, teaching a
pair of male bottlenose dolphins how to catch their own food. Every day,
the team releases dozens of live fish into giant sea pen where the
dolphins named Tom and Misha live.


The two males then race
around the pen, diving, darting and somersaulting down to depths of 45
feet in pursuit of their frightened prey. Like a proud father, trainer
Jeff Foster watches from the narrow dock that encircles the pen.


Not long ago, he said, Tom and Misha had no idea what to do with live fish.


"We had literally
thousands of fish in the pen, and they just wouldn't look at them,"
Foster said. "They had just been so used to being hand-fed in a captive
situation that they did not recognize fish as a food source."


When Foster first met the
dolphins more than a year ago, he said they would only eat if humans
placed dead fish directly in their mouths. If fish was thrown into the
pen, it would go untouched and end up rotting at the bottom of the sea
pen.




Both dolphins were in failing health when wildlife activists discovered them at a run-down tourist park in 2010.

Both dolphins were in failing health when wildlife activists discovered them at a run-down tourist park in 2010.


Tom and Misha are part of the Back to the Blue project, an expensive, risky and somewhat controversial experiment to reintroduce captive animals into the wild.


"It would be like taking
your dog and releasing it into the woods," Foster said. "If you don't
prepare your dog for that, it would never happen."


Foster, a Seattle-based
expert on marine mammals, had experience with another high-profile
release program that ultimately ended in failure.


More than 10 years ago,
he worked in Iceland as part of a multimillion-dollar effort to prepare
the killer whale Keiko from the 1993 movie "Free Willy" for release into
the wild. Less than a year after his release, Keiko died off Norway.


But Foster said he believes Tom and Misha stand a much better chance of survival.


"These animals haven't
been in captivity as long as Keiko," he said. "Keiko was held in
captivity for more than 20 years. He was held as a solitary animal for
many of those years."


The two dolphins, who are both about 12 years old, have been in captivity for five or six years, he said.


"They've probably spent
the majority of their life out in the wild," Foster said. "Because we're
dealing with two males, you can develop competition feeding with them.
... They're ideal candidates for reintroduction back into the wild."




Dolphin parks, like the one where Misha and Tom were found, are prevalent in Turkey, although not fully regulated.

Dolphin parks, like the one where Misha and Tom were found, are prevalent in Turkey, although not fully regulated.


Tom and Misha first
attracted the attention of wildlife conservation activists in 2010. At
the time, they were kept at a Turkish resort, where tourists paid to
swim with the dolphins in a shallow, filthy swimming pool.


"The pool in Hisaronu,
Turkey, where Tom and Misha had spent the summer months of 2010 had such
a high bacterial count ... that it was a significant health hazard to
the dolphins and for the unsuspecting tourists who paid to swim with
them," Shirley Galligan, a representative of the Born Free Foundation,
wrote in an e-mail to CNN. "The water was filthy with feces and dead
fish and a layer of 'sludge' at the bottom."


According to Born Free, a
nonprofit conservation group based in the United Kingdom, the dolphins
were underweight and listless and would not have survived much longer in
the pool, which "having been hastily constructed, was in danger of
collapse from subsidence."


A coalition of
environmental groups successfully campaigned to rescue the animals and
transport them in the back of a truck to a sea pen in the Aegean.


Born Free has taken over
the costly and time-consuming program to rehabilitate Tom and Misha. So
far, the effort has cost $800,000.


Both dolphins are
expected to be released within a matter of days. Born Free is keeping
the exact time and location of their release secret to protect the
animals from curious human visitors, excessive boat traffic and the
threat of poachers.


Tom and Misha's progress
will be monitored with specially designed satellite tracking devices
that will be pinned to their dorsal fins.


Even the sponsors of the program admit there is no guarantee of success.


"There have only been a
handful of reintroduction (programs) with mixed results," Galligan
wrote. "Returning any captive wild animal to the wild is never without
risk."



Returning any captive wild animal to the wild is never without risk.
Shirley Galligan, Born Free Foundation


One of the only
successful cetacean reintroductions on record involved an orphaned
female orca named Springer. Foster was a member of the team that helped
rehabilitate the emaciated animal and eventually reintroduce her to a
pod of related killer whales off Canada's Pacific coast a decade ago. She has reportedly survived and thrived in those waters.


Michael Moore, a marine mammal expert at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, predicted major challenges for Tom and Misha in the weeks and months ahead.


"Can they break the bond
with humans, and can they create a bond with other (wild) dolphins?" he
asked in a phone interview with CNN.


"The irony is that if
these animals do get released into the wild, it's a big, bad world out
there, and they will have to learn how not to get entangled in fishing
gear."


According to Moore, Tom
and Misha's release will have virtually no impact on the world's wild
dolphin population, which faces an onslaught from industrial fishing
nets, decimated fish stocks and polluted seas.


But he and other dolphin
experts say successful reintroduction could both increase biodiversity
awareness in Turkey and set an important example for the multimillion-dollar captive marine mammal entertainment industry.


There has been a rapid
increase in the number of dolphinariums and "swim-with-dolphin" programs
cropping up across Turkey over the last decade.

Do you believe that Animals that have been in captivity can be safely released

in the wild?

Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • BlondeAphrodite 2012/09/13 21:51:09
    No, this is not a good idea...
    BlondeAphrodite
    unfortunetely no
  • Vision of Verve 2012/06/05 21:05:06
  • susan BN-0 2012/06/05 17:37:12
    Undecided
    susan BN-0
    I don't know,I'm not an animal expert,but I think It's sad that they were In captivity In the first place,why do people think animals are here for our entertainment It's sick.
  • Brian ☮ R P ☮ 2012 ☮ 2012/06/05 15:56:54
    None of the above
    Brian ☮ R P ☮ 2012 ☮
    Animals held AND raised in captivity, simply cannot develop the skills and instincts needed to live in the wild. Wild animals, captured in the wild and held for short periods, will never lose those skills and instincts, and can be released back into the wild.
  • Rowena Ravenclaw 2012/06/05 15:50:54
    None of the above
    Rowena Ravenclaw
    The only animals that need to be in enclosures are endangered or rescue animals. Non-threatened animals belong in the wild and should never be disturbed there.

    Releasing animals back into the wild all depends on the animal itself. Some animals it works fine for, but others it takes some time...
  • Jack's Pearl 2012/06/05 15:43:59
    No, this is not a good idea...
    Jack's Pearl
    They don't have the habits for living in the wild.
  • Flowers 2012/06/05 14:08:31
    Undecided
    Flowers
    Like the article says, It has to be done slowly and by trained professionals. I think ALL animals in the captivity should be trained and interacted with as if they were releasing them into the wild eventually. That way, the animals wouldn't have to relearn how to be wild. For example, animals in captivity shouldn't just be given food and teach them that food from human trainers hand is a 'treat' Lions should be given the chance to hunt their prey and eat them like they would in the wild. It will never happen though. Because people are not ready for that to be seen with their own eyes. It's a shame IMO
  • Sharon1992 2012/06/05 07:29:04
    Undecided
    Sharon1992
    It depends on a matter of factors, like how old the animal was when it was caught, if the location of its family is known, etc. It is not a good thing however to release captive-born cetaceans into the wild, because they don't know anything besides their concrete box. That doesn't make it right however.
  • Vitalani 2012/05/08 23:43:28
    Undecided
    Vitalani
    It can be a great thing. Anyone with any common sense what so ever knows that wild animals are NEVER fully tamed. They will always have their basic instincts for survival. Of course the longer they are held in captivity the worse their chances are for surviving. But animals are caught, rehabbed, and released ALL the time and they do perfectly well. Rehabbing wild animals is proven to work.
  • merlinskiss 2012/05/08 22:41:12
    None of the above
    merlinskiss
    I do not believe in holding animals in captivity,,, Unless they are politicians... Then, they should all be caged and only released when they do the right tricks...
  • Little Angel 2012/05/08 19:17:25
    No, this is not a good idea...
    Little Angel
    This might work in some cases, depending on the animal and if it is
    taught to survive on it's own. There is no guarantee that it would
    work and they may try to return to where they were set free.
  • POWERSHAKER 2012/05/08 16:13:58
    None of the above
    POWERSHAKER
    If you ask me, they should never be penned up in the first place. They should be left alone in the wild. It's pretty bad when you have to teach a dolphin how to catch their own prey. Dolphins were never meant to be caged.
  • Lerro DeHazel 2012/05/08 15:24:17
    No, this is not a good idea...
    Lerro DeHazel
    +1
    No this is NOT a good idea.
  • joshua ben-ami 2012/05/08 15:13:38
    None of the above
    joshua ben-ami
    Sure, done properly many species can be re-introduced into the wild....
  • ur XLNC 2012/05/08 02:36:57
    No, this is not a good idea...
    ur XLNC
    +1
    This is a no brainer. A critter that is accustomed to being fed without any effort on its part will not survive, or it will seek out people that don't understand that the critter just wants a handout.
  • Kat 2012/05/08 02:23:49
    No, this is not a good idea...
    Kat
    There are a lot of things they couldn't prepare them for in the wild. Going from a neat orderly life in an aquarium or water park to the wild, find your own food, evade predators, tides, storms to avoid, many variables that couldn't be taught to help live in the wild. Unless they've been there a very short time and already know survival skills.
  • beachbum 2012/05/08 01:10:22
    None of the above
    beachbum
    For some, definitely.........depends on the animal, length of captivity, any injury or that sort of thing.
  • Piperpc 2012/05/07 22:42:21
    Undecided
    Piperpc
    +1
    I believe that sometimes, this works. Depends on the circumstances of the captivity, of course, and the time spent in captivity. I'd rather see Tom and Misha have some brief freedom in their natural environment, than to suffer in the kind of place they were rescued from. Their survival is a "roll of the dice".
  • Jerry 2012/05/07 22:28:12
    Undecided
    Jerry
    Not just released in the wild, if originally they were captured, " special considerations on the protection and welfare need to be recognized, and adhered to ".........
  • aherbert 2012/05/07 20:00:57
    Undecided
    aherbert
    I do not know I am not an anmimal expert ... I hope so though ... I hope rescued wild animals can be released backed into the wild.
  • gregaj7 2012/05/07 19:24:06
    No, this is not a good idea...
    gregaj7
    +1
    Like sending a poodle out to be part of a pack of wolves.
  • Dagon 2012/05/07 19:19:13 (edited)
  • Pat 2012/05/07 19:09:21
    Undecided
    Pat
    I think that they are trying to prepare the dolphins as best they can but the wild is so totally different from their current environment, I worry that they may not make it. Some captive animals are rescued and release to "sanctuaries" where they have far more freedom but can still be looked after since they don't have the skills for living in the wild. Dolphins and whales are such large animals I don't know how it would be possible to prepare them for the wild. I feel so bad for them.
  • Sister Jean 2012/05/07 19:07:16
    No, this is not a good idea...
    Sister Jean
  • BornToBeWild 2012/05/07 19:04:33
    Yes, this is a safe thing for tamed animals...
    BornToBeWild
    with proper training and knowing how intelligent they are...their own instincts can also prevail to their existence back in the wild! Once they are excepted into a group of others, they will continue to learn and survive!
  • User Deactivated 2012/05/07 19:01:45
    Undecided
    User Deactivated
    Any animal kept in captivity long enough loses some of its primal instincts and such. This can prevent them from hunting or protecting themselves properly at times. Though things can be done for them while in captivity to help those things along. Sometimes it is necessary to keep an animal if it is injured or the like, but it shouldn't just be done for the sake of doing it, then releasing them.
  • bob h. 2012/05/07 18:59:27
    No, this is not a good idea...
    bob h.
    +1
    No, they have no survival skills for the wild.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/19 05:50:56

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals