Quantcast

California Legislators Approve Robot Cars on Public Roads: Do You?

Fef 2012/08/31 18:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Ready to share the road with robots weighing 4,000 pounds of metal moving at speeds up to 65 MPH? California legislators voted to approve California Senate Bill 1298 (SB 1298) that “would permit autonomous vehicles to be operated or tested on the public roads in this state.” The senate bill also added that the robot cars will “offer significant potential safety, mobility, and commercial benefits for individuals and businesses in the state and elsewhere.”

It doesn't surprise me that the state legislator in California, where Google flexes its political power, would allow the bill. It also doesn't surprise me that the state senate already wrote nearly 1,300 new laws. I actually look forward to less California humans driving on the road, particularly in Los Angeles. However, we need to verify that these robots won't suffer road rage and go all "Terminator" on us.

ARSTECHNICA.COM reports:
Legislators pass new law that would set safety and performance standards.
arstechnica reports legislators pass law safety performance standards

Read More: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/08/robot-c...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • sglmom 2012/08/31 02:24:45
    Yes
    sglmom
    +11
    As someone who is BLIND
    I truly am encouraged that these Self-Driving vehicles are going into real life applications ..
    This is going to be ..
    if the costs are brought down to where it is affordable ..
    a BIG BOON in securing independence ..
    the ability to be FREE to move around so much more ..
    for those with Disabilities
    (and definitely for the Vision Impaired/Blind ... especially me!)

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Royo 2012/09/04 22:50:23
    No
    Royo
    +1
    Oh yea, what a lovely idea to give all of our power to machines. And what exactly happens when one malfunctions? Not a good idea.
  • DrRenovation 2012/09/04 22:43:28
    No
    DrRenovation
    Sorry I meant yes...
    now multi-tasking just got easier
  • Its Me, Joel 2012/09/04 22:34:48
    Yes
    Its Me, Joel
    IF...A driver is in the seat watching it. WE ALL KNOW MACHINES DO MESS UP!!!
  • Freedom 2012/09/04 22:22:29
    Yes
    Freedom
    Fine by me. They can't drive worse than people, right? Plus, with robot cars no one would drink and drive anymore. Yeah!
  • Little Miss Opinions 2012/09/04 21:23:14
    No
    Little Miss Opinions
    Let a car drive for me? I think not
  • DOriginalDonald 2012/09/04 21:21:08
    Yes
    DOriginalDonald
    Just not the smarmy ones like the Knight Industries Two Thousand ;)
  • lolitalovely 2012/09/04 21:00:53
    No
    lolitalovely
    I meant yes! sorry.
    I won't be driving it though.
  • nate 2012/09/04 21:00:23
    No
    nate
    I love using computers, but I don't want one to drive my car for me. Then again, I hate driving so this may actually be useful :D
  • Callaway 2012/09/04 20:53:28
    No
    Callaway
    +1
    What on earth will all the lawyers, court systems, police agencies or cities do for revenue when these become the standard drive for the late night trips home from the bars or parties make the robot walk a straight line or blow into a breathalyzer? In all seriousness until all cars and trucks are equipped like this or they have their own separate road system this sounds like a accident waiting to happen. Christ are we that feeble or just lazy now the car has to do the thinking and pray tell who will be programming the on board computer?
  • wgossett99 2012/09/04 20:42:23
    Yes
    wgossett99
    +3
    So far the testing has been near flawless. The cars "see" 360 degrees with radar, and have GPS to use for navigation. The robots pay attention 100% of the time, don't get sleepy, don't yak on their phones, don't text while driving and don't spill food on them selves while driving. I would love to be able to nap while my car drove me from work to home in the evenings.

    I would rather have one of these cars drive my parents (89) around that have Dad drive.
  • Ole SGT Joe 2012/09/04 19:59:33
    Yes
    Ole SGT Joe
    +1
    They will have a place in society but not be the savior for all transportation. Theoretically, an idea that must be regulated with their own roads, etc.
  • wgossett99 Ole SGT... 2012/09/04 20:31:14
    wgossett99
    Having their own roads doesn't make sense. The idea is for these cars to navigate existing roads with existing traffic.
  • Ole SGT... wgossett99 2012/09/07 15:51:11
    Ole SGT Joe
    I realize the roads will be shared but was hoping for something less invasive. Intermixing smart technology with not so smart "in control" physical drivers could spell disaster.
  • wgossett99 Ole SGT... 2012/09/11 16:02:01
    wgossett99
    You may be right but I think the "smart cars" will be able to avoid collisions better than humans because they won't be distracted by phones, radio, texts, food, etc. The 360 degree radar is a significant improvement over our limited vision.
  • Ole SGT... wgossett99 2012/09/14 17:57:31
    Ole SGT Joe
    With that being said, i agree. Hope I live to see the day.
  • wgossett99 Ole SGT... 2012/09/17 13:25:32
    wgossett99
    Me, too.
  • wes 2012/09/04 19:44:21 (edited)
    Yes
    wes
    Then you could drink your ass off , you could text all you want, you wouldn't have to worry about how far 800 yards is to your next turn, you could sleep on the way to your destination, you would have automatic traffic incident avoidance, and all without the smart ass stinky cab driver, where do I sign up?!
  • Small man big mouth 2012/09/04 19:39:42
    Yes
    Small man big mouth
    As long as you put them on the 10 fwy near alhambra and the 60 fwy near puente hills. YOU KNOW WHAT I'M SAYING
  • metalformer 2012/09/04 18:51:56
    Yes
    metalformer
    Well, that depends: do they transform into robots? :P
  • Otter 2012/09/04 18:28:54
    Yes
    Otter
    If the benefits out-measure the risk, I say "Go for it."
    Anything to save lives.
  • dzzshadz 2012/09/04 18:21:28
    Yes
    dzzshadz
    Love them want one.
  • kepowell 2012/09/04 18:13:05
    Yes
    kepowell
    I'm from california and sure didn't know anything at all about this but I think its a good idea not just for those with disabilities but think of all the things commuters could get done while their car drives them to work. Commuting is just the biggest waste of human time I can think of so I'm all for it. (If it works of course!)
  • Small m... kepowell 2012/09/04 19:41:49
    Small man big mouth
    They're safe they can only go as fast as everyone else in l.a. 10 MILES PER HOUR.
  • jewels2012ascend 2012/09/04 18:10:09 (edited)
    No
    jewels2012ascend
    ...
  • wgossett99 jewels2... 2012/09/04 20:33:35
    wgossett99
    Cars that run on water?!!

    Something tells me you slept thru science class.
  • jewels2... wgossett99 2012/09/05 16:28:19 (edited)
    jewels2012ascend
    ...
  • wgossett99 jewels2... 2012/09/06 15:53:13
    wgossett99
    What school did you go to? What did you major in - witchcraft?

    Actually I am more interested in what you are smoking - lol
  • jewels2... wgossett99 2012/09/07 02:49:15 (edited)
    jewels2012ascend
    ....
  • wgossett99 jewels2... 2012/09/07 15:12:36
    wgossett99
    You still didn't answer me. What school did you attend? What degree do you hold?
  • [Ev@n] 2012/09/04 17:53:55
    No
    [Ev@n]
    +1
    I would not be comfortable putting my trust in something that could possibly malfunction and harm my life
  • wgossett99 [Ev@n] 2012/09/04 20:35:38
    wgossett99
    I guess you don't fly very much. Most passenger planes run on autopilot including take-offs and landings. The pilots are there to override if an emergency occurs.
  • [Ev@n] wgossett99 2012/09/07 15:22:18
    [Ev@n]
    Nope. I do not fly
  • Andre 2012/09/04 17:45:32
    No
    Andre
    What, taking away one of our last freedoms ?? I drive between 200 and 300 miles-a-day, mainly in greater Los Angeles and wouldn't dream of having it done automatically, if I would dream it would be a nightmare. Where is the pleasure, one can take as well a bus. I do not question or worry about a danger this could bring, computers are very reliable, IF people do not mess with them. In my career of IT tech I very selden see something wich is computer related, most if not all the problems come from the connection between the seat and the keyboard (read: the operator).
    A computer cannot think nor reason. This brings a potential problem in my mind. Take a long line of automatic cars on the freeway, all running at the legal speed and on a safe distance from each other according to the weather conditions.
    Scenario one: an automatic car is on the onramp an wants to merge but the space between the cars is too small, is it going to sit there forever ? Now, we humans, see that problem and or slow down to let them in or move over to the left.
    Scenario two: same line of automatic cars, you a human, drive in the middle lane and have to take the offramp. Being a human, you may "force" things a bit and squeeze between two automatic cars. The car behind you immeditately senses that ...



    What, taking away one of our last freedoms ?? I drive between 200 and 300 miles-a-day, mainly in greater Los Angeles and wouldn't dream of having it done automatically, if I would dream it would be a nightmare. Where is the pleasure, one can take as well a bus. I do not question or worry about a danger this could bring, computers are very reliable, IF people do not mess with them. In my career of IT tech I very selden see something wich is computer related, most if not all the problems come from the connection between the seat and the keyboard (read: the operator).
    A computer cannot think nor reason. This brings a potential problem in my mind. Take a long line of automatic cars on the freeway, all running at the legal speed and on a safe distance from each other according to the weather conditions.
    Scenario one: an automatic car is on the onramp an wants to merge but the space between the cars is too small, is it going to sit there forever ? Now, we humans, see that problem and or slow down to let them in or move over to the left.
    Scenario two: same line of automatic cars, you a human, drive in the middle lane and have to take the offramp. Being a human, you may "force" things a bit and squeeze between two automatic cars. The car behind you immeditately senses that and slows down or brakes, the car behind that one, has to slow down and brake almost twice as hard and so on untill the tenth "robot" cannot slow down anymore and rearends the 9th. Or does this "robot" make the decision to change lane, IF he can.
    Scenario three: Again freeway, light traffic. An automatic car come on the freeway, accelerates to the legal speed and joins the line, another one and another one until we have a continuous line, all automatic cars following ech other. The freeway is full, in the right lane, the other lanes are still vacant because all cars run at the same speed and thus there is no need to overtake. When, and based on what will a "robot" "think" of changing lanes.
    Scenario four: Again the continuous line of automatic cars at the legal speed and a safe distance from each other. Somehow an automatic car ventured in the second lane, only now it nears the exit, what is going to happen as to its logic it cannot merge ??
    Apart from all those questions I dread having this taken away from me. True is it will be long time before this would be the only option but it is a decline of the quality of life.
    Another thing is that the state would see a drastic drop in revenue as speeding would become a thing of the past. And you know what the state will do to compensate: indeed, new and/or higher taxes.
    (more)
  • wgossett99 Andre 2012/09/06 15:57:23
    wgossett99
    You have never taken a taxi or limo? Driving is a chore. Going from point A to point B is the freedom. Letting a robot drive is no more freedom limiting than letting the taxi/limo driver take you where you want to go. You still choose where Point B is.
  • Andre wgossett99 2012/09/14 18:26:32
    Andre
    Yes, I have taken a taxi a few times out of pure necessity and HATE it, I never would want to be driven around in a limo, no driving a pure pleasure and I love every second of it and every inch I travel. The freedom is doing it yourself and not so much as choosing point B
  • wgossett99 Andre 2012/09/17 13:32:14
    wgossett99
    I see from your profile that you are still in college so I'm guessing your age to be 20-25. I'm 63 and I have commuted to and from work for some 40 years. I suspect your opinion may change once you are fully part of the rat race.
  • Andre wgossett99 2012/09/22 19:55:22 (edited)
    Andre
    Apparently my profile is wrong, I am 53 and drove daily since and the last 20 years 200 to 300 miles daily. Depends also on what car you drive. Currently I am using a Range Rover with the compressor and 510 Hp on tap as my daily driver. I doubt that you ever had the pleasure of driving a V12 at full bore. An unforgettable experience. The most memorable drive was in a (borrowed) Ferrari Daytona Scaglietti convertible from LA to Vegas. Once past Barstow we drove it flat out (we were with 2 Ferraris). The song of that V12, the wind in the hair and the feel of that car going 150 Mph + is unforgattable. But we do not have to go exotic to have fun, three of the most pleasurable cars I ever had were a couple of 1967 Shelby Cobra's, a convertible and a coupe (for the unitiated two Mustangs on steroids) and the third, a lowly 1942 Jeep. The last proving that we do not need speed per se to have fun. I had my share of cars, a Maserati Ghibly, Maserati Bora, Lotus Elite, a 1974 Gran Torino wagon with a 450 police interceptor engine (factory original) to name but a few. Now, being older I still love those cars but prefer room and cpmfort, so I had a few Suburbans (454's) and even a Ford Excursion. But, since the beginning I also drove Range Rovers and LOVE them. \
    We do not nee...

    Apparently my profile is wrong, I am 53 and drove daily since and the last 20 years 200 to 300 miles daily. Depends also on what car you drive. Currently I am using a Range Rover with the compressor and 510 Hp on tap as my daily driver. I doubt that you ever had the pleasure of driving a V12 at full bore. An unforgettable experience. The most memorable drive was in a (borrowed) Ferrari Daytona Scaglietti convertible from LA to Vegas. Once past Barstow we drove it flat out (we were with 2 Ferraris). The song of that V12, the wind in the hair and the feel of that car going 150 Mph + is unforgattable. But we do not have to go exotic to have fun, three of the most pleasurable cars I ever had were a couple of 1967 Shelby Cobra's, a convertible and a coupe (for the unitiated two Mustangs on steroids) and the third, a lowly 1942 Jeep. The last proving that we do not need speed per se to have fun. I had my share of cars, a Maserati Ghibly, Maserati Bora, Lotus Elite, a 1974 Gran Torino wagon with a 450 police interceptor engine (factory original) to name but a few. Now, being older I still love those cars but prefer room and cpmfort, so I had a few Suburbans (454's) and even a Ford Excursion. But, since the beginning I also drove Range Rovers and LOVE them. \
    We do not need exotic or facy cars to enjoy te ride however (exotics can be a pain in the ... and dig a hole in the wallet), even mainstream cars can be fun. Proof, one of my alltime fun cars, cars with the highest FPM ratio (FPM = Fun Per Mile) is an www2 army jeep with a top speed of almost 60 miles an hour. And I do not take into account the off-road factor, a Jeep is a ton of fun to drive around, especially ni the city. It can be kind of a drag on the freeway, but still. It is not suitable for long distances the short wheelbase making the ride very choppy and tiring. Speed is a factor, yes, but not a necessity, I LOVE puttering around in a very fast car.
    Oh, and by the way, drive responsibly, same as drinking. Keep your speed ALWAYS in proportion of the condition, meaning the capabilities of the car, the road, the traffic and the weather. Driving a limo, a grossly overbuild and underegineered car at 90 miles is lethal, while driving a Porsche for example at the same speed is just warming up
    So, in conclusion, would you have had the good fortune of driving a fun car in your commutem you probably would not feel that way now and I do feel sorry for you, you missed a heck lot of fun during those 40 years.
    (more)
  • wgossett99 Andre 2012/09/24 14:59:15
    wgossett99
    Sounds like fun but not my style. I prefer more natural things like fishing, gardening, SCUBA diving, etc. But, to each his own.

    Stay safe.
  • biggman100 2012/09/04 17:31:29
    No
    biggman100
    Hmm. Robot jobs, robot cars, robot planes. Whats next? Oh i know, everyone will be out of a job, and there wont be any money being spent on the economy, because robots dont spend money, so what will all you people who want this to happen do then?
  • ZB 2012/09/04 17:22:34
    Yes
    ZB
    As someone else said already; those with disabilities, like legal blindness, will gain independence. They will be able to do more without having to be driven everywhere by someone else. Lets hope it works out and is not too expensive.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/20 06:08:06

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals