Quantcast

Casting Catfight! Is Sports Illustrated Cover Girl Kate Upton Hotter Than a Victoria's Secret Model?

SodaHead Living 2012/02/16 17:48:39
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Kate Upton, the busty bombshell on the cover of the current Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue, is probably the hottest model around right now. But Sophia Neophitou, who does casting for the Victoria’s Secret shows, turns up her nose at the 19-year-old newcomer, even though Kate Upton has appeared in the company's catalog.

kate upton  kate upton victorias secret

"We would never use" Upton for a Victoria’s Secret show, Neophitou told The New York Times. Upton's beauty is "too obvious," she added. "She’s like a Page 3 girl. She’s like a footballer’s wife, with the too-blond hair and that kind of face that anyone with enough money can go out and buy." Ouch. Them be fighting words!

The Times describes Upton as "wholesomely proportioned," at 5 feet 11 inches with a 36-25-34 figure. But this is precisely why she's a refreshing changes from the emaciated, hollow-cheeked models we've seen on the runway lately. "When Kate first came in, everyone at the agency thought I was crazy," Ivan Bart, the "superagent" who heads IMG Models, told the Times. "She wasn’t 'fashion' enough."

Upton knows exactly why she has the look that just might knock Gisele Bundchen off her stilettos. "People told me I couldn’t be fashion, that I’m just an old-fashioned body girl, only good for swimwear," she told the Times. "But I knew that I could bring back the supermodel. What can I say? I’m relatable."
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • colin 2013/08/12 21:31:36
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    colin
    She is hotter than all of them except candice.
  • Joker 2013/04/19 22:18:35
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Joker
  • beach bum 2012/06/17 09:31:36
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    beach bum
    yes
  • Kelseyyyy 2012/05/12 06:29:27
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Kelseyyyy
    Love her but this is who I really love Adriana lima Adriana lima
  • Stef and the City 2012/03/27 05:50:20
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Stef and the City
    +1
    This is stupid because they're all hot but different kinds of hot. Same with the girls who pose in Playboy and magazines like it. It depends on who you're asking and what they are into.
  • Jenn 2012/02/23 02:05:53
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Jenn
    She's beautiful.
  • patti.burroughs 2012/02/19 22:24:12
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    patti.burroughs
    She is a new found babe . I expect she will end up as a V.S. model oneday!!
  • Izzy! 2012/02/19 16:12:54
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Izzy!
    +1
    Nothing about Kate Stands out. She's just another pretty girl. AND HER BOOBS FRIGGEN ANNOY ME.
  • Monica Izzy! 2012/02/20 18:57:05
    Monica
    +2
    I know, right! Droopy boobs in side-view in S.I. photo. She can hold a roll of quarters under them. Helpful hint: Tighten bikini straps to lift them up....high and perky boobs rules!
  • Izzy! Monica 2012/02/21 22:17:09
    Izzy!
    Thank you! UGH. She just drives me crazy! She gets all this hype for being "The most beautiful model to graze the Sports Illustrated cover" But I really just don't like her.
  • ETM262 Izzy! 2012/02/21 03:04:25
    ETM262
    +4
    Kate

    Ill take her over any victoria's secret model and over any other woman in the world.
  • Michaela★ 2012/02/19 15:27:28
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Michaela★
    Um, arn't most victoria secret models already wearing practically nothing? honestly, I don't freaking care what this girl dies.
  • Roxxi 2012/02/19 14:17:30
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Roxxi
    +1
    Well since Victoria's Secret celebrates the female body, shouldn't a gorgeous and curvier girl be up there with those size 0 models? They are slightly curvier than other models but Upton has a body that a lot of girls can relate to without looking so skeletal.
  • bob h. 2012/02/19 14:01:49
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    bob h.
    +1
    Maybe if she got her ribs to stick out and her face to cave in a la crack head, she'd fit in better.
  • Chi~Cat 2012/02/19 13:15:42
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Chi~Cat
    +1
    She is so pretty and rocking...the "others" will be catty jealous ping pongs.
  • Mackenzie <3 2012/02/19 04:29:08
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Mackenzie <3
    +1
    Love Love Love the victoria secret models, i wish to become one .
  • tamra 2012/02/19 03:47:47
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    tamra
    they just are.. and that all I have to say about that=)
  • ★☆Ams★☆ 2012/02/19 03:33:56
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    ★☆Ams★☆
    +1
    She's a pretty girl but kind of generic looking. There's nothing about her that makes her stand out.
  • Christyyyyy 2012/02/19 01:56:55
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Christyyyyy
    +2
    Adriana lima much hotter
  • AurouraNatasha 2012/02/19 01:12:09
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    AurouraNatasha
    can we say wanna be
  • Calla Tor 2012/02/19 00:48:42 (edited)
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Calla Tor
    I think Miranda Kerr is a lot prettier than she is, but as for hotness, I don't know, I'm not a good judge of that.

    Miranda Kerr on ellen

    Miranda Kerr clothes

    Miranda Kerr wings

     miranda kerr eyes
  • Catita 2012/02/19 00:39:43
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Catita
    +2
    I don't know, show a pic of her without make up. LOL.
  • kawaiigurl1234 2012/02/18 21:50:10
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    kawaiigurl1234
    I mean she isn't HOTTER but she is pretty though.
  • Hawaiianprincess 2012/02/18 20:41:53
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Hawaiianprincess
    Way hotter
  • Quietman ~PWCM~JLA 2012/02/18 20:14:23
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Quietman   ~PWCM~JLA
    +1
    They all look good to me!
  • Liz Del Rey 2012/02/18 18:10:55
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Liz Del Rey
    +3
    adriana lima
    adriana lima
    Adriana is way hotter. :D
  • Clover Liz Del... 2012/02/19 10:45:27
  • Watermusicranger 2012/02/18 17:07:05 (edited)
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Watermusicranger
    +1
    Are you Kidding????????????????



    old Victoria s Secret Model

    Sophia Neophitou
  • ★misfit★ 2012/02/18 16:18:04
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    ★misfit★
    +4
    It's not a matter of who's hotter, she just doesn't have the right look. Unfortunately, VS wants very skinny models. And also, her face is pretty, but it doesn't stand out at all and I think VS probably wants memorable faces (think Miranda Kerr, Gisele Budchen, Adriana Lima). So basically, she's hot in her way, they're hot in theirs.
  • Meh 2012/02/18 15:34:30
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Meh
    +2
    Victoria's Secret model are way hotter
  • Lefty 2012/02/18 14:49:24
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Lefty
    Especially in slow motion!
  • Lobster Man 2012/02/18 12:30:49
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Lobster Man
    +1
    only one VS model that is as Hot Candice Swanepoel Candice Swanepoel Candice Swanepoel
  • Fenabarb 2012/02/18 10:25:43
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    Fenabarb
    water water
  • Untouched 2012/02/18 10:04:40 (edited)
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Untouched
    only Candice is hotter than her...

    candice swanepoel bikini
    the other VS models are just as unhot as kate is
  • Beanybudd 2012/02/18 03:52:06
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Beanybudd
    +3
    She's pretty, but she doesn't have that magic sparkle that these models have. She is a common beauty. Really nothing special, as harsh as that is. I looked through some of her modeling pics and they didn't have that kind of energy you get off looking from a VS model where you're just tranced. I've seen so many girls that look similar to her. VS models, it isn't like that. They ARE the "it".












    See that ^^^ just browsing through their pictures are addicting!
    She's pretty, but she doesn't have that magic sparkle that these models have. She is a common beauty. Really nothing special, as harsh as that is. I looked through some of her modeling pics and they didn't have that kind of energy you get off looking from a VS model where you're just tranced. I've seen so many girls that look similar to her. VS models, it isn't like that. They ARE the "it".


    victoria secret
    victoria secret
    victoria secret models
    victoria secret models
    victoria secret models
    victoria secret models
    victoria secret models runway
    victoria secret models runway


    See that ^^^ just browsing through their pictures are addicting!
    (more)
  • Clover Beanybudd 2012/02/19 10:46:47
  • Little Miss Unicorn 2012/02/18 02:08:36 (edited)
    No, Victoria's Secret models are hotter.
    Little Miss Unicorn
    +3
    Kate is too... Typical. Victoria's Secret are the rarest of the rarest: voluptuous but in slim frames. I think she should stick to swimsuits, because she has way too much chest and hips. Not that she isn't pretty, because she is, but the VS models have this special something... Kate is just another blonde with a big bust.

    Kate Upton could NEVER knock Gisele Bündchen out of her stilettos. Gisele is a supermodel, only übermodels like Cindy Crawford and Linda Evangelista could knock her out.

    Candice Swanepoel

    Candice Swanepoel

    Miranda Kerr

    Miranda Kerr
  • Untouched Little ... 2012/02/18 10:20:47
    Untouched
    the only skinny AND curvy one is Candice
    gisele, miranda, adriana, alessandra are shapeless
  • Little ... Untouched 2012/02/19 16:36:23
    Little Miss Unicorn
    They are shapeless because that's the way models are supposed to be so they don't attract the attention from the clothes...
  • abbiekat 2012/02/18 01:34:21
    Yes! Kate is too hot for Victoria's Secret.
    abbiekat
    +2
    I think she is very beautiful.

    beautiful

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2014/04/23 14:50:06

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals