Quantcast

Diet Soda May Be Worse for You Than Regular: Which Do You Drink?

SodaHead Living 2011/02/10 15:59:08
Related Topics: Diet, Coke, Health
You!
Add Photos & Videos
You may think you're being healthy when you crack open a can of Diet Coke, but drinking these types of soft drinks regularly may raise your risk of heart attack and stroke, according to a new study.

In a nine-year study of more than 2,500 people, those who drank diet soda every day were 48 percent more likely to have a heart attack or stroke or die from those events, compared with those who rarely or never drank soda, WebMD reports.

Believe it or not, you may be better off opting for a can of regular. There was no increased risk of cardiovascular disorders among daily drinkers of regular soda, says study researcher Hannah Gardener, an epidemiologist at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, according to the health website.

But experts say the study is inconclusive -- and drinking diet soda instead of regular soda may still be a healthier choice.

"The body of scientific evidence does show that diet soft drinks can be a useful weight management tool, a position supported by the American Dietetic Association," Maureen Storey, senior vice president of science policy for the American Beverage Association, told WebMD.

Storey says researchers failed to control for two important variables -- family history of stroke and weight gain -- that affect stroke risk.

No matter how you look at it, diet soda is not a healthy beverage. It is not a naturally occurring substance, and it offers no nutritional benefits. That said, sugary regular soda has been blamed for obesity and other health issues.

Bottom line: Don't drink soda, period!

Read More: http://www.webmd.com/stroke/news/20110209/is-diet-...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Sister Jean 2011/02/10 16:06:52
    I drink regular
    Sister Jean
    +12
    and I am tired of post being stolen...I put this on yesterday as soon as it made the news!!!! tired post stolen yesterday news grrr

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • ryan 2011/09/28 17:05:04
    I drink regular
    ryan
    i like soda alot
  • That_Kid_That_Everyone_Hates 2011/02/21 06:15:13
  • MorganRae 2011/02/16 18:30:46
    I drink regular
    MorganRae
    Diet pop tastes like poison
  • Jim in SC 2011/02/12 02:57:32
    I drink regular
    Jim in SC
    I don't like the taste of the artificial sweeteners. My favorite is soda from Central/South America where they still use pure cane sugar. That is the best Coca-Cola I have ever had.
  • MorganRae Jim in SC 2011/02/16 18:32:15
    MorganRae
    +2
    Have you ever tried the brand 'Jones'? they have a bunch of wacky flavors and they're all made with pure cane sugar.
  • Jim in SC MorganRae 2011/02/16 18:33:16
    Jim in SC
    Never have. I might try it out now, knowing that. They're probably really good.
  • jade 2011/02/11 23:00:37
    I drink diet
    jade
    I've never thought that it was healthy but then again I haven't drank it because of it's 'health benefits' I just think it tastes better
  • Vanquished 2011/02/11 21:35:23
    I drink diet
    Vanquished
    Because things are correlated doesn't necessarily mean they are causally related.
    There are a few things here that make this seem false. People who drink diet more likely than not have a weight problem, those who drink regular are less likely too. Also, Maybe it has something to do with the caffeine intake of those who drink diet daily. The study doesn't compare diet with regular, it compares diet with no soda... The whole thing is flawed. I'll take my cancer from diet over diabetes from regular.
  • IndyLinda 2011/02/11 21:33:17
    I drink regular
    IndyLinda
    About three times a year, LOLz!
  • Scruffy 2011/02/11 21:13:22
    I drink regular
    Scruffy
    Diet soda IS BAD for you!
    If you want to save calories drink lite beer! :)
  • PhilCooper 2011/02/11 21:07:09
    I drink regular
    PhilCooper
    I actually prefer plain, filtered water, room temperature, that I buy in bulk in my own reusable jug from a local store.
  • Chris G... PhilCooper 2011/10/08 09:07:42
    Chris Godwin
    +2
    That you drink with your man life partner, right queer bait?
  • PhilCooper Chris G... 2011/10/20 23:56:00
    PhilCooper
    If I excite you, Chris, the problem is with you, not my appearance.
  • Dagon 2011/02/11 20:38:02
  • Scruffy Dagon 2011/02/11 21:15:30
    Scruffy
    You need to do better research.
  • Dagon Scruffy 2011/02/14 20:08:37
  • RobertJames 2011/02/11 20:29:41
  • Trust Noone 2011/02/11 20:10:35
    I drink diet
    Trust Noone
    +2
    I drink diet soda when eating 5 cheese burgers and 3 orders of fries, this way I can justify eating like a pig.
  • LindaFawkes 2011/02/11 19:43:47
    I drink diet
    LindaFawkes
    I drink diet but very RARELY now as I found out that coke rots your teeth! There is a substance in it that is acidy and it is one of the worst drinks you can have. I used to drink it by the gallon many years ago when I was anorexic - to fill me up - but now I only drink it if there isn't anything else. teeth substance acidy drinks drink gallon years anorexic drink rotten teeth
  • PhilCooper LindaFa... 2011/02/11 21:11:00
    PhilCooper
    It's phosphoric acid, an additive in most colas to give them tartness and act as a preservative. Phosphoric acid is also an excellent rust remover and stain remover on concrete. Oral bacteria produce acids as well from their digestion of carbohydrates — candies, refined starches, etc. — which contributes to tooth decay. At least diet sodas don't have the sugars that bacteria can digest.
  • Jessicmaka! The cleavage qu... 2011/02/11 18:55:22
    I drink regular
    Jessicmaka! The cleavage queen of  ~PHAET~
    Diet pop tastes like crap.
  • Lena 2011/02/11 18:26:40
    I drink diet
    Lena
    i drink diet but not all the time
  • Dallas 2011/02/11 17:57:56
    I drink regular
    Dallas
    It's bad either way, but if I'm gonna drink it, it's gonna be the good stuff!
  • Catlareu 2011/02/11 17:06:32
    I drink regular
    Catlareu
    Diet soda tastes nasty! I don't drink soda that much, but when I do I want the real thing!
  • xxxx_XX 2011/02/11 17:01:04 (edited)
    I drink regular
    xxxx_XX
    +1
    Has anyone notice the very obvious: Usually it's the FAT people drinking the diet soda's and the skinny ones like me drinking the regular beverages. Pepsi throwback does not contain corn syrup either!
  • Catlareu xxxx_XX 2011/02/11 17:07:20
    Catlareu
    Can we feel the love?
  • Dagon xxxx_XX 2011/02/11 20:39:33
  • xxxx_XX Dagon 2011/03/03 00:32:18
    xxxx_XX
    +1
    Of course respectfully: mellitus sufferers have to take necessary measures.
    Diet and exercise is also crucial in that case.
    Wish you well !!!
  • AndyWolf 2011/02/11 17:00:30
    I drink regular
    AndyWolf
    +1
    Soda is a treat for me. I like to go to the A&W; and get a float after a more-grueling-than normal workout. I cannot drink diet. I'm actually allergic to Aspartame. All other artificial sweeteners just give me a headache. I always know when I accidentally drank something with artificial stuff in it.
  • Catlareu AndyWolf 2011/02/11 17:08:06
    Catlareu
    +1
    We used to have an A&W where I live. They made great floats!
  • Fillmore 2011/02/11 16:47:22
    I drink diet
    Fillmore
    I dont drink soda.....its bad for you....duh
  • FunkyMunky 2011/02/11 16:44:59
    I drink regular
    FunkyMunky
    +1
    Not surprising. There has to be some kind of trade-off. Diet Coke is Coke that sold it's soul to the devil.
  • Catlareu FunkyMunky 2011/02/11 17:08:25
    Catlareu
    lol
  • o 2011/02/11 16:42:49
    I drink regular
    o
    +1
    i hate anything that has NO sugar in it. i have about 4 sugars in my tea :S LOL
  • xxxx_XX o 2011/03/03 00:33:37
    xxxx_XX
    +1
    I too am quite addicted to real sugar.
  • o xxxx_XX 2011/03/03 16:58:15
    o
    same. i dont have anything with no sugar, apart from chewing gum
  • xxxx_XX o 2011/03/07 00:19:00 (edited)
    xxxx_XX
    I truly like sugarless kisses though.

    And sugar is easily metabolized by the human body, whereas aspartame is not.
    I'm 5'10" (1.75m.) and 155 pounds (+-66kg). So sugar isn't giving me any trouble.
  • Fef 2011/02/11 16:39:18
    I drink diet
    Fef
    +1
    Everything will kill you. At least diet will keep you looking good and able to fit in a smaller coffin.
  • JerryNewman 2011/02/11 16:37:29
    I drink diet
    JerryNewman
    I may switch to something healthier if I have to, darn it.
  • 2226693 2011/02/11 16:25:25
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 9 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/06/20 06:04:02

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals