Quantcast

Best Pizzas in America 2012: What Makes a Great Pizza?

mrosen814 2012/09/18 22:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
What make a great pizza? There are many questions that must be asked and answered, to determine the quintessential pizza list of 2012. If you want to check out the list of the best pizzas of 2012, click on the link below.

According to Fox News, "Maybe great pizza means the use of the freshest ingredients and seasonal toppings? Does it involve a structural integrity to the underlying dough that ensures you can lift a slice without experiencing droopage? Is it an airy, charred cornicione that makes even the most ardent crust-chucker certain not to leave one pizza bone behind? Must it employ artisanal sausage, or does old-school pepperoni count? Does it involve fresh mozzarella? Or just the expert scattering and sauce to cheese ratio of good old-fashioned, low-moisture aged mozzarella and sauce made from canned San Marzano tomatoes? Does a bar pie count? And how do you stack those up against deep-dish pies?!"

FOXNEWS.COM reports:
Who makes America's best pizza? We get the experts to weigh in.
foxnews reports americas pizza experts weigh

Read More: http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2012/09/18/best-piz...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • wedge56 2012/09/19 02:26:03
    Other
    wedge56
    +4
    Hunger and sobriety. No such thing as a bad pizza at 3:00 a.m. after bar hopping. Besides, bad pizza is like bad sex....it's still pretty good.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Elz joe keeney 2012/09/19 22:02:52
    Elz
    my dad and i had a thin crust pizza from papa johns it was terrible.
  • Joker 2012/09/19 14:27:55
  • Christopher Kirchen 2012/09/19 13:36:54
    Other
    Christopher Kirchen
    The first three, plus fresh ingredients.(sausage, onions, etc.)
  • Jareth Majere 2012/09/19 13:19:29
    Structural integrity of the dough
    Jareth Majere
    Super crisp crust, then a good, not-sweet sauce, good toppings but not so many that they flood the pizza with grease. Then little salt, pepper, parm & red pepper flakes
  • glen 2012/09/19 12:55:47
    Other
    glen
    All of the above but the seasonal thing
  • lovemykiddos 2012/09/19 12:52:46
    Fresh, quality cheeses
    lovemykiddos
    It's all about the cheese. I have to have fresh cheese and lots of it.
  • cesspool 2012/09/19 12:31:37
    Other
    cesspool
    All of the above with the exception of seasonal toppings.
  • Zombiecat~Metalhead4Life 2012/09/19 11:46:09
    Perfect sauce ratio
    Zombiecat~Metalhead4Life
    I think it comes down to the sauce really. If the sauce is crappy it throws the whole thing off. I think I have yet to taste pizza sauce done right.
  • BlackwinterG36C 2012/09/19 11:40:33
    Structural integrity of the dough
    BlackwinterG36C
    All of the above.
  • Cleaver62 2012/09/19 11:40:26
    Other
    Cleaver62
    +2
    For me it is the crust. I love Chicago style deep dish pizza with some sweet sausage and onions and lots of cheese. Giordano s Pizza pizza
  • Venus Akers 2012/09/19 10:36:46
    Seasonal toppings
    Venus Akers
    I love when they put all kinds of vegetable toppings and of course perfect sauce ratio... not so much cheese, too fattening! :-)
  • Richard Hewlett 2012/09/19 09:07:04
    Other
    Richard Hewlett
    All of the above.
  • Beat Magnum True Hero 2012/09/19 08:33:56 (edited)
    Other
    Beat Magnum True Hero
    +2
    The foundations:

    Crust - fresh, hand tossed and stretched, and good ingredients (rub in a little garlic).
    Cheese - fresh and a mix. I like a mix of provolone/mozzarella as opposed to pure mozzarella.
    Sauce - A good sauce has a little bit of wine it it for flavor. One place back in Phoenix does it and it makes a huge difference. Again, add some garlic.

    And Garlic. American pizza doesn't respect garlic enough. If you build on a food foundation, you could feed me a a fish-head and haggis pizza and I'd still love it.
  • Richard... Beat Ma... 2012/09/19 09:20:34
    Richard Hewlett
    That was pure pizza poetry every single word,a true pizza connoisseur!
    I totally agree with you on the cheese provolone/mozzarella mix,
    the splash of red wine in the sauce and the garlic, garnished with roasted garlic. Drool!
    And then, Beat, you had to go and mention a fish-head and Haggis pizza, nasty!
  • Beat Ma... Richard... 2012/09/19 13:43:02
    Beat Magnum True Hero
    That's the whole idea... if you start with the right base, it makes any topping good!
  • Richard... Beat Ma... 2012/09/20 02:25:25 (edited)
    Richard Hewlett
    fish-head and Haggis pizza? I draw the line at fish-head and Haggis pizza!
  • Zombiec... Beat Ma... 2012/09/19 11:42:13
    Zombiecat~Metalhead4Life
    Sounds wonderful. Nowhere around here for me to get real pizza.... only places are chains like Pizza Hut and Dominoes. >:L
  • jim 2012/09/19 08:23:39
    Other
    jim
    +1
    Knowing that real Sicilian pizza isn't just thick crust with a thin coating of tomato paste.
  • Tella6 2012/09/19 07:50:53
    Other
    Tella6
    +1
    All of the above
  • Kibbles 2012/09/19 07:37:38
    Other
    Kibbles
    +1
    The ability it has to be a deep dish.
  • jp 2012/09/19 06:22:14
    Other
    jp
    People
  • CrazyJason 2012/09/19 06:18:13 (edited)
    Perfect sauce ratio
    CrazyJason
    +1
    Round Table Pizza kicks ass..! so does one of those legitimate, authentic deep dish pizzas from Chicago (the ones with the sauce on top)

    pizza kicks ass legitimate authentic deep dish pizzas chicago sauce

    pizza kicks ass legitimate authentic deep dish pizzas chicago sauce
  • Zombiec... CrazyJason 2012/09/19 11:43:05
    Zombiecat~Metalhead4Life
    +1
    that looks so good!
  • David 2012/09/19 06:06:16
    Structural integrity of the dough
    David
    +1
    Now I want pizza ):
  • johnqpublic 2012/09/19 06:03:10
    Other
    johnqpublic
    +1
    It's the water. And you can't make pizza with a soft dough. And while Chitown makes a decent pizza, nuthin, but nuthin, beats a real NEW YAWK PIZZA!
  • Saga 2012/09/19 05:29:14
    Other
    Saga
    All of the above. ^-^
  • Sandman366 2012/09/19 05:26:07
    Other
    Sandman366
    +1
    Good toppings, doesn't matter if seasonal.

    Best pizza I've ever had was this nowheresville (probably literally) place in Italy, was this delicious seafood pizza. Was years ago, but I remember calamari, squid, shrimp....and more.

    Best pizza ever, and the only people to argue it don't like seafood.
  • littlebuffalo55TBA 2012/09/19 05:13:53
    Perfect sauce ratio
    littlebuffalo55TBA
    The right sauce is the key along with REAL cheese! Lampost Pizza in Torrance Ca. exemplifies this!
  • shadowcat_2 2012/09/19 04:46:49
    Fresh, quality cheeses
    shadowcat_2
    Plus the dough
  • Raithere 2012/09/19 04:36:06
    Structural integrity of the dough
    Raithere
    It all comes down to the crust. Although personally I'm quite particular and very fundamentalist about pizza toppings, that's a matter of personal taste. Without a great crust the best toppings in the world are for nothing.
  • marty 2012/09/19 04:18:34
    Other
    marty
    All of the above.
    Also under dough, should be its flavor.
  • Pinkdesertrose 2012/09/19 04:18:17
    Perfect sauce ratio
    Pinkdesertrose
    +1
    mmm...Now I am getting hungry for pizza!
  • bcarrera 2012/09/19 04:01:18
    Other
    bcarrera
    With great pizza, comes great responsibility to eat one.
  • American Nate 2012/09/19 03:54:55
    Structural integrity of the dough
    American Nate
    All meat, and stuffed Crust

    meat pizza
  • Zolfie™ 2012/09/19 03:38:05
    Other
    Zolfie™
    +1
    Good tasting pizza is by good tasting dough, sauce, topping combined well.
  • Sean McDonald 2012/09/19 03:23:53
    Structural integrity of the dough
    Sean McDonald
    +1
    The Dough
  • Surya 2012/09/19 02:56:58
    Other
    Surya
    all the above XD
  • Dugard 2012/09/19 02:54:47
    Structural integrity of the dough
    Dugard
    Dough. Everything else you can add or subtract. The dough is the foundation.
  • Olde' Smoke 2012/09/19 02:44:23
    Other
    Olde' Smoke
    Limp dough, the right sauce, lots of cheese, good toppings, and lots of grease
  • wedge56 2012/09/19 02:26:03
    Other
    wedge56
    +4
    Hunger and sobriety. No such thing as a bad pizza at 3:00 a.m. after bar hopping. Besides, bad pizza is like bad sex....it's still pretty good.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/19 07:53:51

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals