Quantcast

Baby-Swinging Yoga: Sick or Safe?

SodaHead Living 2011/01/20 22:00:00
Related Topics: Facebook, Teacher, Chinese
You!
Add Photos & Videos
If you're like us, you took one look at this photo and asked yourself, "Is this for real?"

photo real

According to Gawker, it is. The website says Lena Fokina, the Russian baby yoga teacher and viral video star seen swinging babies in this photo, is legit.

Fokina claims to be a child-rearing expert based in Dahab, Egypt, who specializes in "extreme developmental gymnastics."

Nathan Thornburgh interviewed Fokina for Time magazine, and she admitted that "not everyone accepts" baby yoga.

He then asked her about the baby featured in her baby-swinging video, which went viral before YouTube took it down (it was in violation of their policy on "shocking and disgusting" content).

"Her name is Platona, and she was two weeks old when we took that video. We have a lot of children like her here. They are early readers, singers, talkers, swimmers. You haven't seen anything like it anywhere!!"

Sounds like the "Chinese mom" of Dahab, Egypt.

We watched a bit of the video in question, and frankly, it made us sick to our stomach. But Fokina maintains that being swung around is perfectly healthy and fun for babies.

"This system has been used for over 30 years in Russia and the children are all alive and healthy," Fokina said.

Anyone know a good pediatrician to call about this? We're not convinced.




Read More: http://gawker.com/5737061/baby+swinging-yoga-is-re...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • BLT ^MOTOOP^ 2011/01/20 22:37:35
    Sick!
    BLT ^MOTOOP^
    +15
    Definition of Shaken baby syndrome
    Shaken baby syndrome: Injuries, particularly to the head, caused by violently shaking an infant. The syndrome is the commonest cause of infant death from head injuries and one of the most serious kinds of child abuse. The syndrome also goes by other names such as shaking impact syndrome.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • sebzki.revrski 2013/02/23 05:02:36
    Safe
    sebzki.revrski
    if there haven't any reports of falling babies or dislocated arms and legs, then I believe it is safe.

    gotta have an open mind in order to see the world like everyone else!
  • Kezzi Rose Lavigne Biersack 2012/04/21 11:56:22 (edited)
    Sick!
    Kezzi Rose Lavigne Biersack
    That's horrid CHILD ABUSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Jessica 2012/03/04 03:29:04
    Sick!
    Jessica
    Even if they weren't dropped, it looks like it could cause bad stuff to the brain. I mean, look! I think blood would rush to their head. D:
  • Meeka8 2012/03/03 18:53:36
    Undecided
    Meeka8
    I find this very intriguing. On whether it's safe or not, they've been practicing this for thirty years and there haven't been any reports of problems. I'm sure something can go wrong if you don't know what the hell you're doing, which can be said about anything. I can't judge them on their practices because there are things we do in this culture that seem ridiculous to others. Even in our overly protective culture, believe it or not, babies get dropped *gasp!* Children are pretty resilient, even at such a young age. They fall, get dropped (don't some of you deny ever dropping your children... it freaking happens), topple over something, get trampled by dogs. And "swinging" is not the same thing as "shaking". You who continue to post what Shaken Baby Syndrom is needs to read over it again.

    I watched a mother swing her child, cradled in her arms, what some would consider "violently" because the child needed the extra stimulation it provided. And a DOCTOR told her to, for those who seem to only believe what comes out of a doctors mouth.

    I wouldn't mind looking further into this cultural practice.
  • sweetfire Meeka8 2013/02/02 03:28:12
    sweetfire
    +3
    It was done to me when I was days and months old. I was born with some issues (some of my left side paralyzed etc) my mom did this to me and some of her friends children. Me and those children grew up together we are all very healthy and happy and all the issues I had that I was born with are all gone. :)
    I have never even been to the hospital before and I am 31 years old. My older brother also had this done to him he is healthy and is a computer genius so I'm not sure what harm it has done. (We were born in Russia, but raised here)
  • Anya 2011/08/29 06:43:22
  • Davis 2011/02/03 13:50:14
    Sick!
    Davis
    people who are that CRAZY or STUPID and should NEVER have children. what is she tring to do? give the babys brain damage? if she wants the babys to swing there are many baby swing in stores that wont hurt the babys so she should go buy one and stop being a stupid b****. if someone did something like that here they would in up in jail.
  • sebzki.... Davis 2013/02/25 00:49:28
    sebzki.revrski
    you said it: "if someone did something like that HERE they would end up in jail" but that someone is not HERE!
  • اسيرة الدموع 2011/01/27 16:12:43
    Sick!
    اسيرة الدموع
    It will hurt them
  • abby 2011/01/25 15:52:49
    Sick!
    abby
    i dont even have to explain why i disagree with this i mean ARE THEY SERIOUS?
  • jennifer_55 2011/01/25 14:05:44
    Sick!
    jennifer_55
    wat if the baby falls??? wat do they do then???
  • Meeka8 jennife... 2012/03/03 19:03:11
    Meeka8
    +1
    What happens when a baby falls? (psst, it happens all the freaking time!) You pick it up, comfort it, and go on with life.
  • sebzki.... jennife... 2013/02/23 05:00:33
    sebzki.revrski
    +2
    pick the baby up no??
  • ellie 2011/01/25 08:16:21
    Sick!
    ellie
    cool anyone could do that
  • GeraldL.KingII 2011/01/25 06:05:06
    Undecided
    GeraldL.KingII
    +1
    This is the problem with us American's, when we see something that goes against OUR nature it's sick and wrong. We have idea what the benefits are of what she is doing. Leaches and maggots are used everyday in medicine. Being an EMT I have seen child abuse and shaken baby syndrome, this is NOTHING like it. Would I subject my child to this? Probably not. BUT that is for the rational, INFORMED parent(s) to decide. My school district requires some vaccines that I have refused to give my daughter. My wife and I researched all the vaccines and have come up with a plan to address those vaccines which can wait. But here again, this was a decision WE made after a complete and careful education session from many sources.

    An old Native American saying comes to mind: Don't judge a man until you walk a mile in his moccasins.
  • KaylaPearlRay 2011/01/24 23:40:46
    Sick!
    KaylaPearlRay
    That's sick! you could hurt the baby's legs very easy, child abuse
  • sebzki.... KaylaPe... 2013/02/23 05:00:58
    sebzki.revrski
    +1
    you are bs!
  • Chris 2011/01/24 22:52:42
    Undecided
    Chris
    Different.
  • MO.gal 2011/01/24 22:45:37
    Sick!
    MO.gal
    I would call it child abuse.
  • letmelive 2011/01/24 22:35:19
    Undecided
    letmelive
    holy moly!!! haha its kinda scary
  • mana kai 2011/01/24 22:28:57
    Undecided
    mana kai
    Your watching natural selection at work
  • Jojo_is_loved 2011/01/24 22:26:41
    Sick!
    Jojo_is_loved
    +1
    YOU DON'T SWING BABIES. END OF STORY.
  • Vezman 2011/01/24 22:22:42 (edited)
    Undecided
    Vezman
    I wouldn't say "Sick" but it's definitely not "Safe" either.



    My wife is a nurse and she worked for a very good chiropractor, and medical doctors don't treat him very well either. And I would never have gone if she hadn't have worked for him, but with me, my wife, and three boys in my family we haven't had to take antibiotics for an ear infection in over 11 years......the medical docs cringe when she mentions that to them too.



    In the video I didn't see her put a bunch of needles in him either, but some people believe in acupuncture. To me acupuncture is crazier than what this woman is doing, and if it's been shown to have no long term effects???



    I would think that the biggest concern would be to dislocate a joint or something.
  • sebzki.... Vezman 2013/02/23 05:06:39
    sebzki.revrski
    +2
    Open your G**damn mind!!!
  • Julia 2011/01/24 21:41:54
    Sick!
    Julia
    +2
    this lady is crazy! but - i guess as long as she doesnt hurt the kids shes ok they dont seem to be crying or fussing in videos..)... i just worry about people who dont know what they're doing trying this and harming little babies...
  • 2315217 2011/01/24 20:24:08
    Undecided
    2315217
    +1
    I am not a doctor!!!!
  • Wise Soul 2011/01/24 20:08:24
    Sick!
    Wise Soul
    It's all fun and games until someone drops the baby. fun games drops baby cracked egg
  • sebzki.... Wise Soul 2013/02/23 05:08:33
    sebzki.revrski
    +1
    My friend, tell me how many times did you fall when you were a little kid?
    personally I fell down some stairs my dad set up and got out of it with no scratches!
  • JillianMusic'JunkieWooden 2011/01/24 19:42:38
    Safe
    JillianMusic'JunkieWooden
    +1
    I accidentally clicked Safe instead of Sick.
    That is just awful. This is how babies die from SBS
  • Vezman Jillian... 2011/01/24 22:47:32
    Vezman
    I only watched one video, but I didn't see her shake the baby. Maybe I wasn't watching the same thing....
  • GeraldL... Jillian... 2011/01/25 06:14:44
    GeraldL.KingII
    +1
    Have you every seen SBS? As I posted before, I am an EMT and I have. This is NOTHING compared to SBS. If you watched the video you can see that this lady is doing everything she can to make sure that the babies arm's do not twist and that the head isn't cracked like a whip. Babies are ALOT more resilient than you think.
  • Jillian... GeraldL... 2011/01/25 20:03:10
    JillianMusic'JunkieWooden
    EMT or not, NO newborn baby should be held upside down by their legs and swung around. Its WRONG. Regardless of the fact. I would never subject my child to that, I don't care how "beneficial" it can be. Why does a baby need yoga anyways?
  • sebzki.... Jillian... 2013/02/23 05:08:58
    sebzki.revrski
    +3
    lets see how many babies have died out of this practice?
  • Texas Johnny 2011/01/24 18:13:43
    Sick!
    Texas Johnny
    +1
    WTF?!!
  • Muver 2011/01/24 18:10:09
    Sick!
    Muver
    +2
    This is a horrible video to be out there, any number of dummies will assume this is a good thing and right to do.....WRONG....I would like to see the response from a large number of infant professionals....Who would think this would be a good thing, just the sheer weight that gravity is producing on the hips, legs, knees, in ternal organs, the brain....this is at best child endangerment, abuse and cruelty .....Remember when Michael Jackson dangled his child out of the window, and it right side up....I wish this woman was in the United States so she could be arrested and put on trial....PLEASE , some appropriate organization, Stand Up and put a stop to this.....if nothing else, it is just barbaric.!!
  • Pei 2011/01/24 17:51:56
    Sick!
    Pei
    How is swinging someone around in the air yoga? And Russia is not a country I look to for medical advancements.
  • Greta 2011/01/24 17:20:03
    Sick!
    Greta
    +1
    those are some damn ugly babies!
  • StephenChipman 2011/01/24 17:00:38
    Sick!
    StephenChipman
    Even if there were some benefit I wouldn't do it the way she is doing it. Looks more like baby torture not yoga. Where do people come up with this crap?
  • guitarplayer2571 2011/01/24 16:59:20
    Sick!
    guitarplayer2571
    +1
    can anyone say brain damage?
  • thegalnextdoor 2011/01/24 16:55:24
    Sick!
    thegalnextdoor
    I know of a gal who was swung when she was a baby and it definitely hurt her.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 19 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/24 09:38:18

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals